High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20075/2024dismissed

Union Of India Through Secretary To Government Of India v. Nirmal Singh

2025-01-13Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma9 pages

!"#$$#

! %!& !"$'#$#

!" !

( ) ) #$% & '

*" +,* # ))

) -

+,* )# )) ) * ()*+,-./ ( 01(1234542)0 16704 ,89:15+ ;9(50+<+545492+( ( 1501241 ,89:15+12, ( 48+6 1,=1> ,89:15+;9((+7<92,+259

????

)

) -

.# 0(9*)050+4275125=(45<+545492 50+<+545492+(70+(+42

24929;2,41 <(1.7;9(50+7+5542)174,+9;50+9(,+(,15+,@

&22+A*(+ '

17 <177+, -. 50+ >+1(2+, (B+, 9(:+7 (4-*21> :92:+(2+, =0+(+-.750+:>14B9;(+7<92,+259

;9(50+)(1259;

7+(84:++>+B+259;50+,471-4>45.<+27492;9(50+7+(84:+(+2,+(+,-. 04B42+;+2:++:*(45.9(<7&'017-++21>>9=+, -.:92,9242) 50+709(5;1>>9; .+1(12,@,1.7;(9B50+(+C*4745+ .+1(79;

C*1>4;.42)7+(84:+;9(+1(242)7+(84:+<+274924250+

/&0%/1/&23 %!

+7<92,+25 9

=17 +2(9>>+, 42 50+ 2,412 (B. 92

#$#12,=17,47:01()+,50+(+;(9B92@

+7<92,+25 9

=17)(125+,(+54(42)<+27492 171,B4774->+5904B17<+(50+ +27492+)*>154927 0+(+1;5+( (+7<92,+259 =17(++2(9>>+,4259 +;+2:++:*(45.9(<7&7+(84:+'92

##@ ::9(,42)5950+

<(+81>+25<9>4:.

*<9215514242)50+1)+9;7*<+(122*15492 (+7<92,+25 9

=17,47:01()+,;(9B7+(84:+4250+92@

1;5+( (+2,+(42)17+(84:+9; @.+1(712,@ ,1.7 =04:0=17709(5-.

.+1(12,@,1.7 791759B16+50+79>,4+(+21->+,59:9B<>+5+50+ C*1>4;.42)5+(B9; .+1(7 ;9(50+<*(<97+9;)(1259;7+(84:+<+27492

50*7;9(50+7+:92,7+(84:+(+2,+(+,-.04B4250+ @

+7<92,+25 9

=17 ,+24+, 7+(84:+ <+27492 -. 50+ :9B<+5+251*509(45.;9(047295:9B<>+542)50+(+C*4745+C*1>4;.42) <+(49,;9(+1(242)7+(84:+<+274924250+

++>42)1))(4+8+, (+7<92,+259

;4>+,

-+;9(+50+ >+1(2+, (B+, 9(:+7 (4-*21> :92:+(2+, =0+(+-.7 0+ :175 1 :01>>+2)+5950+1;9(+714,(+3+:54929(,+( 0+714,

-+:1B+ 1>>9=+,84,+9(,+(,15+,@

0+9<+(1548+<1(59;50+714, 9(,+(47+A5(1:5+,0+(+421;5+(/ D+1(,12,<+(*7+,50+(+:9(,

0+(+471709(5;1>>9; .+1(12, ,1.742<+274921(.

7+(84:+ 42 50+(+;9(+ 5047 B155+( 47 :98+(+, -. 50+ 3*,)B+259;50+92E->+*<(+B+9*(54250+:17+9;

484> <<+1>9 #@F#9; ,15+,

=04:0017-++2 (+;+((+,5942<1(19 @@4250+:17+9;

,+:4,+,92

#-.50+ !1()+( +2:09;50+(42:4<1> +2:09;(B+,9(:+7(4-*21>

+=+>04

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

++>42)1))(4+8+,;(9B50+1;9(+714,9(,+(17<177+,*<92 50+ &7*<(1'

-.50+>+1(2+,(B+,9(:+7(4-*21>:92:+(2+, 50+

<+545492+( 24929;2,41017;4>+,50+(+1)1427550+4275125=(45<+545492 -+;9(+50479*(5 )%456

6 !

7081/ !& %!

17 0890606 !

0+>+1(2+,:9*27+>;9(50+<+545492+(77*-B457 501550+ >+1(2+,(4-*21>017;14>+,59:9274,+(5015425+(B79;+)*>15492 9

9;50++27492+)*>154927;9(50+(B.

#$ 12,+)*>15492 9 9;50++27492+)*>154927;9(50+(B.

F 50*792>.50+ 9B<+5+25*509(45.=17+B<9=+(+,59:92,92+50+,+;4:4+2:.4250+ (+2,454929;C*1>4;.42)7+(84:+ 50*7-.50+79>,4+(;9(047-+:9B42) +2545>+,597++650++2,9=B+259;<+274925904B 0+714,+)*>154927 1(++A5(1:5+,0+(+421;5+(

& ! #$ '

$ "

'( "#

% % %

%) % % )

% !)

& ! F'

(( * % % +

%) %

)

% )

,- "#

$ .

% "#

/ 9(+98+( 50+42475(.9;+;+2:+84,+9>4:.>+55+(9

&'G

GG&+2G9>' ,15+, $ 427+(5+,:>1*7+&48' 42 50+ +)*>154929 9;50++27492+)*>15492;9(50+(B.

F 0+ (+>+8125<1(5=0+(+9;

47+A5(1:5+,0+(+421;5+(

!"#

<+(*71>9;50+1;9(+1B+2,B+25=9*>,B16+45:>+1(5015 (+>4+; C*1 :92,9215492 9; ,+;4:4+2:. 42 (+2,45492 9; 50+ 1<<9745+ C*1>4;.42)7+(84:+ 4759-+1::9(,+,92B+(45 791759+27*(+501512 1(B.<+(7922+>47+>4)4->+;9(15>+17592+7+(84:+<+27492 $

0+>+1(2+,:9*27+>;9(50+<+545492+(7;*(50+(7*-B457 5015 50+3*,)B+259;50+>+1(2+,(B+,9(:+7(4-*21> (42:4<1> +2:0

+=+>04 (+2,+(+,42:17+545>+,17 & '

=17295:9((+:5(150+(=17:925(1(.59>1=12,;1:57

50+(+;9(+ 29(+>412:+9*)0559018+-++2<>1:+,9250+714,3*,)B+25

0+(+>+8125<1(1)(1<07 179::*(4250+8+(,4:5&7*<(1'1(++A5(1:5+, 0+(+421;5+(

* $ %

)

(2( 3 )

, "

% 5& 6)% ) 78

(23 (( 6)%9&

) 78

22' /:

) %

)

) ) ) : #

) 1

;<=

>=6?'2 @

@ %60* %

: #

60*

%7 "8# : !!!! !!!!

(3 6

)

A 1 5 )

, "# B ? "

% "

)

#$ % ))

(% )

* )

9 %

CD )

)

% % %

CD C 9

EC % 8 8 & ) % %

* " # $

(

‟

)

* $

% +

" !" "#

# "#

) )%$

)

$ )%

6)0* 6 22/*

% )

) (23

% 9

9 ) " ,

-./ .0 %

02.0 .03 "# 9 "#

* 1

"#B ?"#

9 (/

!7 !& 7086 % 0#

42:+50++A<975*>154927B1,+42<1(1)(1<079 #59 9;

50+3*,)B+25(+2,+(+,-.50+92E->+<+A9*(542:17+545>+,17

!6 ! 7!6//!! 08 ( #)% ! )6!38 / 5/

(+<9(5+,42 .04 3

" " -.- <1(1)(1<0 =0+(+9; -+:9B+7 +A5(1:5+,0+(+421;5+( 98+(:9B+750+,471->42)+;;+:57 4;12.

9;7*<(1 +A:+<5492 9 &48'

17 -+:1B+ 427+(5+, 84,+ <9>4:.G>+55+( ,15+, $ 50*7 425+2,+,59=9(617129-751:>+(150+(1)1427550+ 79>,4+( :>14B42) (+>4+; 9; :92,9215492 42 50+ (+C*4745+ 709(5;1>> 9; 7+(84:+

! !

' () *!

+ , &

! !

/ -

01 2&3

......! ......

4 0 5 .. .. .. &

! !

/ -

6' () 5 7

. #

012 %

8 96* !

)

$ % %!)

)

! %

)

C *

* C

) (

(

6 !

)

) * *

0+(+;9(+ 50+3*,4:41>8+(,4:5&7*<(1'

,9+7(+2,+(2+)15+, 50+7*<(11()*B+25(147+,-.50+:9*27+>;9(50+<+545492+(7 501550+ +B<9=+(B+2559:92,92+50+(+C*4745+709(5;1>> -+:9B+779>451(4>.

8+75+,4250+9B<+5+25*509(45.

+7<+:41>>.=0+250+0+(+421-98+ *2,+(>42+,<1(1)(1<07 179::*(4250+8+(,4:5B1,+42)% ! )6!38

/ 5/ + &/ 1>>*,+,594250+8+(,4:5B1,+4201B1"1*(E7:17+ ,9 428+753*(47,4:54924250+(459*(5 5950(9*)03*,4:41>425+(8+25492

50*7B16+50++7<9*7+,:92,9215492

927+C*+25>.

50+:*B*>1548++;;+:59;50+1*509(451548+ 3*,4:41><(929*2:+B+2517:1((4+,4250+1-98++A5(1:5+,<1(1)(1<0

B1,+ 42

* % 50*7 :9B<>+5+>.

:9*25+(814>7-95050+7*<(11()*B+257(147+,-+;9(+50479*(5 -.50+ :9*27+>;9(50+<+545492+(7 50*7;9(,+2.42)5950+(+7<92,+25 50+ -+2+;459;50+7+(84:+<+27492;9(0477+(842)4250+ B+(+>.9250+ )(9*2,50150+017295:9B<>+5+,50+C*1>4;.42)<+(49,9;7+(84:+

-+74,+79250+;*(50+(;>4B7.)(9*2, 501592>.50+:9B<+5+251*509(45.

471*509(4H+,59:92,92+50+714,709(5;1>>

@ 92+50+>+77 42 5+(B7 9; 50+ ,+:>1(15492 B1,+ 42 50+ 0+(+421-98+ *2,+(>42+, <1(1 17 :1((4+, 42 50+ 8+(,4:5 &7*<(1' 50+ :>14B79;,*1>;1B4>.<+27492421,,454925950+;4(75;1B4>.<+27492 4;

(+C*4(+, =9*>,-+(+75(4:5+,;(9B # 17+28471)+,-.50+ 42475(.9;+;+2:+!+55+(,15+,

6!/1 7086 % 0# 21;5+(B150 50479*(5;42,729B+(454250+=(45<+545492 12,=4509-7+(81549271-98+ 50+71B+47,47B477+,

0+4B<*)2+,9(,+( 17<177+,-.50+>+1(2+,(4-*21> :92:+(2+, 47B1425142+,12,1;;4(B+,

47<97+,9;1>92)=4501>><+2,42)1<<>4:15492&7' 4;12.

) -

;

:) ) *;

$'#$# 231> 0+50+(7<+1642)G(+1792+, / +7G9 0+50+((+<9(51->+ / +7G9