← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5032/2015dismissed

Hdfc Ergo General Insurance Company Ltd. v. Sumittra Devi & ORS

2023-10-09Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh7 pages

  

    

   

   

   

 !"#"  $%&'((  )" "   



 

    

  

    !"

  *  +,*"-.

 *-

#"$%&'

 ()!%* ")!+,!

-   .(% -* ")!+"

  )- /0!"#.1* ")!+ ,!

!" !2 3  *- /   2 -.

.

,."$%

+!/%#. -  ""  24233526  

"  $%  -  !//.

 "  /!%

!/ +*.0. -!

-!//.

1 3 -$ .,,+ !,-+ !,-./ ' 2 3 --.

!!.#-78(." .#-9 #"$!35 %

"-9 9!

:.#  ; +:'+!. !'

<<'=4>?9-.+-9 !9"$% ").#-"9

.

"9.-'

+!/% 3454352?!.#- 9!#9.-- +:! "$"", !".#-#!!"

* --"#!!"-. # !#9.-- +:  ;

"- +:/9.-++."!3454352?"-./- +:9 "

.)$%-/.#-""!-,!

."++."! .#-

."/..( . "9 :!-!

.9- -9

 "+ """  !2'@>;352?""3454352?9 +!

"".- +!+ "!.+.!9.- # "!-,!

."++."-- " "! /!

- 25*555;' /!- -.

/!-%

 %  +:9  6*555;'"- ! "! !-   4*555;'! =*555;'  /!-$%"!.#9!

: !,!".#'

!".#!,-#!!"

, !/- +: ? !.+ ").#- ".-!

!,  !//.

 "  ,."  9 .  /  9- .  -  "/."  -

.! -.!,/!% "/!%$9-./"-"+ ""

- !"/."--"+ "/9.-++.""

.#-+!

!, /!%/"- !"/."-,+ # ".#!9

-.!,- +:

.A .!!9) 9-. %.#,!

".

/.

!,-+./.+.!*

!?""--/!-%9# !,!.#-9 ?*555;' 6 -+./.+.!9  !+! "$%

!/%!-# !"-- /.

!/..$- .! -. !,/!% "/!%$9 ").#-"-"+  "."".9 , ""--!

..

-).#!

( ".+.!! .-+!/ .!.+.!-!- ) /

!,-+./.+.!9  !"." <   -  ".#  !,  -   *  -  ,!!9.#  .

 9 , /"$%-!//.

*,!

".

!

!,-+./.+.!&'

2 B-- "+ "!.#-78(." .#-/9.-   ++."  + .#  -.

 "-  "

.#  "  .  +!

  !,  -.

/!%/9.-- !"C 

 3 B--  -  +./  .

 ."  ,!

 +!/ .!  

+./"C.,% *9.-9-". C 

? .,*.,% 4 -+! ,!

-+./ D/."+./ !2/.  ). B'2" - !"+"+!%!, ""3454352?D'2"

. -.".  + ..!D'2;

* "+!%!,+-/D'3*!

/!

/ !

!,"+ "D'?*-+ .,.+!,"+ "D'6* +!%!,

+!.+D'<*+!%!,#.

.! .,.+!, +:

!'<<'=4>? 0 D '41 "+!%!,"

.).#.++!,-/ .#-D'= = -!- -"*- !" ./!% "

!/%,."!""+%)."+. !

!,-.

",+"

,.%-.

)."+9 +!

"$%!

*$%-!//.

 @

, - .#+! ,!

- *-!//.

"+.""

!2 3.,)!

!,-+./ '

!" !2 3"-"

-- 9 .! -.!,/!% "/!%$9 !"

").#-"-"+ ""-!  %!,-"+ "

9 @*555;' /!-"-#!,-"+ : 2>%

!  - $  !,  -  !

  /!

/  !

 D '? -  !  /!  !, +!/ .!9 ++"  - +-"

"/.. !,33<33 9  ."  "  ++!

".#%  -  !  +!/ .!  9  

"  

>*55*@@5;'0@*555E <5FE 33<331$%-!//.

9-.

.# -./#"9 "-/!% "-

++!/%9 -"

(!.%" ) %.$!%- ."/!!,+!/ .! !, . !,>F /, !/-"!,++.".. .G.!".,

 -9 ""/!9 !"!

."9.-.?5"% --/!%

"

+!/%9 -".$!%-. !-9 ""

/!- !,23F /.. .G.! > 8.# ## .)" '

+ !/%-  ,." -   25

-)- "-+! ,!

-  22 -+! ,!

'

+!/%9-.

..# -./#"!

- +!""--9 "

"$%- !//.

9!

- >*55*@@5;'.

!-.#- ."--/!-% 9# !,-"+ "9  6*555;' - $""$%-  . -.

+./.+.!"- *- 9 !!++ .!!

 !,!

- !//.

! +-+!+ .!--/!-%9# !,-"+ "

9  @*555;' - $, +!""-  +.!<!,- /!%  !/ .!  +  D

.!  H/!-%  9# I /  - /!!,9# "/"!$%$,!

/!-I ).+""!! .+"$!

+- # "- *.-. + -/!-%9# !,- "9  6*555;'!%$9 9 !#%

"  @*555;'$% -  !//.

 "  - *  -  ./#"  !

 !,  -  !//.

A.

!$/!".,."  !

!,-.

+!.! *-+! ,!

- - +" .+!-"+.

.!!, "-  -.#-!

.- 9 ".

+!/% ./."*  "$%. 8 +- #

/")J -J/ ." -

352? K?=4 23 -!- -"*-+! ,!

+./ '

2 39-. !

.#-./#"!

-  $/."-- 9!

:.#  +:!9"$% ").#-"-.

 /!-%9# 9  6*555;'"- ! "!!";!"-#!!"

.;, !/- +:,!

9-.+--9 ."$!

9# !,4*555;'!

 =*555;' /!-" +--!//.

.#-%

"- /!-%9# !,-"+ "  @*555;'.-.#-!,- !).

.! !, -  /!%  !/ .!  +    9    -  !.,.+.!  ""

?25<3525-! ,!

2 3- ,  #"- -+ 9 ,

"$%-+! ,!

-'

+!/%.

!.+$!- +  .-. + -/!-%9# !, -  "+ "  9   /!

  - 25*555;'    /!-    ""  .  - +!/ .!.+.!"- *9 .#-%

" @*555;'

/!-  .  -  .#-  !,  -  /D.//  ./.   !).""  .  -  /!%

!/ +-+! ,!

- !" !2 3- ,

+!""--,."$%-

+!/%" ) !$ ".

/.

" 2?

-)+! ." "- $/.

.! /"$%+! ,!

-   26 -!%.

.)!)" .- ,."$%- '

+!/%.

 !9-- - 9 "

"$%- !//.

"24233526.

( "  !$!

-!"$ "+" 2<

- + +./.+.!9 ,."$%  !, "!.#-78(." .#-#"$!35%

*9-!9

9!

:.# - ;+ +:'+!. !'<<''=4>?!9"

$% ").#-".

"9.-'

!/% -+./.+.!*.9 +.,.+%""--  .#/!

-25*555;' /!-*  %!,"+ "

 $.#+ 9 6*555;' /!-"- "! 9# 9!

- 4*555;'!=*555;' /!-$%"!.#$!

9!

:!,!".#'!".# -#!!"

, !/-,!

+:'+!. !.9 ) -+ !,-    !, -  "+ "  -  -  /!-%  9#  !, -  "+ "  9 6*555;'!%  !/-) / /".-+./.+.!*..

)."--"+ "9!"!,$ A.

"!" :!#(!

%

! ."-"

.#-+!

!,-.

/!%/ + 9.- +:'+!. !'<<''=4>? .

!".

"--9#+..# ./." /!% !/ +9  @*555;'-./!, ++."9-.+-!!:+!344352? -!I$ / !

. $0$  (1$2  $

"  "   $ '3  *$ $4 /  

 5(    $2  6 $ '  "  ,% "  $ %3 /   !7 8  -   *  -"  -  - /!% !/ +.

9, #.

.!/!$,.- 9!

:

"-.

"" .+ !,"-!,9!

:/"!++." + ""

.#".-+!

!,/!%/" -!"$+! "

+-"

"-/!-%9# !,9!

:/ 25*555;' /!- "++!

".#%9 ""+!/ .!!, 25*>3*@<5;'!-+./

. 24

-.#-!,-$!)".

+

.!*-/!-%9# !, "!.#-$.#

" @*555;'$%-!//.

"!

! ,, , !/%# ).,.

/.%!

 )

.%  -,+ "

+.

+/ + !,-+ 9+."$%-'.

++!/% .

%".,, , !/-!,- +  2= /!

  2   !).

!!+.!?5!, /!%

!/ +*!.

/..$#. %!



"$%

 -!//.



 $ .A .!!,9.

.)!)" 22$ $9$::$$ %3 "( (( $2*$ $4 $ %3 7 #8 -;*-!I$ D!

!$ )"-" - +-/!,- B!

:/I !/ +*-!//.

.

- -!

.%! ,+ " ./- -!#-.,.! .+- +!!,-!% !  $ .  A .!  !,  9*  .  $.#    9,   #.

.!    -.

D!

..!!,9- $ . "$%-!I$ /!

.( (2

<<$2";#   62:$%(3$ :

$ $ $ %3 "1  ($ 6 $ ':<$ 0,% "$ %3 "+.""!;")" 2@ !

-,!

#!.#  ! *!# !",!

. , +.

/"! .- + * ! $ .A .!!,9- $ .

"$%- '

+!/%9-.+- A.

"(".+.! 2> ! A%  -    ,."  $%  -  '

!/%.

- $%".

/.

"  7.

 *-8 )" "   $6 $ - % Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No