← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3977/2010dismissed

Charanjit Singh Walia v. Surinder Mohan Singh And ORS.

2017-07-13Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi12 pages

     

 !

"#$ %$&'(')* 

+",")-'#').+/"0'"

11$00")# 2( 3,')%$, +")').+")%#+$,( $(1)%$)#(  * 45  / 56  

  

   / 567 5!

 

         

         ! !

   

!

 #  

 "

  $ % &  !

 



 '% '% ())* ! 

    "



   

 (% '( %'') +    

 (



"     "

- .



/"

  0 "

 1   .



2  

    

 

     (3%  2 (3%   2   *( '4 ()&)  #    (3% 

   %) '4 ()&)   

 "  ! 

    ! 



. 6  7

6



6   . 6 "     #  

   1 7

6



6 

     "



 %) '4 ()&) # 

  7

6     

 %) '4 ()&)  # 

   (' '% ()4% 1     ,      

 

  #  7 7

6

$ ( &   !

 

  !

        "  

"   !    

 (38 

  

 (38         "0 

  

   # 

"    

     1   " 0!

  

""    ,      !



  0 

   0  0    %' '9 ()4&  1

       

   :

 " " "



   .

   



!  " 

"      ; 2     < "    " !

  ( 5   "

.



"

  = < % 5



 

.



"

 2    = < * 5 #    %) '4 ()&)

  = < 5 7

6



6  2 2

     "



 %) '4 ()&)   "



    "

 = < 5   #  $ % & 

    = < > 5



 < %*  = <;

& 5  

 !    "

 "





= <;

5

 



6

= <;

) 5 $ (% (>     

8    =



 = <;

('

5 $ ( &       



6 = <;

(( 5

 '9 '( ()4&

    $ ( &  

  



 = < (% 5  

   

  

= < (* 7  1 %) '% ())% !

 

  " (%

  $ % ?

*   !



6

  (38 

 



   

  $ ( &= <;

(%+ 5 $ ( &    



6   = <;

(% 5 . 6 #  

    :



 

 = < (%;

 $ (%2

 ! $ ( &    . 6 

7

6



6 = <;

(%@ 5 $ ( &   

   

  "   

   !  = <;

      0

     

   " ! 

9    

  



  

  "       #  

      " 2       "   #  

 %) '4 ()&)    #   . 6  

    

!

 #  



; $ % &  !

 "

 

 

2  "

 '% '% ())* /

      

  !

    .!       

  ! 2  /     " "

   



 (% '( %'') . 

    

     .   + 



                2   !

 2   , #  



  

  "   !

 

  .   

:

    

     #    , "  ," . 6

    !

  

  "

!

   

 2 

 < %*  * 

   AB  C D

!

""

 !   

@# ('



        !

"  

        

  

 !



"

 



"

     #"

$%&'() %

*  " *  ++,(,) ( -).%( /  ) ,      1    ++'

(11#)& & 2-  # 3    ++'

() ( -)

.(045) 5   0    ! 

        

 '% '% ())*      

   !    "

   ;

  - 

 (% '( %'') .!      "



    ;

  - 

 (% '( %'')     

 '% '% ())*  ! 2 

 



 "   "  '4     %& '9 %'')    ('

 0

1   *& 



1  %)* 

 

 +        (8 '& %'(( 1 "  " 

   5  "

 

(8 ') %'(>   

 "           

/ 

"   %& '% %'(&      

   (9 ') %'(> !         

 '% '% ())*  1        

   "  %8  $ "

     #  2% 2&  $ 4*'*2 %'(& !  !

 

0





  

    ! 

  



      "





  #      

 



;        

!

"

  ,  ! 

  /   



     %) '4 ()&)   #    ,  ! "  *( '4 ()&) . 

 0      #  "  ," . 6

 .!        !

   

  "

   " 2   ,

  ,"



6    

" 

  ;       ," 7

6

  

  2  

"

!

 #  

   !

 # "

 

  

  

 '% '% ())* .

         !

!

  

"  " 

 ,  

    < %*  * 

  

   1 

"    

   ! 2 2 

!

"

     !

  ""

   ! !  

 

"  " 

  + 



     ;

  -

 #"

       !     

   1      

 *& *4

" !     

 

        





 

     

  

 



  

   

 

 !"# $          

%



       &  '

                



 

 !"# $ (







        

%





     

%



 (      (  

 

 !"# &   

       ) **

      

%



   

  

%



&   (     

 

 !"#          '

            ) 



 

 !"#   



 &            +,       

        

%



       

%



 

 

   -(

&

      

 

 !"# 

      

%



  

   % 



&

   ./%  



   

 * # !"" 011 1

 020. 3(    



   

42  



 

   (   

&   

 



 '

 0111

3(

    

   2   



  4   

%



 & 

 3



   

    

&    



 5

   3( 

  

          (  

  $   



 

  

 '

      

%



                 

% 



  

        

  &  

           '

      

 

 !"#

 



   

 

%



           &    

%



 

  %   

   

  &    (   

%



 $    $ 





     '

        

%





   

%



  

(

  / 

 6 &

0  2  7 2     

(

     ( 



 

 !"#        

   

%



  

 

   &   

    7%

1  6 &

0 2    

 & 



      





 

   

0 2  7  $   7  



 

) *

# (     & 



        9:

:

 7    6 &

0    





 

   

    '

   



) *

#  &      

  



  

     

%



 

&           

 

        

%



  

) *

#          '

 $

      



     '

         

 &   4 ;

        

    



"     !

.    :

 !    :

  !



   ! 

 :

 

 

      !  #

 

 

 , (''



  

    " !

 ! .F "

","<")")"-$)%,")")%")#+$,2( 5$=(+><",-')'")% #+$,(7

9! :8 $  

   

      "      " 

  !

 

  

!    "    

  $

 

   " 7     "

 

    "

 !     ? / 56@ (* '& %'(&   (  5 0 3 G3$ 5  G3$