High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/308/2022allowed

Sabir v. Mubin And ORS

2026-03-30Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal6 pages

!

"#$#%&''(

& )* ' +,- .*

!

"

!

"#$%

!

"&'(

) /// ,- .*0' *

*

+

!

-

)

- .! / 01 - %22%%2%2

! 3

!!

%

*

#44 !

#566 .!

7, "

81

+

!#2 222*'

! 3 !!

- + %924%2#6( -

*

,-

3 -

, !

, ,

":&;<%255 -- ,

3 =&2 -

>

?

, ": 9%) ;2;9 . !

!

7 %!#%1 3#"4 ,

,

,

! + ,

!

!

!

!

-

3 <( "#%6 %424%2#6

%;5 &&;()- ,

> %#

!!

!6&@

! !,

,

+

!

- 5'

A -- ! > . & ) -

- !!

!

9% 222*' !

! -

!

(

!!

-

- ! - 3

-

= ! , C

'

67'

892 :;

;<0 . + =#9 #% #!

2#

5'

.>$

%?'('73 $;$

!#%@;9# $'

0

3#%'* $89 !'3 B

9< #

$3 #%8 59 ;<

0 A 43#' 9

! 9<?'('7

'('7 %!$8 $'

A4 "%3#$

C

9$ %! A $ 3 2#%1 !#84< #% ;9$#%1

$$#$

9<,#!C

+B#44%$ ;

0;9;19 < ;$

9% $'70>8 9<% 3' $;

!D !#$ =#4# C'

7E'

.+ @#!#% #!

2# 5'

.>$

% ?'('73 $;$

!#%@;9# $'

0

3#%'* $89 !'3 %3 B

9< +3

4 ;9$#%1 < 0

4A 4' 9 !

!

9<?'('7 ('('7 %!$8 $'% 4 "%3#$

' #< ""#!

3 $ ;!

;$

9% $'70>8 9<% 3=C ;# #%A9B'

7?'

. 9' + "3#% %"3 892 ! !#$ =#4# "

# #"

5'

< #%#%1D8 9< !#$ =#4# C + =#9'

7(' *

9% !";%$ 4 98

9$

!"8# * %! !#$"3 $;<< 9C + =#9 $ 5'

F 5'

G0* %!59 C9 89 + @#!5'

%!5'

7'

7F'

*

9% !";%$ 4 98

9$$;=<#

A9 3 < 4=#44$ 9B7 9B + 3#9"<

$'0?> %!< 4=#44$ 9B 9B7F + @#!

"< $ $' 70F((>0

=#9 $;

! 8 "<<;%#

! 9 "

;9 9#13 #=# $8

!;8%

%!9

! 9<?'('7 '('7'

$;

! 8 9< !#$ =#4# C D'

9 + @#!

$;

! 9 "

;9 E 3 <

"

4 9#13 !

! 9< ?'('7 ('('7' +0

9$< C= 19

!@;$ %! #9"<8

#%'

7' *

9% ! ";%$ 4 9 9 $8%!

$ $;=<#

!

9$ 3 #4 ! 89!;"

%C !";<

9!#%1 #%@;9# $ 3 2#%1 $;$

! #% ""#!

'

9$3 % 892 !< 4=#44$ 9B7 '

7G'

9< <#%

#% 9 "9! #% 4#13

#! 9#2 4 "%

#%$0 # #$ "9C$

4 "4

9

#%

""#!

!

! ?'('7 8

=#9 %! + @#!

$;$

! <;4 #84 #%@;9# $' 3 A

% 0

3#%'* $ + =#9 %!+ @#! 5'

F %!5'

'

+ =#9A

#

$3 #%8 59 ;<

0 A 43#' 9

! 9<?'('7

'('7' $;

! 9 "

;9 9#13 #=#

! ;8%'

@#! A $

% +3

;9$#%1 < 0

4A 4' $;

! 9 "

;9 E

"

4 9#13 '%2# A * %!!#$"3

$;<< 9C %! 59 C 9 89 0 < 4 =#44$ 9 4# =4 '

4=#44$ 9B7 9B7F#% $;< $'70F(( + @#! %! 9B7 9B#% $;< $'0? + =#9 9 4# =4 '

9+ =#9$;

! 9 "

;9 9#13 #=# '

@#! $;

! 9 "

;9 E

"

4 9#13 '+0# !

= 3 4!

C<;$ 3 9 !;

"

#% 9 8 9#!

<% 3$

"3'

9+ =#9"4 #< =

9%#%1 $'

70>8 9<% 3=CA9B#%1 $;9$#%1$$#$

@#! "4 #< ! =

9%#%1 $ 70>8 <% 3=C!#%1 ;# #%A9B=;

%!";< 892

#9#%"< 3 $=

%89!;"

!%9 "9!'+0#%"<

9$#$!

9<#% $'G>8 9<% 3

"3 9 <#%#<;< A $ %9<$' +0 = $#!

$

$0 8

9$ !

4$$ #%"<

"3 $ 9

<% 3$' C 884C#%1 89#%"#84 $ $$ $$< "<8

#% $892#!

!=C %H=4 +;89 ;9 %!# #% "

''

%1 !#,+'>$'

% 94%!# '* !'7GG?

(( =2 $ #! "

$08

9+ @#!!

"<8

#%;%!

9 44A#%13

!$& +9''

!$ <;% $' 7'

4 70 '

*$$ #%"< I $'G8'<'

9

<% 3$ F0 '

#% $;

9#%1 !;9#%1 3$8#

4#J

70 E'

#% $;

9#%1 9 %

70 ?'

)$"3 $I $'> 9

<% 3$ (0

?

('

9 %$89

#%0 $8 "# 4 !#

<#$"' ?0

(G0 '

=#9 !

$ "<8

#% ;%!

44A#%13

!$& +9''

!$ <;% $' 7'

4 0? '

*$$ #%"< I $'G 8'<' 9

<% 3$ F0 '

#% $;

9#%1 !;9#%1 3$8#

4#J

70 E'

)$ "3 $ I

$'> 9

<% 3$ (0 ?'

9 %$89

#%0$8 "# 4!#

<#$"' ?0?

?0 9 ! ! ,-

! .DB%1

A

)

- ,

)

+

!:-

!

) ,

, ,

- - ' + ,- 4 ,

- - %22%%2%2

)!! 3 C !C

-

%2#6 %2%%

)-

- !!

; ! ) !A E,

- 242=%2%4 #222 )

(

!

) ) ,3

6

, .1 ! ! ,- .* 9"30( 3

F

+ ,*

F