High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4666/2018dismissed

Kulwant Singh v. Appellate Tribunal Cum Deputy Commissioner Patiala And ORS.

2018-05-16Mr. Justice Krishna Murari4 pages

!"# $ %& ' ('! )**""+',!

"-!.-*! .. '"&' /* /)

' '$!0&*'.')1 '&* ' !"!# $%&!'

'*&"" %''

2* , +',!

" $ ' 3 )-!.-$!, 1 "

%',&#&', * !

' "

' $ '3 )

2 ", '* 4 &'# *"' %"- 5 6

57! , '* 4 &* ' !"" 1#"" ''

2 * , )**"" +',!

"-!.-*!

.. '". %&**" ", &* ' 8'

" '&* '&!'%, '&!'& ''!

' '.* ""%" +&+',!

"#&!

' %**'!

&' %&* '""#&**" ", '* 4 )' %&.& &'& , &', &* '

' 9&1&'"'

" '&* ' %1 ' !"

&!%&& &

:' !".'7 &&'* 4#& ,!5 ' %&, "1 %" %#&&# %,! ; &# ."

;'*"$ %& !"# $ %&* '&' :& &. &1 , "1 % *'"

" %#& &' ." /* 4" %#&&# &, "1 %#&&* '9 & "! '1' ', &* '& !"# $ %& &# %' '' <)' &" &' . +&' '& .*""

**. %&'*' )%%'1 '* 4**'&&+',!

'&$ '3 )+& ',!

"'&* '* /4

=-*'. & !

. '* 4 ) ' '' # * * '*& ""

&'&*' &'#&.! &&! /46

6#"'%' "$ :&

& '%' >1 & * ' *

. ?"."

'* 4**'&&!&' 0 % ""

" 56

5 ) ' ' % ' .'" ''&$!,1 "%',&1''

2""#&**" ", '* 4, "" % & '" **'1.! &" @!

'* 4 )%%'1* '*' ''**",! '. !

! !" )**" # . , ' %' "1''

2 9

'. #&&''*9**'.#

&*!"''!. &+&!&',"# &1 ' #&&*'1 *" . #&

( 1#&1,A1&' 9 A!%. '*'

&!'&"!

- B

! " " "

# $%#

! $ # !

% !

" !!"! $&

% ! '

$ ( ' " %

! # )

! !

$ '

# $

!" !

" !!

! $ #

$% 1# ,19. & '1#&+',!

'' ""# % & * *' '' , '* 4- &' +' ' &#'.#&&*!&*&&' ' #!" !'1&*' &# %*''7! & !. ;1 % ""0 '&*' *'1,. &. &'"%&.0&."

"," '1 &' '- " !&! * &&, . #!",*'1&*' , '*' & ' '-9.,' *' .0!&' '

! "1

&1 ' ,"1& '&' '

&#'#!"!'

&,0 &. ' !*'1,. -- "+&!*"', '&!''#&!

.'$.'&', 'A . )

C/A*"C &&'*0 %=' D= &&'/*',"