High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5029/2015dismissed

Reliance General Insurance Company Limited v. Sonia Garg & ORS

2015-08-05Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

!"#"$%&%'( ")% '$" "'"* )'&+* '$" ,- './%,%!"#--")) '! 0"*&+& 1,!1'% *2 '#!3"*& "&-'#"'!&

( 4/ 1 5 /1 *"&"'!(6

* 75+, * &3 ,89#:$ !"9*!3" --")) '! ;3"!3"*!3""-*!"*&)$ )'"<&- -"*, .8" ))<"#!&"" !3"7+#2,"'!= 8"*""**"#!!3""-*!"**'! > ;3"!3"*!3"7+#2,"'!&3+)#8"*"-*!"#%'!3"#%2"&!= 66 66 /1 9

/ 3"%'&+* '$"$,- '.3 &%)"#!3%& --" ) 2 %'&!!3" < *# # !"# 9 - &&"# 8. !3" !* $$%#"'! ) %,& *%8+' )9%'# %'&3*!4!3"%*8+' )49:%#"<3%$3$,-"'& !%'! !3"!+'"&?>9@9 6 )'2<%!3%'!"*"&!AB-"* ''+,*, !3"# !"%)%'2!3"$) %,-"!%!%'!%))%!&*" )%C !%'< & < *#"#%' :+*!3"$) %, '!& 3"8*%" $!&!3"$ &" *"!3 !'@>95*%&3 ' 5+, * &%'$"#"$" &"# )'2<%!3'"1+*"&35+, *9<'"*!3" )!$ *8" *%'2*"2%&!* !%'/6> 6? '#3%&&'1 !%&3 5+, * !3*< &*"!+*'%'2*,1 %'%D&-%! )9 ' -+*9!%* *$"1! !%'%3! %'!3"& %#$ *;3"'!3"$ **" $3"#--&%!"

66 %3! 3.'"E 3 # $!*.9 %&!*%$! !' %3 *9 !3"' !*+$D 8" *%'2*"2%&!* !%'6 6>@>?$ ,"*,!3"--&%!"&%#"9 8"%'2#*%:"'8.*"&-'#"'!6#*%:"*%' * &3 '#'"2)%2"'!, ''"* '##%*"$!).3%!!3"& ,"<%!3!3"$ *9 & *"&+)!<3%$391 !%&3 5+, * !3*#%"# !!3"&-!9<3"*" &5*%&3 '5+, * '#1+*"&3 5+, **"$"%:"#,+)!%-)"%'7+*%"& 3".<"*"*",:"#! %)%! *.

&-%! )9 ' -+*98+!) !"*'9!3". )&&+$$+,8"#!!3"%'7+*%"& F# !"#>+'#"*1"$!%'&F9>?6 '#?F

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

$) %, '!& 3 :"3" *#)" *'"#$+'&")*!3" --")) '! '#3 :"

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

&+,, *. '#%'' !+*"%'G+%*. 3"*"*"9&!*%$!-*$"#+*"

#" %:%)*$"#+*"%&'!!8"))<"#%'!3"-*"&"'!$ &" 3"&! '# *#-*%& )&'!& ,""*"9%'"&3 *&3 #3 & $)" *).&! !"#8"*"!3" +*!!3 !3"< &! D%'2!" %' &3- '# 3"3 #<%!'"&&"#!3"$$+**"'$"3"#"$" &"#< &<*D%'2%'%* *$"1! !%'9&%!+ !"#'" *8. '#!3"-&&%8%)%!.%'"&3 *&3 # 8"%'2-*"&"'! !!" &! ))%&!3"*"3"*"*"9!3"&! !","'!

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

&& *":"*9 !3"*" %& &+--*!%'2 ":%#"'$"%'!3"*,%':"&!%2 !%'$ **%"#+!8.!3"-)%$" & *"&+)!<3%$39!3"#*%:"*"'#%'2!*+$D< &$3 )) '"#8.!3" -)%$" 3"*"*"9 # '! %'# '. %))"2 )%!. * %'%*,%!. %' !3" %,-+2'"# < *#3"& ,"%& $$*#%'2).

'&"G+"'!).9!3"-*"&"'! --" )%&#%&,%&&"#

&7D&