High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/75/2017dismissed

Purushottam v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2017-01-10Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages

#$%&#'#("!) !"

''%*#+

,%'% -##(##.*%

%/0%

!"#$% %$&!"'(

%& #%*1#'%*2)0$#) */

33333 %$&! * / % #440 * +/'40 0% 0#0 5!

!"67"

!"689' :";/#%%0<(*/'(++%%) 0#0 !

!"689' : ;*00#*-$#( #//# */'(++%%<(24*/=%'0-$

"*#(## #$*#(# #>$)"??@8%*A"??@$B;*#% +0 * / + * /% -#/#$* 04 *+ < 0%C'#0

#%* 1#'%*2) #0 $'% * / *#% %'<+0*##%/*#+0+$#'%0-$"

"??@$ 0$#0#0

)/%%*#<4<*/% -#/#$* #$***#%/#%%0*+#$'#9#+#% C'# 9#+# + #( $4%0 %'7<#0 * /*#%/#%%0*%+#$'#9#+#+*##0 4*0'$#) #+#4#)=*)=*$*% 0+

9' :"5 '* %'<+0 *# */) #$$' *% //'#()$<'#0#$/#$/#*#40/+ #0=##$%)=#%$0#%-#/#$*,#4**##)$2

$*##) %$ 0 * /#$*#(# $ *0 "

!"6 <( 0#4#$#00#)#+() #+*#)=*0/04'04#4#% *+#00#%7'%$+/#*/'(++%%C'#*% +#$'# C'#$# %'#() # %*= $#'% $ 0#0 5"

!"6=#%%0'/*/)=*$*=#%0'(/00 9' :5 =#%%/$$#(+0**#*#+0 +#$'#$$#%0'($4%0#0*%4#0)**#%0#= *# *% ' 9' :@)# 0#0 D ?

"??!) =*<(*#%<0*#*##04*0'$#) =*%$4%0++0# *#+0 #$=#%<'4**$*/'(++%%)<'#$(/$ #0'%+#)#$$/0*$+/##0+0*/ +*/%-#/#$* '*%'<+0*#*/$0'#% %#40'0-$"

6"??@$*#%<=0)%%$ *$+/#$'0*#<#0<(*/'(++%% #0(*$/0 '*%'<+0*#*0'$## C'#$#=#%$+/0*(# !""#0*0$'+%%'<+0 <(*+=40 ##)*0$'+%=$+4* C'+#=)*%+#=#%#<<$#$0 #4#0 0%)*/$%0*$#0)*)*0% '0$*#4##$$/#< %'//*%$)**#%0#=*#*%

) '*0$%00<(*4*'*#=* *+

) )* , -.//.01 232"

% 0.4

- 2+&0$00@ !"!)=**$*#4=#%#0*0 +4*/*+%$*/+%*# **#0 /#%%0*%+#$'#9#+#+*##04* 0'$#8;) #+#4#)=*)=*$*=#%$4%0 *#*#0*#0$'%*/)%* /#/<2#0*#9'%##$*0*#0*=*#*% $#0+*%'<+%%%E 1#'%*2)) */'( ++%%*#0*0*#*9#+#$0'$0<(*# #04*0'$#)=*%$4%0<(*#0 -$*0'$#)#(##*=#)#(##,#(#04$''

%()%#)1''2%*# %()1''2%*#)+#$*# #0%* #0-$*0'$#)*##+%*###0#%*#$*#*'$ #0% -$* 0'$# 0#) ## %' / -$*4)*#(#-*2%*# #%*#0)

8F'$2=;0$#0*#0 4*0'$#) #+#4#)=*#%<4'%0'$#<#0

''##2 %()+%#*#%#%$4%0* #04*0'$#)**<#%%*/$0+ *'$#0%-$*0'$#0#)=* 0#0

!!D #0 %%$# 0# %%) = * 0#0 !"!

*/%%-$"

6"??@$='0#//(#% -$ "#<%*/'(++%%+*-#/#$* $#%*%<4'0<0%C'#0<#++<*#%$'0#( *0%C'#$#%+0-$"

-$% "#0#+00

5 /%%-$"

"??@$#0#%'0&:

# 6

-'%/%#0+##-#/#$*G::::H #$* :8";

* $ * /'( ++%% $$0 +#() %'%/0#(-#/#$*G::::H #$*)#%*$#%+#(<):: 8#;=*#$#%#4#%*+%/$#($+# $%'0%4#)C'(#)* / * $ /'( ++%%% $$0*$*#4+#0/$04#2#4#% *+*0%$*#4*%0'%%+#: '/'00$$*##$I 8<; 0'4*$'%# C'( #(* #%%=*$**$#<+0)#44*+ #0C'#//'(9/# G8 ;(-#/#$* #$*)#%*$#%+#(<)%'%/00 '0 %'<:%$ 8";) %*# #2 /# #( #$ /$04*#+ #$*#(#0'4 */0*% %'%/%#0%*#*#0*$0%)+(#(* //(*#+ #$*#(#*%/%%%%'0*% $:: 8;*%#-#/#$*# #$*$++#04+#>( *#+ #$*#(#I 8;*%# #$*-#/#$*&

00*#*%'%/%/0# #$*#-#/#$*) #%*$#%+#(<)%*#9$0(#+*0# *#04*$*#4/'%'#$*%'%/%0

9$/$+#$#%%4+#'/'0 H 85;*$*/'(++%%$$0+#() #%'$*C'(#%*+#(0+#0#44# //'(<4*#0#-#/#$*G::::H# #$*)#% *$#%+#( <)#%2*+%*=$#'%#4#%*#$ //%0<#2#4#%*+)#0<(0+*+ +*%$:: 8#;#*%$*%$$0<(#$+# $' # $ 4 +# '/'0 #0 /'%*#< =*+/%+# /09$04 %9+*%I 8<;*=#%0%C'#0<#++<*#+

#$*#(##*+*%$I 8$;*$'%#(*0%C'#$#%+0 %$"

# *%$#%++<*#+

#$*#(#I 80;*%#<%+$%$'+4%* #+ #$*#(#=*'//+%%# #+ #$*#(#I#0 8;**#%<4'(+%$0'$*0%$*#4 *% 0'% #0 *% $'#$ * $ % '0%#<*/'<$% 8@;/%=**#%<+0'0%'<:%$85;+#( < 0%C'#0 :$ %'$* /0 #% +#( < +0*0<'9$04*/0%9 (#%

7 8 ;(/% #440 <(# 0/#%%0 '0%'<: %$%8";)85;#08@;)+#(=*#/0*(0#(% +*$++'$#*0)/##//#* +

G86; (-#/#$* #$*)#%*$#%+#(<)+0 '0%'<:%$85;)%*#*#0*$0%)+( #(*//(*#+ #$*#(#*%/%%%% '0*%$:: 8;*%-#/#$*# #$*$++#04+#>(* #+ #$*#(#IJ::::K 8:#; *%-#/#$*<44%$#4()#

#$**#%$#4($++#04+#>()#0

#$* *# $#4(% ###<) # #$* 4# $#4($++#04+#>(*#+ #$*#(#I#0K 8;*%# #$*-#/#$* HB /

08 2

2 # 6

-$"

*#(## #$*#(# #>$)"??@):

#$#'%8#;)*=4$#'%%*#<%0 #+(&:8##;*#%<$$0)<'$*#4%*#< #+0 # $+# $#% # $) /'%*#< =* +/%+%%*#(#%IBI

#$#'%8%;)*=4$#'%%%*#<%0) #+(&:

A8;

#%/#(#(##%#(6200'*+ #( +#(4$'':/#-$()%$ # :/# #2 #0 %$ +#(

/#4$'' '#/+#2I 8';

#%/#(##%$$(<%I 8;

*#% /#%%0 +#$'# 9#+# % C'# 9#+# + #( $4L0 %'7<#0&B $>#04*#+0/%%)$#% * $#00# *#% /#%%0 * +#$'# 9#+# + #( $4%0%'7<#0)='0#0%C'#$# *% $*#4'+ 1#'%*2*#*+#*/ =#%C'0<$#$0*%C'#$##//#(=#%'0< $4%0 *#0#0C'(=#%$0'$0)=#%'0 *#=#%$4%0#0*%#$*#%<#0=*0%+%%4 *#//#<(*00#*-$#()*'%)*/%%-$

"??@$='0#//( 2E*#++#08%'/#;=#%#$#%) =**/*#0<#0*+#$'#9#+#+ *$4%0<#0)<'*>'04+*#0<00*<#%% *$'+'%)=*$*0/%$<#(0%C'#$#)*'%)* >'04+0'/='0<#//$#<*/%$#%

+00/%%-$"

"??@$)9#$0 #<)='0#0%C'#$#*$#00#*#%<#0 * $$# + * $4%0 <#0 * 0 * /'( ++%%)0#0'/*0<(*00#*-$#(#//# +4*/+*/%-#/#$**#4 /#%%0*+#$'#9#+#+*%'7#0$4%0 <(* #(##-$*0'$##0)#(##)*=#%/$( 4#)>'%0#00%$##($<(9$%4*

9 /=>'0$#=

*44#%%)00#(4#(#0 /%(*+/'400% 4'0$%+#0'

/%#0%0%+%%0 $/( *% 0 < 4 '0 %4#' #0 ##$*0*%'

3.:& *%$+ ./ 2- !"'( - - 28 ., ;< .2

= 2<

- - .> = 2<