High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4964/2015disposed of

Raj Rani v. Hardyal Singh And ORS.

2018-08-10Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan7 pages

!"#$"%&'&#()**

(& ,,"-- (!

."/'0'

/12 -3&(45#!5"/'

"',#(1"(!'

/12 -3&(45#!5"/'

,,"-- (!'

."/'0'

35/& 78 / (#!5"/'

"',#(1"(!'

/"'"(!)

/.&,0-91:#% !"$#/

/&!&( &!! - (1 /'5#;835 /7 9 1:#% !"$#/ //0(35 /7 91:#% !"

$#/!5" ,,"-- (!'

/#< (35 /7 91:#% !"$#//"',#(1"(!'(#

/ +(""'5 -5#!/ 91:#% !"$#//"',#(1"(!(#6 &( (1$#//"',#(1"(!(#=&(

6 >>> 5&' #/1"/ '5 -- 1&',#'"#$

+ (& .' /12 -3&(45#!5"/' (1 6 /12 -3&(45#!5"/'.' 35/& 78 / (#!5"/' '?#!5!5"'" ,," -' /&'"#0!#$ < /11 !"1 * , ''"1?2!5" 9 (%5;0- /&"$-2&!7 2?"(#!&%"1!5 ! %- &7,"!&!&#(0(1"/3"%!&#( #$!5" #!#/."5&%-"%!< '$&-"1?2!5", /"(!' (1!<#7&(#/ 1 045!"/' $#/ +0'! (1 1"@0 !" %#7,"(' !&#( #( %%#0(! #$ 1" !5 #$ /?5 + (3&(45&( 7#!#/:"5&%-" %%&1"(!!5 !!##;,- %"#(= (!5"%- &7,"!&!&#( (&<&1#<#$!5"1"%" '"1< '&7,-" 1"1 '

,/#$#/7 /"',#(1"(! (# ?2 ! ;&(4 '! (1 !5 ! '5" 5 1 /"7 //&"1 &77"1& !"-2 $!"/!5"1" !5#$!5"1"%" '"1 (1":"(10/&(4!5"-&$"!&7"#$ /?5 + (3&(45!5"/"< ' 7 !/&7#(& -1&',0!"!5", /!&"' (1

":"(%/&7&( -,/#%""1&(4'5 1?""(&(&!& !"1 ( !5" %- &7 ,"!&!&#( &! < ' ''"/!"1 !5 ! #( = /?5 + (3&(45< ',/#%""1&(4#( 7#!#/%2%-" (1< ''!/0%;?2 &,,"//0%;?" /&(4/"4&'!/ !&#((# =6* (1#( %%#0(!#$ <5&%54/&":#0'&(+0/&"'<"/"'0$$"/"1 (15"'0%%07?"1!#!5"' 7"#( /&7&( -% '"?" /&(4 #=*1 !"1< '/"4&'!"/"1 ! #-&%"3! !&#(95 (1& (1&/0(1"/'"%!&#('69==6 !< '

%- &7"1!5 !1"%" '"1 /?5 + (3&(45< ' 4"1 ?#0!=2" /' !!5"!&7" #$1" !5 (1< '" /(&(4 '9A,"/7#(!5$/#7!5"<#/;#$<"-1&(4 5" %- &7 ,"!&!&#( < ' %#(!"'!"1 &( !"/7' #$ $&-&(4 '", / !" </&!!"( '! !"7"(!'#(?"5 -$#$!5"/"',#(1"(!' /#$#/7 /"',#(1"(!(# +

(&'! !"1!5 !'5"&'!5"-"4 --2<"11"1<&$"#$1"%" '"1 (1?"&(4!5" <&1#<< '"(!&!-"1!#%#7,"(' !&#(#( %%#0(!#$1" !5#$5"/50'? (1! < '$0/!5"/'! !"1!5 !%- &7 (!(#&"$ !5"/#$!5"1"%" '"15 '/"!&/"1 $/#7!5" /72 (15 '":"('"/:"1<&!5 /2 ( #-&%" (1&'4"!!&(4 ,"('&#( (1 ''0%59% ((#!?"!/" !"1 '1","(1"(!#(!5"" /(&(4'#$!5" 1"%" '"1 ( !5" ,-" 1&(4' #$ !5", /!&"'9 !5"$#--#<&(4 &''0"' <"/" $/ 7"1?2!5"/& -#0/!)

"#$#%& ' ( )*++

, , - !.

/ ( / . .

/ /

/)*++

! !! / .

= .

)*+"#

" '/"4 /1'''0"#$&(1&(4'<"/"/"!0/("1&($ :#0/#$!5" %- &7 (!' (1&!< '5"-1!5 !1" !5#$ /?5 + (3&(45!##;,- %"#( %%#0(!#$&(+0/&"''0$$"/"1&(!5" %%&1"(!!5 !!##;,- %"#(= &(:#-:&(4!5"#$$"(1&(4A&('0/"1&,,"//0%;?" /&(4/"4&'!/ !&#(# =6* (1<5&%5< '?"&(41/&:"(&( / '5 (1("4-&4"(!7 (("/?2 1/&:"/( 7"-2 78 / ( ('#$ / '@0 (!07#$%#7,"(' !&#(&'%#(%"/("19/&?0( - 5 ' ''"''"1!5"7#(!5-2&(%#7"#$!5"1"%" '"1!#?" '*9A,"/ 7#(!59 < /1"1 ( 11&!&#(&(&(%#7"B C!#< /1'$0!0/",/#',"%!' (1 5 ' ,,-&"1 !5" 70-!&,-&"/ #$ !# !5" 70-!&,-&% (1 ( 7#0(! #$

' 9A5 '?""( < /1"1!#< /1'-#''#$%#('#/!&07 (1 ' 9A !#< /1' $0("/ - "D,"('"' 5"!#! - %#7,"(' !&#( 7#0(! < /1"1 &'

' 99A -#(4<&!5&(!"/"'!B6 C,"/ ((07$/#7!5"1 !"#$ &('!&!0!&#(#$!5"%- &7,"!&!&#(!&--/" -&E !&#(/&?0( -&(5&' < /11 !"1 * 5 ' ,,#/!&#("1!5"%#7,"(' !&#( 7#0(!&(!5"$#--#<&(4!"/7') - &7 (!# $ !5"/

'9=9A - &7 (!# 7#!5"/

'9=9A = - &7 (!'#= (1

!<#7&(#/1 045!"/'

'99A" %5

"',#(1"(!#

(&<&1#<

'99A

65 '?""($&-"1 !!5"5 (1'#$!5", /"(!' (1 !5" !<# 7&(#/ 1 045!"/' #$ !5" 1"%" '"1 '"";&(4 "(5 (%"7"(! #$ %#7,"(' !&#(

5 ' ?""( $&-"1 ?2 + (& -'# %- &7&(4 "(5 (%"7"(! ' -'#7#1&$&% !&#(<&!5/"4 /1!# ,,#/!&#(7"(!#$!5"

%#7,"(' !&#( < /1"1?2!5"/&?0( - #0('"-&( 65 ' /40"1!5 !!5"/&?0( -5 '

''"''"1!5"7#(!5-2&(%#7"#$!5"1"%" '"1 ' '*9A,"/7#(!5 (1 <5&%5&'#(!5"-#<"/'&1"!&'0/4"1!5 !!5"%- &7'"!0,#(?"5 -$#$!5" %- &7 (!'< '!5 !!5"1"%" '"1< '" /(&(47#/"!5 ( '9A,"/ 7#(!5?21#&(4!5"<#/;#$<"-1&(4 (1&(!5&'/"4 /1(#!#(-2 /12 - 3&(45%- &7 (!A ,,"-- (!(#5 1'!",,"1&(!#!5"<&!("''?#D ' F?0!

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

79 G 7? /1 / 5 ' %%",!"1 !5" :"/'&#( ' /"4 /1' 1"%" '"1 ?"&(4 "(4 4"1&(!5"<#/;#$<"-1&(4 (1 ''0%59?"&(4 ';&--"1<#/;"/5" 1 !"#$ %%&1"(!&'= (1 /12 -3&(451&"1#(#0('"- 1#"'(#!1&',0!"!5 !&(/"- !&#(!#'0%5,#&(!#$!&7"":"(!5"7&(&707 < 4"' 17&''&?-"!# ';&--"1<#/;"/<"/"(#!&("D%"''#$

'*9A,"/7#(!5 (1"/'0%5%&/%07'! (%"'9!5" ''"''7"(!#$!5" 7#(!5-2&(%#7"#$!5"1"%" '"1 ' '*9A,"/7#(!5?2!5"/&?0( -9&'

$$&/7"1 5&'#0/!95#<":"/9$&(1'7"/&!&(!5"%#(!"(!&#(/ &'"1?2 %#0('"-!5 !;"",&(4&(:&"<!5" 4"#$!5"1"%" '"1!#?"=2" /' !!5" !&7"#$5&'1" !59!5"/&?0( -#045!!#5 :" ,,-&"1 70-!&,-&"/#$

&('!" 1#$!#!5"70-!&,-&% (1 ',"/, / 7"!"/'- &11#<(?2!5","D #0/!&(

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

G&7&! !&#(%!'"";&(4%#(1#( !&#(#$1"- 2#$==1 2'&($&-&(4!5"7 &( ,," -&" 65"%#(!"(!'#$!5" ,,-&% !&#(1#(#!1&'%-#'" (1?/&(4$#/!5 (2+0'!&$& ?-"% 0'"$#/%#(1#( !&#(#$!5"&(#/1&( !"1"- 2 5",/ 2"/$#/%#(1#( !&#(#$1"- 2#$==1 2'&($&-&(4!5"7 &( ,," -&'9 ''0%59/"+"%!"1#('"@0"(!-29 69&'1&'7&''"1#(7"/&!' '

-'#?"&(4!&7"? //"1

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

5 ' %%",!"1!5" ,,"-- (! (& ' -"4 -/",/"'"(! !&:" ' -'#-"4 - 5"&/#$!5"1"%" '"150'? (1 (15 '4/ (!"1&(5"/$ :#0/ '- % ''5 /"

#0!#$!5"!#! -%#7,"(' !&#( 7#0(!#$ ' 99A 5"/" -&''0"&(!5"&('! (! ,," -$&-"1 !!5"5 (1'#$ +

(&&'<&!5/"4 /1!# ,,#/!&#(7"(!#$!5"%#7,"(' !&#( 7#0(! :"(&(/"4 /1!5"/"!#9(#&(!"/$"/"(%"<#0-1?"< // (!"1 #0('"-$#/!5" ,,"-- (!1#"'(#!1&',0!"!5 ! (&5 1 /"7 //&"1&77"1& !"-2 $!"/!5"1" !5#$ /?5 + (3&(455 ! , /!9":"( !5"!<#7&(#/1 045!"/'<"/"-"$!$#/0,;"", (1% /"<&!55"/&(- <'&" 4"1, /"(!'#$1"%" '"1 /?5 + (3&(45 !<#0-1 -'#?" ,,#'&!"!# (#!&%"!5 ! (&5"/'"-$5 1(#!$&-"1 (2%- &7,"!&!&#(0(1"/3"%!&#( #$!5" #!#/."5&%-"%!'"";&(4%#7,"(' !&#( !5"/'5"5 1?""(

6 &7,-" 1"1 '/"',#(1"(!(#&(!5"%- &7,"!&!&#(!5 !5 1?""($&-"1?2!5" , /"(!' (1!<#7&(#/1 045!"/'#$1"%" '"1:"(?"$#/"!5"/&?0( -!5" ,/"'"(! ,,"-- (! (&5 1(#!%#7"<&!5%-" (5 (1'(!5"</&!!"( '! !"7"(!$&-"1?"$#/"!5"/&?0( - '/"',#(1"(!(#9'5"5 1(#!":"( 1&'%-#'"1<&!5/"4 /1!#!5"$ %!07#$/"7 //& 4":"(&(5"/"D 7&( !&#( &(%5&"$?2< 2#$$&-&(4#$ $$&1 :&!D FA'5"%- &7"1!5 !'5"&'

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

$#0(1!#?"<&!5#0!7"/&! (1&'1&'7&''"1 (:&"<#$!5"1&'%0''&#( ?#:"9 (1

6 /"1&'7&''"1

-0%;2 F5"!5"/'," ;&(4A/" '#("1) "'A# F5"!5"/ ",#/! ?-") "'A#