← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3967/2010dismissed

Kailash Kumar And ANR. v. Anil Kumar And ORS

2016-09-02Mr. Justice Arun Palli21 pages

       

  ! !"#$#%&!' !()!* + 

,#-$.,/(*%0% .!* ''!--% $ 1$   %#-,/(*%0 .!*$   !$'%0!% $ 2& 3 4224   

    



     

 



  !

!"# $%!

" 

!! 

& !"# $%!

"

  '! ( )

%   '!!

  *



  '+  24+   

     

       

        

           

  !"#$      #%&  



 " 

'("        )   #%&   *  

 

   +(   +( , -    



   .        (&  " 

     '("* 



   #$#/#00( *    $ '   +$ '          ( 1                   

            +#                     



          



      *   2   3*3

 



    2   

   

*     "  

     

    

     3*

+#$6%7$#!#0!#  (6#/#0!$     *              

 *                      



*     $ 8   +$ '   

 

     (&" 

         

  1                       9 3*:

      ; <# =          

     



>5   ) >4 ( =         >

 48 $ =    2   2 

 >4 ? =           *     

 2  >48 ' =           >48 & =      >48 6 =   

 2  >48 ! =     *     *   >48 0 7  @ '    )    /0#(#00?=# 

  )     

  *  



  )      

 * 

   *   2      3*:

 3

 *     

 

    2        A *      )   

                  *       )   * 

  *     *  

  A      

         

        

                      +(    !         *   

*     +#

5       * 2    /0/'#006 &    *      

         +&*        9 

       

 "  



?#7  ($33



  2      

    

 

    *   

     6                       3

 94+'(//#     3

  (0##(//&   

  "  9 

      * 

    ; <B  0'#006     

3

        *   

   ; <+= 5     * 



     *   

     )    *           5      "#//&#00'+  

*      *   

  C*           D2   *                   9 5

6         2      

2        *    9  *          9

  A    B     

 2  *                      8 

    E    

 @ 5*    

*    

       9 

3

        *      

 3

   2         *               A *          9 

     

  





  

       

    *           9 

       *      *             5* 

     9 

    

    

3

     

    5   +(    !      

      *            

    

* A *                



   *        *                        *    *           9   3

     0'#006      *    2    C*                     

             *  2       

*  

   AD 

   2.% *7%8#*#  /*/+  2.%  (!$.9*8#*# * .!  ! 2.*$. *%0% .!*+ 957#066

&(!    

 ; <  D           



5                

    





  *  

       

              A    

* 

  



    

    *  

         

     

          

      

               **   @ 5*   

 *     AD 

  

  

   9 

        5 +( ! 5

+#        

*    0'#006C* 5 +(

!                  5

+#      5    *   

            9   3

                      

        "     9 

   @

  !  

       9 

3

   

 "      3*:

    *  *        

 

    

           4 +( !   

      +( !  *      

      *    *               9 

3



              

2  *      %        

 +( !   2  

    

       *  

 

 3

           4  ?# 7  (6 33    "    *           



  *  0 1     *            3

 * 

   +#$ ' 

     *     +(   

       ((##(/#( 



   +&                    7   +&

 

:

    

       *          9 

           

                   

      +(  ,   -            * (&"    

                +$    '  A       +(, -          +#B  "           *  

  #/

 3

F  3       

     

 

  2 

    9 3*:



 *   

 2  *        

7  9*     

     2    /0/'#006      7

 *  

   *  



"

   3

  /'/?#006 (//'#0065  * #$##(///

     *         9 

 *  

             *    

   

 4 ?#7  (633

    

  9 

         

     /#/&(/#/ A    

                *  

  ; # * #$##(///G7

9* F "

     ( 9   9* 4 3   "

  * * #$##(/// $               *  :     #0!'!& 



  -     

 

  *

   G7  9*  #$##(///

    *     ; <5  G  7    9*  F "

            ;

#  ?%?%#0065   *  



  

   

 (  

   #$%?%#006  5    "   C

 A 

 5

 H  7     3 

 +  8       3    )      

 ((%'%06



 (/%'%06       $  5 



  '%?%06 (/%'%06   5*    

8  

 % G7  9*

5  

         *   



 " 

      

 8 ;#$%##%(/// 8  

 ;F "



 % G 7  9* @ ##         

    *        9 3*:

    )     9*

*    



"     

3

      /0/'#006  

   2           9   3*  :

       9* *     

(//'#006 #(       

   

     

          3*:

    

     *   



   2         "   

 2     

         

                   *     =      

)  

    )          A     

    9 3* :



   *      

  *  

=

  =        

  *  

  )    =     )  

  

 A   

 

       9 

 (##((/// 

"  3*:

    

 

   *  

 

 

   3

 3

D (0##(//& 94+'(//#*       *        #$       

   

       7  7 #0!'!&*    *     *    *      *        9 



   "   3

 A   

          9 

 *            *     

           #? , 3         +# $ '  

   

 

  +# '       

  

        

    /0#(#00?                /0/'#006     *        )  

 )     /0#(#00? A   *           /?/?#006            *        

  *       

             



   

    *     *   A        

          3

  94+'(//#

          *    

   3

  9 

3

 



      

      *                          

  *       3

      

          *      #' A*    

*

        

   

 

  *  

       3*:

   *    

    3

    2   *   (0##(//& 

94+'(//#      3

      4 ?#7  (633       *          9 

 

  

    #& A*   

              

 

    3*:

     

 /0#(#00?; <3  )     3  

  *   (#(0'

  *     @  4(#/(#00'       



   

      *   

    

  2   ('/?#00' 4('/?#00'    =

   =   )     

2   /6/&#00'    

 2   /?/0#00'        4/?/0#00'       

   

   (#/(#00' 

  2   

   )  =    

*  2   /?#/#00'   2   ###/#00'               <9  

        ###/0'  

    @               ###/0'   

2   (##/0'   2  

  ?##0'       I         2    ('##0'            2      !#(#00'  

 4   2   #/#0&<

    @

5 4#/#0&      ; <

               +  =     ($(0&   )  @ 4($(0&    

        )                   ($0&4 

    

   

2   #0?0&   )   D      2  

        (!'0& 4(!'0&   *   

       

    +&    6         9     *    ($60&  (&!0&  



  #//0#00&       

 2   !##0&     

4 9  2  

   *     &#(0&   2     4 (/#(0&I   2   

6#06 

(##06 4  (##06                        

 +&6         2   ('(06  *    4    9 3*:

      <4  =      

     

6     *       

  )  @    

      2      !?06  4 !?06      =           2        0'06  *    2    76'%   E    0'06               

  *     

        "#/&0?  *     

2  



2    9    *                 *   *            #6 A*   *  

       

           = *   

    )            J * 5      

          *     *   ('(06   '

    *     *      = 

             2      

 $    ?

        %       

      D      2              4 4$ ?

 *   2  

 

     

  

 * 

         *       4    ('/(#006     D       

    )             -           

     ('/(#006      2      /!/?#006  * 



= A * /!/?#006   2    /0/'#006 =             =

  

('/(#006   *       E

          2  

)   *   

        5      

 

   2    I  *             

   

     3*:



    )   =  )        )    =    ('/(#006   #! +  

   3

 9 

 *    *           4 ?#7  (633A * 

 *   *  

        *   *   G7

  9*      #$##(///        *     

        

  /0/'#006    

 

G7   *  *  

 /?/?#006     

  

        

           

    )    )      



   /!/?#006/0/'#006         D   

3

*  *          3

2     

  

*    

    )  

              )          ('/(#006 #0   *      

 

      +#B  "                     

  #/

      3*

 

+#$6%7$#!#0!# 

:

5 3F "

   "        2   #%&    '(,      

   

       $/#/#0!#

    *   

  

           *   

: * 

    *      *    *     *               (6#/#0!$ 9                 (#/##0!'          *

       

      +#      +#                      "     

    

    

(/         

  

#/ 

    2       *         

%   2  





                  +# 

    *               %  

      (# 9  

              3

  

 

        *    

    

   

   

                      

 :

5 3*  (#/##0!'  

     *      

 

       *             

*    *   

    

 

 *                

 



    )         *                     A   

         * 

    #0!'      (#/##0!' 

      *                  

         

      

   

                          4 $07  (9 33  *  (#/##0!' ((  *   *   

 3



      2   

 

       3

                  

 



        

3

 94+'(//#I         3

                         * 

         )          

      )  J*

          *     *   

   #0!# #0!$   *     

  

      ($

 *     *   

  *        3

       "     

9 

      *   2   

 D  D  * 



   5 

    9 

    *        

   *     

               

            *  

   

*      #0!'!&4*      

     *    *        3*:

   E

 *   2    

#0!'!&   *     *     "                      

  )     

 

    (? 3

5   

                       



  *  

    *       

    94+'(//#

       

   

3



     9 

 ('               

*                     

9 

       3

 3

                      7'///% ;24<   !' !()!* + 

   =  " %   I %+ = 

 I %+