The Commissioner Of Income Tax-I Chandigarh v. Sri Guru Gorakh Nath Charitable Educational Society Ropar


  





























 
















  

  

 



  

!!"" 
#$ %
&$$
&'

(

 )"
*$ "
%+,
!

!    !

" #
# $%
&

 #
 !

" #
##'"
 - 

. / 
 $,
,

 
!!""  .  '
%$,
%  0
.  '$
 +,
,


##()*+(,(-.( 
!!",
"
$ 
%
2

 
 

,
32 4
 ,
 
5 56


 
 


 
 

!!"" )$ ",
  
4
 ,
 
5)$ "56,
!


(  7 7


3

4  $

#
 

,
 
!!"

 !   %+

)
""0
)+
 
)$ "
 



) $

 
 

 


 
%+
$ 
%

 
 
0
8$ 

"0,

0 
!!"

,

 $ 

 



  



 





       



 

   

  

 

                          



  

      

    

  !"#"

#"#

   

     



 !  "#"

#            

 



 $ 
$"


 


 

 %+ 0

0 


 
%

3 




!!"
 
$ 
%


 
,


( 

2

  ,



3

4  $
6,
:
 !!"
)+
 

 
 "$
 
%+


!

  
 

0
) 
$


 )"
 
 
 
%+ 0


0 ""+
 
 "$"+

 )"
!$!

 
 
!"
0 
 
0
 

 


) $  

!
 
0
 +
!


$);
$
 !
 
0  
 
0
 +
" 

!$)"
) 



0
$ 
$  
" 
 
)$" 

"

)
'

 
$ 

 & "
%+

 
%+
 
 
!0

 +

)
 
)+ 
 ,
"+,
:
%
% 
0 
0
"
 
$) 
 . . $
% ,
 
& "
%+

 
!"


"

" 
 
  

 
)$" 
"'
 
$)
 
$ 


 $
 
" 
 ,


)
$  

 


 
"
0
"
'
   
!  

 
 $"
"
 
 

 
%+

" '


  
 "
"+,
%
"
% ",
& 
<"
%
(, !,
" 
0
$ ,
$ $
 
 $


0

 
 )$" 
"
0

$  

$

 
")"+

 
 ! $
 $

 


$


 
$

 
%+ " 

$ 
 
 
+
 2
 
" 
 !

 4

6

 

 
 
!
0
)"0


,
0
'
   


0
$ 

 
$ 

 

"'"+
 




 
  "
+

 
 
"

 

)  
 
)

 
 "
)+


)
$  
" 
0  +

 

)

 "+,
)+
" 
 
%+
0   
!
 

  


0
 +
 


)"
!" 
 

 

)

0 
):
 
 $  

 
+
  '! 

0
 
 

 )"
!$!
$ 
%
46, 
0
 


,
 
)$ ",

 
!$ 

 3

,

""0
 
!!"
 

 

)
 

 %+  $ "

 
 $
,
 "+,
  
 
  " 
"


)
$  ,
 
 
0
0""
:$ 
 + 
 

 
 
)$ "
0

:$

 
 

 0,
 

 $"

)
 




 8$+

 
)


 
"
0
 

0

!!!
 
)$ ",

$
$ ,

""0
 
!!",

0
 
 

  


 
 
$

+
"

 
):
 
  $  


 $ "

 
,

 
 
 ,
  "+
"
 

 
 
 
$)
 
 

0
)

 :$ 

 
%$!
$




  



"
:$ 

 
%$!
$




 !" "

!

#$$  

%&!$ "' (
&)


) !""+
"
 
"
:$ 

 
!
$
0
" 
0 !!+

! 
 
 ,
$"


)
"
$!
 
 
:$ 

 
/'

 
=
$

)


 "+,


/   

)+
 
)$ "
0
!:

)
 
 
$ "

 
!,
0


 
! 
 )$ "
0

:$

""0 
 
!!"
 
$ 
+
  
 $"

 
 

)'

 
 


 8$+ "+,
 
$

 
 "
 
) 
'

0
  
)+
 %+


!!",
 


 "+

 $


0  
 


 
 

)+
 
$ :$
   
 


 
%+


8$"+

 
$


 +
  
  

)
)

$!
 
 :$

 
 "

 
) 
'
,

$ ,
0

 


0
   
 
 
 

)
$!!"
)$
0

'
   

/ 
%
 ,
 
!$



!),


$ 

%  

 

 "#    &


'

 

 ( 



 

   

   "&  "#



"#'



( * "#    

        

      





      

   



   

  

 +        ,

"# 

       

   

- 

     



  

 (* "#  

          

, "# ( 

   ( 

       

    

(

 

    

.

%



    ) "#    

     

   

    &"#   

(     

   

 

0

   

 



  

    "#



"#

 

/ (000( 



  

    



  

 







 

   

    

   

  '

"#1    

     

   "#



"#  

2 

2







 

       "#&  "#



"#'



'

&"3#   

 

  

 

   "

#



"#& 

  



  

& 

   4

"5 #(006"33

006#''

 + 



  

           



   



   

    



-

   

(

   (  

    

  

   

.

%

 

    

               

         



  

  '$ >
!$"

 
)

0$"



 0
 
  


+
"

 
):

 
$
 
  $  

 

 

 

!!$ +

) 


 $

 
 $ ,

$"

)



 
$

 $,
 

!0

 
 

"'
 
 

 
$
 

+
"
)$



/ 
% ,
 
! 

% 

?

 ""

!!"+

"

 
  
 +
$

 $
$ "
$
  

$"""

 
  
!
 
 

!!+
"

 )"
!$!
 ""
 )
 "$

 
"
 

 
!$
+

 
!

!

  

  
! 

%
 ,
 $,
"

 
!0
$  $)  4 6

 "
 


 


 
$



 
$

 
0 
):
)$
 
 


'!
  
 







 
$ +
0 "
 
 
!!" $ 
%

 
 
 8$+
 
 
 
! 
$
0

 )"
!$!


)
'!

 

 ):

 
$,
 $,


)
'
 
 
%
46  
 )"
!$!
 
 

 "$
"

$
    

 +
 
):

 "
!$)"
$"+



 
$"+
 
$

 
$

,
,
)$ ,
 
!
!
  

0""

)

 )"
!$!

%$) 
46


$ 

7

"8#)9 

  9  

 

(  

(      (  & 

 

  "      ( 

 

   # 

   

   

-

    ('





  

-

  .

%

     

  

  

- 

   

  

  ( 

  

 

 

 (  

 (

 

    

   



 (       ( 

    

  



(  

 



(



(

 

 .'

&%

             

    

      

   

 

    

          

  & ) 

 '     ,'$ 
!


)
'
 
 
)+
 
)$ "


!"
+
" 
$!
 
:$ 

 
$

*  + , &

" "

"

"-

 . %& "/

0  12&32,

0
)
$!

"
)+
 
!
$

 


123455)!2 *46(7.)(-#6.578
4$!6

=0,


"

)

 



9 @ 

 
$

$$  

%&!$ "' #" !" "

/ "

"-

 0 1((&34 ,
$)8$ "+,
"
 
! !"
" 0

 "$ 
 
$ 
%
4

6


!!")"
0 "   
 
!!"


$ 
%



0
" $ 
"
 
):

 
$


)
'
   

" 
) 


$ 

:

   

( 7

 ;"3 #

   



  

  



7

;"#

   

               

   

   

(   



7

( 7

;"3 #

(       

   

    

    

                  2 

    ( 



  

    7

 

    <     

 

    7




( 

 



  2

   ( 



  

     

(     

2  





  7

;"#

;"3#" # 7




 





  

 

  7





 

 +    



 

 7



( +  

  

  



 (      

  

  

     

  



"3# 7



(  

(    

 

 

 

  

 

 



-  

(   

- 

 7

 

  (    

2    

-

 ( 

 

 

 

      

    

 

   

(  -          

     

   

   



     

 

              

  +

 

 

 $

:  
$
$ ,
 
+
" 
)+
 
$ "

 
$!
 
:$ 

 

@ 

 



.)5;<=5
)75<)(7.)(-+(<.7(>-5<427
4$!6,


)
 
)+
 
)$ ",
", 0$"
)
0 $
 +
)

 
!0

 
 

"'
 
 ):

 
%+
 
 

 
)
$)
0 
)


 $!!"+

 


$
$ ,

0$"
) !!!
 
 
$ '
 
 
 ,

 
)
 
!!"
0

"+
)
",
'! 

0
 
"
0


)
!$
)+
 

  "+,
 


 
)$ "

3



 0



 
 


 
!!" ,
"
$  %
 ,


% 
 
!!"
0
"

 

+
,
 0$"
)
!!!
 



 !$"+
A 
)
) ,
 
! 
!!"
 
""0 # $(?.

*(< ##()*+(,(-.(  67.);+.5 427.65

4*;5  












 2(.-52+