M/S Kohinoor Autos & ANR v. H.M.T. Limited & ANR

   










 

 






 !"

"#$%$&'
(")!"*+",
-

!.

/


0%
1.$&,
2!%/
 3 &4. ,

&!.", ))"33 &!% 5",%2%  6$*$!"4/
$&7,"

&!.",  "%)&4"&!%   

 ! ! "#

$%

,"%"&!'

,( ($/
48# !"/ ,
!."
))"33 &!%

,5 $+. 8
( .&$/
48# !"/ ,
,"%)&4"&!
 99999







































! "#  $8$3
$%#::;



,
!."
," %&%
*"&!$&"4
$&
!."
))3$# !$&/
<.$#.
$% %2)),!"4
+=
&
$4 8$!/
4"3 =

-
4 =%
$&
,"$3$&>
!."
))" 3
$% #&4&"4 
%! &4%
4$%)%"4
 $8$3
$%#:;



, =",
$&
!."
))3$# !$&
$%
,
)",*$%%$&
!
* ?"
>4 4"$#$"&#=
$&
!."
#2,!
""% 33<"4
%2+7"#!
!
33
72%!
"@#")!$&%




 ))"33 &!%
,"
>>,$"8"4

!."
$*)2>&"4
,4",
4 !"4
:-/ <.","+=
!."
+7"#!$&%
$3"4
2&4",
("#!$&
-

!."

,+$!, !$&
&4 &#$3$ !$&
#!/

,
%.,!
A
#!B
,
%"!!$&>; %$4"
!."



    < ,4
4 !"4
:/
. 8"
!."
4$%*$%%"4

,( ($/
3" ,&"4
#2&%"3
,
!."
))"33 &!%
%2+*$!%
!. ! ,"%)&4"&!
/
+"$&>
!."
* &2 #!2,",

8 ,$2%
?$&4%

!, #!,%/
. 4 ))$&!"4
!."
))"33 &!%
%
4" 3",
$&
!."
=" ,

,
!."
% 3"

!, #!,% &4
$!%
%) ,"
) ,!%
$&
!."
,"

".%$3
 3 &4. ,/
.$33 2,
$%!,$#!
 3 &4. , &4
".%$3
. >< , /
$%!,$#!
1 )2,!. 3 
."
"*, &42*


&4",! ?$&>
< %
%$>&"4
,
!."
=" ,

;C/
+2!
!."
% *"
#" %"4
!
"@$%! <"
--C
.","
< %
&
),8$%$&

#. ,>$&>
!."
$&!","%!
$&
!."

"*, &42*

&4",! ?$&>/
2)!
!."
=" ,
;-
"%)&4"&!

%"&!

"
" 3",%.$)
>,""*"&!
,
!."
=" ,
-;
&4
;C/
$&
<.$#. ),8$%$&

#. ,>$&>
$&!","%!
< %
* 4"/
+2!
%$&#"
,*
!."
4 !"
 $&#")!$&

4" 3",%.$)/
!.","
< %
&
),8$%$&
,
#. ,>$&>
$&!","%!/
!."= ,"2%"4
!
%$>&
!."
% *"
."
$#$ 3%

!."
 
6!4
2%"4
!
8$%$!
, ),*!$&

!."
% 3"

!
!."
$#"

!."
))"33 &!%
&4
,4","4
!
) = 8 ,$2%
$&#"&!$8"%/
+2!
,"%)&4"&!

%! ,!"4
#. ,>$&>
$&!","%!
!
!."
, !" 
:D
)",
&&2*
+=
))3=$&>
)"& 3
&4
#*)2&4
$&!","%!
."=
%! ,!"4 !.," !"&$&>
!
2!$3$%"
!."
+3 &?
#."E2"%
! "&
%
%"#2,$!=
,*
!."
))"33 &!% !
&
)),),$ !"
%! >"
"%)&4"&!

$%
&!
* $&! $&$&>
!."
##2&!% ),)",3= "
2,!.",
%2+*$!%
!.
!."
,+$!, !$&
),#""4$&>%
$&$!$ !"4
+= !."
 
,"%23!"4
$&!
) %%$&>

!."


 < ,4


%",8$#"
< % ""#!"4
&
!."

))"33 &!%
."=
# *"
!
?&<
&3=
<."&
!."
"@"#2!$& %""?$&>
$*)3"*"&! $&

!."
< ,4
< %
$3"4
&4/
!.2%/
2,>"%
!.$%
2,! ,
%"!!$&>; %$4"
!."
$*)2>&"4
,4",
&4
!."
< ,4
+=
>$8$&>
)),!2&$!=
! !."
))"33 &!%
!
4""&4
!."
#3 $*

!."
 ;,"%)&4"&!

",;#&!, /
,5 $+. 8
( .&$/
3" ,&"4
#2&%"3
,
,"%)&4"&!

   &  ; 
%2+*$!%
!.
!."
&!$#"%
<","
%"&!
+=
!."
,+$!, !,/
*2#.
3"%% * &=
,">$%!","4
&!$#"%
<","
%"&!
!$#"
< %
3%
%",8"4
!.,2>. )2+3$# !$&
$&
!."
&"<%) )",
A&4$ &
@),"%%B/
+2!
!."
))"33 &!%
4$4
&! ))" ,
&4/
!.",","/
!."
$3$&>

!."
+7"#!$&%
$%
&!.$&>
+2!
&
!!"*)! 
4"3 =
!."
"@"#2!$&
&4
8",," #.
!.$%
2,!
&4/
!.2%/
2,>"%
!.$%
2,! ,
$,*$&>
!."
$&4$&>% 
. 8"
." ,4
!."
3" ,&"4
#2&%"3
,
!."
) ,!$"%/
)), $%"4
!." ) )",
+?
&4

!."

8$"<
!.

!."
,+$!, !,/
<.$3"
#&42#!$&>
!." ,+$!, !$&
),#""4$&>%/
&!$#"4
!."
 #!
!.
&
* &=
## %$&%/
,">$%!","4 &!$#"%
<","
%"&!/
+2!
!."
% *"
# *"
+ #?
<$!.
!."
,"),!
!.
!."
),),$"!, 
!."
$,*
$%
&!
8 $3 +3"
8"&
&
:/

&
!!"*)!

!
%",8"
!." ))"33 &!%
!.,2>.
!."
,$&#$) 3
$8$3
2,!
!
 3 &4.

,
< %
* 4"/
+2!
!." ,"),!
# *"
!.
!."=
<","
8$4$&>
!."
%",8$#"
8"&
!."
,">$%!","4
#8", < %
%"&!
&
:/
+2!
!."
% *"
# *"
+ #?
%
A2&#3 $*"4B
" 3$%$&> !."
,"*"&!$&"4
 #!/
!."
)2+3$# !$&
< %
3%
# 2%"4
!
""#!
!." %",8$#"
$&
!."

4 $3=
&"<%) )",/
$"/
&4$ &
@),"%%/
+2!
="!
!."
))"33 &!% 4$4
&!
))" ,
&4/
!.",","/
),#""4"4



&

."
44,"%% >$8"&
$&
!."
))" 3/
+7"#!$&%
&4
+","
!."
,+$!, !,
$%
!."
% *"
 "@)3 & !$&/
*2#.
3"%%
#>"&!
. %
#*"
,!.
%
!
.<
!."
%",8$#"
< %
&! ""#!"4

!$#"
%"&!
!.,2>.
,">$%!","4
#8",
&4

$%
4""*"4
!
+" %",8"4
%
)",
!."
),8$%$&%

("#!$&
F

!."
"&", 3
3 2%"%
#!
&#" !."
)2+3$# !$&
< %
""#!"4/
!."
))"33 &!%
. 8"
&!
+""&
+3"
!
),8"
!. !."
44,"%%
< %
$&#,,"#!/

*

!."
8$"<
!."

=
<","
8 3$43=
%",8"4
&4 $&!"&!$& 33=
4$4
&!
#&!"%!
!."
,"*"&!

,
!."
,">$&>
," %&%/

4
&!
$&!"&4
!
4$",
<$!.
!." $&4$&>%
,"&4","4
+=
!."
44$!$& 3
$%!,$#!
24>"/
&#.?23 /
<.","+=
!."

     +7"#!$&%
. 8"
+""&
4$%*$%%"4
."
% *"
,"
$,*"4 ))" 3
%! &4%
4$%*$%%"4 '()'*+', & )-#

  ! "  ,.*'/-

$%

"-')-', /('.01234,'./2'5 6'/4 "-')-', '(,).+7' 6'/4