← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7721/2017dismissed

Dharmbir Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2020-05-29Mrs. Justice Raj Rahul Garg10 pages

  

   

  

 

  ! "#$% & '() '* "+& 

"

'

,! *

 '- "

 ". & '!



!/".

"

!

0# 120* *     '

!

"

# 

 

  

 

      

 

  34

25 !



"#  "  $%$&'$() * !,)-  . 

 .

/     .   $0$0(1%(  

   2($0'$(1!

  3 .

$&$)(14)5 

 " 6   2(('(11$ 



       '$(0,'$(%* !,(-"    

/  

  '4(''$(%* !,'-  .         '$(0,'$(%* !,2-    "7/  '$$08 

  

 (&(''$(%* !,&-  

.

/

  " "

00 8

  

"  '((''$(%* !,0- /

 /  

  $%$2'$()*

 !,%-    

  "        '$(0,'$(% 9 /    $%$&'$() * !,)- .

/     

  "   

"

 /"   $%$&'$()* !,)-  2'%*- !:.3  



;/ 7  

/ <   

/ <  

"   

 /"    . .

#   " 

7   "/

 

/   '$($'$$2 

. 3 3=! ($$$''$$'* !,1-  

   "        '$(0,'$(%* !,2-  

.

.  .    "7/  '$$0

/  

  .

 

 



   ($

($$>"  5  

 "   /"  * !,)-  "/   

 "   :"/ 

.

<.  3        ! '$$'*($- 3301$  /"  .

"  "/ 

 . .

  ?   

/  :"/ 

.   @  3 "#      !'$$(*2- 382'$* !,((- 9 

    .



 

.

  "            /     ,(7    3  '$(0,'$(%   " 

6 .

        <.<  8       

     (&(''$(%* ,'-

  /   .

/    2'%3  



;    $'(''$(%* ,2-  /    " 7/  '$$0   "   

/     3 '$(0,'$(%   

   

 /        $2$('$() A$0$1'$(4     

 " /       "  "  /     

       ($  < 3     8       '%$&'$(1  .3

   ($

   ,(B

3 '$(0,'$(%5    

 " 

 "   3 '$(0,'$(% 

 "/   /

 "  " / 

  

  3 '$(0,'$(%* !,2-     " 

 7 "/   

      3 '$(0,'$(%  *  !,2-        

     " "  



   +#

 .

<  "



  '4(''$(%* !,'-"    3<   

  '4(''$(%* !,'-  

" /

 



<

</ 3 '$(0,'$(%A



/  

   .

3* !,2-"  

7  /   

     3 '$(0,'$(%



3 

  " 

 * !,'-7 



 "    

       (&(''$(%  *  !,&-        "          '((''$(%  *  !,0-     /"   (%$&'$()* !,)- 

 " " /  / 

/ 

 

 

/ "  .

 

"     2'%*- ;/ ,( !,7!:.3  



8     C, D2'%*- 8   "          

  .  

   .

  " 

 /  /

 3

7;  /  /

"  " /  



/    "

/< 

     C, * - 7  3

,73

,77

 

 / 

   " "

  

      "

  E * -*-7  3

,777

        *.- 7 3

,73

,77

 

 / 

   " "

         "

    8  /  /

   //   / 

/ <

      .

 

 F  .  

"  

/ <    

 " 

 (&(''$(%* !,&- 

"  /"   $%$&'$()* !,)-



   2'%*- ;/ ,( !,7!:.3  



  .  

/   





% "    '%$&'$(1  .

 "





   3    ($   /'$$%,'$$)'$(%,'$()    3 '$(0,'$(%* ,(B-   /

('

 

   C, D(' 

7 " C 8 ".

    

.

    "

 !

 6  / "

/   ?/ "    "

, 

  .

 / "

 F 7   3       .

  .

     .

 .  .

    

"

 "    " "  

 .  = 

   "   

  

.

  /



/      

 3 /'$$%,'$$)   



 " 8 "         

  ('(((11( '((((11$ '%$)(111 (2$%(110 (&$%(110*

!,('!,()-  

    / 

            <    <8 

 .

       

/ /

.

/  3 '$(0,'$(% 





.  7 "#$ 

* -  / "      /   * - "  ($

/   "

8 

3 8 / 

  "        "/      8           

 "   :"/ 

  $

* -     /  / 

/  

 8

:"/   .    



 

  

 (&(''$(%* !,&-

"       3 '$(0,'$(% 8       /"   $%$&'$() * !,)- "  "

/ < / 8 

 (&(''$(%* !,&-  " 

     /

              .

           

   ,(



 (&(''$(% * !,&-  /  "/   ?  /"   $%$&'$()* !,)-



 "  " /    "      '((''$(%* !, 0-8 3 %" "  & !'$()*(-

38&)( +/  " 

 /  /

 /  

  "   /    "    .   / "              /     .    "    "          . .

       /   "      /   8   .

 "/    /   

 /   . 

 .  

71   .

  C, 1 9       /    .

  "   .  

.    .

.

 .:

     /   



/

 "  



      ($   .

        

"         /  7    /  /

,//  

 .



   7:"/  9:"

&

& !1! !

* - <.  +3  .

   /

. . 



 /   .

   .



 /   

.<.  +3 

" "".

;!<-=:( '



"

93 (110*&- 38%1'* 3-      & ".'

* ,! *

!!

(*'$$2-& 330$ /   

 '"

>* "+& ;!*

 '- "

345* 7$3 9:"

& 

& !1! !

4!:/'

5   & ".'

 * 1!  !

 4!:/'

         //  

 

    "



    /

 

0$B00  "

7 

  

     .



 "

.  

  /"      /        

       :"/     9:"

& 

& !1! !

4!:/'

/

 /   /

  "/A   .

/     .  

   / 

 /    

 .:

     3/   8  3// 

              /

 .

   "           /  7'()"  & !'$(% *(- 38&14 3   " 

  

/.

      !:.  3   

 *G+    @-      "

 / .

"  "/    =  

" /"  3 

  !:.



+

         * -    D  .        . 

F= 

 ""

 "

  

  . /  .

 "/    7'0  

.



 C,

?  



      





 !     

 

 

     !   !    

    

  "

     

 

  #    

       

   !     

     !



    

     

  

    

 !  

     $

   

     %!

 

  



       



      

 !

 

         

  

  

       

     

     

    

       

 

    & 

 

         !



    

' ()*+)+

  !

!

 ) '  + '    *,-     

  &                

! 

 

     

   

 



#   

   !

 

   

       !     

  

   .

!      .

!  /  (*0

    1

  

    

   .

!     

 '!



 

 

     



            !



   

  

   

!2 

                 

 

$

 

      

  !

     

      



     

  2      3       

 

  !  

  

 





! &        

 

   

   

  

  <.     3    &  "  * %  +,! '$(0*'- H0&&   5!#   :"/ 

. 3  .

 /  

  ;

/.

  !

* - "

 / 

$ .   " 

.<.  3 

$

* -  " .

 "/ <.

 3 +/   /    ;

/   

 $

* -     "

, 

"    /.

     "

 .   // " +

/       " +

/   "  

. 

  8

  "   "               8    ;

/< 

      "



7         /

  3    +/  . // 

8       " 3  .

   

8    .

 "/   7 (4 :"/ <.  3.

  C, D(4 7 

+      



  .

#     

  /   

 

   8   ,/ "

 3// 



      7 

   

 "

    8     

" ".  +



 

3  / 8 

 

D    F D F.



  /     /  "D  "/ F7.

/  A   !:

* - +  "/ F 7 .  :"/    . !:.  ! 3 5   7   

 /"      3  "<

<      /    .

                      .  

  "   . :"/   

 



 (&(''$(%* !,&- /  $%$&'$()* !,)-   /    "/       8 

   "   /      

/   

   5 '1$0'$'$     :