Market Committee Amritsar And ANR. v. M/S Dewa Singh Sham Singh

   

     
 



  







!

""    # $

!

%""  &'

() **+)) * +)'

'

' ),

""""""

--..' )

 # &/"

 '

+ 0, ,'* + 0,

"""1
-  ) 
& !

 23 &
"

  4 



 

      

        4 

"

        ! "  #  

     $

 # %"        !!&% '  !

# ! &# #( #" ! ))$*)


))
*)+   & !  &    #' +,

-$
$&% '

+.

.$'

 !# !  &# #( #"  ! ))$*)
 ))
*)+/""#(#  0#  !      &  (#    "     & &%"!

 & #!&  &% 0!& &% / '

0 #&    #(  & &"

    #  !"/   & &"  11# (#     # 2 /#  &   ! #" &#   #(  #'#$)34 #( "# ## % 34 '# )-$ &%  # $
 

2 /# &  #( "# ## %  

)-      #(  5/    (#   0!  "! &%    #(

+

51#  //!"#'#$)34 

)-$'# #  !  " "&  "     !!&%  '

!#&# #( #" ! ))$*)+

5  & !  * /   5 (#"&  !51#  & !  1#

,

1#    /"  &#" (#"&        !    1#   /  &     / !      !  1#  / #  !   2    !     # /  !   ! #  

-

    # 6(#"&  1#  


      

      !

 7

7.

$7 .  # &    $
  !  "# ## #" /  &%  8  &       %#     &% /   



2#  #!" #"  

.

  &##  5# *

                                  

                                  )

 $
 #( "# ## %  

)- / ! 5&# * 63 8  9&& # (  ## &! & !   &   ! *& * 34        "# #  #  #"      !     &%    :" / #!##; 34  "# ##/ !#   &%     :"#!##<

  * 34   !   /! "# ## #"    #!&; 3 4  !      /! #!& =

2  :    /  #             #(  #( "# ## % 34'# )-$

'#$)/ !  # "# ## '#
7/ :& &!&   5# * 6% "

9*-)+ * -'7* ) 8 :

9  $
> +
3$434*-3 4?&%    #    !  "# #  #  &# #   :  & "# ## / #!  & &%   &% /    <

93 *45/&:& &!&  &% !"# ##&# # :  & "# ## /  &% !   &% &% "  & *  1&& &/:& &!  &   1&&  /  !  5#    !

 5 % " *& "    ! &  !  % &&       # @  8    ""   A#    5#    /   !!&        1&&   &  /  :&     &  5        !!     

3$4 5    # ! A#  !"# ##&/&# # :  ! "# ##&  &*B # #  # &!  "# ##! "# ##&# #:  &

3
4?&%   #/ %#  %& / &  "   

3+4?&%  !  &  /"##  %& &%    &%  #" /" &! 

3,4?&%  #" !

))$*)
 #/  !  &&   !/ 1#  #:  1#  "

3-4?&%   #    3C/4&  &31      1     36#4  ##   #"41# 63#45#&304 0  3 4    0  1&  0  2  1 3(41D3048 3C4#%%

    &  3 #"4  6%  &  3 4 #  #3  4B 3 #4" 34'(&!*6 &%  /    #(

34?&%  21@34 2  '  354  '  35  4  B  34 2 # 3'!4&#354## 3#4   #/    &   &  #          #(  #"/  #" #  &% 

$93.4?&%   #

@ &% /    #( <
93)4  ?  &%            !  36& 4 & &#    #( ;

   &%"!& &%           &  /  !  36& 4     & "/  # #&  "    &* $# !    &&  < +%  '

% "98& 

<

  6      1#         "#$ /  $
  )-  '#$)

)-$'# # * E::

::

::

0F   #&1#  :&   # /"  !  0"1#       # " %#    

 #  

)
7/  

1&    " # !&%  / #"  &%   # #    &# #    #   "  &  #     0F  #&1# #( & #(G: B&   H %  3$7 -4
11-7

2 /   &/ ! " #&     
- (#"&  ##/ $3434  H %"# ## % "3 & '"# 4 $7

/ #%/ * E
-    #       &  (#"& &%   G !,$B 2 "        &# #   #  5       B" #  &    &#"/#" !&% &   "# ##// " #"   &%  #  #  #&# # # "

   B" # /    &         &#"  $3434    &    #%/ & /  !   B" #/ # " " &   = 5#/# A# ! !0F   #&1#    
   !

" #    3$7 +4
11
$ 2 (#"&  #( "# # # %   )-
3 F #(  F4/ #   % /#"     // #" &#    

 $. #(  !&%  "# ## #"  &% 

G:  '#+. #( "# ##

% '# )-,3 E #( '#=4  "# ## &  % &%   /"&# #!  &%   #      I    "      / /   &  !  "        0F     #&  1#       #  ! "C#" 0" 1# /   :       / #" /  &%   & #""    &% / 

5 /" !0F   #&1#  $   %& '

     2'  $7   1 
7+  /       '( "# ## %   )- 3  F '(  F4 '( "# ##

% '# )-
3 F '( '#F4/ #    '( '# ! "# ## #"  &% /: 34 '#,.  '( '#/&  # /#    0F     #&  1#   !   "  #  ( 3#4 I!"# (#"&  !

" #  (3#40F  #& 1#      '(  '#,.

 '( '#& #/# A#  / "# ## #"   !  &%  /   A# /# //  "    " 2     %#    '( &%  ! /  A# /# #      '(  '#,. '( '# :   / * E   

/  &%   J5&% &&  &% &  B         &   "# ## #"  ! &   &%      #       &!     !        &   !    "@ # (   &:&#&'$D*##/  "# ##

      # #  '  D*##        #8  '  D*##

'#,. '#

% 1J 4    &%    &&     "# ## #"   &%  # &!    !    &  !  /!     

    !  #     "# #  #   / !&%    ##  # &K2   &   "# # #! !

 &%    

G: J34 #  #        "# #  #     &  % %    /"&##! !/"&&##!   %  #  /  "     !  "# ## !#  #  &%  =

I"    &     /  "" "   0F  #&1#    "# ##  %/  &% '(       " ! "    #! '  & :   / * + & "#&   &    !    /  '#,. '#/## A#   / "# ## #"  !          &%    2       &&     /   #/## A#   / /  "    " 2     %#     '(  / " # '(   &%  ! 

2  &&    /      A#   /#    #     ! +/   )    )
7/   %"/  &  / " 5  :/  ! 0"1#  !%"   & / "/ !C/G:&B      H!"

 2      H!"    / !#  0"1# &:#*
   " 8"" #" &/  !#   0" 1#

,  +  /              LM    /   L"&  M 2 #  E+ "&   4  "  / !          "     !"   #!

 5&!     /  */   3$4           &!     #     

3
4I#    !  " &    #!    # /    ! "  % # # &# (  &      #   "&  

3+4"&   &/  &  # # (  /  ! "    = 5  !       /       "&  #&      #     %   /  !" &    #! 2  !   % # # & # (      #     "     &!    "&         )    1 *222     /EG  1  35 !  / 6#!4=   ! &  #!/    #    " &    /     " 5#  #!    &         / ##  

)

)  !/   4I      "   ! &    #! # &    

       

3$4 # "      "     &     #            #&  

3
4H    #  $7 $+ # "         & /   ! "    #! =

- # * 3
4  )  " /&   #   $7 $+ #  "     #         " 2 &#   /          ! "            "  &   #   $7 $+/# 

  $7/  # / "    2     !  "       #! /   &/ & !&    &! "    2   $7   /     #  34              "/   ;   34           #    2  /      $7  &     N  J &1&I%B  32' ))1 $,7$4O

.

 0/     $    :     $7/    /             "    

 # & "  "     #    # "  &           !  # # "  #!    B%/ $$#  : &   / "    #  # /"&#   &   "/    " # "   ! # #  "  #!  

)  $
 /  #  " / //   B%/ $+ /      #   /  "       L #M /   ##

$7    (  "       &%     " &   #!!  "  /##    !    &     ""   &   2#    " &  &     !"/ "                   #             "

$

2  H!"    " &  &  /    !          2 &     !  "/& &   ! " 5  /      "  !&#     &          /  /        "  5   

/#!#    "  !        !    !  /          #  ! !  /  &        ?    #& /# ! H!"

/  #  &            !" #  "/

$$  5#      (#"&      0" 1#  H!"#     #    5      !

 H!""!& =  $
  ! "# ## #" /  &%  0/'#$)34 '#&"          "       #   /    #  /#       #   "# ##/ #"  /  &% &% /    !  #   &!           #  ""   "# #  #  "  #"         &%  &   "  /       )
7  0F     #&  1#   &  1&  I%  B& F   3#4 &#&    #  

5"  /   ! " !

2  D H!"F 3#40F  #&1#    #&#"&%  /    "# ##  2    %#     &% /  !  =

$

!"       A#   *

)       & 


*"  + 

     *  '         )       )   

             & ,- 

#% "I* ""#!

&!!  &&"    0! 2  &"# '  &% &&  /:&I*$ 2  &! &     #   "   #"& /" & !!   &% 0! 0&      # &     #    !      /"   !& &% '

   I*$/# (   *:&  ! #   ?#"" / #  &    *& # &  #&    &%  &&    !  %  1&&   0   '/  I* &          # !&0!A#  #"  & #(

+

5!//"  %     0! 5&/  &&"    0!!& &%        5   /  #     #( 2/  1#     "&        #!#    #( &%  # $
/#          '#  ! & &%  !   *&% &&   / /

,

"/  #&// !#& 1#  %!& !'(!

 )!

  ( !*  !'!

  +, "$
-,, . ! &% /# ( &     #  "    #  1#   11#  #&:"(#  #  !      #  '#  !  (  /   (# #  ##   ! / !( 

-

"&    &  &

; 4 

<  %""    

 I %"D

P I '    P