High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4394/2016allowed

Patel Engineering Ltd v. Nhpl Ltd

2016-08-22Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages

"# $!%&'&"( ) ($ * +*

) , - * . /-

!"

# ! " ! " $$$$ % & "! '#( ) * + ,#

* - & ) # * /-

*

-

"

%-./+.%0 ( #' ! "

!

1 #'

54#545" # 1!

!%3304 " !6 %330!65" !"

! "! ( " #)!"

!

'7# "! " 1 #( (

"( !

!

# "" # "8! # +..+ 9

1 ' # " !

(

4 , 9%58

&

2 (' : !

"! ( , ; !

!

(

, ( 8 4 )!2 9:::5%-+ (4<=-- (5& : , ( #

'

" ( !! +3%%+..- ( =! #( ,

! !

(<> "

" "

! (

( 6

# " # ? %+ "! # '

( "

= , =

1-@" " "

!!

: " ## #9! ! ( "!!

! "

, =! (

# (

"" ! ' (

' ( (

#

#, # ,

# # "

!

! ++.<+.%0 " " '( -" %330!( %-.0+.%0, !

"

-<" %330!, 91 ' = ! ! " 9 A 7! "

# (

"(" B& CB

"

1 )!C:!( # #)!'

! (""

# #!"! !

" ,

# '

! #" #

!( D'+../( ! # +.%0 %.@/./-03/79 ( E%+F:! (

'""! "!

"

!(

! ' ! " # (' # " !! ' # ( # ) " # '"

G H !

'# " , 3"

%330!

B#" CB

C # ! '

B" C

# ( ##"

" ! !! !( -0" %330!, "

(#""

"" !

' #

(

" ! '

( (

!

("!

" "

!

! "!

(

7 ! !!!" '

! "

! ( ' !

"

#)! #"

!

1

! ' ( !

! ( ""

.-.3+.%0 # ! #"

"

2! -0" %330!: "

!

!

!#'

1

!

"!

#$ $ $% &'()*+, --!

1 !! (

'

) #' 6#2 , $%. !

/0 )+. &)''*+#(*' 1 $. !

% 2 2.&)''(+#34-

"" # 3(

7 "(

# ((

!

"

1 "

! "( ! ( ( " # "A ( ( E %+F "

"' ! !

# "" # # '

! ! (

" #'

3" %330! # ,

91 ! 1 (

"

1 " ! ' ""

" ,

" # (

"

1 :!!

( " 1 ! , # 9! ! '!

!"#)! # !!: "

! ) "6#

1 "!

5 0 $% !

"!

6 .&7 )3+ )8 +((! #! !

! !

# "

"7' # ! =! ( I

" #

54#5!# '" " : !" # " (

#! # "

J "# ' "2! 3-0" %330! 9 .2

.0%

!

" #$

"

#$ %

" & &

"

#

"

#"'

"

34. 9

(

)&

" ''"* +,-. /+,-. ' H)= " !

' ! 3 H -3%K+11 "

"!#92! %"2! -/" 2!

"

" ! " " ' )! (

#' , !

! ) "

6#2 , $%.:

4 5 1 $ .:

4 5 ! #'

54#545" %330! "! '(

" ! =! (

!'" -<" %330! -0: ! !

"

#)! 2! -0" %330!!#

( ( " !# #)! -<"

%330! ( ' ! ! ?99 ?

( " (

3" %330! ) , $%.:

4 5 1 $ .:

4 5 " ( " " "

"

) #'

1

:

4 5(

(# # " !

!#'

8

!

) " 6#

1

2.# !

1 8

."0 &'3)+,0 ( " "

"6#

1 ( !

6#2 ": 2 415 -%<0<"+.%+ %<./+.%< ( ( ( :#!

# (" ## ' (

"

# " " !

! !"# ! "A "

! ! # A

" (

"

!

( "! ' 9 A "

"( ! !8 ""! ""

!

# ' ! 91 ' = ! ! " 9 A A

7A "

! "

# ( ! !# ' ( ! " ( # (# " ( " !

'99'

( "" " # A 4( 5J

"# A A !

+ " # " # ( ! (# " "

! "

!

#)! ! !! '( # !

( " ! #)! !

(

"

# !## " = "

"! # !#' #((

! " " J "

!

, ! !"

"#'

54#545" %330!

#'( , 91 '

! ( ? #)!"

"#

#' A "

" ' : ! #)! # "

#'

!

"#

!= # !

& " # (

/-

($ * +*

'

&

7

!'3 "

& #

!'3 "