← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4971/2015allowed

M/S Raja Ram Corn Products Punjab Pvt.Ltd. v. Suncity Projects Pvt.Ltd.

2015-08-05Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan8 pages

  

        

!"#$#%&'&() *

' !+! !, -(-$.%"'/.(+!01"2"$ 33#44!("  5#-'.'

6.(%&"7-+#%"'1"2"$!($"8#-'

 #'3($#("'

)  92  6 :

26  -#'#(");

-.(##"!4&/6#(&-$1%!"#/<&"8/ -5&08!1!&(/$1%!"#/-"8#!33#44!(" -!'8&'8 83-!/$1%!"#/--#'3($#("  =8#"8#-"8# #3-"#-'4%!4(#<'3!3#-,!70#!44<#$"'## "8#+.$>,#("?

 0#-##--#$""8# #3-"#--(" @ =8#"8#-"8#+.$>,#("'8.4$0#-#3-"#$&("8#$&>#'"? ;;

;;

:

26 /

2 33#44!("8!'&4#$"8&'!33#!4!>!&('""8#-$#-$!"#$ @ /  3!''#$  07  "8#  4#!-(#$  $$&"&(!4  &'"-&%"  .$>#/

8!($&>!-8/1&$#<8&%8"8#!334&%!"&("8#!33#44!("-!""!%8&(> <#-    @;/  !-&A-!,!  -.3  .'&(>  6%&#"7/  6#%"-;/ !(%8A.4!/&(%,34&!(%#<&"8"8#-$#-$!"#$ /3!''#$07 "8&' .-"&( "&"4#$!' 

     

  <!'

$&',&''#$ 8#'8-"%("-1#-'7&(141#$&("8#3-#'#("%!'#&'"8!" "8#3-#'#("!33#44!("8!$#!-4&#-&4#$!(!334&%!"&(.($#-6#%"&( "8#-0&"-!"&(!($ (%&4&!"&(%"/B &('8-"9"8#%"9 -

;;

>-!("&("#-&,3-"#%"&(&("8#-,-#C.&-&(>"8#-#'3($#("" .-(&'8  !33-3-&!"#  '#%.-&"7  -  -#%1#-7    '    %--#'  34.'

&("#-#'"!""8#-!"#D3#-!((.,-,"8#$!"#!<!-$&# @@"&44"8#$!"#-#%1#-7 68-& !(+&":.,!-!&(/"8# 4#!-(#$ $$&"&(!4  &'"-&%"  .$>#/  8!($&>!-8/  1&$#  -$#-  $!"#$  /$&',&''#$"8#'!&$!334&%!"&( >>-&#1#$07"8#'!&$ -$#-/"8#3-#'#("!33#44!("&4#$ 0#-#"8&'

.-"/<8&%8<!'$&'3'#$( 8#3#-!"&1#3!-" "8#  -$#-  3!''#$  07  "8&'  .-"  (    &'  -#3-$.%#$  !'

.($#-);

8#-#-#/!,"8#1&#<"8!" "8#-$#- 3!''#$  07  "8#  4#!-(#$  $$&"&(!4  &'"-&%"  .$>#/

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

;@;

('#C.#("47/"8#3-#'#("!33#!4&'!44<#$F (3.-'.!(%#""8#'!&$-$#-/"8#3-#'#("!33#44!("&4#$ !(!334&%!"&(0#-#"8#4<#- .-"-!""!%8&(><#-@;/ !-&A-!,! -.3.'&(>6%&#"7/6#%"-;/!(%8A.4!/ <8&%8 <!'$&',&''#$0768-& !(+&":.,!-!&(/4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%" .$>#/  8!($&>!-8  8#  -#4#1!("  #G"-!%"    "8#  '!&$  -$#-  &' -#3-$.%#$!'.($#-);

E@ #!-$.$&%&!4&4#$3#-.'#$8#-$#-8!'0##( 3!''#$07(904#&>8 .-".(+!0!($!-7!(!&(

 1&$#<8&%8-$#-3!''#$07 "8&' .-"( <8&4#$&'3'&(>3#"&"&(.($#- 6#%"&("8#-0&"-!"&(!($ (%&4&!"&(%"/B/ 8!'0##('#"!'&$#<&"8$&-#%"&(07"8#(904#&>8

.-""-#'3($#("6.(%&"7-+#%"'-&1!"#2&,&"#$" .-(&'8"8#'#%.-&"7&("8#'., '%--#'0#-# $$&"&(!4  &'"-&%"  .$>#/  8!($&>!-8  <8#-#  3#"&"&( .($#-6#%"&(@"8#-0&"-!"&(!($ (%&4&!"&(%"/ B&'3#($&(> &("8&' .-" "'!"&'7"8#!<!-$"8!"

,!70#.4"&,!"#47.38#4$!>!&('""8#,/<&"8&(!3#-&$ .-  <##A'  -,  "$!7  &#  "8#  -$#-  3!''#$  07  "8# (904#&>8 .-""8#'#%.-&"7&'(".-(&'8#$<&"8&( .-<##A'/"<#-@;/!-&A-!,! -.3.'&(> 6%&#"7/6#%"-/!(%8A.4!/&'-$#-#$"0#!""!%8#$ <#1#-/'.%8!""!%8,#("'8!440#'.0+#%"""8##!-4&#- #(%.,0-!(%#'!($"8#&("#-#'"%-#!"#$&(!1.-"8# "8&-$3#-'(0#-#"8#$!"#3!''&(>"8&'-$#-8# !""!%8,#("<&44%("&(.#"&44"8#!<!-$/&&(!447!&-,#$&( !1.-    !33#44!("/  &'  '!"&'&#$   6/  -,  "8#  1#-7 3#-!"&1#3!-""8&'-$#-3!''#$07"8#(904#&>8

;;

.-"1&$#<8&%8

 8!'0##( $&'3'#$&"'#4&'#G8!.'"&1#<8#-#&"&'-#C.&-#$ 07"8#(904#&>8 .-"".($#-'&>(#$"3!''!(7 -$#-!""!%8,#("'!&$"<#-<8&%8<.4$%#-"!&(47 0#  1#-  '"#33&(>  !($  1#-  !($  !01#  "8#  -$#-   (904#&>8 .-"<8&%8%!(("0#3!''#$07"8&' .-"

!($  <8&%8  &'  !4'  !>!&('"  "8#  3-3-&#"7  '  -#>!-$' .-(&'8&(>'#%.-&"7&("8#'., '%--#'0#-# "8&'  .-"/  (  '.%8  '#%.-&"7  8!'  0##(  .-(&'8#$

#-"!&(47  &"  &'  .3"  "  "8#  !334&%!("  "  !33-!%8 !33-3-&!"#  -.,  8!1&(>  "8#  +.-&'$&%"&(  1#-  "8# 3-3#-"7<8#-#'!,#&''&".!"#$->#""&(>!""!%8#$"8# 3-3#-"7!($>#""&(>&,34#,#("#$"8#-$#-(904# &>8  .-"   #-8!3'  "8&'  !334&%!"&(  8!'  0##(  &4#$ .($#-  ,&'%(%#3"&(  &(  "8&'  .-"  !($  '!,#  &'  ("

,!&("!&(!04#6/!334&%!"&(&'8#-#07$&',&''#$F 8!1#8#!-$4#!-(#$%.('#4-"8#3!-"&#'!($8!1# !4'%!-#.447>(#"8-.>8"8#&4#   !,    "8#  1&#<  "8!"  "8#  4#!-(#$ $$&"&(!4  &'"-&%" 8!($&>!-8/8!',&';$&-#%"#$8&,'#407<-(>47&("#-3-#"&(> "8#-$#-"8&' .-"8&' .-"8!$'3#%&&%!447$&-#%"#$"8#4<#-

.-""8!"&'#%.-&"7&'(".-(&'8#$<&"8&(.-<##A'/<#-@; /  !-&A-!,!  -.3  .'&(>  6%&#"7/  6#%"-;/  !(%8A.4!/  &' -$#-#$"0#!""!%8#$8#'!&$$&-#%"&(<!'%#-"!&(47>&1#(" 4<#- .-"8#4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#/ 8!($&>!-8/8!'

0'#-1#$"8!"(<8#-#&"&'-#C.&-#$07"8#(904#&>8 .-"""8# .($#-'&>(#$"3!''!(7-$#-!""!%8,#("'!&$"<#-<8&%8 <.4$%#-"!&(470#1#-'"#33&(>!($1#-!($!01#"8#-$#-"8#

;

;

(904#&>8 .-"<8&%8%!(("0#3!''#$07"8&' .-"!($<8&%8 &'!4'!>!&('""8#3-3-&#"7 8&' .-"!&4'".($#-'"!($!'" 8<"8#4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#/ 8!($&>!-8/07%,347&(> <&"8"8#-$#-"8&' .-"<.4$8!1#1#-'"#33#$!($1#-!($ !01#"8#-$#-"8&' .-"!($<8!"3-3-&#"7<.4$8!1#0##( 0-#!%8#$ !"8#-/07("&,34#,#("&(>"8#-$#-"8&' .-"/"8# 4#!-(#$  $$&"&(!4  &'"-&%"  .$>#/  8!($&>!-8/  8!'  '8<(  "8# $#&!(%#""8&' .-"  !"8#-/8&'-$#-&'!>!&('""8#3-3-&#"7 =8#("8#-$#-3!''#$07"8#4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#/

8!($&>!-8/&(!334&%!"&(.($#-6#%"&("8#%"<!''#"!'&$# !($"8#!33#!4<!'!44<#$!($%#-"!&($&-#%"&('<#-#>&1#(07"8&'

.-"/"8#-$#-"8&' .-"'"$!'&"8#-$#-3!''#$07"8# 4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#/ 8!($&>!-8/8!'0##(,$&&#$ !($%('#C.#("47/"8#'!&$-$#-'"!($'!""8#'!,#"&(>!'&&" 8!'  0##(  3!''#$  07  "8#  4#!-(#$  $$&"&(!4  &'"-&%"  .$>#/

8!($&>!-8 8#4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#/ 8!($&>!-8/8!'

0'#-1#$"8!"'#%.-&"7 '%--#'8!'("0##(.-(&'8#$ 8#-#-#/"8#4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#/ 8!($&>!-8/<!'

-#C.&-#$  "  3-%##$  <&"8  "8#  !""!%8,#("    <#-    @;/ !-&A-!,!  -.3  .'&(>  6%&#"7/  6#%"-;/  !(%8A.4!   8# 4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#/ 8!($&>!-8/8!'.-"8#-0'#-1#$ "8!"&"&'.3""8#!334&%!(""!33-!%8"8#!33-3-&!"#-.,8!1&(> +.-&'$&%"&(1#-"8#3-3#-"7<8#-#"8#'!,#&''&".!"#$->#""&(>

;B;

"8#3-3#-"7 !""!%8#$!($>#""&(>&,34#,#("#$ "8#-$#- "8&'

.-"   !,    "8#  1&#<  "8!"  "8#  '!,#  &'  !4'  <-(> &("#-3-#"!"&("8#-$#-3!''#$07"8&' .-"( &(

@ !'<#44!'"8#-#4#1!("3-1&'&('6#%"&( "8#%"4!7'$<(!'.($#-);

E  ;"<&"8'"!($&(>!(7"8&(>%("!&(#$ #4'#<8#-#&("8&'!-"-&(!(7"8#-4!<-"8#"&,# 0#&(>  &(  -%#/  <8#-#  <&"8  -#'3#%"  "  !(  !-0&"-!"&( !>-##,#("  !(7  !334&%!"&(  .($#-  "8&'  !-"  8!'  0##( ,!$#&(! .-"/"8!" .-"!4(#'8!448!1#+.-&'$&%"&( 1#-  "8#  !-0&"-!4  3-%##$&(>'  !($  !44  '.0'#C.#(" !334&%!"&('!-&'&(>.""8!"!>-##,#("!($"8#!-0&"-!4 3-%##$&(>''8!440#,!$#&("8!" .-"!($&(("8#-

.-"F "'8<'"8!"&("8#!-0&"-!"&(,!""#-'/"8#+.-&'$&%"&( "8#  .-"  &'  #G%4.'&1#    "8#-  -.,  %!(  %,#  &(" 3&%".-# -#1#-/"8&' .-"8!'"8#+.-&'$&%"&(1#-"8#6"!"#'.(+!0 !($!-7!(!!'<#44!' (&(#--&"-7 8!($&>!-8/!($<8#("8&'

.-"  $&-#%"'  "8#  4<#-  .-"  "8!"  (  "8#  !&4.-#  "  .-(&'8  "8# '#%.-&"7<&"8&(.-<##A'/"8#'!&$<#-@;"8#'!&$ -.3 .'&(>6%&#"7&'-$#-"0#!""!%8#$/"8!"<.4$,#!("8!""8# 4<#- .-"<!'!."8-&'#$"##%""8#!""!%8,#("8#3<#-" !""!%8"8#3-3#-"74<#$-,"8#-$#-"8&' .-"!($%.4$("

0#-#'"-&%"#$07"8#&("#-3-#"!"&("8#4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%" 8!($&>!-8("8&'<!7/"8#&,3.>(#$-$#-&'("8&(>/0."

;;

$#&!(%#"8#-$#-3!''#$07"8&' .-"( &(  @  8#-#-#/"8#&,3.>(#$-$#-$!"#$@ / 3!''#$07"8#4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#/ 8!($&>!-8&'("

'.'"!&(!04#&("8##7#4!<!($"8#'!,#8!'"0#'#"!'&$#8# '!,#&'!%%-$&(>47'#"!'&$#

('#C.#("47/"8#3-#'#("!33#!4&'!44<#$ #-#3!-"&(><&"8"8#+.$>,#("/"8&' .-"&($'"8!"

<8&4#$#%&$&(>!334&%!"&(.($#-6#%"&("8#%"/1&$#-$#- $!"#$ /"8#4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#/ 8!($&>!-8/ 8!$  "!A#(  "8#  1&#<  "8!"  6#%"&(      "8# %"  &'  4&,&"#$  "  "8# 3-"#%"&(3-3#-"7/<8&%8&''.0+#%",!""#-"8#!-0&"-!"&(8&'

.-"  8!'  .($  "8!"  "8#  '!,#  &'  %("-!-7 "  "8#  3-1&'&('   6#%"&(      "8#  %"   8#-#!"#-/  "8#  &,3.>(#$  -$#-  $!"#$ @ 8!'0##(3!''#$07"8#4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#/

8!($&>!-8/  -#.'&(>  "  &,34#,#("  "8#  -$#-    "8&'  .-" 8#-#-#/<&"8.",!A&(>!(7.-"8#-%,,#("'&("8#,!""#-/"8&'

.-"&'"8#1&#<"8!""8#3!-"&#',!7(">#"+.'"&%#-,"8#

.-"68-& !(+&":.,!-!&(/4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#/

8!($&>!-8/&("8#,!&(3#"&"&(&4#$.($#-6#%"&(@"8#%"/ "&"4#$  !'   

              

       <8&%8&''"!"#$"0#&G#$- !->.,#("'8#.-"8#-3-%##$&(>'"8#'!&$%!'#<#-#'"!7#$ 07"8&' .-"8#-#-#/A##3&(>&(1&#<"8##G"-!-$&(!-7'&".!"&( <8#-#"8#4#!-(#$$$&"&(!4&'"-&%".$>#&'!%"&(>%("-!-7""8#

;*;

4!<!($&($#&!(%#"8#-$#-"8&' .-"/"8#'!&$!-0&"-!"&( %!'#0#!-&(>-0&"-!"&( !'#/"&"4#$!' 

  



        &'<&"8$-!<(-,8&' .-"!($"-!('#--#$""8#

.-""8#4#!-(#$&'"-&%".$>#/ 8!($&>!-8/<&"8!$&-#%"&(" %(%4.$#"8#!->.,#("'!($$&'3'#"8#'!,#<&"8&("<,("8' 8#3-#'#("!334&%!"&('8!44!4'0#$#%&$#$07"8#4#!-(#$&'"-&%" 8!($&>!-88#-$#-"8&' .-"3!''#$( &( '8!440#&,34#,#("#$&(4#""#-!($'3&-&" 8#!33#!4&'!%%-$&(>47!44<#$

:

26    

*

'+A'