High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/156/2013dismissed

Umesh Trehan v. Commissioner Of Income Tax-I, Chd

2016-08-09Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan4 pages

!"# $% &' (!)*)+#, #- "#

*./.

( 0/*1* )**)/!23.4)5/.

*4(*

/*(+ &/ 655/7 348(3!/(.

( &* /8*.)155348(3!/(./*4( 9999 .)*)* 5)*((./4/!(.

( /):1 4)*)**)5(.

(;****<* 5)*((./4/!(. )**)/ ! % *' 7.). ) (1/ 4)*)**4 (.

(<* 5)*( (. /4/ ! (. ****)5 !!)/ . ((/ /()*((.****(=/"##>2#- "

.****(4*(.((.!

7)5*1:*(() ?1*()* ! 7/)*)(.)* +2 '

# $%

' # (%

)% '

+ $,

., ..$

" & '

& ! #

(,/%/% & !&

# ,%

(,/%/%

& !

! &

'- !

(,/%/% #0 $ .

(!) 4/(1/!)!:1("

#>//* .*7** (4!/*/1()=

#$ "##>3*1/8=7*41(4 14/ *() $$2 ! (. (3 , %!/ *./( @(. (<'

1/)5*1/8=3(.****!!/444)() )!"

#//*!/ (() .*1/8=//()4)(4(.(4)* *1/.4:4(8/ 1(.4)*/)*1(!11(41/.**4* ** * 5)*(11(4*.

.****)5 !!)/(4(.((.****.4 411(4* *7/(. #3##3>#3 $;2411(41/.** 1()5(3#3 3A,#;27.).7/4)*8/441/)5(.1/*! *1/8= . ****)5 !!)/ (6 (. !)51/ ! 11(4 * * 1()5( #//**:*( 1 ((.11(4/!)(*4 1 )4)8*(( .(/4)5/*1 (*!(.*****()4) (./!)(4 **1(4: *.(7/1() )B4 .****.4!/(.****(=/)?1*()*.7 /( !

/4)5 =3 (. 11(4 ) /4 !/ 1//44 *. * ! :1( # //* ( (. /( !

C 7* 7/641((:3 $3- ;2

.)8*((/?1)/4!/.)8)5(.(1/8/!:1(

#//*7* 1 (4:=/!//)5((.****<*: *.(* $

#$ "##> . ****<* )( 1( 14)5 (. /!)( /4 41/)5 (. =/ 7* A,3#3--#;2 . 1( ! *1/4 * * $

#$ "##>7* 3>,3> $;241*1/4 *7* 3"3"-;2 . 55/5(!(.*(./1(*7*"3A3#"3$##;2 .(( (1/8/!/ (.(=/)(.(/4)51(7* $3">3, 3$ ";2 .(( (1/8/(.1* /?1)/4)8*((!:1("

A//* //()( =(//= :1*)**.8)5(1/8/!:1( #//*/?1)/4)8*((! :1(

- //* /4)5 =3 (. ****)5 !!)/ 1(4 (. 14)* *4)11(4* *7/(. #//**"

A//*

.****3.78/3(44(.(8/)1*1(*15.( (:441(4!/(.!)51/!"

A//* /)*(3.(4* (.(1(! -# *7/(.!!)4**(*15.((:441(4* )8*(()*/?1)/4)!)4**(*!/(.11(4*.* !1/(./(4*(.( $- *15.((:441(4*)8*(()* /?1)/4!/(.)8*(()&;*) *)4= 8( D(4 4(.($A A#

*15.((:441(4*)8*(()*/?1)/41(!4:(/* *)(.* */*.* *

()( =(.: 1(/4)5( (.****7/6*1(( =A"

$ * > E.(./(.*1(*!/4/(!"

A//*/()* ?1*()!!( .****.*(4414=8)4(*(: )*.(. * ./)7.).(.****)5 !!)/.*((.!)51/! "

A //* ( : . 4 ( : /8/* / )//()

)* /!1* ( 441((.1(** )4:=(.****!/(.)*1((:

*)4(:/8/*/)//() )(./ ./):1 )44*1 (4:= /41)5(.14)* *4)8*(((

#//*4(.44)()!

# *(:1($A * 78/3(./):1 *1 (4)!81/ !(.**** .****./4 =:55/)84:=(.*1 ()) .)*!81/ - . */5/4*?1*()* (A)*4)*)**4*(.= 4(/)**1:*(() ?1*()! 7 , F1*()* 4 *4(/)**1:*(() ?1*()!

7 .****4841(*7)(.1()(/*((.)**)*(// 4((. =* (7*!14(.((./7/:1*)**(/*()* 7)(.(.*)*(// /) 4)=7*(*(:

)*.4 *!/ *(. =*//43*1! # *)*

54(.8: 484(.) =/4)((/=).)*1(7*!14 .1( 7* 484 !/ (. 1/* ! *(/1()5 .1* ./ 7* 8)4(.((.=7*)!(5)8!/*(/1()!.1* )! */5/4**1 =!54*(!(.*)*(//7*/( =5/(4

)!*/5/4*(./(/*()*7//(*)(/!/ (7*!14* ((/!!((.((./7*/) 4)= . */5/4*?1*()* 4 )* *3(./!/3 4)*)**4

# (./*1 (3(. )*4)*)**4 (S.J.VAZIFDAR) CHIEF JUSTICE (DEEPAK SIBAL) JUDGE 'ravinder'

Whether speaking/reasoned √Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No√