High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/707/2014dismissed

M/S Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited v. Union Of India Thro General Manager Norther Railway

2016-03-31Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh21 pages

$ % & '(&)*+ , ) ( ++(( - &

./ 0 &12 ( 1 3 (45 6 %& 4( 3 + '

7&) 8 7 9 4 &( % 2 9

++(( !

&( 9 ++(( !

((

7 +-) 9 + !

(( # 65 0++

(( (

" #

+ 1

)) +

3 (45 *( ) . :& ( * 1 6 * 1 ! ;*( ) . :& (;#4:5( ))& +

:5++(( + = (45 :4 + ( 14 ++( (5 & !# !#.3 (45*( ) . :& (

! ;.. :& (

;# )

: 1 ) :( &5 >& & 7 !#.3 (45

: 9 4 + <) + : &<+( 1 9 (5 + 1( )++( ) + 6 (5 ++(( : &

9 + = (45 5 1 9 & +(&) + & ) & 3 (45 7 3? 9 &

+& (5)+ & 5 5 :4 3 (457

* 2 7&+9

11 4(9 1 :4

(( )+& (45 1 1 )(( .) (

)75 )!.

7# & 3 (457 *)+& 3 (453 + !*33#4 :

& 4 )0 )( 1 + : )?

1 ((1(95 11 +(&) + & 4 4: 1 + :5++(( &13 (45 . ?@1

) & <

:54 1(5 +8 1 <

&( <)+(

:4 & 3 (457 3?!%5 #

'+& &!/' # :5* 2

7&+9 4 ? () 4 & .

7 ) &? () 1? () <

4 : 1 :5 + = (45 )++(( .( ) & <

9(51 19: ) ++(

+ <

(( ( ) : &+ ) (

+( :4 )+ ( +& 9(9 ) <+

1(5<

4 1 : 1

& (45 + )& ( ) &): 5 4 (5 : 1 &1 . &

( + :? ( .59+& + 9 1&) &:)

4 +(

: 9: ? )

++(

) 4 :? 9 3 (453 +* ) & !%5 #'+& 3 (457 !/' #: 1++( ( ) )+

4 ): &:= !#7 .3 (45

4 ) 9 4 + <) ) & ) 1 ( ) & 914 <) ) +5) ( 951 4 9 (&

&:= !#7 .3 (45

++(

(5 5 4 ( & !# !#

.. :& (

. (5 ++( =++(( )?

4:& ((1(1 1 1 4 9 .

74 & & 3 (457 4 ). + 5 <

1 1 1) ( 14

) 4 :? +(&)+ & ) & '+&4 .

7 +4

& 4 :4 4

4 ) ? () 1 4 1(5(9 4 (

4 ? () 11 4( (9 4 4 <

&( *( ) & 4 ++( 4 : +& :5 +

(

1( ) 1& 4 ) 4

<) +)

:(& &04 (54

( ( : : 1 $

5)+

: 1 0

* 2 7&+9 :4 & '+& ? () 4 (45 + 1 ) &((54 : 1

& & 1 ((1((5 9 1 1< ? () 04 ( +( )& 4 + :5) ? )4 ( :(: & . ( )++(

( 14 ++(

(54 &1: +( )4 ) :( &5 >& & 7 !# .3 (45

4 9 9 4 &5+ <

) (54 & <+( 5 &( : ( )++( (4 ) :(

1 &:)

) :5&

( + +( *( ) . :& (+ )

( )++(

1& ) ++( ( )

+ 4 ( ) :( &5+ 4 4 & &( 9: ( ) : 1 <) <+

: 9 &+ + = (45 >& & 7 !#.3 (45

>& (5++(

(5 ( : )

1& )

++( ( ): 1 ) :( 8& :( <+( : 1 9 (5 ++ 1 *( )

. :& ( *&

(++(( &:) *( ) . :& (

) 1 (& ( ) ) 4&( :& 91 & ((1(1%

914&( : ) 14 <

4 & 1(44 14 +)

:( (44&( : ((1(1

: &) 54 9 4

14 &0 + (59:(14 ? () 4 + = (45 9: 1 1

? () + & .

70 &++ ( &+ 8& 1) 7&+)*&

%& '

& ( (& (

)**+ , -*./ ( ( : +( &+ 8& 1)

% 1*&

( "

(

0//.

1% ..& :

8& 1)

((1((51 14 ( :(:& & 7 0 * 14 + 4)) 5 : + 5 1 ( 9 :5) ?& )& +5& %

((1( 1 ( ) + : ++( (5 &( 9: ((4 7 !#. 3 (45

4&( :++( :(0 &++ ( &+ 8& 1) ' % 1*&

& 1,

2 (

)**3 1(& &2 04+

( + +( ( &+ 8& 1) 7&+)*& ,

5 6

& $"

%& !# 3*3!* 9 (# !7*# (5 1 9 1 ( ( )& .3 (45

)

&:= 7 .. :& (

)+( 4

&:)

) :5( &

( + 4 :(

91 &1 )+&1 +

:5*( ) . :& (:& 51& 4 ) . +& '

& .) (

) 75 ) !.

7# &( 3 (45 3 + !

33#4

& . 1:1 4 : +

:5 )+ & 5 * 2

7&+9 ) (5 )+ & 5

1 4 :4

& !%5 # '+&!/' #4 ? () 1 4 : 11 .++(( + + + ) 14 & 5+ :8 & .

& 3 (457 4 4 )& :? () +*)+& 3 (453 + !*33#. 1 4 : 1 1 1 : ? () A9 &

( ) & 1+ 9: + 4 44 + <)

+7 !#.( )4 : ) 4 ++(

+ 4 ( ) 9: 8 :5 + 1 )9: 9 :5 + <) + : & !#.3 (45

.: >& 4 :1 +

4 1 1 :5 + ;91;; ((1( 1;B . :4 91 ((1(1 95 % ;:(7&+)*&

%& '

& 1 2 <+( )91

: : 51 <

+ : +) :5 (4.: 91 &)) 5)& +? )

1 ()& : )1 & (

: 51) 5 & ) 59 4 1 &91 )+(51 <

& 1(40((1(1 & 4 4&( ((

:9150 + *& ((1(14&( : + : : :5(4 4 1

9 ( <+

(4 . 1

& 9(9 + ( 1 :9+ +( 1& 191 ((1(1 1 1? () <

&( :53 (45 4&( & &: 91 &)) 5 ) 1 ( )+( + &

+& (5 1 4 551 . + 4 ( 1 1.<

1& 9 )(

1 & 1 (0 +1 1 <

+ & .

7. 11

9 ( 5<+

+9 & + :

: :5(44 4&( : 1 4 ( ((1( 1.& <

11 :5 + ( :

91 ((1(1 0 &

+& + & .

& 3 (45 7 )+ & 5 * 2 7&+9 :4 3 (457

14 : 11 +

4 4 ) + :5++(( 4 & 5(( 1 + .)+ 8& & 5* 2

7&+9 9: (( 1 & (( 17 ) (

+ >&

& :5 & 51 9 1

& 1 1 & 1+ 5

:) ((1( + 1 :5 )+ & 5 < &5+4 :

(( 1 9

1 ( ((1( & :(:5 5)+ . :& (*& 4(1( 5

11 :5 (4 ( :(+5 11

4 04&( : :1 <

+) :5(4.+(++(( :5+ 1 ( ) & + + ) ((1(1 1 <

14&( (+ ( ) & ) :5++(( ((4 +)

:( + <) & !#.3 (45

' +(>& 4&( &((5:++( :(

&) + 0 &

+& + :8 9: :5++(( 1 91 1 1:5 + .++(( )+(4 : 9 + 1 ) :5 + = (45 9 ( ( 1 5+ ) 1 1 91 1 1 . ++((

( ) 9 1 ( 1 (&):

:1 ( )

:( 1& <+( (55)?

>& (5:&) ? +3 (45 .& )) (4 ++(:5>&

(5++( ++(( : 9>& ( ) 4 ++ )(( 1( ))?

1 & =( ) 3( :5&

(++(( 8& 1) 7&+) *& '

1 2

) +( )+( 4 ( ( 1

(45 )+(

1 ((1( 5 & 9 +9

7 0 3 (45

4 ( )4

+ :5. :& ( . :& (( 1 ++( :5 3 (45 )

: ((1( & :(.++( + :5/ 0 4 )

. :& ( ) :57&+)*&

0/.*1-2 , 9*9 .

& ( 5 4 )

0 &:

>& ( 1 & 95 11 % ;:(7&+)*&( 1 19: ((1((59 : 1 : 9 ( 7 0 3 (45

+( &+(

. :& (' & & (

1:5 5)+ . :& (*&& : : 9 :5++(( ) 8& 1) .( ) +&:5++(( ( 1 :94&( ((& .3 (45

&:=

4 ) 4 < ) ) & +5) ( 95 &1

4 9 ( ) (5 (( ( ) :5 < ) &

8 4&( :) :(6& ++(

(5 : + & !# !# .. :& (

4 1 9 >& 4 1 8& *( ) . :& ( & ++( (5 ) : ( 5( )++( ( & .3 (45

6):?

1&+ + 1: ) 8& 1) % ;:(7&+)*& #

&& '

0//31)2 ,

+/-44 ( ( 14 ) ( & () ) ( 4 ( ) 9 ) ? 4 (45 & ) ) ? 1 1<

1 4 (&( : 7 , ) 4 : 1 &1:? : 1 4 &5+ + : )?

1( ) : ( ((4

= ;)&

8 8 $"

< 8 $"

0)=0*=0//*

>8 !

8 8 &

8< "

>8 $"

, 8 0.102182

(8 0/91(8 )0 0/9-2

, 8 .4=#

8 &

8 ? 8

$ <

8 & '

8 & -&

, 8 0.102182

(8 0/9- !

8< &

8< 8

< "

7< 8

< $"

, 8 0.102182

(8 &

, 8

.4=#

(8 <

< 8

>8 "

( !8

< $

8& ! >

< "

8 & ( < 8

!8 ! !

, 8 .4=#

(8 & ,8

8 !

, 8 .4=# $ $ " > $"

8 $ 8 $ $"

< "

8 @& ):9 ++ , ) 4 (( ++(5 91 4&( (( 4 )

1 7 .3 (45

(+ 1 7 . 3 (45

1 7 =6 0 3 (45

# ( ) + : ((:++( :( &( ) . (5: (& ++(( (( : ( &

91 ( )4 +(

(5: :5+ + :

( ) : 1 & ( ) & . 3 (45

.( ) 4 ) (5) & .3 (45

(5 ++(5 1 + +9 ( )

:): :5( ) .*( ) . :& ( 1(5 (& ++(( ( & )& ( ) .8& 1) ' % 1*& "

& 1,

2 1 2( &+ :5&

( ++(( 4&( &++++(( ;

( 1:9 & 98& 1) 7&+)*& #

':7 1 2& 1& :( 4 + 1) ? 03*2 . '=0-(=004 4 ) .

& :53 (456 4 ( <

9 11.+ ) 91 5 ((1(1 ( :5 *&:9 ( 1:9:

% ;:(7&+) *& +( ++(( (5 & 7 !# !# . . :& (

9(&

(& 1 ) : ( 5 : *( ) . :& ( ( . :& (;

8& +4 & 5>&( )& ) & .3 (45

1 ) 7 4 ( 4 8& +4

& 5*( ) . :& ( 7 4 + : ( )

+ ++( 4 4 5 ( ) ++( (( : ) :5. :& ( :) 7 .3 (45

*( ) . :& (

((4

! " #$ %& '

$(102 $

> 8

8 58 !

> 8 $

(8 =

$ "

" (8 8 = 12

8 8

= < "

8 "

, 8 4) (

" (8

1$2

"& B10=(2

> 8

8 8

< 8 0)+ (

" (8 0/4/ 1)+ 0/4/2

8 58 !

> 8 $

< 8 8 !

( 8 0)+ (

&C 1)2

" (8 0/4/ 1)+ 0/4/2C

$ $

8 $

8 $"

$ (8 &@ +&+ + 7

!#!# !:# !#4&( :(9 +& ( +9

4&( 4 . :& (4&( : ( ++( ( ) ) :5++(( & !#!#! # !:# + &:= 7 +9

.3 (45

&( )

& 4 ((:++( :( >& 1 )

1 5( )

:5 *( ) . :& ( &

1 :5 .3 (45

&( ) &

: 1 :5*( ) . :& (4 ( >& 1 )

1 5( )) : + ( )4 : ) :5++(( :. :& ( & .3 (45

& 4 ((9:(? )4&( : ++( :( ( 7 +7 !#.. :& (

4 ((9:++( :5. :& ( )

1 ) 3 47

& 4&( ( :

( 1 . ) ((4

$ % %

)*(+2 ( $

8 8

= < "

< $"

$ =

1$2

88 !

& 1)2 ("

$= 8 $"

= < "

< "

! 8 8 "

8 $

8 & 1-2 ( $

< 8

< $"

< 8

! >

8 "

< "

!8 <

$ % $ *( (

8 8 8

= < "

8 0*9 $

< & +& (:94&( 4 + &:= !# 7 + : ( ( ))+

(

& 1 :53 (45 ((91 9 4 + <) ) & ) 1 +

&:= !# 5 ) ) >& 5) 4 1) :()+( :5 :(+ 4 + <) &:8>&(

1 9 4 ((: ) : ( ))+

+ &:= !#+

: ( & 91 +1 :5 3 (45 ((9: 9 :5 ) :(4 < ) ) &+5) ( 95 &1

4 9 (@ & & ( ) 4&( :) :( .& (( ) 1)+

4(( & 91 4 <) ) 54

( ) (( : ( )+

& 91

)5:

1:5. :& (

( ) ) & .3 (45

( ) + 4 3 (45 )

4 + <) ) & ) 1 +5) 91 ( 951

)5: +& (7 4&( 4 ++( )+

4&( (5: ( 1

3 (45 )

4) & 4 ) < : 9

. + (1 (&+ 9 ) 5

(+ 1 ++( ( ) 1 9 4 ) < $ +&( ++(

( )4&( :) :( . 8& +4 & 5 . :& (

&)9 (( :5+9

.3 (45

&( ) & () &:= !#7 .. :& (

9: ) ++( :( >&

) 5( ) :5. :& ( *&

(++(( )+

&+ +4 . :& ( ) ++( : +9 7 9

:5 + 5 ( 17 .. :& (

. 7 ((4

, %

8 =

$=8

12 8

$= 8 8 0-

? !

"A 1$2 $=8

12 8

$= 8 B

$ $= 8 10(2C 8 0-

88 8

88 A 8

1$2 $= 8 8 0-

8 $= 8

12 8

$= 8 8 0- $

8 $

8 .4# 1,8& 0*92

" (8 & 1)2 !

8 $= 8

8 "

8 $= 8

8 ! 8 &

+& (7 4 ( 4 ( )

4&( 4*( ) . :& ( ) ++( 5( ) 4 5 1 5+9 ++(

) & !#!#! # !#!#.. :& (

: + & '9 &>&( ( ) & !#!#! #

:+ & (<+ ) ) ( ) : + & 7 .3 (45

0 & ++

( ) 5 4 : +9 4 1 + 4 4 *( ) . :& ( ) ++( 5( )

7&:= !#7 9 <+ &:= !#4 ++( ( ))5: + +

&:= !# ( ) :( 5*( ) . :& ( & & )?

1 ++( 4 ) + : & &:= !#7 3 17 .. :& (

4((9 )

&:( ) + : ++ 1 *( ) . :& ( : (1 :5 )

++( 5( ) + & .. :& (

:& 9+4 (1 ) (5>& )4 : + : & +9

.3 (45

&( ) & ( 1 7 !#.. :& (

7 !# (5)?

++( :(+9

.3 (45

3&( ) & :&( ) ((4 1+ & + < 1+ &( + &()

4 +9 >& 1 )

1 5( ) ) *( )

. :& (.+4 >& ) ( ) &

19 :57 !#.. :& (

0 ) >& ) +9 & .3 (45

3&(

) & 9: )+( 4 (5 *( )

. :& ( ) ++( 5( ).+4 *( )

. :& ( (5 +9 & !#&

( ) ( ) 4 >&( 5: ) :5*( ) . :& (& 7 4( & &:= !# 4 &:= !#

1:5( )9 (( & &:= !# 4&( : )

& (

)

>& ) &:= !#7 &( (( 1&) &

(++(( *( ) . :& ( & +4 (5<+

>&( & !#.. :& (

)4&( !# & 4 4&( : 1

) & 4&( ( :1 1 &5 +9 4 +)

:( 4 (1 ( &

:1 9 &+(&& &+(& % ;:(7&+)*&:5

D& 16

10//.2 , 3-9 4 >& 4

1& A< *& ) &5(( 5(44 4 : ((1((9544

) =

& 4 1 + +9

3&(

:5 & (&( &

! & # &( ( ) & : + ) (5& 4 +9

3&( ( &( )

(5: + & 4 +9

+ 9 ) :& + & 4 + ( ) + : &% ;:(7&+)*& #

':7

1 ! +:9 (9 + + & # ( 91 ( 14 4&( ((4

)

17 =6( !

47 #.( ) :) : :5( ) :5+ +9 7

( 4 1 9 4 < ) & ( 1 ( ) & )& ( ) 7 ) ( &) ( ) + 8& 1) 9 ++(( 1

+ ) (5 ( ) :

9 &+ + = (45 )

4 + : + <) ) & 4 7 .3 (45

++( )+

4&( : )

:(1

(45 )

& .. :& (

7 ++( ( )

: ) :5*( ) . :& (7 !#.. :& (

4&( :++( :( & ++( (5 ) :( 9 4:9 &

9 &( ++(( ( 5( & &5+9

.3 (45

. )+&1 (( 1 ++( +

:5*( ) . :& (:5&+( (( ++( )

: 1 9 )

!"#$ % &