Cholamandalam Ms General Insurance Company Limited v. Suman And ORS










 

 





















$%&
'
(&)*+*,
-
.

/0$1$,($0$1
#
&,&$0
,+2$,)&

3%(












44&00$,%
























5   21$,
&6*
$,(
%/&+


























































&+4,(&,%+  #-
 73
# 
 
 8
3

&+&,%- #+
5$,($,$
#$0/%$9
(6)$%&9
'
%/&
$44&00$,% #
2(/*
$,$9
(6)$%&9
'
#
8&+/$6
$%$4
*,:/9
(6)$%&9
'
&+4,(&,%+


%
!















;;;;;;;

 8
39

 3 /2:/
%/&
4&+&,%
$44&$0
4&'&&(
<=
%/&
,+2$,)&
14$,= )/$00&,:&
*+
1$(&
%
%/&
$>$(
($%&(
 !9
4$++&(
<=
%/&
#% ))*(&,%
0$*1+
*<2,$09
822?+/&%$
'
+/%9
%/&
*<2,$0 3&$,&(
)2,+&0
'
%/&
$44&00$,%
+2<1*%+
%/$%
%/&
*,)1&
'
%/& (&)&$+&( $0@*,(&
*,:/
A
#$/*,(&
*,:/
/$+
<&&,
>,:0=
$++&++&(
<= %/&
*<2,$0
A

.B
4&
1,%/
$+
$))(*,:
%
/&
%/&
(&)&$+&(
>$+
$ ($*0=
>$:&
$,(
%/&&'&9
,0=
&,%*%0&(
%
1*,*121
>$:&+
'
$,
2,+?*00&( 0$<2&
>/*)/
$%
%/&
&0&6$,%
%*1&
>&&

!!
4&
1,%/C
>/&%/&
%/& (&)&$+&(
(*&(
$+
$
&+20%
'
%/&
$))*(&,%
*,
D2&+%*,
*+
$0+
*,
(2<%
$+
%/& &:*+%$%*,
,21<&
'
%/&
6&/*)0&
>/*)/
>$+
*,606&(
*,
%/&
$))*(&,%
>$+ ,%
:*6&,
*,
%/&

>/*)/
>$+
0(:&(
,
%/&
+$1&
($=
'
%/&
$))*(&,%C '2%2&
4+4&)%+
A
!E
)20(
,%
/$6&
<&&,
:$,%&(
<=
%/&
*<2,$0
$,( %/$%
2,(&
%/&
),6&,%*,$0
/&$(+
$,
&F)&++*6&
$12,%
'

!9 !9B
/$+ <&&,
:$,%&(
<=
%/&
*<2,$0 /2:/
%/&
%&+%*1,=
'

2?/(&6
*,:/
*%
>$+
(20= 46&(

<&'&

%/&

*<2,$0

%/$%

%/&
(&)&$+&(
>$+
>?*,:
$+
$
1$+,
$,(



%/$%
<&*,:
+
$++&++1&,%
'
/*+
1,%/0=
*,)1&
A

.B
)$,,%
<& ),+*(&&(
%
<&
&F)&++*6&
&+4&)*$00=
>/&,
,
),%$=
&6*(&,)&
>$+
0&(
<= %/&
,+2$,)&
14$,=
,
$,=
+244%*6&
+%$%&1&,%
)20(
<&
&F%$)%&(
<= %/&1
%/2:/
%/&
)++
&F$1*,$%*,
'
%/&
$'&+$*(
>*%,&++ 
'$
$+
%/&
+&),(
*++2&
*+
),)&,&(9
$
4&2+$0
'
%/&


+/>+
%/$%
%/&
&,:*,&
,21<&
'
%/&
%$)%
>/*)/
>$+
*,606&(
*,
%/& $))*(&,%
>$+
(20=
1&,%*,&(
*,
%/&

>/*)/
>$+
0(:&(
,
%/&
+$1&
($= '
%/&
$))*(&,%

/2+9
%/&&
*+
,
(*+42%&
>*%/
&:$(
%
%/&
*(&,%*%=
'
%/& ''&,(*,:
6&/*)0&

6&,
%/&>*+&9
%/2:/
0&$(*,:
'
):&,%
&6*(&,)& <&'&
%/&
*<2,$0
%/&
&+4,(&,%+B)0$*1$,%+
46&(
%/$%
%/&
(&)&$+&(
/$( (*&(
$+
$
&+20%
'
%/&
$))*(&,%
)$2+&(
<=
%/&
''&,(*,:
6&/*)0&
*,
D2&+%*, 3&$,&(
)2,+&0
'
%/&
4$%*&+
$&


%/$%
%/&
$>$(
' !E
$+
H'2%2&
4+4&)%+I
,
%/&
$++&++&(
*,)1&
'
%/&
(&)&$+&(
:&+ ),%$=
%
%/&
(*)%21
'
%/&
,7<0&
24&1&
2%
*,
H




  
 


  I

J

J.9
$+ $))(*,:
%


 )$+&
+24$
%/&
(&)&$+&(
<&*,:

=&$+
'
$:& %/&
)0$*1$,%+
$&
&,%*%0&(
%
%/&
:$,%
'
H'2%2&
4+4&)%+I
A
E
,
/*+ $++&++&(
*,)1&

/&&
*+
$0+
$
),+&,+2+
%/$%
$>$(*,:
'


0$?/
% &+4,(&,%


2,(&
%/&
/&$(
H0++
'
),+%*21I9


0$?/
&$)/
% &+4,(&,%+


%
!
2,(&
%/&
/&$(
H0++
'
06&
$,(
$''&)%*,I9

!9B

,
$))2,%
'
H'2,&$0
&F4&,+&+I
$,(

9B
,
$))2,%
'

H%$,+4%$%*,
)/$:&+I9
%%$0*,:
%

!9 !9B
&F)&&(+
%/&
0*1*%
'

9B
'
%/&
$<6&
/&$(+
$+
:$,%&(
<=
%/&
,7<0&
24&1&
2%
*, 

 )$+&
+24$

%
*+
$0+
,%
(*+42%&(







%/$%
&+4,(&,%
 !

'$%/&
'
%/&
(&)&$+&(
*+
&,%*%0&(
%

9B
$+
H'*0*$0
),+%*21I $+
:$,%&(
<=
%/&
,7<0&
24&1&
2%
*,
H

  



 

 



  I9

. 

 ! ,
6*&>
'
%/&
$<6&9
%/&
:$,%
'
H'2%2&
4+4&)%+I
A
!E
<= %/&
*<2,$0
*+
(&&(
%
<&
&(2)&(
%
E
$,(

!9 !9B
:$,%&(
2,(& %/&
),6&,%*,$0
/&$(+
*+
(&&(
%
<&
&(2)&(
%

99B
>/*)/ *,)02(&+

9B
$+
H+42+$0
),+%*21I
%
%/&
>*(>
'
%/&
(&)&$+&(9
!9B
$+
H'2,&$0
&F4&,+&+I9

!9B
$+
H0++
'
&+%$%&I
$,(

9B

$+
H'*0*$0
),+%*21I
%
&+4,(&,%
!

'$%/&
'
%/&
(&)&$+&( /&
*142:,&(
$>$(
*+
1(*'*&(
*,
%/&
$<6&
%&1+ .





































































K
 8
3
L +/$1+/&




























  G/&%/&
+4&$?*,:B&$+,&( -







&+



B




G/&%/&
&4%$<0&
-
















&+



B