← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/270/2013disposed of

Punjabi Coop.House Building Soc. v. Commr. Of Income Tax Chd.& ANR.

2015-07-31Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan8 pages



    

 !"!#$%$&'()*+,

(&-.$/!0 $1!(%!($)"$&23#$! * 44//!))& 5% 6!77$%%$&!0&#7!8+6&"$206&"& 6!0 4 !%/&"!& % ' 9:

 3;

:

 9:

 3  3  

         

     

-*;(70 $ )+ ! 

"!# $%&$& ' (& $& )   *

++ ,  *-  +"!# $%&$& '

"!# $%&$& ' * * .

 $/&"+!

- 0/ 1234



$0 $& '- '

*"+!

-

  !*

  5   676  7  5   1    2 !*

4"!# ((/85 8$& $ + $&&%.&9

'

7     "!# $%&$& '  

:    + *

.

 + $'

"  

+ $

 ;

< 

  +  / /&%&$08.

 

 * *++* !



+ (&&=  /(++* &&&=  '& ++* 

(&&=    * "   

> ++

$( $&&%1 2>34, 7

 ?+ 5 1* 2,,34   !

  ,   +  5+

  ?+   +* 1!,54     >          ,,  !,5  12

64

   +$ $ 

   + 



+       * * *!,5,    

++*  

@(&&= 

 + +1 9$ (&

 4 *

+*  1

 + $$(&= 4 5

)>  

   .

4 +'





(&&=   /





 &&&=   - >

:

 

*4 + $





(&&=  $)





 &&&=  *+

  ->

-  



* !,5

=



 *'

&9   <   +  >

4 + 9





(&&=   '/





 &&&=  *+

+->

-

 

 * !,5 

=



*) /$ 

4 +$) %(





(&&= 

 )0 (&





 &&&=  * +

-++

-> ++







8    



  ++



-  

 *  !,5

=



*/ '/



47



+  $) %(





(&& =  )0 (&





 &&&= *+

++



+



1 4 * 



 +

+   

:+     

 8   +

-  

 *  !,5

=



*%



4A ++* 

(&&=     * 

+  $$(&=   ++* 

 &&&=    * 

+  $$(& =           

      +    !,5

+        *    *  !,5     +  +   

    *  



   ++   5 +A- 5++       

 )

$&&%    >

 $( $&&%    -  $  

5

 ) +    + >

  +!,5 

+ 

+  !,5 *



*  

*    !,5

! +

+  

14 *

  

+ 

 



+ %

    '

&9   

  ) /$              +      >

          

  *   +!,5 *= * 

  *  

+*+

+> +

 4



*

  &&&=  

              >        +  ''&&&&&&8.  

$$(&=  

 

   +//



(

B     + $&&%.&9 

 

+  

+   9& "



   -  + >    !,5    

*   





  /

!C 

$0 $& &- 

  )'1'4

 >    +  *

 !,5

  



     +   +    2 3  !   C  +  +

 

 

  $')

  

 $/

 !C

  -

* *  +   > + + %'(&&&&&8.

 

  !C

 

$1)%414

(' !   99$12 99$34        

  ++

*   

 +     (' 99$

* 2 3

  >  $( $&&% 

    + $&&%.&9C +    

  "



  6 6+ *14 14$ 1)%4



 

*  C*5++"+!

-1

4D5"!14E ; 

 $ $& - $5"!14 



*      C     +  *   +   

%'(&& &&&8.  +  

 *

 >  ! 



*!*

!

*  +> *=+ 

 * !*

 C* -

   > 

6

6

     ;     

 $0 $& ' -  '   !*

 

 C* -   >  - 

6

6



 





 * "

!*





  +$1)%414 

(' 99$  !    > 

* -  

!!*



 + + 





*

 )(&& =  !

 *  -+  ()B  : *!*



   -+  ()     + 

       

            

   -+  ()

* 

 F    

 

": +

$$ $& (  "!# $&& $& '1

  

    

 

 

+  .

4  

$1)%41414 14 G 4

 

 * (' 99$G 4+ *  +2 3H 4  +   - 

 +   * H

       

 

  .



>

$( $&&%





'

&&% $( $&&% '

&9  ) /$    







  . 

 

# 

**   



 + >

$( $&&%



 + (' 99$

'

 !    

 

+               

   

   B    ('   99$  *      +*  $1)%414



 (' 99$= *  

" * >

$( $&&%  *- $) $&&  + 

 (' 99$ = $ 1)%414 

( " *+ *    .

   +  + 

 -

*

  

  

 *- " 

>

$( $&&%  + *   *     "              +      

   -  

 *       



  

  "        



*  

 

+ * *  / !-* 

 - *         =   -+    ()B

    * 

+

!!*

* 

  .

* 

 -    +  

 +   '

(         

*   



  +             

* +5  ,5"?

!



  " * 

  +   +  !*

 

         

    *

C   

  

-*;(70 $ )

("2! ()*+,  !6!!/3$&26

<2%< ("2!