High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7536/2017dismissed

Suresh Verma v. State Of Haryana & Others

2018-07-04Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath7 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'() ) ) ) * * * * +,#&-.#,/! #"%"%'#, .& "!"# !,0!'!!'1"-#,& #&2'1#'"& 3(4 53 3(4 53 3(4 53 3(4 53 663 663 663 663 ,#&#'"( 3,!78"%'9-:17$!"#:

,"-#2#"%"%'#, 3,.%&-!;!,9:11;:!,0!'! 663 : 663 : 663 : 663 : -# 2#"%"%'#, <!& #;#$"#1 !& 3!0, "-# 3+'%$%2!; ,2,!"%': !'%2!" ' # /!1# ! ,#2,#&#'"!"%' " "-# +2#,%'"#'1#'" ;%$#:!'%2!"'"-#2,#"#=" !"-,#!"2#,$#2"%' , 2,7%1%'9&#$+,%"0-#,#!

"#,:-# %;#1

<-%$-<!& 1%&2&#1 ' -# 2#,!"%7# 2!," "-# &!%1 ,1#, ,#!1 !& +'1#,( >%"-+" #=2,#&&%'9 /0 2%'%' ,#9!,1%'9 "-# #="#'"!'1'!"+,# "-#"-,#!"!22,#-#'1#1?0"-# 2#"%"%'#,:"-%&2#"%"%'%&1%&2&#1 %';%/%'#<%"- !1%,#$"%'",#&2'1#'" "$'&%1#,"-#$;!%/

"-#2#"%"%'#,1#"#,/%'%'9"-#"-,#!"2#,$#2"%' %' !$$,1!'$# <%"- ,+;#& !'1 1#$%1# "-# $;!%/ "-#2#"%"%'#,?02!&&%'9!&2#!@%'9,1#,<%"-%'! 2#,%1 "</'"-&!

"#,"-#,#$#%2" $#,"% %#1 $20 "-%&,1#,!'1$//+'%$!"#"-#1#$%&%'" "-#2#"%"%'#,A -# +2#,%'"#'1#'" ;%$#: !'%2!": %' 2+,&+!'$# "-# !

,#&!%11%,#$"%':2!&&#1"-#%/2+9'#1' %'1%'9'/#,%"%'"-# $'"#'"& "-#,#2,#&#'"!"%' "-#2#"%"%'#,!'1,#8#$"#1"-#&!/#-# 2#"%"%'#,-!&"-+&$-!;;#'9#1"-#&!%1,1#,?0<!0 "-%&2#"%"%'#-!& !7#,,#1 "-!" 33

+'1#, #$"%' )* "-# ,%/%'!; ,$#1+,# 1#: B C , &-," D"-# ,4E -!& !;& ?##' %;#1 , &##@%'9 ! 1%,#$"%' " "-# !'1 : !'%2!" " 2,"#$" -%& ;% # !'1 ;%?#,"0 <-%$- %& !;;#9#1;0 ?##' "-,#!"#'#1 ?0 "-# 2#,&'& '!/#;0: 7"!, %'9-!-;!!'1 +&-!'"!,&-!1:%'<-%$-'"%$#-!&?##'%&&+#1"%& !;&!7#,,#1"-!"7"!,%'9-!-;!;#7#;;#1! !;&#!;;#9!"%'""-#1#2+"0 //%&&%'#,: !'%2!" !9!%'&" "-# 2#"%"%'#, "!@%'9 ;!$ ,/ -%/ -# &!%1 $/2;!%'"<!& ;@#1%'"?0 "-#"#!/ $/2,%&#1 11%"%'!;

#2+"0 //%&&%'#,: !'%2!": #2+"0 +2#,%'"#'1#'" ;%$#: !'%2!" !'1 #-&%;1!,: !'%2!" !'1 7%1# "-#%, #'F+%,0 ,#2," 1!"#1 *) : "-# 2#"%"%'#, <!& #='#,!"#1 !;; "-# !;;#9!"%'& ;#7#;;#1 ?0 7"!, %'9- !-;! " %& !;& !7#,,#1 "-!" 6!+&!; 6%&-,#: 3#/?#, !,;%!/#'" -!& !;& !&@#1 "-# -%9-#, !+"-,%"%#& " 2,7%1# 2#,&'!; &#$+,%"0 " "-# 2#"%"%'#,-#2#"%"%'#,-!&!;&!7#,,#1"-!"-#-!1,#9%&"#,#1'#

)1!"#1

B +'1#,#$"%'& *)!'1 "-#!";%$#

"!"%':!'%2!"%"0%'<-%$--#-!1!;;#9#1"-!"-#-!1,#$#%7#1!&#!;#1 #'7#;2#$'"!%'%'9!;#""#,?0<-%$-&/#?10-!1"-,#!"#'#1-%/"2!0 ;!$&"-#,<%&#-#<+;1?#1'#"1#!"-"%&!;&!7#,,#1"-!"'# !'8##7!'!!'1-%&2#,&'&+&#1"/!@# %;"-0$//#'"&+2'-%/!'1 !;&+2'-%&'#2-#<.%@!&#/7#1!'!22;%$!"%'' ""-#

: %"0 !'%2!" , "!@%'9 ;#9!; !$"%' !9!%'&" !'8##7 !'! # -!&

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

#&2'1#'" -!&,#;%#1+2'"-#,#2," "-#$//%""##$'&"%"+"#1" ;@%'""-#!;;#9!"%'& 7"!,%'9-!-;!!'1-!& +'1"-#!;;#9!"%'& " ?# !;&# ' "-# ,#2;0 %;#1 ?0 ,#&2'1#'"& : I ) 1!"#1 J :%"%&&+?/%""#1"-!""-#,#2,#&#'"!"%'/!1#?0"-#2#"%"%'#," "-# #2+"0//%&&%'#,:!'%2!"!'1+2#,%'"#'1#'" ;%$#:!'%2!" , 2,7%1%'9'#9+'/!'!&-#<!& ##;%'91!'9#,"-%&;% # ,/+'@'<' 2#,&' <!& /!,@#1 " "-# '$-!,9#: #$+,%"0 ,!'$-: : !'%2!"

) <-%$- +1-7##, %'9-: +? '&2#$",: '$-!,9# #$+,%"0 ,!'$- -!1 $'1+$"#1!'#'F+%,0!'1,#2,"#1"-!""-#,#<!&'1!'9#,""-#;% #!'1 ;%?#,"0 "-#2#"%"%'#,"%&!7#,,#1"-!""-##'F+%,0<!&!;&$'1+$"#1?0 !//#-!, %'9-: "-# "-#' '$-!,9# ;%$# &" 6%;;!: !'%2!" ?+" ' "-,#!" <!& +'1 ,!"-#, !& 2#, "-# &#$+,%"0 ',/& %&&+#1 7%1# 3#/

*J J 1!"#1 : 3!0, %& '" #'"%";#1 " !'0 9+'/!' ' 7#,'/#'" #=2#'&#& & !, !& "-# 9+'/!' 2,7%1#1 " "-# 3!0, "-#3+'%$%2!;,2,!"%':6!,'!;%&$'$#,'#1:%"%&$!"#9,%$!;;0 /#'"%'#1"-!""-#2;%$#&#$+,%"0J9+'/!'%&2,7%1#1"-#,!'1-#, !/%;0 /#/?#,&!&"-#0-!7#,#$#%7#1"-,#!" ,/+,#'1#,0'9:9!'9&"#,!'1 -%&?,"-#, 9%'1#,0'9',#9!,1"

)1!"#1

B :%"%& !7#,,#1"-!""-#/!""#,<!&%'7#&"%9!"#1?03!-#'1#,%'9-:<-1%1'"

%'1!'0",+"-%'"-#!;;#9!"%'&!'1' "-#+'",!$#1,#2,"%'"-# <!& &+?/%""#1 " %& !;& !1/%""#1 "-!" "-# 2#"%"%'#, -!1 /7#1 !' !22;%$!"%' " "-# #2+"0 +2#,%'"#'1#'" ;%$#: %"0 !'%2!" " "!@# ;#9!;!$"%'!9!%'&"!'8##7!'!<-+&#1"/!@# %;"-0$//#'"&?+" &%'$#"-#/!""#, !;;&%'"-#$!"#9,0 ''$9'%K!?;#

#'$#:"-#,# ,#:' ;#9!;!$"%'<!&"!@#'?0"-#2;%$#&2#,"-#,#2," "-#,#&2'1#'"&: "-#,#<!&'"-,#!"""-#;% #!'1;%?#,"0 "-#2#"%"%'#,'"-#&+?&#F+#'" ,#2;0: %;#1?0,#&2'1#'"&: I)1!"#1* *:%"%&!7#,,#1"-!" !,#&-6+/!,.#,/!:?,"-#, "-#2#"%"%'#,-!1,#9%&"#,#1

%' "-#0#!, !";%$#"!"%'6%;;!:!'%2!"+'1#,#$"%'&

: I ) "-#!'1#$"%' "-#,/&$"%'<-%$-%'7#&"%9!"%'-!&?##' $!,,%#1+"<#7#,:%"%&!7#,,#1%'"-#&!%1,#2;0"-!">%"%&7#,0/+$- 2#,"%'#'" " /#'"%' -#,# "-!" ' "-# $/2;!%'" ! $!&# B 1!"#1

* B +'1#, #$"%' : J !/?;%'9 $": %"0: !'%2!" <!& ,#9%&"#,#1%'<-%$-!,#&-.#,/!2!%1! %'# J:!

"#,!1/%""%'9-%& 9+%;": ,/ "-# $+," ;#!,'#1 3: !'%2!" $!&#

1!"#1

J& : J !/?;%'9$":,#9%&"#,#1%'%"0:%'<-%$--# 2!%1 %'# J!

"#,!1/%""%'9-%&9+%;" ,/;#!,'#1 3+," $!&# 1!"#1* BBBJ&):)*:))*: ,#9%&"#,#1%' %"0:!'%2!":%'<-%$--#<!&!$F+%""#1' ,/"-#'4?;# +," #/,!8 .#,/!: "-# "-#' ;#!,'#1 3: !'%2!" -!" !9!%'&" "-# '#2-#< 2#"%"%'#, !'1 &' !,#&- 6+/!, .#,/! '!/#;0 .%@,!/ ! $!&# 1!"#1

-!&?##',#9%&"#,#1J&

:;!"#,' #$"%'

!'1 $"-!&?##'!11#1!9!%'&""-#&!%1.%@,!/ !'1!$!&# 1!"#1 J&

!'1 !'1 $":-!&?##',#9%&"#,#1%'%"0:!'%2!"-#",%!; "-%&$!&#%& 2#'1%'9 %' "-# +," /" -!&-% !;! -!+-!': ;#!,'#1 11%"%'!; #&&%'& +19#: !'%!2" !'1 %=#1 , * , "-# #7%1#'$# 2,&#$+"%'<%"'#&&-!"!$!&#

1!"#1* J&)*: )B:

: : ): : -!&?##',#9%&"#,#1%'%"0:!'%2!" !9!%'&""-#2#"%"%'#,+,#&-.#,/!:-%&'#2-#<.%@,!/&' !,#&--%& ?,"-#,K!1!'11!;?%,-%&$!&#%&2#'1%'9%'"-#+," 3&.%'"%: ;#!,'#1 3:!'%!2"!'1"-#&!/#%& %=#1 , *'"-%&$!&# .%@,!/"-#'#2-#< 2#"%"%'#,-!&?##'1#$;!,#1!&!2,$;!%/#1

#'1#, -#,#!,#/!'0$!&#&,#9%&"#,#1'"-#2#"%"%'#,!'1-%& !/%;0A"%&!;& &+?/%""#1"-!""-#,#%&'!22;%$!"%'#7#, %;#1?0!,#&-6+/!,.#,/!, -%&'#2-#< ,&##@%'92,"#$"%' "-#%,;% #!'1;%?#,"0',#9!,1""-# &"!"+&,#2," %;#1' ) *:,#&2'1#'"&: I)-!7#&"!"#1"-!"

"-#,# !,# B 3+'%$%2!; ,2,!"%'& %' "-# "!"# !,0!'! %# 6!,'!;: !'%2!": !'$-@+;!: %&!,: /?!;!: -"!@: !,%1!?!1: !/+'!'!9!, !'1 +,+9,!/ -#

%$# "-# +2#,%'"#'1#'" ;%$#: !'%2!" /!1# $,,#&2'1#'$# <%"- !;; "-# +2#,%'"#'1#'" ;%$#J//%&&%'#, ;%$#J #2+"0 //%&&%'#, ;%$# "-# !

,#&!%1 3+'%$%2!; ,2,!"%'&?+"#=$#2""-#3!0,& "-#3+'%$%2!;,2,!"%':6!,'!; !'1!,%1!?!1'"-#,3!0, "-#3+'%$%2!;,2,!"%' "-#"!"# !,0!'-!&?##'2,7%1#1&#$+,%"0?0<!0 2,7%1%'9!9+'/!'"%& !;& /#'"%'#1 "-!" "-# 3!0,& 3+'%$%2!; ,2,!"%': 6!,'!; !'1 !,%1!?!1 -!1 9#'+%'# "-,#!" 2#,$#2"%': "-#,# ,#: "-# 2,"#$"%' <!& 2,7%1#1""-#/?+"%'& !,!&"-#2#"%"%'#,%&$'$#,'#1:%"%&!7#,,#1"-!" "-#,#%&'"-,#!"2#,$#2"%'""-#2#"%"%'#, -!7# -#!,1 ;#!,'#1 $+'&#; , "-# 2!,"%#& !'1 2#,+&#1 "-# ,#$,1<%"-"-#%,!?;#!&&%&"!'$# -#,# %& ' 1+?" "-!" %' "-# ;#""#, 1!"#1 : ' "-# &+?8#$" ,#7%&#1 &$!;#J',/& &#$+,%"0 " ?# 2,7%1#1 " 7!,%+& .&J1%9'%"!,%#&: "-# '!/# "-# 3!

0, %& $'&2%$++&;0 !?&#'" -# 2#"%"%'#, ?#%'9 ! 3!0, $!''" $;!%/ &#$+,%"0 !& ! /!""#, ,%9-" <#7#,:-#-!&!,%9-""!&@ ,&#$+,%"0%'$!&#-%&;% #!'1;%?#,"0%&%' 1!'9#,%&,#2,#&#'"!"%'<!&,1#,#1"?#$'&%1#,#1?0"-%&+,"7%1# ,1#,1!"#1 2!

!'1<-%;#1#$%1%'9 "-#&!%1,#2,#&#'"!"%':"-#+2#,%'"#'1#'" ;%$#:!'%2!" +'1"-!""-# 2#"%"%'#,-!&'"-,#!""-%&;% #!'1;%?#,"0,!"-#,!$!&#7%1#

1!"#1* +'1#,#$"%'& :)*:)B: :

: )!'1 <!& ,#9%&"#,#1 !9!%'&""-# 2#"%"%'#,%' %"0: !'%2!" " -!& !;&

+'1 "-!" "-# /#/?#,& "-# !/%;0 "-# 2#"%"%'#, !,# !$%'9 7!,%+& $,%/%'!; $!&#& <-%$- -!& "-# ,# #,#'$# %' "-# ,#2;0 %;#1 ' ?#-!;

,#&2'1#'"&: I)1!"#1* *-#';0,#9%&"#,#1?0"-# 2#"%"%'#,<!&

)1!"#1

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

&"$&"& G663 H G663 H G663 H G663 H ) ) ) ) * * * * -#"-#,&2#!@%'9J,#!&'#1 ( #&J -#"-#,#2,"!?