Union Of India Through Secretary To Government Of India v. Ex Nk Baljinder Singh And Another
!"#$$#
% & !$'#$#"
!
( ) )
"#$ % !
&
*! +,* # ))
) -
+,* )# )) ) * '()*+ ,-.
'
/0'01234 31(/ 05/6/3
+78904* ;*434381*'<
'
,/3=01-) /0'=0
+78904*
'*6;81+*14
>>>> )
) -
.# /'8)(/ 3164014 ?'34 ;*434381
/*'*31
1+30
;'0-6 6*4431( 063+* 8'+*'
@ # $ A11*B)'*
;066*+ '=*+ 8'9*6 9819*'1*+
?/*'*,-6 9D03= '*6;81+*14
('014 *D*=*14 +360,3D34- /3= *9)'34- 8';6 AC ,**1 0DD8?*+
981+8131( 6/8'4:0DD
@ +0-6 :'8=
-*0'6 *0'131(
/&0%/1/&23 %
*6;81+*14
*1'8DD*+ 1+301 '=- F
F"
+369/0'(*+ 4/*'*:'8=
$
*6;81+*14
('014*+ '*43'31(
0+=3663,D* /3= ;*'
*16381 *()D043816
/*'*0:4*'
'*6;81+*14
'**1'8DD*+
*9)'34- 8';6 A 6*'739*C
# #
998'+31( ;'*70D*14 ;8D39-
);81 04403131( 0(* 6);*'011)04381
'*6;81+*14
+369/0'(*+ :'8=
0:4*'
'*1+*'31(
-*0'6
@ =814/6
+0-6
?/39/ 6/8'4
@ +0-6
=05* 68D+3*'
*10,D*+ 98=;D*4* 4*'=
-*0'6
;)';86* ('014
6*981+ /3=
*6;81+*14
+*13*+ 98=;*4*14 0)4/8'34- /36 98=;D*431( ;*'38+ *0'131(
**D31( 0(('3*7*+
'*6;81+*14
:3D*+
,*:8'* '=*+ 8'9*6 9819*'1*+
?/*'*,-6 /* 9/0DD*1(* 0:8'* '*2*94381 8'+*'
,*90=* 0DD8?*+ 73+* 8'+*'
@ # $
8;*'0437* ;0'4 8'+*'
/*'*310:4*'.
BBBB BBBB
BBBB
BBBB
BBBB
BBBB
BBBB
BBBB
BBBB
! " # $"
%
"
&'( " )*
**D31( 0(('3*7*+ :'8= 0:8'*603+ 8'+*'
;066*+ );81
A6);'0C
'=*+ 8'9*6 9819*'1*+
;*434381*' 1+30 :3D*+ 4/*'*0(03164 3164014 ?'34 ;*434381 ,*:8'* 4/36
)%4566 7081/ & % 17 0890606 # @
98)16*D 6),=346
4/04 :03D*+ 98163+*'
4/04 4*'=6 *()D04381
"
*16381 *()D043816 '=-
F@
*()D04381 *16381 *()D043816 '=-
81D- 8=;*4*14 )4/8'34- *=;8?*'*+ 981+81* +*:393*19- '*1+34381
68D+3*'
/36 ,*98=31( *1434D*+ 6**5 *1+8?=*14 /3=
*()D043816 0'* /*'*310:4*'
A
F@
+ ) ,-
.
/ "
0" ./ "
" "! " 12 ./ "
" "
" " - )* A
C 22) %
3 "
" +
" -
45 . / "
0"6 . / "
) . /
" " ! " )* 7)
8'*87*'
31364'- 73+* 8D39D*44*'
AC<
<<A*1<8DC @
316*'4*+ 9D0)6* A37C
*()D04381
*16381 *()D04381 '=-
'*D*7014 ;0'4 ?/*'*8:
/*'*310:4*'
;*')60D 0:8'* 0=*1+=*14 ?8)D+ =05* 9D*0'
4/04 '*D3*:
E)0 981+8104381 +*:393*19- '*1+34381 0;;8634*
,* 0998'+*+ =*'34
*16)'* 4/04 0'=- ;*'6811*D *D3(3,D* D*064 81*
!
98)16*D :)'4/*'
6),=346
4/04 2)+(=*14 '=*+ 8'9*6
'3193;0D *19/
*?
*D/3
906* 434D*+ # $ %&
98''*94 '04/*'
9814'0'- D0?
:0946
4/*'*:8'*
'*D3019* 8)(/4 /07* ,**1 ;D09*+ 2)+(=*14
'*D*7014 ;0'0('0;/6
899)'
7*'+394 A6);'0C 0'* /*'*310:4*'
+)% 0" 8"9 +2):2)+:
' "
"4 .
/ ; "
<! "
= > 2):')+::
?
22
? ! "
= > +:):1)+:
7@ / "
" " " @
/
"
" " @ / $"
9 A
B)C )1:
+:
D :7)
)+:
D 8%
@ /
8% " = .> /
"
@ ---- ---- 2') " "
< "
"
E 9
< " "
" 4 . / F" C ) .
/ "
" . / 0"
"
2 "
"
" % "
?
G H"
" !
"
"
G HG
"
?"$ IG
> > !
" 9 > )% ." /) !
'
‟
( ) ! " *
. / "
./ ./
% "
0"
0"
*"
@
+.+/
8 % " +::7)%
" " "
" 2):')+::
?
+
" ?
." / ")+ "
,-.-/" 0
/1-/-/2 . / ?
./
" "
"
"
"
% " 9 H )"
). /F" C )./ ?
27 )
7 & 7086 % 0#
319* *B;864)D043816 =0+* ;0'0('0;/
2)+(=*14 81G,D* ;*B 906* 434D*+
6 7 6// 08 (#)% )6 38 / 5/
'*;8'4*+
-/32
,-,
;0'0('0;/ ?/*'*8:
,*98=*6 /*'*310:4*'
87*'98=*6 +360,D31( *::*946
3:
01-
6);'0 *B9*;4381 A37C
,*90=* 316*'4*+ 73+* ;8D39-<D*44*'
@
314*1+*+ ?8'5 8,6409D* '04/*'
0(03164 68D+3*'
9D03=31( '*D3*:
981+8104381 6/8'4:0DD
+)
0"
-
" + )
- " $"
G
" % " "
" "
% " )G
+2J" #' " 2"
"+::
-
"
" "
)%% "
" H
) /*'*:8'*
2)+3930D 7*'+394 A6);'0C
+8*6 '*1+*'
1*(04*+ 6);'0 0'()=*14 '036*+ 98)16*D
4/04 *=;8?*'=*14 981+81* 6/8'4:0DD
,*98=*6 68D340'3D7*64*+ 8=;*4*14 )4/8'34-
*6;*930DD- ?/*1 /*'*310,87* )1+*'D31*+ ;0'0('0;/6
899)'
7*'+394 =0+* )% )6 38
/ 5/ +&/
0DD)+*+ 7*'+394 =0+* /0=0 !0)'G6 906*
+8 317*64 2)'36+394381 '34
4/'8)(/ 2)+3930D 314*'7*14381
=05* *6;8)6*+ 981+8104381
816*E)*14D-
9)=)D0437* *::*94 0)4/8'340437* 2)+3930D ;'818)19*=*14 90''3*+ 0,87* ;0'0('0;/
=0+* )
"
98=;D*4*D98)14*'703D6 ,84/ 6);'0 0'()=*146 '036*+ ,*:8'* 4/36
98)16*D
+*1-31( '*6;81+*14
,*1*:34 /36 6*'731(
=*'*D- ('8)1+ 4/04 /* 98=;D*4*+ ;*'38+
,*63+*6 :)'4/*'
:D3=6- ('8)1+
4/04 81D98=;*4*14 0)4/8'340)4/8'3H*+ 981+81* 6/8'4:0DD
81*4/*D*66
4*'=6 +*9D0'04381 =0+* /*'*310,87* )1+*'D31*+ ;0'0
90''3*+ 7*'+394 A6);'0C
9D03=6 +)0D :0=3D0++34381 :3'64 :0=3D-
3:
'*E)3'*+
?8)D+ ,* '*64'394*+ :'8= F
*17360(*+
31364'- *44*'
6 /1
7086 % 0#
1 0:4*'=04/
4/36 :31+6 =*'34 ?'34 ;*434381 ?34/ 8,6*'7043816 0,87*
60=* +36=366*+
3=;)(1*+ 8'+*'
;066*+ 9819*'1*+
=0314031*+ 0::3'=*+
@
36;86*+ 0D81(?34/ 0DD ;*1+31( 0;;D3904381A6C
3:
01-
:)
) -
;
:) ) *;
$'#$#" 120D
/*4/*'
6;*0531(<'*0681*+ .
*6<8 /*4/*'
'*;8'40,D* .
*6<8