Naveen Kumar v. Central Administrative Tribunal & ORS

    
  

   


  

!"!#$!% (

)*)

+,!

%!./"/&'

(

0)*)

+$!!'

123+#

)))))))) !,/,/&'!#

" 4!#"2"

!',#+5

%3/'/",#+,/$!

#/62'+5
7+'%/8+#7

!'.7
7+'%/8+#7 &,7!#"

))))))) !"9&'%!',

"
 ( :

; )

<
 

4 < 

:

; )

<
 1; < #!"!',( #) <2#!'%!# ;+36+

%$&.+,! 9!,/,/&'!#) #) )
) &=+5

%$&.+,! >/,7 ")

+#,/ &=+5

%$&.+,!

0) ) ) 1; <

) !,/,/&'!# "&287, ?2+"7/'8 /3928'!% %+,!% *)

)

@

''!A2#! 
!',#+5

%3/'/",#+,/$!

#/62'+5
7+'%/8+#7

!'.7
7+'%/8+#7

7!#!/'+-,!# #!-!##!% :,7!

#/62'+5: $/%!

"!!B/'8 +99&/',3!', #&29 ::

9&", +-,!# "!,,/'8 &#%!#"

''!A2#! @

''!A2#!  %/"3/""!%) "7&#, -+.," #!?2/#!% '&,/.!% #!"9&'"!

+%$!#,/"!3!', /""2!% +/5>+= !.#2/,3!',
!55 -/55/'8 @ 9&","

#&29 ::

9+= 6+'% ")



8#+%!

9+= ")





+$!!'

123+# "&'

25,+'

</'87 +995/!% 9&",)

!

>#/,,!'

  )

)

+8+/'", &55

0)

!

>#/,,!'

!

%!.5+#!%

"2..!""-25 97="/.+5 !--/./!'.= ,!",)

!

.+55!% 0))

3!%/.+5

))

 9+""!%)

&>!$!#

.+'%/%+,2#!

#!C!.,!%

8#&2'% 3/"3+,.7 >#/,/'8"/8'+,2#!"

#!5!$+', 9+9!#"

/)!) "7!!, %&.23!', 9+9!#"

!,.)

95!+ "!,,/'8 -+/5!% 6!-&#!

#/62'+5) 7!+#% 5!+#'!% .&2'"!5 9+#,/!"

.+#!-255= 8&'!

,7#&287 .+"!

-/5!) 5!+#'!% .&2'"!5 #!"9&'%!', %!9+#,3!', #!5/!% 29&'

.&'%/,/&'

) @ +%$!#,/"!3!',

#!9#&%2.!% 6!5&> 9#!""

.+'%/%+,!

"7&25% -/55 >#/,/'8 &,7!#>/"! >/55 #!C!.,!%

:) @ 7!

.+'%/%+,!

"7&25% .&9= %!.5+#+,/&'

.&523'

7/"7!# #2''/'8

7+'%>#/,/'8) ,7!#>/"! ,7!/# +995/.+,/&'"

>/55 #!C!.,!%):

95!+ #!"9&'%!', %!9+#,3!', >#/,/'8"/8'+,2#!

%&.23!', %+,+ 3/"3+,.7!%)

7!#!-&#! .+'%/%+,2#!

#!C!.,!%)

7/5!

'&,/./'8

92#9&"!

.&'%/,/&'

"!!

,7!#!

'& /39!#"&'+,/&'

,/3!

!A+3/'+,/&'
&2#, %!,+/5!%

)0)

)

&9!#+,/$!

9+#, 2'%!#

D!

7!+#% 5!+#'!% .&2'"!5 9+#,/!"

6!'!-/, +..!""

!A9!#,"

#!5/!% 29&'

&2", 9#&.!""

"!5!.,/&')

#!.&#% .&',+/'"

"7!!,"

+55 #!5!$+',

9#&.!""

6!+#/'8 "/8'+,2#!

* /39#!""/&'")

+'% #/,/'8 !A9!#, &9/'!% -&55&>"


     

     

       

 

                      

       

        

      
'

!A+3/'/'8 #!.&#% >!

-/'%

 

%!.5+#+,/&'

.&',+/'!% &# /'-&#3+,/&'

"2995/!% 6!/'8 .&##!., B'&>5!%8!)

* "/3/5+# %!.5+#+,/&'

3+%!

+'&,7!# %2#/'8 .&2#"!

%&.23!', -&#3) 7/"

#!-5!.,"

%!$/+,/&'

>#/,/'8)

!.5+#+,/&'

3+%!

&'!

3&%!

%2#/'8 %&.23!', 62, &2# 3/'%"

+..!""

3&#!

.!#,+/'

$!#/-/+65!

3+,!#/+5 !",+65/"7 /%!',/,= 9!#"&'

+99!+#/'8

-#&3 "7!!,"

#!"25, 3!%/.+5 6!-&#!

%&.,&# '!$!# 8&, !A+3/'!% !A9!#,)

.+''&, -/'% -+25, !A9!#, #!"9&'%

5/3/,!% ?2!#/!"

92, 7/3)

95+./'8 #!5/+'.!

A9!#,"

%#!> +'

/'-!#!'.!

/39!#"&'+,/&'

&2# 3/'%"

"!#/&2"

!##&# !",+65/"7!% .&'.52"/$!5= /39!#"&'+,/&'

%2#/'8 +'

"!#/&2"

3+,,!# /- .&'.52"/&'

3!#!5= +##/$!% +'

+""239,/&'

&# +'

/'-!#!'.!

>/,7&2, .&'.52"/$!

$!#/-/+65!

/'-&#3+,/&'

.+'

"!#/&2"

#!9!#.2""/&'"

+--!.,/'8 9#&"9!.,"

+'

+"9/#+', +%$!#"!5=) , ,72"

/39!#+,/$!

.&'.52"/$!5= !",+65/"7!%

-+., 6!-&#!

,7!= -&#3!% "2.7 +'

&9/'/&') !#!5= 6!.+2"!

%!.5+#+,/&'

$+#/+'.!

>#/,/'8 %2#/'8

0 >&25% /9"& -+.,& >&25% 5!+% "2.7 .&'.52"/&'

9+#,/.25+#5= >7!'

3&#!

+2,7!',/.

$!#/-/+65!

/'-&#3+,/&'

"2.7

"/8'+,2#!"

/39#!""/&'

+$+/5+65!

&287, 6!!'

$!#/-/!% A9!#,) ,72"

.&'-#&',!% "/,2+,/&'

>7!#!

!$!'

/- >!

"!, /3928'!% #/62'+5 #!C!.,/&'

#!+"&'"

>!

3!',/&'!% +6&$! >&25% ",/55 5!+% 2"

/',&

"+3!

,#+9 #!5=/'8 2'$!#/-/+65!

%+,+

.&'.52%!

-+$&2# 9!,/,/&'!#)

'

,7!"!

./#.23",+'.!" >!

%/#!., 8!,

%2#/'8 .&2#"!

!A+3/'+,/&' $!#/-/!% 95+.!

#!.&#%)E

&> 6!!'

-/5!% #!8+#%/'8 .&39+#/"&'

52.B/5= ,+B!'

&,7!# %&.23!'," 3!+'/'8 ,7!#!6= +%%/,/&'

"/8'+,2#!" +995/.+',9!,/,/&'!#"

,+B!')

A,#+.,"

#!9#&%2.!% 2'%!# :

/"92,!%

;

+#B +$/'

123+# "&'

<7) 25,+'

</'87 &55

0 /,"

.&39+#+,/$!

/'?2/#= "+395!

9#/',

;

<  <  <* 6!!'

-&2'% .&##!., 3!+'/'8 ,7!#!6=

/39#!""/&'

"+3!

9!#"&') '

6+"/"

+6&$!

-+., .&'.52%!% $!#/-/.+,/&' !A9!.,!% %/"92,!% 9#/', #!8+#%/'8 +6&$!"+/% .+'%/%+,!

6!!'

-&2'% .&##!.,)

1/'%5=

+99#&9#/+,!

+.,/&'

,+B!'

25!"):

, 8&!"

"7&> 3+,.7!% &,7!# %&.23!'," 3!+'/'8 ,7!#!6= "+3!

9!#"&' >7& -/55!% >#/,/'8

 ,/3!

".#2,/'= +5"&)

%3/,,!%5=

"./!'.!

>#/,/'8 >!+B "./!'.! >7!#!+"

"./!'.!

-/'8!# 9#/', 9!#-!., "./!'.!)

7!#!-&#!

.+"! ,7!#!

.7&/.!

6!,>!!'

&9/'/&'

>#/,/'8

!A9!#,

&9/'/&'

-/'8!# 9#/', !A9!#,

&9/'/&'

-/'8!# 9#/', "+-!

#!5/!%

29&')

</'.! .+"! 3+,.7!% "9!./3!'

/39#!""/&'" ,7!#!-&#! 7!5%

"+3!

9!#"&' >7&

&'"!?2!',5= &#%!#"

''!A2#!@

''!A2#! #!C!.,/'8 .+'%/%+,2#!

8#&2'% 3/"3+,.7 >#/,/'8"/8'+,2#!"

$+#/&2"

%&.23!'," 7!#!6= ?2+"7!%)

&'"!?2!',5= 9!,/,/&'

+55&>!%)

</'.! %/"92,!% "2..!""-25 .+'%/%+,! %/#!.,!% .&395!,!

+55

-&#3+5/,/!"

+99&/',3!', .&'"!?2!',5= /""2!

7/3 +99&/',3!', 5!,,!# #!"25, %!.5+#!% ,7!3 .&'"/%!#/'8

#!"25, .&39+#/"&'

/39#!""/&'" "+3!

9!#"&' >7& +995/!% #&29 ::

9&", "2..!""-25 "+3!)

.&395/!% >/,7/'

-&2# >!!B"

%+,!

#!.!/9, .!#,/-/!% .&9= &#%!#)

+#,/!"

5!-, 6!+# ,7!/# .&",")



4 <  

1; <





0)*)

"CB"

7!,7!# "9!+B/'8 ( !"

 & 7!,7!# #!9&#,+65!

( !"

 &