Navdeep Dhingra Yamuna Nagar v. Commissioner Of Income Tax Karnal Haryana
! "#
$
! "#
$
! "#
$
! "#
$ %&
'( ")*
%&
'( ")*
%&
'( ")*
%&
'( ")*
''
''
''
''
, *!-!
, *!-!
, *!-!
, *!-!
.. !! "
* " .
/01 *"
.. !! "
* " .
/01 *"
.. !! "
* " .
/01 *"
.. !! "
* " .
/01 *"
!'"&
!'"&
!'"&
!'"&
2# 2# 2# 2# 3425,44 3425,44 3425,44 3425,44 3425564 3425564 3425564 3425564 * # 2* "7 8 "05 " *&%
( 2* %:
5-* 0&%
2*5 ( "( *&9 80&%
2* &( 2( " *)0&%
2*) !(- :0&%
!'"& ;;;
8 % ( 0<* += 8 % ( 0<* += 8 % ( 0<* += 8 % ( 0<* += >
!?
-! ( ") ")*&
" .
/''
* ?-"
+0<(
** !3 3=0( "& ) *(0 " (330*& *'
.. !! "
* " .
/<''
+!=<(
**
** !3
<=3= ++ *& *! -* ") :0-"& *5
" " .
/ @A<(
**
** !3 3=" ?-! "
!!'* . !
!
2B! !
* ! % 4 &0 "
A0
9( !
&+: *
*0& C !*
-"
-"
& "% 9 *&! "!
'* . !
! 2B!
!
* ! % 4 & ( !
&
C$
* ?-
!! !(0-"
-"
"% " ?- +& ") "& -"
-"
& "% " .
( "
*:
.'
":
:0
-*""
& * ") " " .
C0@@0
B> (
-*" 9 '* - : "! *- ":'*
& ")! "
*!
*% ") "
! -"& * 5
" D< = "& D <= "&
''*'*
") * E- !
"
*.
" "
+:0 -"
?7! % &
*&
A
3!!
!0 " +-& && ")C
))* ( !*& *0
+09( ( !& !. !!
<= (
9( (9 +!& !. !!
-"!
+
!-?.
&+:
&( ! &. !! "!0
&. !! "!B!
-+& " *. ?
! ! "! 9 ": **?*
-"!
+ *
&* 9!
"
<""
/-* >A=&
A
09( "0 '- :.. !! "
*
" .
/( !* *&
" * " * . "
")& -.
!+ ' '
& ( ! ?
" * % & ?: -"!
+ *
!-?.
(-)( &. !! " !
?- 9( &. !! " !.
-"& * * " "&'* "& !
&0 '+
-'"!- ( &. !! "
"&.-!
0+7 * '*%
?!
": *! .'-)"
&*& *!9( (
&-'"*
&!
!.
"-++ "&% & -"!
!-?.
?:
*& & "
A0 &-* ") !
* ( (
&&*
* &
& @
A .
7 ")
-* &. !! "! (
&. !! "!0 "
+.!
9:
*!
+!
7!?
!! ") *& *" A
(
"!?
")( )(+:?
"&9
":.
-+&* " "
!
&*.
-"& *'* !
!(
"* )( +:*
9( + .
7 ") "! -"!
+ * +! !-?.
"! * "*'* "-*
-+ *+:9(
" !?
& ( (
*& -"!
+ * '
!0 '
*-!
.'-)"
&*& *! !-*% :-"& *5
"<= ! "&-
&"
A(
09( ! *
* 2B!!
* % 4 &0& C$ !"?
.'
": "& C ! " ( ! 9" ?
(
.
++9 ") &. !! "!"
A9( (*
++9!#> FG- !@ ( ! .
-* "
! !.
"!
" ! ) ") "
1 .? " .
* !("!"!
" !) ")"
1 .? . "!
-"
*.
-* ") .
& "
.? <= 5
?7! * -"
").
G- !
.!(9 "):- !+ ''
&
+) " "
9( (
9 ! '
" ") 1 .?
*! +
/'+ !
!'
*'
$
* ") " ! .
! !/'+ "&!-* "! ( ! ! -!
& ?: .
* "!
"
?- +& ")
7 .? ( ! !.: "& % &-
!
9 ++?
& ".: " .
*..:
*: "& "
*
$> A ( !
!-** * !.
?-:.
+'
"& !.
%+-"
* +:09 ":'* "& !!-?8
"
" 5
*!-** * !?
") !-?.
&H &. !! "!9 ++9
&@
A0 9( (*
&! ++9!#>
F-* ") -*!
:'
"
'* . !
!
* !<=4
"& -.
!*
")
"!
"
1 .?
*: '* . !
! (
-"&( ?:0
!-** !-. !
B> + " .
* "
+
$> A !.: " .
( ! -!
"!
*:?- +& ") ( !!-** *(
".
%+-"
* +:!-?8
"'
"H
-*" :
A>
! !
"( !!
&
&
A "&+
&@
A (
!! ")
*0
!7
/'+ " ( !
& ! * " : "
-*" (
'+:"
&. !! "!(
"!*
++9!#> F !
&+: "
*&9 !?
.'+: ") * "?: :
"& & ! "
?-! "
!!
!
'"
I D
3!+ ' '
&3 9 ! ) '* !-*% :
. *.
")'* !+ ''
"! .
) "
*: )-* "&&" ":"
/-!9
?-! "
!!
"&&" '*
* " .
* "% & '"
H !! ")
7 ") "
"! &
"
A "&@
A( +&
!"'+
!* &9 (* !'
* * "0
:0
+ ")
-*"*&-* ")'
" :
'*
& ")!0
&*
"& !" &
*.
%+-"
*:"
-* "&0
0'*
" +-&
"
" A
))* ( !*& *0
"
+ ( <=0 & !. !!
+ ( ( +! & !. !!
3!
"!
E-
*.
' " "* *& !! ")
*(
-* !-?!
+E- "! 9?- " E- "!
* !
&8-&
" "&* *& ")9( ( *)-.
!(
&&* #> 6(
&-* ") : *.
!+ ! ! *.
7 ") "!J
6(
**
*. ! !
?+ ") !! ")
&& " .
J "-! '*% "
+.
" .
! -'"
&. !! "! " "
)* +'
:
0 9 ( " *!"
+7"9+ &)
.
: &. !! " ! %+-"
*: "& "
& ?:
* "* 0?
"!
&. !! " " " "
+: &. !! " !
& 9 ( " *
!"
"&?: !! )" ") % + & *
!"! *-!
+ .'-)"
& *& *! *
+!
.
&. !! "0"
A ++9 -'?: 9*
&. !! ""
@
A?- 9( + + ")( !*
-*"& &"
&. !! "
"!
:* '*
& ")!
) "D
+.!
9:
*!
99
7!
+ !
0& &
'+
! "& & "
.
7 ") &. !! "! ( ?
") &. !! "!"
0"
*+: 9:
*!
+!9 ":
!-''*
* "*'* "-*
"
&. !! " !!-?!
09 ( " !'
+7"9+ &)
"
& ..
+:*9 ( "*
!"
! !-?!
"& .
: ?
"!
6
"!9 ?% E- "! "!
"&"*
!" (+&
** & "
+: ")-'"
0& !. !!
+ <,44= <,44= <,44= <,44= <564= <564= <564= <564= *:
$ *:
$ *:
$ *:
$ " (