← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/208/2013allowed

Comm. Of Income Tax-Ii, Chd v. Narender Kumar Gupta

2015-01-08Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu9 pages





            

  !"# #$%&   "

''())( * '

#+%"#(,#"

-----..

//#!

   0 #  2 '# .!# -----

). !

 3   453 - 1 055  453 - 1-1-65

) !

3)- 7#)"("

,,#%7 #!

%*!"

#..

//#!- 3- #7(1"#8#%7 #!

%# 3--3-3,#%7 #!

%*!"

 ). !-

055%-9 5:

   





   !

$$ %

&$&'!

(  ) &)&!

( !

* +

$$+  $ , $+-  . /

 !

 

!

  

0  ! 1! 23 %  0 !!1113 $ 0 2!4!2123'





$

*

+* 

$"



2 46

$

$



 $  

7 

 



 /

 

!

9&$  

$+



# 

0 2!1!3

$

: "

" $$

$$"





7  8 /

 

!

9&$  

$+ 



;

<



2 46

$

$



$$+ 3 4%'%'



0 !2=!443

  



7

 $  

 8 /

 

!

9&$  

$+ 



;

<



2 46

$

$



$$+ 0 !=!=3 

"

 >  



 $

  

*



 

78?



 



$

  

" =

$ 0 44!=! 3 $

$"



0 !54!23

 

 

0 4! 4!=53 

$"

0 !2=!443 @

4%'%'

@

=4(

=5 %

&

&'

$

# 

 "

 A3 B 0 C 

0 5!! 53

"  0 !3



@ D:!

A3 @ @  D

@$!

A3 D @  (!

A3 B E (



A3 @ @ F

@$



0 2!1!3 $

 







 $$

0 !!1113

A3 B E (

!

@ @ @ F

@$!

A3 @ @  D

@$

A3 D @  ( $





 0 !=1!3

$



 "

$$+

26

0 !=!=3



0 2 $ @

5=(

$$







$

$

(%'!



 = !

0 2 $ @

5=(







$

$ $



$$+

($

 

:





$$



  

0  ! 1! 23 

# 0 2!1!3!

0 !2=!443

@

4%'%'

0 !=!=3

$$+

"



 



 

+$$

( %$'!

(  %

&(%'& 

 

 





!



 + $"



$

$

$

"

  $ 

#

 +

$$ $"



$

 :



 "



+$ 



0 2!4!2123!

 $"





 "

#$ $

 !



# 

 " !

"

 0 !3





$

"!

  $$$



($





$$

$





!

 !

:

!

:

* 

 $"



 



$$

$" 

: 

 (

.''())( * '

#+0)-1'!-1#!)"#( ? %'

=5 0 4 <>9?

($

$ $ 

: 

 (

."

''())( * '

#+%

#!(#/#0)-1"(;#$2 '#1(,/# ?!

4!

1  4 /  

$





$

$







$$

$!

+$



,

$$+ @

4% '

$



"







$

 0 !3

(%'







$$  





0 !!1113 $

0 2!4!2143

 $ !

 

$



 $$

$

* "

,





$ , 

 

$

@$  

<$$ ( $ )

  $"

 "

$ !

$"

+*

$$

/









  $ $+



 $

$$"









 $$!







 $$!



  

$

$



#

+$

 

$"

$"

 

$

#  3  

<$$ ( $ )

% $

$'



$ 





+ 

#

  

$$ $









!

$$+-  .

'

7





$





 #

  

$$





$

 

$+-      

          

  

 



 

 !"



 ""  # 

 $%%&'( #  ) *

'#

+$  ,

 +$ -.   

  /  ,00"  ,

  ,  1

,00"    +$  , 

 ,

    ,00"   

" 

#   30       

   )   

  +  ) 

     !+$ .)   45

"

  

   #  3   

 # # )

+6 

#  +$  !  ,

    78  .



 

   

"          !  # 

#  "

' 9    " 

   # #  " 

+-  .

  ! +#  "

 +$  5  2  ,

    78  .



 

 

  !"

&5  ( +

8

  !  ! +$6

:

  +,   !#  "

;

 7 ,

  

:

" 

"   #  

*  

  33  

   "

  

 , 

 ,

          + .

  !  "0&+ 2"< ;4'4%4'(  3   "0   #+ 0   #+$, 

,

 

"     #   *   

 = $



$



$



3

G 





 





 





$$

$

$ $"

:



$





#

$



$$+-  . $"



 



 $

$"

$





 

$

$



<;

; 3@$ ; <$$ ($





$

  $   



H !

$  





$$"

 

 

 $$

@









$$"

+

 #



 

"



"





$

 $ 

$ +  

3  %5'

=5   $ 

  

 ,





"

$  A3 9 ( 

(  $

 

$ ?

$!

+!



$

 

 



"



$





 #











 $"

$"

56!

 "

 $ 

 

$

!





!





 :

/ +$

$*

$"

+

"



$$ +

$$!

 

#

$$"

+



 

 $ 





#

$

=

$

$$"



!

, $+ 

 +



 $

 

$"



$

$$

 $



"

$

  :

 :



$"





$

(, $"!

+ $$+

$!





   !



$

, $+ 

 

 

$

:



$+

<

 

$$ $!

(  ) &)&!

( !

  2

< 055=     I"!

2

<-1-65= @ @ @+$   SHAMSHER SINGH 2015.01.13 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh