Sajjan Singh v. Sudesh & ORS.




    
  

   

  

  

   
             !"# 

$% "!!  !"

# "$%" 

&$$"
%"" ''%%"()* ''+$,-.(/

0*" ""$
%"""/ &$$"$,-.($-'*"%" $./

$% "!!& 1-' "$%" "23$$'45 "$ %%''"6"3$-,45 "$"%$5 '") 5  $"  ".-(    $ %"5-      $".4 $+5"4$*.% )$"*42+)" "*. "(+"3 0$%"%%'$*".$,-.( "%*)$1-"*'++$"*)$- '*)$ %' %%''+(*)$'15'7-. "

5!%5$,-.(" 8  .""*)$"'1-"+" "(*)$' "7-.4!%5$,-.(" 8 4 (.$%%'%" ""*),,.$ %%''$" 0$%"'.%"%'#8
4892

89
-'0+4!%*+,,.$%%'' ,5.$ 4$*"$"+"%"*) "%#  +$""%#9"$%-"$"  $%"(-".8:;9 :5'*".<3#

 8  

  ;-*)"%#  "

$"' *$'  $"("4"%#   5-" "%#90$%' $%%''$$ %%'',5.$'+)%" %'#89
4' 0+4!%5"."'*".53#   8

$"
*".$0$"+%-*+$( $*"$"+$$+'*)+) %"-( (')'( +".$3%'

4".+$$4" (-". :=;9 : %'#8
("3*)'":>?1@: '' $$" ,5.$"(-". 9 : =;9 :+$$ '-#"$"%" %'#8
"" %' #892("3*)'":A>@6: ''$$"0$%" -( (') '(  +  -*,      $  $"  $  " ,5.$"$"-""+-''$"$" )%"+$-+" $"%")"+$-..$ %"$"-.$$1-",5.$   '5.

*$$'.'$"

 4((B-"4$($"

%+)'5.*$$"'.'$" 0$ (')((*" ,5  .$4  +$-  $  3+'.  '  +)  ''.'')   --$"')  ("  "  $  '(    ,5  .$  5 "."'

 

%#   '$+"(4" %"'(")*,4   4$."- (*') $-C'- $%' C'( ("'  "( $1-"  ("45""$,5.$+$'+ -' +" $; $' $"%"%"#8
4892 89
5$,-.("



8%5'-
 
       
 "."<3#  8



80$%%''$'$+" (') '(-(%"D-*5%"%" 8  9     $  +".')  ''.  $  (')  '(  

+5"''0$' " $ "$" %"%" "''. 8:  "*),,.$,5.$ ,')(

8:;9 : 0$"(-".89

:;9 :*'. ,5.$0$(--'%"+  8  "-'4' %"(-".8:;9 :(%".%'#8
'

0+4!% ''$$" $",5.$0$"$ *'*)$+".  #9 " 3.-%"( "($5'1-" #  +"(" # $($"-"'.-" $("   %"  +"  (  +  '    *$'    #9+$"$)$"('"%'$* 3*) #   0$'""'1-"5+ -%" 

 $,-.(4 "3."$%"-(

 (')'(

4-*D-')( *) (') '( 8

9 4($'$"% #9$5*(+";'-5% $%"%" '$;  $$"%'-

9$$"  #  $-%"%" ,5.$$)"'-$ ()("$)'3".')4-#  43-% ,')4  +"  +"  .  $  %%''      5-"    $  E-# +"+".$  5-'')- '*)$%%''+""*( ,,.$%" ""%%''$,-.( "%*)$'""'1-"*-$(  5-" +$$'"7-.4!%0$%%''1-"%"

8 $,-.($$'$$ (')'(

+ ' -"$" "-*(""5 (')'( %"4$" "4$%' -''() ".$$*  (')'( $ (')'( 

" 8

9 +" '')% (%'(4$,%"%"+"%"*+$ %' $*"$"*)    -$4$( -*$",%"%" >'.  .."5  .  $  .  ""  *)  $ 1-"*'+4$%"%%'$*%" ""*)-- -' %' %%'' 1-'  "  $  %%''  $  -*(  $  $  " %%''1-"$(-"') "$+$+$

8  $%"$%'$+"("%5')E  -"$"".-$5'%-*+$%"* $* %'..5."%-D-  '+ $$% - "( ",-$'.$  $ 5--*$"5''(E -"$"".- $$%%''3$'($*  (')%"-( '(

4.5.'- $"+$$ ''$"%5$" %%'',,.$,5.$ "%#  $5% '')$''. "%%" $+"(4+''*3 ($"%"0$%%''4$-.$$($ (')'( 8  9 ("3F

  ("3  ?  "%5')  *-  5    $  -(  "  3   "4%"'-   (')'( 9 ("3 ?4,5.$"$-""+"(%'' "(-".

: =;9 :+$-%%"5' ,,.$%%'' 0$1-"*'+$5 '%%"%'. $%"4 -(

 ("34 8  ("3F

   9  ("3?".$%"%5$-(( "-"""*)$'.$$",5.$+(% ' $$"%'-

9$$"- "(-".8:;9 :"$) +"(%'$""$; 8:;9 : 5-"

 "%#9".'"-'4"% #  4*4-'' $ $"- "(-".

:=;9 :$; $" ,5.$%'-

9$$"-

 "(.

$$"$" "(((B-"'  $ "*)"%#  '$) '+ %*"'$$$(' $ 1-'  "  $  .  "%  -*D- %-"$"$-%%"$,-.(% *)$1-"*'+ +$  $  -*(  $  $  %"-( (')  '(   8     9   "    5'  -(  "  +   .-"    $"  ,5  .$    $"  -'    *  ) (') '(+$-,5.$*..")$-(E $'"54-*($ $-(("3F

  ("3?"3"4'-  -(("3? 5*.5' $%"5   $0" " !"%")4

 $"4:$:4'.+$$ "".' $"-*((*)-'$"% #9";'-5% "(-".8:;9 :4$ - '*)$%%'' "'"+$-D-'"'  %(*'-"  $% 
' 4   $"4$   E$5'")$"-' "$%"%"5-  $".4%"-$%%"*3"" $1-"*'++$ $"*' 0$-*'D- '++$$" ",- "   &$$"$%"$5% "($ -(    (')  '(  

9 8  ("3F

  9

("3?/  &$$"- $%%'''(.'" +$-  D-'  "'    %   (*'/ 0$%%''%"  $%'$"." %'    "%    +"  %"-( (')  '(  

+$'%"-'" $"'$ '' $"%5$" ,5.$$%%''
% #  "%$"*)+) "%')%" $5($ -( $ (')'(-(%" $5. 3 %'

*+$",,.$%' $*"$",5 .$6+5"4$).5)% "%')"."$ ;    "   "%  $"   $  (  (-     ($"%" E%" 4$"%"%'$ -*D- (')'(-(%" $%"%"+'  8  9 $(+"-+".

*"$.-" $%' $"+E -"$" 5""$%"(-".8:;9 : %'#8
4'0+4 !% ''$$" $",5.$-'% $"+.5$",5.$$*(;'-5 +"% "(-".8:;9 : %'#8
4'

0+4!%(')4$%%'' '"%'$ +"( "%#  $"(")$ -(    (')  '(-(%"    8    9   %D-")"*)$1-"4-' "$

%%''$ "')$ "+  '. "%'4$ %'"$+"(*)$"%*" ($%" $%%''"." (')'( -(%" 8  9  E$5+ $ ("4$-(("34F

 ("3?"'*'*" 5 "$%-"% ,- $(""5") E  +-'  $      $  $-.$  $  -(  ("3

    ("3  ?      *"  .-"    $"  ,5  .$4 %""" "%#  4*-$-( $5*-%*)$ $('54$)+"..'-  $-(*)".%'$$(*".-"  $",5.$ 0$  (')  '(   

 "3    + ( *)$ (')'( 8  9

"%5')0$D-$'' ""(G

  

 

   ! "### $ "###%

 




  

 % &=  %" (')'(  8 4$" ,5 .$+.5"(-".8:;9 : %'*".#8
%."'-"+$'":A>@6:$%'4%" $ -(%. 6+5"4$ (')'( 8

+ -"$"( 5 (')'( 9  ("3? 1'-   $ (')'( 9 4*)+) "'A.'$4" ''+   0$$-'%" $%"%")+.  *)$"B$".$ $" $%"*-

)".

*-'" 8 4$  (((*" $ (')4"'5 "4(--'."(+"-+".  " ."$.$""%" $  -'  '(  '  '  0)4   "  + ($ 9 4$ '($5 * 'H+$$"-"

 ;;;

;;

 0$ *)+) $.  $ -' %"4 ,5.$ %")$*.5("" (-".

: =;9 :') "$%-"% - "$%-"% '.$$5-')  '4$

+-'%%')" +-'*'+$$ ,,.$ " %") ,". $"'(

8  9 (35$$",5.$+ '').5"(-".

: =;9 :*)"(-".

:=;9 :') "$%-"% - "$%-"% ' $"  ,5  .$  +    (%    ''    "  (-".

: =;9 :"$+(%''" "

:=;9 :  .5    $(    $  ".'  (')  '(  

4$' "("$ :=;9 :*)$-" " $",5.$ 5-" "%#9 ")5''$" 5-"  "%' $"%$$ (') '( 9 .'*)$",5.$" $-""+-'*$*)$%"5   $4$((5("",  $

'+$*'-""-%$" "")%" '(.-"$( "(%".+$"%. $"$ %"%")E$$4"".'  *'-*-+%"'$; *. $$" %") 0$*".$1-"$"- "%#  +"'''"(-". :=;9 :$",5.$ *(+" "(-". :=;9 :%"$'( *+$%"1')4$",5.$%+)$ )" '5.*$ -"'E$" 

 -$ ++4
%.$4B".$ ((B-"4$($"0$ %"%")' *$*)$",5.$+$"*)''1'E $"$; 

$$"$$("4"%#

 +"(%'"(-". :=;9 :$ ;  $ $" ((B-"' *$51'E$" (')  ,,  .$  %%''4  -""    $"  %" ,5.$ "%#   5-.$"  1$  B-"4  -(  2(*4  B"$  #'4  $    -
%#  $5"%'%" $((B-"4 ($" $",5.$" -3)$"$%"%") ' *$*)$",5.$0$"*)D-""'+$$ '%'+$"""'D-$".$)((5*' %"%")4".""D-" 5'-$"  ("$
   0$ "% $5 '  -) 5  -*$"%'$((B-""'D-$$"".$$

 $",5.$'.''+ -'("0$" -$%'"*)$%"$((B-"' *$) (I"$"-(4$" ((B-"$ ; 

$"(-". :=;9 :%"5-')+*)$" ,5.$+-'*$"*)$"1'E$"$;

9$$"$E$("4"%#  *(' '$"

9$$"- 

$$"

$$"-  "(-". :=;9 : 0-(-%4"%#  +" '' $%'-

$$"- "(-". :=;9 :

'  5-" "%#9$''*5'') $; &$  $  *"54  D-  #     +"   5-" $%%'' 0$%%''$ '- "'"$ '("'  %"% $"$+'; *)"%#   5-" "%#9   $  %"5$- "'"+$-3. D-'"' (*'E$$4(( B-"$"$ $",5.$$; 

$ $"$%+)$)"  %"";- '



   5-" "%#90$%%'' (') $1'E$" ((B-"$-*( '

9$ $"- 

$ $"$"*)((B-" I"$"-(4$%%''*(+"$ ' *$*)$",5.$0$"$.""-..5

 $ $$%"%")' *$*)$",5.$+5" %"(.+"$%%'' $ +"$' *)$",5.$$-' ,%4$- '*)$%%'' "'"+$- '(.%(*' ".')4D-# +" 5-" $ %%''.$"% E  5+    +$  $  *  -  $"*54  $ .""*)$1-"*'+*''+- "-'4$%%'''+$ ""( )"- ""(-".8:;9 :*)"%#9+-'* -*,,-(-".%"%".  
3$' 7-.

   ($*(*"