High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21976/2024dismissed

Union Of India Through Secretary To Government Of India v. Ex Nk Vijay Kumar

2025-01-13Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

!"#$%&&

"#"'#( !"#$)&&%

!"# "

* + + $ #%# & #

,$ -., & ++

+ /

-., +& ++ + , '()*+,-. '

/0'0123431(/!05/6/3+78904* :8'4/*;*434381*'< ==== +

+ /

/'8)(/4/*3164014>'34;*4343814/*;*434381*'6/*'*31 13818:1+30;'0-6:8'4/*6*4431(063+*8:4/*8'+*'+04*+ ?

@ A11*B)'* C 06 ;066*+ ,- 4/* D*0'1*+ 'E*+ 8'9*6 '3,)10D 9819*'1*+>/*'*,-64/*9D03E8:'*6;81+*148 :8'4/*('0148:

6*'739**D*E*148:4/*+360,3D34-;*16381:8'4/*6*'739*'*1+*'*+,- /3E31*:*19**9)'34-8';6AC/06,**10DD8>*+,-981+8131( 4/*6/8'4:0DD8: E814/601+$+0-6:'8E4/*'*F)3634*?-*0'68: F)0D3:-31(6*'739*:8'*0'131(6*'739*;*16381314/*

1(2'131(45"'#!

*6;81+*14 8 >06 *1'8DD*+ 31 4/* 1+301 'E- 81

$ 01+>06+369/0'(*+4/*'*:'8E81@

*6;81+*14 >06('014*+'*43'31(;*16381060+E3663,D*48/3E06;*'4/* *16381*()D043816 /*'*0:4*''*6;81+*148 >06'**1'8DD*+3148 *:*19**9)'34-8';6A6*'739*C81

998'+31(484/*

;'*70D*14;8D39-);8104403131(4/*0(*8:6);*'011)04381'*6;81+*14 >06+369/0'(*+:'8E6*'739*314/*81@

0:4*'

'*1+*'31(06*'739*8: -*0'6 E814/01++0-6>/39/>066/8'4 ,- E814/601+$+0-6680648E05*4/*68D+3*'*10,D*+48 98E;D*4*4/*F)0D3:-31(4*'E8:?-*0'6:8'4/*;)';86*8:('0148: 6*'739*;*163814/)6:8'4/*6*981+6*'739*'*1+*'*+,-/3E314/* @

*6;81+*14 8 >06 +*13*+ 6*'739* ;*16381 ,- 4/* 98E;*4*140)4/8'34-:8'/3618498E;D*431(4/*'*F)3634*F)0D3:-31( ;*'38+:8'*0'131(6*'739*;*16381314/*

**D31(0(('3*7*+'*6;81+*148 :3D*+ ,*:8'*4/* D*0'1*+ 'E*+ 8'9*6 '3,)10D 9819*'1*+ >/*'*,-6 /* 9064 0 9/0DD*1(*484/*0:8'*603+'*2*943818'+*'

/*603+ ,*90E* 0DD8>*+73+*8'+*'+04*+ ?

@ /*8;*'0437*;0'48:4/*603+ 8'+*'36*B4'094*+/*'*310:4*'. BBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

**D31(0(('3*7*+:'8E4/*0:8'*603+8'+*'06;066*+);81 4/* A6);'0C,-4/*D*0'1*+'E*+8'9*6'3,)10D9819*'1*+4/* ;*434381*'13818:1+30/06:3D*+4/*'*0(031644/*3164014>'34;*434381 ,*:8'*4/368)'4

@ +'678

8"# "92:

3 1# !("'#

39"2:

;

2828"#

& /*D*0'1*+98)16*D:8'4/*;*434381*'66),E3464/044/* D*0'1*+'3,)10D/06:03D*+4898163+*'4/04314*'E68:*()D04381 ?8:4/**16381*()D043816:8'4/*'E- 01+*()D04381

8:4/**16381*()D043816:8'4/*'E-

$4/)681D-4/* 8E;*4*14)4/8'34->06*E;8>*'*+48981+81*4/*+*:393*19-314/* '*1+343818:F)0D3:-31(6*'739*4/)6,-4/*68D+3*':8'/36,*98E31( *1434D*+486**54/**1+8>E*148:;*1638148/3E /*603+*()D043816 0'**B4'094*+/*'*310:4*'

A" C "#$ %& '(

) '(

"+, '(

& !

$C ,, -

. "# & /0 '

(

) 1 '

(

8'*87*'4/* 31364'-8:*:*19*73+*8D39-D*44*'8

C< <<A*1<8DC +04*+

316*'4*+9D0)6*A37C 31 4/*

*()D043818

8:4/**16381*()D04381:8'4/*'E-

$ /* '*D*7014;0'4>/*'*8:36*B4'094*+/*'*310:4*'

;*')60D8:4/*0:8'*0E*1+E*14>8)D+E05*349D*0'4/04 '*D3*: F)0 981+8104381 8: +*:393*19- 31 '*1+34381 8: 4/* 0;;8634* F)0D3:-31(6*'739*3648,*0998'+*+81E*'34680648*16)'*4/0401 0'E-;*'6811*D36*D3(3,D*:8'04D*06481*6*'739*;*16381

/*D*0'1*+98)16*D:8'4/*;*434381*'6:)'4/*'6),E3464/04 4/*2)+(E*148:4/*D*0'1*+'E*+8'9*6'3,)10D'3193;0D!*19/ *>*D/3'*1+*'*+31906*434D*+06 ! "# $% >0618498''*94'04/*'>069814'0'-48D0>01+:0946 4/*'*:8'*18'*D3019*8)(/448/07*,**1;D09*+814/*603+2)+(E*14

/*'*D*7014;0'0('0;/606899)'314/*7*'+394A6);'0C0'**B4'094*+ /*'*310:4*'

# - )

#, 5, #5"

/ '(

678

9* :

;

< 6 ", 5 #55" =,, :=

;

#5 5+ #5"2> (

( 8

> ( 4 6 ?

A@ :B +5 #5"C52 "" #5"C :3-

> ( 8 :3-

;

'< 6( > &&&& &&&& , :

/ '

( E

B '(

' ( )

67 8

8 = F G 78 *

67 8

F G F 8 6

=HF < < *

6 < - '

(

& ‟ '

( )

* ) )

(8 '('(

)

! :

#'#( :3 - : #552 -

", 5 #55"

= "# 77 =' (

,-.-/ 0 /1-/-/2 '

( = '(

- 4 6

B '( =,2 #9

"92:8 "'2&

319*4/**B;864)D043816E0+*31;0'0('0;/8 8:4/* 2)+(E*14'*1+*'*+,-4/*81G,D*;*B8)'431906*434D*+06 #8"#"9 #!811#!#"2:

* &+'

+8#5: 171'*;8'4*+31-/32 ,-, ;0'0('0;/ >/*'*8: ,*98E*6 *B4'094*+ /*'*310:4*'87*'98E*64/*+360,D31(*::*9463:01-8:6);'0*B9*;4381 A37C06,*90E*316*'4*+73+*;8D39-<D*44*'+04*+

4/)6 314*1+*+48>8'506018,6409D*'04/*'0(031644/*68D+3*'9D03E31('*D3*: 8:981+8104381314/*'*F)3634*6/8'4:0DD8:6*'739*

)

"# &

F 8 -

- F

#, I "J $

", : #55" &

- -

/*'*:8'*4/*2)+3930D7*'+394A6);'0C+8*6'*1+*'1*(04*+ 4/*6);'00'()E*14'036*+,-4/*98)16*D:8'4/*;*434381*'64/044/* *E;8>*'E*1448981+81*4/*'*F)3634*6/8'4:0DD,*98E*668D340'3D7*64*+314/*8E;*4*14)4/8'34-*6;*930DD->/*14/*/*'*310,87* )1+*'D31*+;0'0('0;/606899)'314/*7*'+394E0+*31+' #!

+8#5:

171- (1

0DD)+*+48314/*7*'+394E0+*31/0E0#0)'G6906*+8 317*642)'36+394381314/*'348)'4484/'8)(/2)+3930D314*'7*14381 4/)6E05*4/**6;8)6*+981+8104381

816*F)*14D-4/*9)E)D0437**::*948:4/*0)4/8'340437* 2)+3930D;'818)19*E*140690''3*+314/*0,87**B4'094*+;0'0('0;/ E0+* 31 ( ) 4/)6 98E;D*4*D98)14*'703D6,84/4/*6);'00'()E*146'036*+,*:8'*4/368)'4,-4/* 98)16*D:8'4/*;*434381*'64/)6:8'+*1-31(484/*'*6;81+*144/* ,*1*:348:4/*6*'739*;*16381:8'/366*'731(314/*E*'*D-814/* ('8)1+4/04/*/0618498E;D*4*+4/*F)0D3:-31(;*'38+8:6*'739* ,*63+*6814/*:)'4/*':D3E6-('8)1+4/0481D-4/*98E;*4*140)4/8'34360)4/8'3H*+48981+81*4/*603+6/8'4:0DD @ 81*4/*D*66 31 4*'E6 8: 4/* +*9D0'04381 E0+* 31 4/* /*'*310,87* )1+*'D31*+ ;0'0 06 90''3*+ 31 4/* 7*'+394 A6);'0C 4/* 9D03E68:+)0D:0E3D-;*16381310++34381484/*:3'64:0E3D-;*163813:

$ '*F)3'*+>8)D+,*'*64'394*+:'8E

06*17360(*+,-4/* 31364'-8:*:*19*"*44*'+04*+

8#13 !

"92:8 "'2&

10:4*'E04/4/368)'4:31+618E*'34314/*>'34;*434381 01+>34/8,6*'70438160,87*4/*60E*36+36E366*+

/*3E;)(1*+8'+*'06;066*+,-4/*D*0'1*+'3,)10D 9819*'1*+36E0314031*+01+0::3'E*+

36;86*+8:0D81(>34/0DD;*1+31(0;;D3904381A6C3:01-

+ /

= <+ + ,= )&&% 120D /*4/*'6;*0531(<'*0681*+ .

*6<8 /*4/*''*;8'40,D* .

*6<8