← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5414/2015allowed

United India Insurance Company Limited v. Asgar Ali & ORS

2019-03-18Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages



     

 !" #!

$

  %& &#!

%' ()*  

   

 

  # 

  %&+!#!

%' ()*    

   

  

  ,-)  . . /- 



  !

"

 " # $   %& '()*)$+,*(  '-%&'().,$ +,*(

 / 0 # $ '*( %&'()*)$+,*(   " 1  %& '().,$+,*( '$ "   2    000  . /-1 '

-* 1 3*4 5       %& '()*) $ +,*( $ 26 

 " 6 7 

 $  0  26   

  "

5  #!

 8  $ $

 95  :; %&'().,$+,*($26  " <

%' ()*2#3  7  "$  0 26 5   %  $

 2 7$ "%&'()*)$+,*( 3+4   8 %& '()*) $ +,*(;   2 $ 26 

" 6   0 $ $*(#+=#,,,1<26      0   > =?    " 

 $  $ "@ ! #0$$ 8 '*; " 



*A**+,*) 3-4



2"

 $

 $   1

" 6   

"$  2 26 <

0$ =,,,1< " 

# 2 #  *#,,#,,,1< 0  

 $

$ "  +(#,,,1<

$$ B 0  22

0  ),#,,,1< *(#,,,1<  6 3)4

# '*1  " 0 

  8%&'().,$+,*(;$   " 6$

   "  0    B $  7      $

   26   <

0$   =#,,,1<   "# 2 # 0 $*(#,,,1<

$$ B #*(#,,,1<

$

$   ),#,,,1<

$

$ " 3(4 '*1  "       $   

 

 

    45  67 8- 9 .4:. ;< <51 *(,*+,*)%& '+*C $ +,*)    $  

0$  +-**+,*+ 0  D

0$2),6

$        

   <

0$ 0  E  0  7 7       $ "6 0

   =,,,1<  " 26  5        26     



%' ()*2"3 " 6#<  / 26 7$ $F:2 

" 

  - /<=   <5 9  .  <5   <5575#!!

'&*  '9>*?+" 

   

$6 *=C*0 F:2

"

     $ 

0$ -,,,1< "# "

   $ 

" 6  

   

  7  $ +-6

$ " $

   G 0 :

# $ # 2 

0$  9 70 7 :  0    "

    "

$ 

   " "     5 $ # 7  0     $ +- 6

 20 

  

 $    G 0  8

;  

 

2

:

 8

;  0      

0$   "     7 7 # $ #0 2  2 "  $    $

5 $ # 6 $ 

" 6$ 

 0       "

 3A4 '*1  " $

    $<  / 

2 :

8

;0

  2$  F:2 

" 

       ,C,=+,*)#  '*)--)$+,*)$26 

      *(,*+,*)

%&'+*C$+,*)#0  "

262   $  $  0 "   3.4    $      2#   6  $ 

 " 6 $ 

 $  "6  $  <

0$ $ "  =,,,1<  0  26     

  

%' ()*2&3 3C4    $ 

$

 B $ # $   2"  $ <  / $  

<>6 >6). 5> 45 67 8-6 9 -@<6<  <51 #? !# #!

%   "&" #!

"0 0  0  "   

$ 

   

0$#" 62     0 $

 2$$  $ 

   #

 60

$  "# 

 " 7 6

$ 

 B / #

8>.4 56>>  45  - 9 ) 6. ;<  <51#!

#><+# # " 00 B

 

 2 "  0

  

 $  " $  "<" 7  %

 # 56A. ;<  <59 >:;<. ;<B;;  <51#!

"'&* - "#'

(*0   "$ 

0$

"6  $    "6 "  $ # $

0 2  2

6# $ 

$ " "6

$

0$0   $ "6    3=4 F0 #      'A* 8; $    $ F:2

"

 > 45 67 8-69

5 8 .<   <51 #!

+ '&*   '9>* !!$  6 

" $   *(#,,,1<    6 2 

 $ 

 $     7 "  

 $ $  B # 2 #  ),#,,,1< 

 $ 

 $

" 3*,4      " "

 $ *- 0

6 #  $   "    0

  $  

%' ()*2%3 3**4 

6#   0  

 $

       "$     "       ),#,,,1< 

 $ 

 $ 

 "   *(#,,,1<

$$ B 2 7 " 

$ 

$  F # #   "   .,#,,,1<

$     3*+4     $      2#    

 $   *(#+=#,,,1< 0  26    # 

  "       $    &1+&1!!!CD '    $1!!!CDE #E "F  +!1!!!CD* 0 >=?   " 0$$ $ " $  " $ 6"#

 6"# $ 6#   6"  "$  2" 

   0        0  

 26     3*-4 

6#  8 %& '()*)$ +,*(; $ 26 

 " 6    6 0 0   8 %& '()., $ +,*(;  "



0  +,,(+,*(

26 5  #!

  "$B  2 8/ G  ;  *C,-+,*= " G  71   1' G   2

 1'