High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5104/2015dismissed

Renu Mehra And ORS v. National Highway Authority Of India

2020-11-27Mr. Justice Sanjay Kumar31 pages

!!"" # $"%& '( () !

**** & +( #,- "./ 0.'

$, "/+ '". $ 1 "

#,2 . 0 !!""

3 -"./ 0.'

4/& ) /& 1,,. 0 ! ****

665)) " +( ! $"%& '( () , ! !!" &""' "2 7 5 85)) " +( !!"" 2 2! "& "

&"( 2 5 965)) " +( !!""""' "( 7,& !"(+ ' 2" '

& !!"', !!

! +( / !25 50"!!"$ 6

66 -( . / !25 "

: :! +( 5 !!!"'"" 9! 0'!!"$ 5)) 9 " 2 2 & ;

2 ' +( " : :'! !!"' 2" ! . $"%& '( () +0(.< $%)< !!" /6 + 5".88: +0(.< 88:<)'" & : " " = &.

2.+5$8 ;

'!" +( !!"" /6 88: +"' !

(522.2.

'!! + /6> $"

%& '(.8: +0(.< 8:<-( +"

' . + 2 !" !!"" 2!& 2 ' $9 6 / +0" & 2? @ 5"".2 2!'' 2 @ " #""&#,.2. !0 8: 3.+ !!". $9: 98 ' " + 5 +(

" ' +( @ .'

'" ' @ 22!' 2$9: ' " +(;4!"/& '

"$98 '" +( $2"1 2 ;

+4" +( ! /6 88:." 2!' 2 0(2' $9 6 2 +( +" ' . ' 4 +( " " = &.2. 6 ;

@ " !""5& -. ", !!"" . '

" "" 5&( 5. 2 +( / +0" & 2? @ 5"".2. ' $9 6 -(22 8 :." = & 5 ""' + !!"!!"(& 2! .A ! @ ( 2 ' $ 8. & @ " + ' ' ")@ . " = & " !!"" $9: '" 2!B .A! @ ( !!""$98 '" 2!B 6.A!@ ( .' "" (+ . !!"" $9: " 0'

!!" . 5 65)) :. & !!"" $98 : '

" ' 5&( - +

' 6.A'

" ( +' "( .A!@ ( . & " '5&(;

" = & ! ! 8 :. ""'& 0' !!" & 2!!(+" !!""9: 6.A!@ ( &.+(22 ! ! $%)<0'!!"$98 9:

. "$ 9 9 :" +(/ "1 2 . " = & " " ''" "(6C 2! .A!@ ( 7 ' $ 8 2"( :.A!@ ( ) 2'

". : :.'

!!!"

2 !+ 2" = &.' ! 2 8 :! 5 65)) :9: .

' &2! !!""B 6.A!@ ( . 5 5)) 92+" +( $%)0' : : "& " ! 0'!!"" !!";

!!" ' +( " = & 9 2! !!"+" !!""'" :.A!@ ( . ' ' +( / !2 5 & ! $%)'!

! " !" !!"

& & !!".2 '" / !25 2 !!"" +( $%)& ! !!" ' 2! ! 2 " + !!" !!"""%'0.< . / !25 "(7! &00+ 2'

$%) ! "& @ ! &+ "2 " !!" " + '2 ""!"' '"! +( 5 +&. 5 ! &'

#,- "." ". 2 2! !!"' " +& &0"

.2 ".

+ &0"

$ +. / !25 +0 !9 2 !!" " +, !22 "(.2 2&2.+ ' 5"" ! 2.2(+ +( 5 "& +" 2!2%'0. ! 2'"2 "( !

! '+(& 4 2 !!" ;

" 2 ! 8 2 . '

&""( !!"+ '2 ""!"' '0"+"+ &+ 5

)""0 8 8 ! 0'3 50"$9 6 8/?3 50"$8:6

9& $ 9 9 :" +(/ "1 2 .

/ !2 5 " & " ' " (0 2! ' " 0 "D 2;

/ !25 +0 /?3!& !!"" '""! & . ! +( $%) " "'(+72 ! &. 2 ' " 0 &"& 2+" ;

0'!' &"(" ' "+( $%) & !!""< /&"(. +( $%)+ / !25 ' !2!72( +!!" 0 & "" " '+& 2!

! ' 22" +!!" 22"" ."!!0"'7 2 2! !!".'

+((! "

. !!" + '2. ! " "

!!"& 2@ 52& . !!""' 7" 2 & : ," 2". +& 1 ' 1 $9A 9:.88A :8.89 A 8 .1 $:9AA . AA . . 8A.

AA.A6...A9.

A6. 6A. 6A .:8A:..A.A

A #""&#,.; " 2 . ," 82"' @ ' & "& 3 ,2$"%& '( $%$.2128 12 9:. & & 0""&2;

/ 6 8: '

6 9;

" /6'!

+" >D 6 8;

"7" @ ' &$% $212:9 129 ++

/ +0" &.2.'2 52! ( 2? @ 5"" +0(. < 5?< /6 8: 2 2!!(+" @ " #""&#,.' $9 6 ;

. &D @ "

8 E5&(5&()5&(2! " '

&22" 5&(-0 22"!" $%$ '+& & '.2""+ 5&(5 & " "!" 4&5&(-" '

22"!". +" 2F&& 5""&5&)2! & " "" . 2 + " 5? " , 2!""( !72 " @ 2."

& @ " #""& #,' &$% ' $ 8 8 52!'' .A!@

( 8: ! 22" " ;

22" " ' 7 & 5""< 22"" 2-" #""&#,;

7 & " "" "0 5? " '+&@ $% ' ! " 0"0 "" (! " E & " ".22" " ' 22"!"% 20 $%.#,' '' "2

!" 5!. 2. 2 &' 22"A "0 "6( %", 0 " '+" !& % '

20 2#""&

" !! #,-(!' $%#,#"" -(!. & " "" & "2 ' '& 0"!2 "' !+(!

+ " %+0 " '

'2 + 2& 2!' $ 8 8'.. " + & +( + " & !' !'

" " : '" '

'!!72"( '( 2 2$%-(!%+0 '

20 2 #,#"" 2$%. & & '( 7 " /' G" "" $ ;;7" "".

21 & ' . . " & '

""( 22" % 5""< 22"" : " -" ' .A!@ ( 8:! 22"

.' :.A!@ ( '

' ', 99!. & "" 2 2""(% +7 22"" $%-(! +0 5""< & $% -(! " 0+7 '22! 22

& 2,!2! " #, '(2$% " 2$%% ! 5""< ( :..:.A!@ ( . " 2 +!" "& 2!!(+" " ' & $% #,#"" -(! ) 7 2, 5""<'!!72"(C 2,%. .

C "0 5""< (

98 6C" 2 C " " % & -(! '" 22"!"'""2& " "" .+ & $%. 0 6 5&5!! " & . " " " 22"!".+& +' # )"/ " 2$%;

" '""

+( 2

5&(5. +4 0&&2$%"" " !;

!!""<" "" &( 5? 7 5""< :. .

:.A!@ ( 5&(" !!"(&C " !"

6C" 2 B C. " '7 8.A ! @ ( . 2& B 6.A ! @ ( ' ' / 6 > 8:. +&& 2!!!"+" 22"" .A! @ ( @ :!. & 2 2""( 5&(-"

& '. 21 ;

5?' 2+8.A!@ ( @ 6 !. & 2 2""(2! &( 52&5&(5" . 5?+0 &("

& " "" 4&5&- 5" & " ' 22"!" 0&& " $%#,#"" -(! ! ! 6 "!!" " " %!!" 5""< 22"" ( : " ..:.A! @ ( '

' ', 99!. &

2 2""(%"' 22(.!/ 6>

8:.BC 2!

' 2!' +( 5?. !!""20 !!" /6> 8: . ( " '& " " ' " 22" ;

( "2 + !

+( 27! " ' "!" & 2. " 4 !!('

. 2 (" A/ >!5

A1 ,; &52!(.'+&

. !!"" .' +! / >!5'

" . !!"".' +!1 ,; &52!(;

. .

7 !!""' +'

"2',&2!"( ;

("2 @ " '2!!

0&2 2 !2(+40!

& ' ! " ! 7!!" 7&

;

( "2 ( &2 9 & 2 ""@ !!&

! @ " ;

( "2 ( & @ 22! + !

2 (;

( """0!!', !

!& 0 " @ " (+ + "" ( " + @ ;

( " 0('

+ " 22"

0 "2 @ " "!" " !!"" " ' $ 8 8.'

2!'!&& .A! @ ( 8:9! "2 " '" 2-(! 222"!" & 2. " ' & " 2 5&( 2, " ' " +" 6.A!@ ( ;

("2 +"9," 9 2" " '" @ "!20"

"( & 2! /6> + 8:BC 7 @ " ;

(" & 2& " & + 2 7&!" /6> 8: ..A "& 2 ..A ' " &. & !" + . /6> %'0. +(+" ' . !

( 522.2.4 !";

. ' $9 6 ! +( 5? 2 ! ""(. " @ ' 22"

" 5&(5.'

+(2!B 99! + 2 %"72 3'%"@

" @ '& " " @ "'(2#,#"" -(! '"(&0. ( ' +(%! ! " " .""5&(5 2!'& "(7 % 6.A!@ ( '!!"+" " @ ""(!+ @ "

+ '

"7& 2! ' %" 5? +4 +( ! !""(! @ " 2 "!% &"( " ' 2 & 2! 2 !!" &&0 +( "' . !!""" +5$8 + " "

= &.2. /6 88: ""' "2 2;

. ( 2!' +( 5?' @ +

4& "2 2;

( +4 !" +( 2 + !! !!0 " '& " "+ . . "

22" ;

( 0 2.'

' 0+" + +. 2""(+" " ' "" & " "" ;

(! " + #,#""

-(! "2 2, ' " +"

6.A!@ ( ;

(!( & ' ""' "2! /6> 8: "(''72 +( !!""+ " "= &.2..>5 .

+ . !!"" "" !!""4"(7 /!"3'( 6 0 D& 2 !! + "" @ >5 " 0" 72;

. !'(.'

'2, F7%"2 !!2 +'0 " ' '+ H !!!! ( &' 2H + "&2 H & !,&' % +4 !" +( !!"" + " ' & " "+ . . " 22" % 22 "2 2+" " ' "" & " "" / !&"(. "2 ! 2'" + " "

= &.2. "(F7'" +( !!"" 0 '" +( 2>5 2, " ' " +" 6.A !@ (

) 72.>5 +4 " '!

( 6% 2 + & &"" ' 2!" 2 %"2 22+ '

" ' &7 +( 2% 2 5? 0 ! !7 2!2 2!' ' 22"0"

% 2' ' 2,0"

+ ''& && 5""< 2' 99!% 2 2! +' "2 '0

!% 2 !!( @ '0 !"+ "2 + ('"" + 2 -( : . " " = &.2. 2 +4 +( !!"" /6 88:;

. +0 ! @ ( /6 88:'"2 " !!"" (!! 0 &"'

& . " + '0"

;

" = &+0 + "" !"A+4 &0 % "' @ +2 '4 &2! ' 5 "' +0 ""&+"' &0 !! "

. ( "

+&% 0 " +

+ 0 .'

+( +& ' 5? 2!%" >5

G 5? 0 ! ! 2& 2! 2 2!

+' 22"0"

!!( ' 2,0"

. " "= & ' 0 2>5 <"2 & " ! ( 6 @ " "

! " %+0 2 "'

" & 2 !'

@ " '!

( 6 " 2 % '0 !0 2,! " ' " +6.A! @ ( 2! ' ' @ % &"( " & !!"" 4 ! )& : !!!"'! /6 88: &.2(+ @ " $%) !0 8:+ ! ' @ " !

+" !

!. & " " @ "'.""!!! +!0

8: "( ! " 2@ + " !

'&D +( / !25 9 8 !"#

!$%& '( ) %"

! ' "* #+!

,( '-+ .

+- "/0 #'!/! -+ #+" %- (12345 #!#- 44326;

.6= &- / !25 +0 8:2! 0 " '!""&" +( 3"2 @ 2& 2! + 2 ' 2 2 !0 /6> 8:;

"0' = & - / !25 . -#-

# $-

"7-8 !"#

!$%& '( #+ #*

( )8 ) - -,- "0/-# "

!"# + 9(

(%% #+

+% # #+" %- (!,!

00-

";2;3"*234< +-8!+-+"#4=3;234<. 8:!"

2 /6> !0 + "2 2 !!2++( 5">02.'!!0 2 ;

/ !25 +0 8:' F( 6 I? /0 / " 5 .'

0!'"&"' ! " & '( '2! 0 .+&!"

!0 + "2 2"(& @ + " "2 ! & 2& 2! 4 +( ++!! +( 5">02. !""2 .+(5 "' ;

/ !25 " /6= 8:.

"2 !!" ? @ .98 . @ 2 8: %'0.2(+ #!"#"*#+!

#+ #" %-

(-/!#$% #+" %- (123455>3?6. ' ("..88 8. / !25 " /6= 8:. 77"

!0 ? @ .98 ."& !(2 " 2 @ 2 8:.'0"0" 5 " " +0 '0 2, ! +& ? @ .98 .!!"+"@

8: 2 2!!(+" & +0 -#-

# $-

"7-8 !"#

!$%& '( #+ #*

( )8 ) - -,- "0/-# "

!"# +9(

(%% #+

+% # #+" %- (' 2 7!!2+ /6> 8: !!"+"(/ 88: & . ( 0 7"

0(&0 ! 2+ +( 8:.!"2. ' " 0 ! !+ &""' I /6>. &2 &" 2!!(+" 8: +0 ;

2! ( & /6 8: @ 2 2!!(+" @ +

/6>) 2 2 !+" !./6> !0 ! !!"2 +( !(. 2! ""+ 2 +( ++!! +( 5">02/6> : . +4 !0 8:. 88:

' " !!"(0(+ 8:/6> 2 " + , +( 2! (A+'

" 2& 2! ) " . 7 8:" !& + , /6> . 88:' " !!"()@ . !(&&0 +( 22!+( + /6> . 2 (' " + /6 88:..+('( ! ' ( & / 6 ";

! " +( . #!"#"*#+!

#" %- ,(

(-/!#$% #+" %- (. / !25 72 ' & !" /6 88: 2 !!" "& ! !!" /6 .

' " +!!"+" /6 88: "( '"" " !2 ! +( 5 .+ !!" /6

88:!!"" /6 ;

! &+@ ' ! & /9 ? @ .98 .!!"" / ;

0(!

! 0&!! !"

2.. 8:.' " + &"! !+ " @ "' ! " (! @ 22! ). !"""+ '' ! & &""'""! ) (("8!

- )!

+- ( ,( - %! -,- "0/-# ) %"

! '

1234;>?56. / !25 !

/6 8: &"4 &2 +,( & !0-( +1233>;@3;6. / !25 2 "('

+' 2('

+" !"( 2 +", ! 2..( 2"!"( ) "'. + ) . 4 2"(. !"(""&")' +0 ""&"(2 & 2 ""&"(0" .+ " ' &!

+"!"(;

/ !25 " ' " "+ ' +" , 5 ) %- - "* %

:% #+ #+ " %- ( ,( A( # -$

-+ #+ #" %- 123455@5<6. / !25

' ! +(+";+ "+ ' /6 6 88:"( & !0 A( 0 A 2&!

+" !"( & '2 (("8!

-)!

+- ( ) % %%

-(B "8: ":- ( +,( -8) ! !-( +123424;5?6. / !25 +0 5 !!"0 ' +";+ ".+( &!!& 0 . ' + ""& "( & 2 /6

88: ) +,(A(9-+ # +12345?4=>6.

/ !25 +0 /6 88:' 2 /6 0"+( " ' /6 / !25 . 5 " , ! 2 2 ' " "( 7!'+( 5 /6 7 ! !0 ) % # $

- -0%"#-!$ / +,( )7! (%)#+!

!, - +1234; #!#-- @?>@60- "

%& 5 +0 74 " ( /6 88:"2 !') +0 /6 . 74 " ( ! ' !!"", !!". !!"+& 5 +('(+4

/6 )' '

& "'.+( +";+ "'

2 +( 5 '

" "&' +4 /6 . !!""5

/6' " +0( "

+0'" ! #!"#"* #+!

,(A(!::

#$!#-- !#$"/0 #'12345> .! >;<- 6 ) A( -8 "#!8(#+!

+,(!#-(%

1234< #!#-- <>=@6. 0- "

5 +0 !"' ("D & '"""' + "(2+" /6 6 88: ! "('

& + ( 2 +' !. .!0 -!!"(& "&"!!"

. "2(+ )2/6> 6 8:.'

@ 2! (&0!

+" ''!!0&"22""! " +@ +! & 2 2! . 5? & !

+" ' '!! : 8 % ' 6 "" "2 0 +( " .. 8.' 2 & 2!" !!"" + +' 5? 0 ! ' + +(

2 & 2. 0 ('"2!

0&+" +( 2+ 5?. "( !! +( 2 F0 . 0 2&2 !!"" & . & !" +( !!""+ +2 0" 2 02'2 ! +" .!0"+" 2 +"' "& " ! - " "= &.2.+5 $8 . ! /6 88:. !!""" ! ( 2." ( F0 !!". !!"" 0 ! (

2! "2 ( (' 7& " +(H ( + & @ " "( 7! 7& +( &' H ( ,0 2 & ."

&7 &2 !"& 2 ().2" +!" +( !!"" +( !" ."2!2 0+" +( !!""+ 5?.".!( '0! +( 2"! &."'

!!"" ( "2 2& /6> +. 8: @ ( 2& 0" H '

220+" !!( & " ' '

4 "( +( @ H '

@ 2!"" &!"+ +"7!.(.

" &.'"" + 2 +( 5? %'0. 0 !!""0& "2+ 5?/&"(. 5? ! "2 ' 2& /6> '5&(" ' 6 ;

( ' " 0 0 "2+( !!"".

(+2 )'"(+ + !!"" + (" ! ( 2(! !!( "2 /6> 8:) 2. ( 0 +"& 2!" +"' "2/&"(.

!!""0 ( "2+5 $8 . !" /6 88:

" "

"2 !( ' " ' 0 +( ' $ 8 8/ !&"(. ( 0 ' ! + + " 222"

!".+ ! /6 88:2 2!"" !;

: ! + 5 $8 2 & 2 ' 0 + " "= &.2. &

!' $ 8) 0' 2.' " +!

!!""(& 2+ ! ' $

8 !!!"" /6 88:) "& "' +0 +02 +( / !25 #!"#"*#+!

#+ #" %- ,(

(-/!#$% #+ " %- (. . 5 !2 !!"" (! & & +( 2 ! /6 88: !!" /6. /2""(. 5 (! +( $%) ' $ 8 8 ""' +( $%) ' 2 )2(+ "2 !!"" 0("0" + " & " " + .

" 22"/&"(. !!""2 0"& 5? " & " "" .""&

5&). ' $9 6 . 22"!" "'

5&(5;

0 ""( ' !!""< " '""& " " + ! 2. 5?, 22"!" !!" 5&(5" . '

' 2 "(22">5 . !!""<" '. 2" 2 " '0 5? !!" 22" 2 2! !(+" 5@ "(. !!""<" !

!#$%,( -"*

)#7 .14553 #!#- B=536 ) ,!#+- !#$% #+" %- ( ,(

# - 1233? #!#- B >;<6. '

" '

& " "" .20 >5 "2 ''& && 5""<22" 2' 99!+ " ! ( 2! ) & . 2(+ +02 +( 5? 5""< ' " + 0!!72"(C 2,' 7 " & $%$"( ' !!"+" " " $% $ 2 "(. !!""<" " $%$$0 ' +( !!""+" !(+' '"

"( + "" " ' #""&#,. 2""(2 ('2"""

!.'& "0"

$+"(.

!# - ( ")(- , + ,( ( !'

+ # -8- (-+.'%- (1455?24>>6 / !25 +0 '

0 +" !" @ " 0 &"( D. ! ". ( " 0 2" !2, +&. 2, 0"

" + 2 2 '& 2! "" !"@ " ' " 0 2" !2,

/2""(. )+%!

# /0 ",-/-# )( )+%!

# ,( !

-,!1 45<> B45>6.0- 5 '

@ " .0' & " "!

!.' " 0+ +!!(' ' 2 !""2?

;' !"

+ +!!(;

0- "

" ' 2 !""2?

" + ! 4 &2% :%/! ((,(%- )#7 . -145@@ ?=?6 ! & @ " 2

+ +& " " '&!"

0"!2 ""(' 2 !""2 !!"" +" !(' ( " '0"

& .+ ( 0 " 5?, 22"

7 +( 5"" !!" ' +"2 "( " . +( 2- !""( 0 "" " . 2 +( > 5 . !!""< ' '. "( . 2 ! 2!!!"+" &" #""&#, %" ! +' " & " $%$.'& !!" 2!%"7!" '

( 7 C + " ""& 5& -.."

'" ( 0"! 22""(.!! 5&(5" . '

"( 22"!" '( +22" ) "& ""&+" ! !!" +( 5?. 5 & " !!""<" '

2!7 ' "' ;

22!' + && .+(( 2&. , 5 ) & . + " !!"" & +" "' ) % .!

! -,! ,( - "*

# 1233; #!#- B=526. 0- 5

" '

"&" @ + 22"

0"!2 0"!2"" . +' '

," "2!! @ " '+" '( 0& !'

2! 2& ! @ " ) @ . "" " ' ' " " 2" 2 2 2!

"(. %

/% #+,(

# -1234= #!#- B4>@@=." = & 5 " ..

@ " ' !2" 22

!" " +"(!

". "'"" 22" F". - "* )#7 . ,( "% # !#$% 1455@ #!#- B43@;6.!!""- 5 ! 0',+( " &"= & @ " " + 0 +",.'& !"2 " .'

' 0(2 !"(;

' &"!!" '" ' """ 0(2 !"(' " 0 22,0"

!. !+"(!!"(& !!" " ' +0!"(. !!""0 2 !(+' " ' ( " '20"

+".

+( ( " , & 2! . + ! ' ! !!"" +" "2 @ " ' 0"

+( 5? .+( +)' 2!0 +( &0 2,0"

@ " .2/6> 8: &""'" ' & 0--7 '8%""

:%! + !

#+" %- (,(%

,!+ (-, (%

:%! + ! #+ #" %-

1 C@3@<C234<+-8!+-+"#433@23456D#!

!(%!,() .

:(%!#$% 1233=;;;<6 7) " +,(9" "

"/0 #' + 12343 #!#- +

(;3>46

%'0. !!"" 0 ! ( 2( 0 ! """2 " ' " " 6.A!@ ( !2,G && + ! 2. !!""+!2 +" "( "2 " +&"( 0"

0'& "( '& !!"" "

! " 2 6. '

@ " +!

>5 . "' /6 ! &. 2 7 2+ " ! 2/ !&"(. ""2 & " 2 . & 2 ' '

& " 7 ;

' " 0+' ,'" & !!"" "

2" " "! ",

% #$

!+)+- +.'

(,( $ ## %+- +.' ( #+" %- (1!,!

00-

"55?"* 45@2+-8!+-+.' %-)0 -/-") "#2@43455>6 ?"(. !!""< !!" (! 2! @ 2"(+4 "& & +( !!""'!!!"( "'

+( " "= &.2;

+4 +! & 0 '+ + 4./6> 88:2," ++!! +( 5">02"

+('(2 " . +"' & "2 . '( +2 '4 &2!' 5 "'/ ( '+( !"!!""0'.

& "(+0 +( " "= &.2;

5 & 2 +5$8

;

+ ,(

#$!#-- !#$ + #+" %- (1234; #!#- B4@?<26. #!"#"* #+!

#+ #" %- ,(%

/ 1234= #!#- )@246 A(9-+"#

8 ( , +,(

+#!:E0"

( #+ #" %- 1234;

#!#- B<2426 0" !!"" +0"(. 5 : ! +( " "= &.2. +5$8 +,.+ "' !!" + 2 &"( 2 3 ""+ '

",-/.- 2@2323 #$A( #+--0 !,&A JA$ !+" JA$