High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5235/2015allowed

Cholamandalam Ms General Insurance Company Limited v. Indu Kaushal & ORS

2019-05-10Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

!"#$%# &'( && )#% $%*% # +& ,#

#+- #./ # &&

#!,##./ ##&0 ,#2 $% *% 3 4 5 6% '#07 #%*% !

8#6(*% .4

#/ %# 6#%5 &%# ! 99 #) 5 #&8

3#/#.8 * 34#

"# $%# &' 3 %## % &# /5 #5# 0+:";; ;

## ### 5 / .

5 & %+;

&# < 6% !

8#6(*% 455# "%#5=%#% # /5#5#0( "><<? 4 !

"%#/@ 554 #!

+ *% #4#55 # "%#5=%#%# &#4#7 #A5+#

/5#5#0(

:;;; '4#45 # !

8#6(*% ? 4 ' # #@&%#+.

"%#55!#/5:

%6.,!= #%.#& 0 38 #/5 5/ # 55 #/#' 5 & #65#/6'

8#6 ( *% 4 #'5 /#7 / 55 #? 5/ #55 # & #?#% &.!

8#6( *% %# %&-%# &? !

"%#/ @ 5# &5$+0 < ? #/# 5/ #%4'# &# #5 . 44#75 $ #54 ,# = +,/(."%#5#45 '#'+;.2? 456%'# ? ## 44#75

5#.

@7."%#5 ##< ## 4#45#'+.2? 4 C&'? # ## # 67. 4556'

,# = +,/(/#? 4/#'#5 6 44.4 %4

.4 %5& %# ! 5.

5# 6 4# %'

&%& ##&&&#+& 0 -4# 4 ##&0 %&4 &#4# $ -4# 6'#&0 . ' 5 6' &D% % 6#5 &D%%# #55 % # 6#5 & ' &&# =#6%4 #?%# # # &46# -#-# #'

&# #.% #& !

8#6(

5%%# 55#/5 5/ 6'#&0 #5% #&.

5/ 44#5'// $+ 4#5#6' &#%4 &5 & !% #& &#' # & $ 4# 6 #&0.

#7%&6- #/# 5/ 4

5//#/5

#/#5 # 5 #. % #& 6'&'' & $ .%

#&&#'# &

; &5 &#. 45 % 4# # A # 7& < 6% %# 55#/5/ 6#50+: ";; ;#/6'#&0 #%5 !

# 8#6(*% .5E,, $%0 &#/. 4 % & &## 4 E,, A # #& 4 5// #/5 E,+ ; A # #& // # $%#,'E,+ + @ &#/%&&# ##&/ $%&&# #. 0 ! $%*% 5## # ,A 6C 5!

"%#/@ 5 ,A!

!* #,A # . #& 0 # /&&# FC+ FC+ # #5#5% . =#6%%0 /%# &#.%0/%# &#.% 0;5#&+%'.4 45 &&#'. =#6%4# &+;;.;.2 4 # #<G&#% # 5

& #H &# &'6 6' #&-'/#'= #4 & 6&&#45/ 4# = 4# #&0%# &'

55#/ &&# %#6'4'5 &# &&&#'5 6&. &%54#6 &&3%# &'66/6' &' & 0 &&45/#&84/#.

'#&0 &%&&# #%5 % $ / ##%# &#655 #%5 ## (#=#6% 6/%6#

7 5 6'#

'#'6+;.2# &'#,# = +,/(."%#5= =#6% #%& ' ,A!

!* #.!#%. ,# = +,/(. "%#5.4 6#%5 && #8#6 (FC,.#' # 6# 6#.

/% ##&' FC,FC,9= =#6% 6#/ #' FC,FC,.#'

#46' 6+;.2 #& '/#6%= =#6% 75 6'####5% 5 & # #&# FC, = # #& 6# %# '

9 / /&## #%C # 45 6# 6 >9 <&' ,0# 45 /#'6# = 7& < .4 456%9I'# = =#6% % %&# $# #% #'

4 4 55#%&99'#.

%&# 6&&= % =#6% && 5 # %&# % / $47 ' 6;.2.

% +. .2 ;C .#%5C +;.

.> . .3 ;; $ /4 # % #' !

$ %

& $

' ( )

(% /%' G %6 4#%%#&#&5 % %+.9 .

<2. ' +;<.;

2 $# #% #'

%&# % 2# %4#C& 6 5 &' % + .992&# .%&' %+ .99C J+.< .

;;2 $/4 6/%# #

< % #'

%&# . %&# %6 %5 &&'6 %+.< .

;;C

J;.

92 $ /4 # % #' !

& $

' %&# . #5 &%#/ + .2 %.+;.24##% + .2%#C&.+<.2= & %+;.

9K<.J;.> .;

92 = =#6% 4#5' 4# & +;;.;.2= #% +;.> .;

92= 4%65#L<G&#% # 5 & % #H % +;.> .;

92 ## #54# # %&C6#%6' # A % . &&4&#'4

@#-

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#