Surinder Pal Sharma v. State Of Punjab And ORS
1 2 "
! !
- 7! !
-
!!!!!! 3
!!!!!!1 +
4!5 0 2 "0 (4!6+ 50
+ !
2 "0 4!2 0
60 ! 4! ' 0 2 " 4 ! (0
+ , !7! 4!
( 0 2 "
+ , !-! 0 2 "0 0
! & + +
"
# #$
% & ' ( "
!!
% ) * 9 +
+ , !- . /+ +2 5' 80 . /+ 0( " + + " + "!.0( " + + "+
+
" : ' 0 2 " * + + ( ; <+!
! 5 " " 0 2 + + 0 +
+2 + 4 8 0 0 ' 7! !
!=
( + ' = # # >
= == " 0 2" + ( (" !=!
7!& & + 2 + +
" +2 + 0 ( ( " + 0 ( +
+ " +2 6 2 +
! , !
- 7
===
" %!7!=== +
+ 2(+
" +2 0 2(
"
!=!=== " +2 +
" +2 + + ! 2 "
#
! "
# $&)
"
%& '( ) **
+ &
, - - .
* ,
3
* / +
0#
" 12
7
&
,
+
"
2
" "
* 4 &
, + &
.
,
$
" "
+
"
* ( 56
"" +" "
"
#
2
"
56 "
* (7
'(
2
* 4
"
"
" * )
" 2
+
"
"
*
-
' ( 8 "
* 9
+ '
(
, "* ' (4
" '( ;
"
"
*
- ! "*
*: : 0 +2 5' 82 2++" " '"@A ?+ < + ( 2 +
" +2 + ! + +++ " 2 (
" ++ '"@ A ?+ +
" 1
!= B= + 2 ++ -!%!
2 " 7!7!
+ (
* ( 2"+ 7!7!
%! + ( + +" " %!%!
-
8: 0
+ +2 + 4 8!0 0 ( ( " ( + + " 1 !- = (
!##B (" " 6 2 !& " + ( + , !-5'0 2 2 + + "
+ 2( " 2 2
!=!=== 2!& " + + ? , , !
7- 7
+ ( ( " + " +2 $ + ( '"@ A ?+
+ +2 5'
0 + *
+ + " +"
" ++ ( + 2 !!
%( + " "+" 0+ "++ "4 @"
' " "0
2" ' + 0 (" " 4 @" "
"0(+ "+ " + +
!
+ 0(" ' ( 0 + $ + , !- #! !
% ) * -9! C (20 " " + , !- 2 !!
% ( "+ ++ + , , !-5' !%!
" + + ( +2 + 4 8 0 !C"0 (+ !
#
7!
+ ( 2 +
, !7 -! & (
+ , !-5')+ +
+ 90
(+ ' 2( ( ( C D + 8
!"# $% & &
'
(!$# )"( /1) " (- (67
- *+ '
.
(% /1 $0$ - )00) 6 , *
- *+ '
. .% % /1)(2." - )000 6 8 7*
&
'
*+ '
)0 0 .% /1 2"( - )0". 6
, '
2 "% %&*
&
'
*+
) !2# .$ % - *+
) ! # 22 % 7 54&
!*+ 34 #!5,# ) !2#& ( !
" 0 + 5' !%!
+ #!
!
% !! + E
(
! ? 0 "+ ( + + , !-5'
%
" + + ( 0 0 " "! -! 4! 5 0 + 0 "
+ ( "
+ 2 !!
% ) * 9+ ( + "
+
+ >
( ("( ! ! $ 0 " +
" + " + $5' + (
++ '" @ A ?+ + , !-5' " + + + ("( ( ! #! & 2 "
+ + " !
%! " + + ' 7! !=
+2 + 4 80 !
+ " + 0 ( +
'= # >
== !C ( "
" !=!
7 "
! & + " 2
+ , !7 +2 5'80( ++ '"@A ?+ + " 1 != B= + 2 ++ -!%!
+ , !-5'
" !%!
!C " 7!7!
+ 0 ( 20( *
( + 7!7!
%!4 4" + 0 + #! !
%) * -9 + " + ! "
0 (20 + 2 " ((+ !
" + " + 2 !!
%
.
"
" 12
, &
,-1 *
*12
;, ,;<<;
5 )&
!*!* 5 )
" " " "
7
&
, - * *** * * 55<
"
"
)=5&=
" *>>55;&*?
@ + =*!* 5
"
" *!= 5;&
" 5& 55B 55 A $ "*4
"
$ A * * 5 "
" * < 55;&
" *** 5<5 55&<)=55B< 55A*$*.
"
+
"
"*>>55;& "
""
7
&
,-1 *:
! . 2 " 0 "
" + !+ " + " +
=
7!7!
+ #! !
% (
+ ( !+ ( 2"
!%!
7!7!
2
+ "
+ " + + , !- 5'( " ((
+ 4!& " + + " 0(" + + " " + " + + >
( " +2 2 +
!& + + " 2
+ , !-5' ( "
+ '@ A ?+ ( 2 0 + +++ " 2 ( + ++ + -!%!
""+ "
" ++ + ! " + + " " + +! A2 ( 0 *+ ++ " + + "
+ ! =! C D + :; !,++ # < 37 -
'4 9
0 (
" 0 ( =*3 "
"
9
"#
" 7
>
. 5'
C D(*.
9 " + # "
+
"* 0
5 -- -=7 >? !<=& )0. .(0#* 8
# " "* * E
" , @ $ + 4 7 74 <7 3'!)".2# $
)
<
"
= !<=& )0(. )2$ # #
,@ @& ' !<=&)0(0 0#,@
%
02 " "
2
" "
"
*@ "
"
" "
" 2
*
" * "
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
5*.
+
"*F
7 <
*.
7
" 7
>*.
& , -= !<=& )0. 2. #
" #
7 <
"* .
7 <
+
"* * .
- !<=& )0". $)#
9
# "
"
"
2
* .
"
"
"#
9
# *.
* 4 9 "
# " " +"
#
"
"
* .
+ # "
9
# *
* .
"*: ! . C D + - '
, !
"
# # 0("
"
0 + ++ + ( '+ +
2!
$ +" 222 "+ "
" "
" " ( " " " ( " " +
!@ " +
2 2 +2 ("
2 ! "- &0
0 ( "
(' ((
2 ( 2
!A2: "
" " *+ ! A A2 + + "
( + "
# &0 ( ( ! + " (+
* "+ ! " 0" "(
2 : 0 + 0( (
++++ "
7
" + ( " 0 " " ""
" " !
( + 2
! + (
+ '1 1+3' + ( 0 2 ""
" " ! 12+ +
*" ( <*E
"
*4 " # "
"
#" + * 4
"
*.
+
"
"
" ++
" 55<*.
"
* * =<* . '+ ' - 84 !
"# ) ))$
&G @
"
*.
#
#
%& 0 "
A " *
"
#
*.
- 3
" ""
3
3
*
" " + *
*: )*HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH
*HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH >*HHHH HHHH HHHH HHHH !* . , '
7 8
47 5
!
# !
))# 2 .2
&G @
9D ,
-34!)00.# ( $ "
!
"
!*!*
* =* . -
'
7!
.#) ) .
9D ,
2
+
%& ***
*3 "
2
"
* 3 ;
*7 )
.
+
*: HHHH HHHH *HHHH HHHH
5*.@ 5 '
'
!
.#0 ."
9D,
7
>
. " "
* .
"
+
"
9
#
" * ! &" @ @2 5" :&7 7 -34 9 " " #0 (" " +
" "
2"0 ++ $+ /
2" "
" + ++ + " 0+
0 *+ ++ "
C !& 0 5* E
I
I *** 5 *5)* !* 7
*E
"
"
"
*
"
. * 4
"
*4 , @5
A B .!0# '
'
#
." % * 4
* E $ ! " * 4 "
* 4 "
!
+
"*4 "
"
,
. 4 *.
=
"
"
&
"* * 7
E $
"
"
*.
" " #
* 3
# 2
* , 8-/, &4<B C!
2# ) 2.D 7 7A<
@
<< C (!) # <> 2.D @ 7A 5 '<
<
C!
(#2
D: * , "
A B - 34 A B !)00.#( $ "
"
, % 4
"
"
" 7
> <
* .
"
*,
+
%
+
"
J $
7 , D
KK***************4
&
"
;
!) =5
K*:
* .
+
+
"
G* 4
"*: ! 5"
:7
- *+ 9 !$ #$%0 ( " " " ": : " <*.
"
*5 * !
;
2
2
*5 * !
"
+
$ A
" +
+ $ $
"- 7, *.
"
"
5 *5!* 5 < "
/ " " -)0"0 &
- *+ * )*9
2
"
*
*$
7#$&
* 4
7# $&
" * 8 <
5" +* >*4
"
E * #
"
"
" *4
"
"
"
* !* 4 " +
# " 7
>
.
"
9L , 7 7 @
!
(#)) 2(2*.
"
"
="
"
>5 " * , "
*4
"
*$
"
"
"
+
* 0
"
9
* 4
9
7#
&5 7 % :
- - = !)0"0# $(%
= 34 !)00.#( $ " 87 - / , &4!
2#) 2.
"
*
"
,
$ >
>
# %& * ,
*@
3@ > 7
"
+
>*4 2 # "
#
7
>
2
"
* 2
"2
+
@ 7 -
!
$# ) * M 2
"
&
2 "
M
"
"
* E
"
"
=" *7
"
< *!* *4
"
"
55< 55)
*E
###### >*4
"
" "
" L
"
"
<5*>*
* *4
" 55 ) +
55>
M
"
"
2 * "
* 8"
*: N0
O
"
=* 4
7 * + @ ) ! # # & )2* .
$ ' (
+
&
< *5<* *
"
" <"
"
* 3
* /
=*5 * **
*E &
"
%& *.
"
*
" "
*
*4
< *<*
"
" "
* 9
<*
"
"
"
*4
+
* , 7
"
" >
"
<"
"
"
"
"* 4
9
"
*
"
*: * 7
+
"" /@ G
* 7 - *+ )00"! # ((2*
, , L ' (
"#
"
<=
* 5* 4 "
, L
" *4
" , L
, &8 -=
)00$!2#&
$ * . -** A
L
' (
"
" : "
"
"
" *.
"
"#
:* * = '
@ '
' 7 @ ' =
7'
+ E 4 @ 7 -7 ' '
74 + ' -
4
74 *
*
7
P*$*G L ' (
4 - 4- +
- 4'
* <*8 "
"*: 7! @2 5" :3 8 - = 9 !# %%0 + " " 2 + " " "2 + "
+
= ! 2+ 0 )*4 "
*9
"
" *> 55& 5 55
,.8
** *!* */
*=* 5
+ "
* 4
"
*: -! & 2( "
2 2 2" ( C D + 0
+ (+ " ( "" 0 + +
2 " !
7! !
- 1!
! +' $ F $, 1+ F $,