High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4325/2010dismissed

Samarvir Kaur@Surinder Kaur v. Sumanjit Kaur And ORS.

2015-03-18Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj20 pages

!"# $"%&%' ()* + $,-,

.)/&01"%&#

22'-* 3 '-* ).4 52)

!!"" #$ % ! ! & '''''''

1 !!"" !" " " "" ( (

( ) "" *+,+--, .

/ 0( ( / 1 !" ( !" ( 2 3"/ !" /4 (567 !! !" ( &67 2 3"/ 4 " 67!!"" !" ""(" "

"" 3 "" ( ( """ (" "" # $ &*8*7 **--5 ! "

""(9 &-+," (" ""(9(

/0( (

( ) ""/ " ""("

"" :

* # $ "&-5*,,--+ " ""( 9(

/ 0( ( .

/ & " ! + &7 ! ( 4 &-87/ " ""(" !

"" 4 ( !" : # $ &5,-;

3"/ 0( ( " ( & ""("

"" : # $ 2!" "6* 0( ( & " "6* ! ( ( " " " /0( (: #$ 9 &* 7/ (/ " ( (( "

! " 2! (/"( /" """!

( " ! ! 2 # $ 0( 3"/ # $ # &*$# --$ # --<$ # (!

$ !" (3" 1 !" # &$ = # &5$# &+$ #!" $ 2 !!"" !" / " ""(9 9( 1 "

" !! 0( (

0( ( / 1 !" ( !" ( 4 " &*8*7

/ >"" % (" ""(9 . 567 !" (

5 3"/ 2 . 67 !" . 67 !" ("(

&-+,

( 0( ""(9(

( ) "" *+,+--, " !! ""(9( ! (! &+ &72" ""(9(

&7! &+ ! &-87 !" ( & (

" / 3"/ / ( ) "" " ""("

"" ?

""!!"" !" " 6*

/0( ( ""(9 9(3 "

( !!"" !" " " "@

!" ( A#> " &+8+<,7--+$

! " 2!

!" B " / ( !" / // " " . " / !

/!!"" !" 2" ! ! ? ""( 1 !" ( 0(

-;,!!"" !" " ""( " ( ! ""(C(2 " 9 ( ""( D 0( ( " 3"/ " " C( (!! (*E ";"

+ ""( 9( ""( !

/ 0( ( ) "" *+,+--, /4 & !" ( &-+, ("

/ ) "" 2 " ""( 9 /

!! / !!"" !" & 0( ( 0( (

7,E "" " ""(C 2 " & 9 0 " " !! !!"" !" ( 67 "

" ( (

" ""( C

! 67 " ""(C / E "" ""

" "/ " 2 /> " ( ""

/ ( ! ! ! 2!!"" !" "

67 " ""( C

" ( / E ! " 2 ) "" *+,+--,/ / &"("" (

) "".

/0( (2!!"" !" "" / !

/ " /0( (

" ( "

( !!

!!!) "" 0( ( & (""!! ""( 9( 3"/ " .

( ) ""

7 & ( ( &5,-; " (

3"/ ("

/ ( """" !"

2!!"" !" !"

!" ( ! " ( ""

( #$ ) "" *++--, ""(" .

/ 0( ( ( ""(9 ((" " &*8*7**--5 ""("

"" " /"/ FG #*$ ) &-87 ""( 9( " " /"/ FG #5$ )"&-5*,--+.

/ !" &7 ""("

"" " /"/ FG #+$ ) &5,-; !" "" /"/ FG #7$ ) "

" 1 "

!!F? FG #8$ )!" "! 6* " FG #<$ ) !" " !

! FG #;$ ) /" ! FG9 #-$ ) //" FG9 #,$ ) !" " " . E "( !" FG9 #$ ) !" ( " ! FG9 #$) 0( ( ( .

( ""*++-, &* !" 3"/ FG9 #*$ C"

8 2 /> "0 (#0

9 $

( @?

( / !" " ! !

. 6+ " ""(9 68 " ""(9(

( "" *++--, .

/ 0( !" ( ( ""(" ( !" 2 &*8*7

/ ""/ >% **--5( (" ""( 9 &-+,

( ""( ( " ""( 9( " ( ""("

"" ( !" " / ( &-5 *,--+.

/ !" ( & &7 # $ " ( ""(" ( !" !" "( ! " . 6+ ""(9 68 ""(9(2 " ( " . / !" /" ""("" .

! " A 2!!

/0( ( ""(9 E" " / 1 " !! !

! 2 !!!

/0( ( ""(9( ""/

" !!4 / !

( / ""

( 1 "

!! ""(9 2 / / ",-,<-<7D.)6>0( ("5-E "-"" ""(9 5+7*, !

" ""(9( "*5,<-<7 5;,,,) ""*+,+--,.

/0( "" "4 65 "(

" ! !! ""( 9 9(? " !" (/

768 " ""(9(2 !" " ""(9( "

" "" # $ 1 65/ ( # $ 1 65

/ 0( (! ) ""*+,+--, # $ 65 1 !" (

/ !!"" " 3"/ 68 # $ 68 3"/ ( !"

( ) "" 2 " .

/ !" ! ! " ""("

"" . !!"" !" " ""(9( & !" ( & !!"" "!!"( ( !/> " ( #0

9 $ " 9 0 ( #H 2 E> $ " ( ,+,-*,,- !!" "/ !!" "/ !" !"

;

! ( " > . !!"" !" " " /0( ( ""(9 "/67

) ""*+,+--,2 !!""> ( > /" " ""(9 1 " !!

0( (? "/" !! 0( (2/ !8 < ( "" @8 D.)63 ! 75* 7-< /" ""(9 !! 0( ( / ! ( " 75* *-7, ( 0( I "

/ ""(9 # !!$ 0( ( ( 4 " 1

(J " ( 0( " 0( ( ( " H &7-<

;5-78 /

(" . J ""( 9

/ 0( ( ( 1 ( 4 "/ ! /4 7-; "

" ! (/ ( ( " ((I " ""( 0( (

(J " ""(

- / "" 1 ( " #56; $ /

! 0( 75* " ! K68

C ( / ( " / (

" !! 0( ( 1 6*

( " ( . J ""( " ! 0( ( / !K68 1

2 56; ( 0( ( / 6* " ! / !

/ !

/ ! " ( 0( (C" "" "

" " 56;

" " 6* "" 0( ( .

"/! ! "

" "

" " 0( / 1 " 2 " > / @ "" " !! " " !! !" 0 1 H " !!

" !!

/ 0 1 H "

" !! " !! "" / 0 1 H "

" !!A2" 2 "> " " ""( 9 0( 0 1 H " !!4 3 / " 2 "> / )

, 3-)-+,6 7 89:4 &;< &0"&

" " . !

/! /(

, / '

+/ / 2 -* 3- /

( +/- 4"%%#'&* ,=, + -- &!0

"/ 1 B/"1 (>

"" .

" ! "

" "

" < " /

( !" "" " ""( 9

!! 0( (3 " / !" 4 !" 0(

" !! "

8 +, /3-8,+:> "%% "#&

" !!

"" ! " 1

? " " ""( 0( " !! ( " 2 ">

A 2 !!"" > /" " ) ""*+,+--, D.9 .

/ 0( ( / (

/ !

2" *E ";"" / !" ""(9( "/"(" " " ( " " !! 0( ""

) ""*+,+--, ? "

" ! ! !!/E > /"

0( (

" ""( 9 9( C 2!!"" 67 " ""(C " ""(C /

" "

/ ( (

" ""(9 9( 2 !

( 0( ( " ""( 9 (56+ 0( ( 4 " ( 6+ " " " 0( ( ( 1 4 "?

56;( / (0( " !!

( 6* / ( ! > "0 (/ ("

(

"!! " !! " 0( ( ""(9 / 1 "

!!2 !!""> ( / / "

( /

!"# / " . !

/! /(

$ %!.> !</ ""

* @& / "

/ "

" . !

" !

/ ! / (

" 2 "

/ >

" & ' & ( ' )*+ #, $!% ? "/0 !

# $ ' & -./ ' + * + / ( " ! 01.1 & . ) 2 2 + 3'

' & ' ' 2 * 2 + "

/ A C"

( / 2 '

*"2 ",3

' $4 % ' 2

! #,, $*% !$!&.%",*/ "" @?

""/

"! " / . !

" ! "

/ /" "

/ 9 3

( 2 '

$ % 5 3 ! ( "" / " "E

! /" ( L" !!B L

" !!B )/ 1 "/" " !!

!! " / / ( ( " !! "

// ( ( "!!

""!!/"

5 / "!!2/ /" (! "

!!! !! /" !!!

!! ?

!0( (6* " ""(9 / ! 6* "

" !! 56; " ( 0( ( / ( " " !!2 / 0( 6* "

!" /" ( 2 !" (0( ( /" " !!

"!! ! ?

!" ( ( "/" !!"" !" ( " /0( / ! ( ( . ! " 56;E !!

"!! 1 B/" ! >

"/ L " /" (B

6 4

.. 7

!# " "" @2 " /" ( ! "

! !!

9? ,9+

, + +,

+ !!! ( ! !!? !!!!

!" / " /" "

+ " /

( " !! / " ( "!! !!/ ! ": !!! " ! /

(

/ !2 /" ! "

! !!

!! /" ! !!

!! 2 / /

!" /" ( / ""

4 ""

!!! !! " !! / / " / ""

(

( !! " / (

/" (:/ / .

!! "" .

!!! A ?

2 !

2 2 *

! , / "" @ " (/" ( !!! "!! """!!" / 1 "/ ! "!! "

E /

( ! " / /"

/ " ! ( / /" H / " ""

7 !! " "

! !! " ( !! ! " /

!! "

/ ( E "" " / ( "("/" ( A ?

-. 8 9

70 -0 (:)

! ;## !. > / "" @2!

4 " ! . !

( M EM M ! B ? / / " / / > ..

6 4

..$ !# "%

( E /"! "

!!! !! /" ! !! !!/@,-+ $ ?,-9- +?

--? 9$ +/ A , + +/ BB

-+ 6 C/,- -$ D, +,- 2 !!! / 1 " / ! " !! "

E B /

( ! " 2 ! !! /!!!

"!! / ! " .

( " M

" !! / /

/ ( ( ! ( !!!A ?

0( ( !

!! !" /"

" !! 2 ! / !!

" "2 4 /!/

"/"

2! ! & !!

"!!/!" !

!!"" !!

!/" ! /(

) "" 0( ( /. ! !!"" !" " ""(9 / (" /

" > "0 ( (" "

"!!"" "(" 1 !" " " 68 !!

E !" " ( !!

/ 0( ( 1 " !! ?

!+ "> ( !!"" " 0( ( ""(9( (" "

" "" @+ 1 !! ""(9(

0( ( 65 ! " ! !" ( &65 65 1 !" / !" 3"/

4 " 1 !" (

< 0( ".

""( ( 65 " " ""(9(! 5, 1

! "" *++--,.

/0( !" ( "65 0( ("

! !" ( / "" 2 !"

. 68 " ""(9(# $

/ 1 !" ( !" &/

. 768 " 9(

. 65/ ( 65 /

0( (

""*++--, 68/

3"/ ""*8-<.

/ A ?/ ( 0( (" " ( "

"6 " ""(9 2 / (

! " ?

/ 0( ( ""(9 / (

"!! " ( " / 0( ! L

" "" (/ "(" (" 0( (

"!!/L

/ "2" "/0(

" ?

! !! "" (

; !!"" " !

""(9(/0( ( " " ""(9 "

" !! 0( ( "" " ? 0( ( !

" ""(9( ""

(" L B 1 " !!B " ( "/"!!"" " !

" /

"!! "" "" !" 2 " /

!!"" " ""( 9 ""

) "" 0( ( 4 ""/" ( !"" 0( ( ""(9

"!!

!2 " ""/( 68 "

/0( ( ""(9( !" " 9( " 1 " !!

! & ( / "

/ 0( ( ""(9 9( 1 "

"6 !! " !! 0( (.

) ""*+,+--, > "0 ( " .

) "" ( ) "" ! / .

/ 0( ( 1 "

!! 0( ( / ) "" ( / 0( ! " " "" / "

- !

"" 1

! .

) ""4 "

/ ! ! 5, 1

-781 "/ " " ""( 9 / " " 65 " ""(9 ( " 2 !!""> !! "

) "" ("") "" " ! !!"" !" " !

() ""*+,+--, ) "" .

/ 3"/ !" (

/ " / > /" ?!!!!"" "" ( ( ) "" ! () ""

(

" ! & ( / / " !!" !" ( ( !/> > "0 ( !!!"

"G /! !!"" / & 3!!" ( ( ! " &*+; *+,;---2!" "" &/

(

! !!" ! /!!""> /" / (

" ! ( !!!" ( ( > " >

!!" ( !" !!" /"

*, 2/( "

" !

2 " ! "!!!" ( ( ! 2

( " !!"( !" !!" ( ( " /" 4 " /

/ "4 " 4 ( !!" 9 '

* )/&01"%&#