Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited & ANR v. M/S Shree Gurdev Transport Co.










 

 

 



!"#

#$%&%'(
)*+
,


%'-)&"!'
#".*#)/
.0.!"%'
1%/%"#-,
2!"%'-!

!'"2#.

00#**!'"& 3#.&)& 4&
52.##
).-#6
.!'&0."
/0!'+,
7%.!
!-,
!*8!'-%
2!%, %&".%$"
#.9#0).

 #&0'-#'"

 

  !"

"!

# $

%&

.#&#'"( . !/!'
52!./!,
-6$!"#, .
"2#
!00#**!'" .3%'-
:2)';#.,
-6$!"#, .
"2#
$!6#!".<.#&0'-#'" =====







































"!

# $

 '() 2#
!00#**!'"&
!.#
!;;.%#6#-

"2#
%/0);'#-
.-#., 82#.#>+
%'
!
0#"%"%'
%*#-
)'-#.
5#$"%'


"2#
.>%".!"%'
!'- '$%*%!"%'
$",

.
&2."
?
$"@ ,
%'
0).&)!'$#
"
"2# !;.##/#'"
-!"#-

!..%6#-
!"
>#"8##'
"2#
0!."%#&,
!'
%'"#.%/ .-#.
.
.#&".!"%'

"2#
&)00*+
2!&
>##'
0!&&#-
. !/!'
52!./!,
*#!.'#-
$)'&#*
.
"2#
!00#**!'"& &)>/%"&
"2!"
!"#.
"2#
0!&&%';

"2#
%'"#.%/
.-#.,
"2#
!;.##/#'"
2!&
!*& >##'
$2!**#';#-
2#
.#&0'-#'"<".!'&0."#.
$//%""#-
&/#
-#!)*"&
 "2#
"#./&
!'-
$'-%"%'&

"2#
!;.##/#'"
!'-
!&
!
.#&)*"
"2#.#,
!
&28

$!)&#
'"%$#
8!&
%&&)#-

2#
&!%-
'"%$#
2!&
+#"
'"
$)*/%'!"#-
%'"
!'+ .-#.
!'-,
"2#.#.#,
"2#.#
8!&
'
$$!&%'
.
%*%';
"2#
0#"%"%'
)'-#. 5#$"%'



$"
2%&
!&0#$"
2!&
'"
>##'
'"%$#-
>+
"2#
.%'$%0!* )."
82%*#
!**8%';
"2#
!00*%$!"%' '
"2#
*!&"
-!"#

2#!.%';,
"2%&
)."
2!-
-%.#$"#-
"2# 0!."%#&
"
&##A
!-B)-%$!"%'

"2#
-%&0)"#
"2.);2
!.>%".!"%'
!&
"2# !;.##/#'"
$'"!%'#-
*!)&#
C
.
.#&*)"%'

"2#
-%&0)"#
>+
!' .>%".!".
.52!./!
2!&
!*&
.!%&#-
!'"2#.
!.;)/#'"
#
&!+&
"2!" >#.#
%*%';

"2#
0#"%"%'
)'-#.
5#$"%'



$",
%"
%&
"2# .0.!"%',
82%$2
2!-
&28'
%'"#'"%'
"
&##A
"2#
.#&*)"%'

"2# -%&0)"#
"2.);2
!.>%".!"%' .3%'-
:2)';#.,
*#!.'#-
$)'&#*
.
"2#
$!6#!".< .#&0'-#'"
&)>/%"&
"2!"
!"#.
"2#
0!&&%';

"2#
.-#.,
"2#
-#!*#.
2!

- &28'
"2#
%'"#'"%'
.
.#&".!"%'

"2#
&)00*+
!'-
!00%'"/#'"

"2# !.>%".!".,
>)"
"2#
0#"%"%'#.&
2!6#
'"
0!&&#-
!'+
.-#.
2#
.-#.
%& /&"
%''$))&
2#
.%'$%0!*
)."
2!-
#D!/%'#-
"2#
E)#&"%' "2.#!->!.#
!'-
%'
"2#
0#"%"%'
)'-#.
5#$"%'



$",
%"
8!&
'"
"2# &28
$!)&#
'"%$#,
82%$2
8!&
$2!**#';#-
>)"
"2#
&"00!;#

"2#
&)00*+ !*&
!'-
%'
"2%&
$'"#D",
%'"#.%/
.-#.
2!&
>##'
0!&&#-
>+
"2#
).", "2#.#.#,
"2#.#
%&
'
&)>&"!'$#
%'
"2#
0*#!

.52!./!
"2!"

 E)!
$2!**#';#

"2#
&28
$!)&#
'"%$#
!'-,
"2)&,
).;#&
"2%&
)."
. %./%';
"2#
%'-%';&
>+
&"!"%';
"2!"
2#
8%**
&#'-
!
'"%$#
&##A%';
"2# %'"#'"%'

.#&*)"%'

-%&0)"#
"2.);2
!.>%".!"%' .52!./!
!*&
&)>/%"&
"2!"
"2#
.0.!"%'
&2!**
'"
2!6# !'+
-%%$)*"+
.

!00%'"/#'"

!.>%".!".
&".%$"*+
!&
0#.
0.6%&%'&
 5#$"%'
C


$" 
2!6#
2#!.-
"2#
*#!.'#-
$)'&#*
.
"2#
0!."%#&
!'- !00.!%&#-
"2#
0!0#.
>A 5%'$#
"2#
0!."%#&
!.#
!-
%-#/
.
.#&*)"%'

"2#
-%&0)"#
>+ !00%'"%';
!.>%".!".
!'-
%'"#.%/
.-#.
%&
'*+
6!*%-
"%**
"2#
/!""#.
%& .##..#-
"
"2#
!.>%".!".,

-##/
%"
!00.0.%!"#
"
-%&0&#

"2#
0.#&#'" !00#!*
>+
)02*-%';
"2#
.-#.
)'-#.
$2!**#';#
>+
%&&)%';
-%.#$"%'
"
"2# .#&0'-#'"&
"
&#'-
!
'"%$#

&##A%';
%'"#'"%'
"
!00%'"
"2# .>%".!".
%'
!$$.-!'

$#
8%"2
*!8
."28%"2
'"
*!"#.
>+
"/..8
>+ .#;%&"#.#-
0&"
!'-
!&
8#**
!&
>+
0#.&'!*
-#*%6#.+
!'-
"2#.#!"#.
"2# .0.!"%'
&2!**
!00%'"
!'
!.>%".!".
!&
0#.
"2#
"#./&
!'-
$'-%"%'&
 "2#
!;.##/#'"
2#
0!."%#&
&2!**
>#
!"
*%>#."+
"
.!%&#
!**
"2#
$*!%/
>#.#
"2# !.>%".!".

*)+

$

 "!

#

 '(,-./

%&

#/-0/-'

.1-(23456'-(.4-7 8-.6 #/-0/-'

-1'0(9)- 8-.6