Gurmeet Singh And ORS. v. Dalbara Singh
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 09.09.2015 Gurmeet Singh and others +.. Appellants versus Dalbara Singh ++Respondent
CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr.Justice Kuldip Singh
! ""
# $ !
! Kuldip Singh, J.
""
%"
" &%
'())
*+ " " ,
#% - " !! !
" " #% #% , - " ..())/ ! "
!!
!
*+ +! ! !
!
(/010 2 *+ !
- ' + "" " 2
3'
'(* )/*
% "
*
!
, !
- '
"
2 !%!
!!!
3
( *"
"
+
!
"" (/010 !
! !
!!
"" * "* + " 2 " , " "
!!
" - 1/ .40054(1 5.0051'. '.005 '(4 .005 "" " %""
"
!
! " " +
!% !
""
" "
%* "" "
+*+ 2
!! $
!
- '
"" (/010
!! ""
3'
" 6%" '(* )/*
% !
" , !
- '
"+45'.54.' /1( % !'(./ 7 .0)))38 *+
!!
! 2
+ *"
* ! " " * 2 * ! 4009 "
" 7 5'4))38 4* 9 " *
" " %* ""
"
2
" " * 2 !%!
"
!! +*+ "
! 400
"+ ! "
!! 6%
!
'00 !! %*87
"
2 '00"
!!
!!
!%*87
! 0)) 4)) 6%
+ 2 " *% 3 !
% %:
!
!%"*% "
!! "
+ + "" !
"
!! " !" !
!
%
! " %*#% * -1(!0(00 (005 " !# $%
(005
!"
! % !
9%
!"
!7 ))38 * % :
!% "" %
+! -1( 0(00 (005 !
- ' 2
" "
!!
; " "
%"*
, "
" % ! % & ' " ()**+(
,
-+(-.../0 $
) 1 # ( 2 #
! % & ' " 3 ( *++
+
++-3( /0 $
)1 # (2 # - 3 4 " # * 1 #
'
! % & $ " (,*,*++
*
-+(- ,/0 $
+5 # - .6" # - 7 # - # 8 9 , ! 7 # & $ " , 3*++
, )
++-.../0 $
34 "# - *1 # :
" !"
!
% !* *+
"
!"
*
!! "*" *
:
"
"
!! " 7 )"
<(=
% ! !
"" "> 9
"
% :
!" &
"+*+ !
- . 1 !
- '
(/010 !%!
!!
"" " :
! !
%
*
:
!%
* 00) !
- 4 5!"
! " "
!
"
!!
" ! " !
* !""
"
!! "
!" !
!
- '! " " !
"% !
- 4 1 *
:
" !" 0(00) ! 2 !
:
"+
# %+ 010 7 ! " "
54)))38 ;""
" 7 5'4))38 ;"" :
" %
/))))38
+ *% !
7 .0)))38
+ :
" "
! 2
500*% !
400
! !* 9
:
" 2 !% ! !
" " :
"
!!
? ;
*% * !" !%
%"
" "" !
%
"""+
%
"+ % "
!! !
:
% * ! % 8 "
!""
! 4)00'
,
.
)+(+
$
*+-.../0
:;;
8
$
:;;
$ $
:;; ,
:;; 3 )+(+
:;! *
:;! )
$
% :;! ( (
$
8
:;! + :
% "
!
- 0 5 +
!
!" .001!""
!
/
)+(+ &
/,
:;;
:;;
$
:;!
,
%
:;! 3
:;! * 9 " % !
2
! !
"+
* 9 "!" *+ !
*+ " ",
#% : " %
"! "
"+ 2 " % @ %
"! ""
+%
% "
! *% !
2
! 9 " % !
2
! %* 6%
"+ :
! ""+
!
* ! :
* !% % ! "
" !
% * :
%
!
% ! !
- 4 5 * ! % !"%*"
""+ "
! .001 !
% ! "
!!
" "
" !$%
% !
"
!!
"
"
+ !
(/010
! !
% !
%
! 4)00' .001: !
!!
" "
"
" ! * "
" ! 9 ! ! !
!
%"
""* ""+ " !! +!
*+ !
"+
% ! *+
!!9 !
%
! +
% - :! !
% ! .001 !
- 4 5 * ! % !"%*"
- !% 6%
%" %"
"
* * A: ! % "!
*
"
+ 9 + "
9
*
*+ " % "" *+ "" % " !
* ! % 9 !
"
+ + "
*
*+ " % ! ! !
! %"
"
* "+
% :
: % *+ %
# < $ ; # 8 !$
..)=,> % =% $ >3), 5 $
- ..+= > ; ,3 $% %* 6%
! !
! !
- 0 5 !
%* 6%
"+ !
"+ B+ "
! " %*
! " :
!"% !&%
9 !
%
* * ; @ %
"! ""
!% %
* % ::7%" ( :
*
% !
!" *+ "
!! 0(00
"" !
*
:
"" "
!
- 4 59
(005
!" ! %
!
9
! ! !
!"
'00'
!7 ))38 /00'9 " !!" 2 '00'9 !
!
* *
/00': !
* % ::7%" (9 % !
*
! "
!!
!
- ' " " !
" 2 9 "
! + !!" ! ! !
""
)
9 ! " !% !" ! !
!
"
!!
!
% *
*% * !!
% 9 ! ! *
% +
%* 6%
* 9
*+ C*" % % 8 $#=> - .,=,> % =% $ >()
!!!" !
!
! ; ! *"
%
+ ! !
2*
! "
9 ! ! ! !
!" :
"*+ 2%
* % ::7%" ( :
"
%
+! !
!% " 2 *+ !
B"& ! "!
!+ #% 0059 !
!! &%
!
%* 6%
"+!" ! !
!
"
""
" 2 %
+! % 9 ! : !
! %" *
!"
*" "+ !
%""+ 9 %+ + " % " * :
: % *+ % + 9 " % $ # 1 $ 9
" -=+(*> #%%, , C*" 2
% * % 8 - $-
# ,-+(, $
..
& 8
..
?? ?
..?
" $
$
" $
7 -2 % - &
$
$
:
*
* *+ " % ::7%" ( @ %
"! ""
!% %
6%
! !* !
*+
%
* "
( "*" *
%"
" 9 % "!
9% *
!
% !
"& B"&
$ % 3 % *
!() * % :
* *+@*
*+
!""
9 "
,
7 , !
!"" ;- & @ %
"! ""
"
%
, 2 % *+
!! ""
#
+
2 % *+ !
% *
!
! !
2
!! % % ! "& B"& !
""
% #
+ 2
% *+ !
B %
* " " % 2 *+ , : !
!
2
9 ! !
"& B"&
"
!
% * ; ! !
% *
*" * !
:
%
% "& !
5
*
*+!
B"& !
* *+!
:
"
B"&
B"&
:
+"" !% " "+ " :
!
% " !
,
"" % " " "
!! + 9 !%
!
* ;
"
2
!
; D% " # & "; B% :
& % !" ! "
!
- '
5)00)! ; " + *
!
! :
!"
!
3
" ! "
!!
9
.00
,"*
"
!! !" " * +$%
"
!! "!!" !
0(00
!
! "
" % %
+!
! "!
!% " 2 *
.4005 '.005*+
B"& :
" !
+ !%!
!! ?
'
" 2 !
"+!%
!! (005
!
!"
" + 9 !
* + " + !
"+ %
""% +
%""+ % " 2 %
+ ! !" *+"
!!3 +
!%!"
!!:
!% "
!
2 *+ :
!% "
" "
! !
- ' 9 !
*+
2 "&
% !
,?/
!
- 4 5 " !
+ "" "
E& & "
" B"& ,?4 "
"
E& !
%
% ; D%
" "
"; # & B%
! "
- " ! 7" * :
& % !
-5
8 8" E& "!
" * ""+ ,?"
@* "*
!
@* % !%
" !@*
%
! @* :
% @*
4 * !
- 4 " :
+ !
!
- '" & + !%! " "
9 !"
" *% 7 '))))38 +3#% 005 "
" 7 5'4))38
* "
!! # %+00 9 %" * ! %
" !
6%
"+
6%
" *%
B
9 + 2" +
9
*
"
*+B"&
*
*+!
9 !
%"+
* "" ! !* 9 !
!!
*+* %
* " *
!
%"
" @ %
"! ""
!% %
"
!! + "" !
: ! !
!! * ! %*7
'00
; !! F2 "
;
/00 % !! F2(
+ "" !
"+
.
! !
!" ! "
"+ !" " * + 9 !
!" !
;
%
"
!%" " & " !%! " "
%
+! 9 !
!" ""
!
!! + "" ! *
"" !
!
"*" +! +3 "
"
!!
8 2 "*% % ! +
2" % + * *+
+ "*" 9 ! +
""
!! "+ "*+* %
* " @ %
" ! ""
" % ! !
!
"
*"
"
" *+
!! *
"
!" *+
5)00): ! !
" !7 5'4))387 54)))38
" " ! 7 .0)))38 7 /))))38
+ " ! 2
!
!2 ! !
!
!!
"
!! " % "+!" "
"
!! ; % !
" "
!!
/ * * !
! !
9 ! !
*
"
! !* @ %
"! ""
!% %
(/0109 "
! 2 !
" 4009
!" '00' "
+!" 9 ! ! !
!
* "
" ! %" *
!
" * " 9 !
* " "+
!! "
!
"
2 !2 *
!
! " % "
% " ;
* ! % :
"+ " 2 *
+ #% 005 !%! " "
!
!"
! ! !
% "
! " 9 ! % + ! C*" 2 %
$ - " " -(5/5 !
()4 ('(()4
"
" !
*
%
+ ! !
!
B"& " &
! " 9 ! !% % 7
!
! "
1 !
" +% % * ! *
%
* " ; !
& " " %
+! "
" "
* ""
"
" ! * "" + ! *+ " %
" ! ""
9 !"" % * ! *+ " %
"! ""
1 "
9 $ $
. = > % =% $ > #%
(
4 5 @ $ '#
. = > % =% $ > #% ),+ 6 # $ 7#
. = > % =% $ > #% * .
, ' 94A1 $94
. =3> % =% $ > 3 15 @ $ 7 #;@
..+= >#%%, * # 9
$ # "
.=,> % =% $ > .
) 9#' '' $ ++)= > % =% $ >
( "4$7!
4
..
=> % =% $ > + + 7$ # $ # #
#4 (.
.
) .3 . 6"# $! %
..3= > % =% $ > +, 6/ ' 8 ' 6/
'
. =>#%%* ! # # $#
;
..
= >#% 3,.
: ! % ! "
""
!
@ %
"!
! " "
*+ C*" 2% 5 $; 6 => -=()4('/ 2
0 # $4 "# -= ..3> #%% ).-
" ! !
"
!! + "" !
! !!
* %*
"6%
!"
%"
" %
! !
!!
*+ " % :
!%""
% :
%
%
!
!!
* *+
%
* " "
% 2
!
"% !
!!
- %*
"6%
!"
9 !
!
!% *
*
! %"
"
6%
"+
"!"
09.09.2015 (Kuldip Singh) "
Judge