High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4087/2016allowed

Kamlesh And ORS v. Ram Dayal And Others

2018-08-16Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

!"#!$%&%"'()) *+,!&-" -!.& //!,,' & 0!.&1&

+2," -!.& !&/"'3!' &

.!&!' (

.)41.5-*/"".637"$ !#".

.)&-% ,%8637"$ !#". -!//!,,' &)

.)4'9!!7*"3'637"$ !#"..!&/"'3!' '"):) ;;;

-%& %& $,%+' &< //!, &!!8%'= !'-'$!+!' "# $"+/!'& %"') .%!#,26% +25!'" %$!3 - $,%+/! % %"'>&#%,!31'3!. 4!$ %"'&'3"# -! " ".0!-%$,!&$ 5!#".! -! ))))6 *1.18&-! .&!!8%'=3!?1 !'391& $"+/!'& %"'"'$$"1' "#3! -"# -. %'+" ".7!-%$,!$$%3!' - ""8/,$!"'))@),%+' & >!.! -!/.!' &'3+9".&%& !."# -!3!$!&!3)&/!.$,%+' &6-.

3!$!&!3 >&.%3%'=+" ".$2$,!'3>-%$->&& .1$852 .",,5!.%'= .!=%& . %"' '") @ -!.!%' # !. " 5! .!#!..!3 " & -! "##!'3%'=7!-%$,!

'35!%'=3.%7!'%'.&-'3'!=,%=!' +''!.52 2,) -!$,%+/! % %"'-7%'=5!!'$"' !& !36 -!#",,">%'=%&&1!& >!.!#.+!352 -!.%51',(

!"#$%!&"&' ()

,% -'& *"#

.%)!/"0'!*"& 1)2,3 !*!

+ 4 + ()

,% -*& *"#

+ + ()

+ ()

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

3!$!&!3>!.! 8!' "5! -!$,%+' &&$,%+' '"):5!%'= -!+9". &%& !."# -!3!$!&!3>&-!,3 "5!3!/!'3!' 1/"'-!.# -!.'3'" "' -!3!$!&!3) D%5%,% 2"# -!$"+/!'& %"'+"1' >&#& !'!39"%' ,2 '3&!7!.,,21/"' -!3.%7!.6">'!.'3 -!'&1.'$!"+/'2) -!"',2%&&1!%'7",7!3%' -!%'& ' //!,%&>% -.!=.3 " ?1' 1+"#$"+/!'& %"') -! &",% .2 &15+%&&%"' .%&!3 52 $"1'&!, .!/.!&!' %'= -! $,%+' &A//!,,' &%& - -!%'$"+!"# &)6A/!.+"' -&&!&&!3 52 -!.%51',%&"' -!,">!.&%3!)'#1. -!.'$!"#&1$-&15+%&&%"'

: $"1'&!,& !& - 3!$!&!3-!,33!=.!!"#$-!,"."#"++!.$!'3 >&,&"/1.&1%'= -!$"1.&!"#-. !.!3$$"1' '$21'3!. -!!=%&"# -!'& % 1 !"#-. !.!3$$"1' ' &"#'3%) >&1.=!3 - 3!$!&!3 >&+!.!,22!.&"' -!3 !"# -!$$%3!' '3>"1,3-7!-35.%=- #1 1.!&/."#!&&%"',51 #". -!1'#". 1' !$$%3!' '33!+%&!)

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

'3-3,&"331$!3"'.!$".3$!. %' $!. %#%$ !&%&&1!352 -!'& % 1 !"#-. 3$$"1' ' &"#'3%'3 >-%$->"1,3$,!.,23!+"'& . ! - 3!$!&!3>&/1.&1%'= -!$"1.&!"# -. 3$$"1' '$2)!$!&!3>&"',22!.&"#=!"' -!3 !"# $$%3!' A3! -)-!$$%3!' -3 8!'/,$!"'))@) -!"'<5,!/!C"1. %'$&!

!! " # $-3 3!, >% - -!?1' 1+"#$"+/!'& %"'%'.!, %"' "3!$!&!3>-">&

F2!.&",3'3/1.&1%'=-%&+!3%$,3!=.!!)G-%,!&&!&&%'= -!#1 1.! !.'%'=& &)66A/!. +"' -6 -! /!C "1. -3 "5&!.7!3 & #",,">&( ) +

7 1,

3 + 894

0 9

54#"4""":!

+ 7

;

% 7

&"4""":!

+ 4

+ + +

&"4""":!

% 7

+ + 6 37!. %'=5$8 " -!#$ &"# -!/.!&!' $&! -!3!$!&!3 >&/1.&1%'=/."#!&&%"',$"1.&!) /"'&1$$!&&#1,$"+/,! %"'"# -!

-. !.!3$$"1' '$2$"1.&!6% $',&"5!.!&"'5,2&&1+!3 - -! >"1,3-7!!% -!.!C/,".!3>%3!.'=!"#!+/,"2+!' 7!'1!&".>"1,3 -7!!'==!3-%+&!,#%'/.%7 !$"'&1, '$2)

'3!.&1$-$%.$1+& '$!&6% >"1,35!&#! "/.!&1+!'3 &&!&& -!+"' -,2%'$"+!"# -!3!$!&!3 "5! &)@6A/!.+"' -)

'3"15 !3,2'3&1.=!352,!.'!3$"1'&!,.!/.!&!' %'= -! $"' !& %'=%'&1.'$!$"+/'2 - '"$"=!' '3$"'$,1&%7!!7%3!'$!-3

@ 5!!'331$!3"'5!-,#"# -!$,%+' &&.!=.3&/.""#"#%'$"+!62! 6% $''" 5!,"& &%=- "# - !7!' -!.%51',-&/."$!!3!3"'>."'=#1, &&1+/ %"' 52 //,2%'= -! .2' "7 ) E! ! " %#%$ %"' 3 !3 F))FF "&&!&& -!+"' -,2%'$"+!"#3!$!&!3& &)6A) '

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

$ !! "

#) %&&"3%.!$ !3) =!"# -!3!$!&!3-7%'=5!!'-!,3 "5!2!.&'3"' >-%$-,&" -!.!%&'"3%&/1 !6 -!+1, %/,%!."# - -&5!!'//,%!352 -!.%51',%&%'$"'#".+% 2>% - -!=1%3!,%'!&%&&1!352 -!/!C"1. %'$&!"#( ( "

)"* %%

# + !! " $$)

-!.%51',-&>.3!3&1+"# &)@6A ">.3&,& .% !&A#1'!.,!C/!'&!&)41$-+"1' >"1,3'">& '3. %"',%E!3'3 &1+"# &):6A%&>.3!31'3!. -!$"'7!' %"',-!3&"#,"&&"# !& !'3#1'!.,!C/!'&!&

&)@6A!$- ) ' 7%!> "# -! 5"7!6 -! .!7%&!3A!'-'$!3 $"+/!'& %"' +"1' %&$"+/1 !3&#",,">&( 4.) ") !3 ,$1, %"'

) '$"+! @6A/!.+"' - ) B %'$.!&! %' %'$"+! ">.3& #1 1.! /."&/!$ & @6IBJ6A :) @B3!31$ %"'& ">.3&/!.&"',!C/!'&!& "# -!3!$!&!3) 6KJ6@A 66@J6@A ) "+/!'& %"'# !.//,2%'=+1, %/,%!."# 6@CJ66A 66CJ66A @) "'7!' %"',-!3& ,"&&"#!& !6#1'!., !C/!'&!&! $)

:6A ) " , 66I:6J &)6A -!#".!&%3!'-'$!3$"+/!'& %"'+"1' 5!.!,!&!3%' #7"1."# -!$,%+' &,"'=>% -%' !.!& HB#."+ -!3 !"##%,%'="# -!$,%+/! % %"''3 %,,$ 1,.!,%E %"') -!//". %"'+!' "# -! $"+/!'& %"'+"1' '3&3%.!$ !352 -!.%51',>"1,3& 2%' $ ) //!,%&,,">!3%' -!#".!&%3 !.+&)

,1$82 G-! -!.&/!8%'=A.!&"'!3( !&A"

G-! -!. !/". 5,!( !&A"