High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6635/2014dismissed

National Fertilizer Ltd v. M/S Kumar Brothers And ORS

2017-08-29Mr. Justice S.P. Bangarh10 pages

!"##$%&%'()* +

,#-&.&

( /0 1121

!"# $

%& !"# $

'

"# $

() *"

+,- ....

1213

"0 & #

'

# )1$

3 # #!4456$ 7#89!$

! && "

$ :

),+,-! *

2;! #

'

# )-2

2; < # %& ! &

$

** ,1,-,, 2; !3

$

& < #%& ! $

2; &

# $

'

# )-$ #& " * ,1,-,,

;

$ = & $

$ &! &

*

*# # # #/ 3

2;<%! *

* 2;

44 $

* &# > 9

1,,1 ''#5.-#4+ $

* 2;# # +,,,? ''#5.-# 4* * # # 2

@ $

# # ,,),,1

# # # " &

-,,,5!

*

@ # #$ " +A$* = ;$ $

) 2$ !

# $* # #>/

*

=

$+,+ 0# ) , &

) @

/

$

$-,5)3 * #$

& @

/ $

$ &*

# 2 2 ; # &

+,,,? @ $ &

&

> 9 # & 2 ; # &

B?A ;

;

2 ; ,,+,,> 9 "

,,, 0

2

$+,,C$ 2 &*

#

,?,,,*#*

* # $# # #0 $C# # $ ) D

! 3

& 2 # # * & ;

# 2 # # $

,?,,,#0#

$ " 2

2 &

# #3 1$# # ,,),,1

44

; "

*

$'DC #

2;

!*# "

*

" & $* $# #! * ! * & ;&

B?A - :

! %& ! #

$

&

$ ;

& ;

D& :

),+,- * ,1,-,, # *&

*

@ # $$

/

1,,1! @ & * 0$ $

## @ # $

&

+,,,?D$ # &

* @ $

# #!

*

$ @ # $ # &

2!

# $D/ # # 2

@ = ;*

$ # #2 # # # # #/ # $

$#C # /

2 #0& $ $ **

"

# # # $

# ;

$ &$ <%

# ;# # *$ : = $

3

*; '

# )619$ #!445E & 629$$

'

# )619$ # *$$

$# # # # 3 69 $ 2C # 3 69 # ## 2 2; &

2 *

2 3 629 # ## 2 2; &

2 *

2$ C '2C # 619$'

# )$ # & ;*

B?A$ @ ;$-;$

4 $* * + $

&3

$

&

# !3 $

"$ ;

2

2 5 $#

& &$

# $ #

" * ,1,-,,!

# # ,,),,1 +,,,?

*# #

= &

#$ # # # = & *

"

2 # #/

$ !1?!51,C = & *

= & !++!5,,C/ *

BA$ ?,,,?

;

/

2

#

$ A?A # ;

;

; ,,+,,!

*

BA2

$ # & #

$-;D

B?A #2

#

$ 0 ; * -;$ $ * <%

# #

'

# )- & 3 # "

2; * 2;

& # 2 D #

# ; *

#$ # # 1 D* 2 & $ #

* * 2;E 82

'

3 !*

#

$

$3 /

'

3 :F3 "

'* ! ,,)69 3 63" ++- ,,)6+9'331,+

44 "

!

" " !

#

!

$ " !

"

" " %

&'!" &

( "

$ %

"

"

) ! *++

,-

..

/

! 1

2 ,- 3 "

4 ,-

2

,- ' "

,-

!

! " "

!

!

5

(

$!

2

,65

"(

2 , - "

,

-

!"

$

"

4 ,

- "(

"

! 4

44 , -

"

" "

" "

" 2 , -

,-

"

5

!"

,- 3

!"

"

5

7 5

,

-

2 ,- !"

,-

!"

7 5

%

! "

5

!

!"

7 5 "

!

,-

5

5 !

!

"

!

,- "

84 ,-

2

,- ' "

,-

!

!2 ,-

,9-4 ,-

/,/- 5

"!

"

! 2 , -

!" " ! 2 ,

-

!

:;<.

"

4+4 "! !4 ,

-

! "! !

1 " "!4 , -

"1 "

!

:;<.

" " "! ! 4 ,- "!

!

"

" " 4 , -

!!

"! "

,

-

" "! "

(

= =

.

5

" '

3 # $&&$%!"#.%67#-&8#-&.&#69% #8#6:;#'"."9-%"< 1 )

66% !

>

?

!

5

" 6@ "

"

!

$

5

" >

? $" " " "

"

" 6 "

>

?

! $ # "

$

5

5 5

$

"

!

"

(

4*4

(

$

(

5 A

$ ! >

?

>

? !

" & $'

3 ! 3

$ $

$

& * $

*2

" *>

= $$# " "

>

& ;$ "

& $

>* & 2 # #;/ 3

$

!$

& ;!* "

!& $

!

" $ 2 # #; 2

2

#0 # # $ 3 > &

"

**# "

2 # # ? ; ; &

$'

# )- * * 2;

E 82

'

3 " & !# $

# !

$

$#= 2

$# #

!

# #

* # #

= $$#/

# #$# $ &

*

* &

# ; $ $ &

*

!$

&

*& :2 # &# 2 # $

&

&

$

/ " * @

2; 2

" * " * @

2; *;# 2

& * 2 # #;/ # & $# # ;$$ &

2

# &

*& 2;2

4)4 !

*

*&

$

$ &$ # 2

"

2 &

3 $ " *

@

2; 2

" * 0 " *# ;" * @

2; #

$

*

# $# # D

# # # "

0 # $ " /

$

;

" 2 $

<%*

3 *

* # " # $

/

* # 2

2 #

=

2

$ 0 $ @ # 3 &

$

2

#C #

# # 2; 4 3

$

BA 2

B?A/ &

BA$

&*#

&2 $

/ * ,1,-,,

* & $ 0 & ;

,,+,,/

* 2

;

B ?A # ;

;

2 ; ,,+,,'

# )619$

#

" $ # $ / '

#

!

" "

"

"

"

"

"

4

"

"

!

"

"

"

"

$

3 69 $ '

# )619 $ # # ## 2 2;&

# #2 *

*

3 629 # ## 2 2; D # &

$ $* $; !* #

B?AD

# ! &

),; 0 ;

B?A $ ,,+,,

$

'

# !

;2

B?A$ $* *

&

$

),;0 ; E &

!

*

* 2

;

B?A$ $* /

$

! **

* # &

B?A D " * $ # 2"

! & $

$

## & ; # = ;* ,1,-,, &

),+,- $$ .=.&")3 + 121 C( ("C G

' 0 &

G

2