High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20079/2024dismissed

Union Of India Through Secretary To Government Of India v. Ex L/Nk Subash Chand And Another

2025-01-13Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%%$

! &!' !"%($%$#

!" !

) * * ##$%!&"

+" ,-+ $ **

* .

,-+ *$ ** * + '()*+,-. '

/0'0123431(/ 05/6/3 +78904* :8'4/*;*434381*'& <<<< *

* .

/$ /'8)(/4/*3164014='34;*434381 4/*;*434381*'6/*'*31

13818:1+30 ;'0-6:8'4/*6*4431(063+*8:4/*8'+*'+04*+ > # ?11*@)'* 06 ;066*+ ,- 4/* B*0'1*+ 'C*+ 8'9*6 '3,)10B 9819*'1*+ =/*'*,-64/*9B03C8:'*6;81+*148

:8'4/*('0148:

6*'739**B*C*148:4/*+360,3B34-;*16381:8'4/*6*'739*'*1+*'*+,- /3C31*:*19**9)'34-8';6?A/06,**10BB8=*+ ,-981+8131( 4/*6/8'4:0BB8:

C814/601+#+0-6:'8C4/*'*D)3634* >-*0'68:

D)0B3:-31(6*'739*:8'*0'131(6*'739*;*16381314/*

0'1&020'34 &!

*6;81+*148 =06*1'8BB*+314/*1+301'C-81

01+=06+369/0'(*+4/*'*:'8C81#

E *6;81+*14

=06('014*+'*43'31(;*16381 060+C3663,B*48/3C06;*'4/* *16381*()B043816 /*'*0:4*'

'*6;81+*148

=06'**1'8BB*+3148 *:*19**9)'34-8';6?6*'739*A81

998'+31(484/*

;'*70B*14;8B39- );8104403131(4/*0(*8:6);*'011)04381 '*6;81+*14

=06+369/0'(*+:'8C6*'739*314/*81#

0:4*'

'*1+*'31(06*'739*8: -*0'601++0-6 =/39/=066/8'4,-

C814/601+#+0-6 680648C05*4/*68B+3*'*10,B*+4898C;B*4*4/* D)0B3:-31(4*'C8: >-*0'6 :8'4/*;)';86*8:('0148:6*'739*;*16381

4/)6:8'4/*6*981+6*'739*'*1+*'*+,-/3C314/* #

*6;81+*14 8

=06 +*13*+ 6*'739* ;*16381 ,- 4/* 98C;*4*140)4/8'34-:8'/3618498C;B*431(4/*'*D)3634*D)0B3:-31( ;*'38+:8'*0'131(6*'739*;*16381314/*

**B31(0(('3*7*+ '*6;81+*148

:3B*+

,*:8'*4/* B*0'1*+ 'C*+ 8'9*6 '3,)10B 9819*'1*+ =/*'*,-6 /* 9064 0 9/0BB*1(*484/*0:8'*603+'*2*943818'+*'

/*603+

,*90C* 0BB8=*+73+*8'+*'+04*+ > # /*8;*'0437*;0'48:4/*603+ 8'+*'36*@4'094*+/*'*310:4*'. @@@@ @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@

" # $%&&'$''(

**B31(0(('3*7*+:'8C4/*0:8'*603+8'+*'06;066*+);81 4/* ?6);'0A ,-4/*B*0'1*+'C*+8'9*6'3,)10B9819*'1*+ 4/* ;*434381*' 13818:1+30/06:3B*+4/*'*0(031644/*3164014='34;*434381 ,*:8'*4/368)'4 *&567

7 !

81920 !' &!

28 19:1717 !

/*B*0'1*+98)16*B:8'4/*;*434381*'66),C346 4/044/* B*0'1*+'3,)10B/06:03B*+4898163+*'4/04314*'C68:*()B04381

>8:4/**16381*()B043816:8'4/*'C- E 01+*()B04381 8:4/**16381*()B043816:8'4/*'C- $ 4/)681B-4/* 8C;*4*14)4/8'34-=06*C;8=*'*+48981+81*4/*+*:393*19-314/* '*1+343818:D)0B3:-31(6*'739* 4/)6,-4/*68B+3*':8'/36,*98C31( *1434B*+486**54/**1+8=C*148:;*1638148/3C /*603+*()B043816 0'**@4'094*+/*'*310:4*'

? ! E &') *+ ,- . ,-

/ &01 ,- &) + ( ? ! $A 11 # 2 &'

+ 34 ,- .5 ,- &)

,- / ( 6 8'*87*'

4/*31364'-8:*:*19*73+*8B39-B*44*'8

?A&

&&?*1&8BA +04*+ E 316*'4*+9B0)6*?37A 31 4/* *()B043818 8:4/**16381*()B04381:8'4/*'C- $ /* '*B*7014;0'4=/*'*8:

36*@4'094*+/*'*310:4*'

;*')60B8:4/*0:8'*0C*1+C*14=8)B+C05*349B*0'4/04 '*B3*: D)0 981+8104381 8: +*:393*19- 31 '*1+34381 8: 4/* 0;;8634* D)0B3:-31(6*'739* 3648,*0998'+*+81C*'34 680648*16)'*4/0401 0'C-;*'6811*B36*B3(3,B*:8'04B*06481*6*'739*;*16381 ! "

/*B*0'1*+98)16*B:8'4/*;*434381*'6:)'4/*'6),C346 4/04 4/*2)+(C*148:4/*B*0'1*+'C*+8'9*6'3,)10B '3193;0B *19/

*=*B/3 '*1+*'*+31906*434B*+06 # $ %&

=0618498''*94'04/*'=069814'0'-48B0=01+:0946

4/*'*:8'* 18'*B3019*8)(/448/07*,**1;B09*+814/*603+2)+(C*14

/*'*B*7014;0'0('0;/6 06899)'314/*7*'+394?6);'0A0'**@4'094*+ /*'*310:4*'

'# . 7

8 '1$1'$& 3 ,- 9

:;< / = >: &1$'$$&

?11 ? / =>:

'$$0'$&6@ - ;

@ - < @ - :A 8 : B " C"D0$'$&E$6&&'$&E 7# @ - < 7# = ,>:- @ ++++ ++++ 1

F 8

3 ,- G D ,-

- .

: ; < &1

< < #

<? ! H ;< /

: ; <

! H ! <: ? AI! > ; > /

8 : > # ,- !

‟ ( )

! " *

,-< ,- ,- #

. .

( ; ','-7# '$$6#

&1$'$$& ? &'; ; ?,- + "

,-. -/ " 0

/1-/ -/2 ,- ? ,-

< < # 8 : H

, -G D,- ?16 !8 !' 8197 & 1$

319*4/**@;864)B043816C0+*31;0'0('0;/8 8:4/* 2)+(C*14'*1+*'*+,-4/*81F,B*;*@8)'431906*434B*+06 !7 ! 8 !700!! 19 ) $*& ! *7!49

'*;8'4*+31 -/32 ,-, ;0'0('0;/ =/*'*8: ,*98C*6 *@4'094*+ /*'*310:4*'

87*'98C*64/*+360,B31(*::*946 3:01- 8:6);'0*@9*;4381 ?37A 06,*90C*316*'4*+73+*;8B39-&B*44*'+04*+ E 4/)6

314*1+*+48=8'506018,6409B*'04/*'0(031644/*68B+3*'9B03C31('*B3*: 8:981+8104381314/*'*D)3634*6/8'4:0BB8:6*'739*

. +

&' + A ! <#

# !

'1J &%) &1 '$$& + ##

/*'*:8'* 4/*2)+3930B7*'+394?6);'0A +8*6'*1+*'1*(04*+ 4/*6);'00'()C*14'036*+,-4/*98)16*B:8'4/*;*434381*'6 4/044/* *C;8=*'C*1448981+81*4/*'*D)3634*6/8'4:0BB ,*98C*668B340'3B7*64*+314/*8C;*4*14)4/8'34- *6;*930BB-=/*14/*/*'*310,87* )1+*'B31*+;0'0('0;/6 06899)'314/*7*'+394C0+*31*& ! *7!49

, '0 0BB)+*+48314/*7*'+394C0+*31/0C0"0)'F6906* +8 317*642)'36+394381314/*'348)'4 484/'8)(/2)+3930B314*'7*14381

4/)6C05*4/**6;8)6*+981+8104381

816*D)*14B- 4/*9)C)B0437**::*948:4/*0)4/8'340437* 2)+3930B;'818)19*C*140690''3*+314/*0,87**@4'094*+;0'0('0;/

C0+* 31 )

" 4/)6 98C;B*4*B98)14*'703B6,84/4/*6);'00'()C*146'036*+,*:8'*4/368)'4 ,-4/* 98)16*B:8'4/*;*434381*'6 4/)6:8'+*1-31(484/*'*6;81+*14 4/* ,*1*:348:4/*6*'739*;*16381:8'/366*'731(314/* C*'*B-814/* ('8)1+4/04/*/0618498C;B*4*+4/*D)0B3:-31(;*'38+8:6*'739*

,*63+*6814/*:)'4/*':B3C6-('8)1+ 4/0481B-4/*98C;*4*140)4/8'34360)4/8'3G*+48981+81*4/*603+6/8'4:0BB

81*4/*B*66 31 4*'C6 8: 4/* +*9B0'04381 C0+* 31 4/* /*'*310,87* )1+*'B31*+ ;0'0 06 90''3*+ 31 4/* 7*'+394 ?6);'0A 4/* 9B03C68:+)0B:0C3B-;*16381310++34381484/*:3'64:0C3B-;*16381 3:

'*D)3'*+ =8)B+,*'*64'394*+:'8C 06*17360(*+,-4/* 31364'-8:*:*19*!*44*'+04*+

7!02 8197 & 1$ 10:4*'C04/ 4/368)'4:31+618C*'34314/*='34;*434381 01+=34/8,6*'70438160,87* 4/*60C*36+36C366*+

/*3C;)(1*+8'+*'

06;066*+,-4/*B*0'1*+'3,)10B 9819*'1*+ 36C0314031*+01+0::3'C*+

36;86*+8:0B81(=34/0BB;*1+31(0;;B3904381?6A 3:01-

* .

< ;* * +< %($%$# 120B /*4/*'6;*0531(&'*0681*+ .

*6&8 /*4/*''*;8'40,B* .

*6&8