High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7882/2017dismissed

Bindu Bhardwaj v. Thapar University & ORS.

2023-04-21Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain24 pages

!"#$% & &

!$%$'%(#$% &)&

*%#' +,!#-,.

&&&&&&/*/*$%!

"! '

+,0,!%*"! */1,%#$/+!

&&&&&& 0$%#%/ 2 3 42&56

67& ! " #$"" % &'

() &(*+,- #*). &( (& &(*/,- #&/.0 (& (1 &(*/ (2 (& &(*) ,- #''. 3" 00 "

03 ,4. #$" 5 ! " *6 (+ &(*'

0 " 0 3"#0() (+ &(*+ "0

0" % " 7 &'

() &(*+ 8 % 0" 0 7 300"*& (6 &(*+ !0"

33"% " 0 0"00 000 7 &( (& &(*/ 0 0(& (1 &(*/3"9 '

7 03 : (2 (& &(*) '

7 000 &'

() &(*+ 3 0 0 03 7- 30 7- -3!

;

3"$"3 "0-- $"3"<0=-!:;

;

3"$"% ;30 3 3!

;

3"$" 7!

;

-3"$"00 0 - $"## 3"$"3"00 $" -- +

0 00" 00

0 3"0" 0

70 000 0" 0 > 3 0 0 0 3 " 03"00 > 30 !

;

00 3 - 00 7 % "3 3 > 3 03" 0 0 0 ?0" 0 3 3 3 3"! " 3 "

0 3 % "300 3" 03 ; 3 0< 0 - < 0 3"% " 7 000 0"3 " 03"#0 *2 (+ &(*+,- #*&.30"3 > 00

)

03% " @ 33" "30 (+ *& &((* 3"! <" 30- #& 7 ! " #$" 3 0<'( ('

&(*' 3 3" < : 0 0 3 (& (1 &(*/3"< : &6 (+ &(*/3 (& (1 &(*/3"

: &+ (/ &(*/ 4 0 30

0&2,.

< 0 33 " 0 0"

0 3" $" 50" 0 000 $"3 3" 00 !

;

('3 - 0 ;3 0 3"% "

00 3 7 0 3" 30 0 7 0 % 3 0

% 0

)

; 0

7 @ < 0 0" % " < 0 00 0 0" 00 < 30 0 % 0'**,&.3 < 0

0 # AB@0 3000 3"3"0 > < 0&&/> < 0 % 0'**,&.3 ; 3 3000 -% "

7% ""33 "3" 0 0 @ 3> < 0 30 3 30 " 03 > < - % 0'**,&.3 ; 0-0"

" 0 0C % 30 " 0" 70" 0

30" 0% 03 0 0 "0"0" 3"% " 300 00-0" 3< ?

30" 3 - " 3 3 0 0 % " 0 "

0000 03 03 " #- -3"" 0 030 3 "-0 7 #- "0 30 - 3 3"% "3" 0 0 30" 0% "3 0 0 0 , 0.

03" 0 00 3"% " 3"0 # A0 < &'

() &(*+,#*). < 9 &( (& &(*/ ,#&/. 0

(& (1 &(*/ ,#&2. 3" 3 ! " 3" $" 3 00" 3" 00 0 0"3 3" " 0 5 " 3" "?9 '

"5 3 3" : "

D ; 0"0 0 &'

() &(*+ 00 *(

7 3< # ,.

@ " 3"% "C ,.

@ " 0 0 " 0 00'**,&. 3"< C ,.

@ 33C ,.

@3"00 "

# E **

;0 3 3

3 ; 3000 0" ;0 3"$"

3 0 $"

7 < " 3 3" % ""

< 000" 3" 0 3< 0 00

>3 30 "50 3" 3 % " 0"

"0 0 # 0" 73"" #0 " 0" *'

() &(*+00" " '( () &(*+(& (6 &(*+ ! 3" % % " # A7 0 00 0 0 0 - !

700 7 0 # 0" 0 50 00 !

"#$ %$

&' ( ))*+$$,-.

) $ $/ 0 1 $ !0

'2 # ) )0

0" 0"% " 0 &( (& &(*/ 0 ;3< " 3" % 3 0"

< 03 3" 03 003 00 000A7$"0

0#*26/D "!# A-- -- ,.

A "D "

0 0

< " #& 00 # 0"% 0 0" ?

* (*08*%%,8/1900,8

#''

, .

3 0 0"$"0030300" 0 "# 3" 0 $""

, .

700 0" 3 "0"$"

""0"

"0 $"3" 0

0 0

0 $" 00 3 % 0 0"

!0000"3 % 0 0" $"

, .

=- 0

0 " 00 3 " 0 0 " ; " 3" " 0" 00 0 0030

, .

0'',. 003 00 3 0" 003% 30 00" -0" 3 ; "0% "0030 00003 7 0030 #- 00 % "

"3 00"

7 00

, . @ 0 ''

& *&F'003 0" 0" 0 3 % " "" 3

000" 30> 0 3 -

% 0" 3 3 303"3 0"

, .

% " 0" 3 0 " 00 0"0 0 0"3 0 "% " "3 00 30 0"- " 00"

3 " 33" 003 30

:"**&; %/+(, $<,%,00,8,=,*% /,%$!#!'%#! /+* (8,' 7/+,0088,/,'/+$!*/1 +,88($% *#!

:,;

+/+!/+<,(/ $%-+*(+/+$!#!-, 0, # +,">% /,>8* +#?

:>;

+/+! /+ <,(/ /,>8* +# ,<<$!# '<<*(*%/ =!$'%#<$!/,@*%=,(/*$%?

:(;

+/+! /+ 0%,8/1 * A( *"7 ,#B',/ $! *%,#B',/?,%#,</!#'($% *#!,/*$% +,880, '(+ $!#!, *//+*%@ 0!$0!&C '/+$!*/* $</+%*"! */1

& + <$88$-*%= +,88 > /+ ,'/+$!*/* $< /+ %*"! */1 ,.

7 :C ,.

7 C ,.

70 C ,.

74<C ,.

" 3 0 3"

03 $"

$,!#$<$"!%$!

)

7 : 00 3 0 - 3"$"330 0 0 $"

0 @

0 0 00000 # ,.

$" 00 $" C ,.

3"30" C ,.

0"% 0-- 0 C $"

003 3" 3 0 0 4< 0033" % 0- 0 C ,.

0C ,.

0 0 0" 0" 3

0 0

$"C ,. 0 0

= !0 0 $"C ,. 0 " 00 $" 0 5 5 "C ,-.

" " 30 $"0 " 0 00 0 4<C ,-.

30 " " $" " $"C ,-.

: $:< 30 0 ## $" 00" ## " 00 3 0 3$"

0C ,-.

% 3" " 30 30 "30 3

0C ,-.

- 3 0C ,-. " C

)

,-. - 0 00 00- 4<C ,-.

< 3-0 3 0 3C ,-. 3 0 - " $" "" 0 30$"C ,-. " 0" 0$" ""0 C ,--.

0< 0$" " 0C ,--.

! 0< -C ,--. "0 0

C ,--. 0 $" C ,--. 00 0 0GC ,--. C ,--. 0 < !$"C ,--. < "C ,--. 0" 0

,---. - "3

0"3- 3$"

,---. 03!" $" " " 0 3

,---. $"

" 03 0"#

,---. : ;B"300 - % 30

,---. "30 "30$"

,---. >0 7 , ". % 0"30"30 $"

,---. - "3 $""

"$" "

,---. - $" - ! 0 0 0 - ! !0 < 0

,---. G 0 0 3"

,---.- 0>0 7 , ". " : #" 0 3 0 "30 3030 $"3 % $"

,----. 0>0 7 , ". 3 " 3 " 30 3 " $" " " " $" 00-0 " """3

,-.

; 00 0 3 30 0 0 70 = 07 H70 F 7 H

,-.

7 # < " #

$-!9 '/* $</+ *!(/$!

:*; + *!(/$! +,88 > /+ !*%(*0,8 (,#D*( ,%# A('/*" $<<*(! $< /+ %*"! */17 ,%# +,88 A!(* =%!,8 '0!"* *$%,%#($%/!$8$"!/+,<<,*! $< /+ %*"! */1 ,%# =*" <<(/ /$ /+ #(* *$% $< ,88 /+ ,'/+$!*/* $< /+ %*"! */1& ,. 7!" "" -" 00 3"

3" 0030

" $" 3" 3"!00 0 "" "" 3"!

,. 7!00303 " " " 3"$"

,. ;003 "!

0 0 0"300 00" 3

:";

+ *!(/$! +,88A!(* =%!,8($%/!$8 $"!/+,<<,*! $</+%*"! */1,%# +,88 =*"<<(//$/+#(* *$% $</+,'/+$!*/* $</+%*"! */1& ,. 000 0 $" 00 !

,. 7!00 3 0 0 < <

,-.

33 !00 - " 3 0 3"

,-. 7 ! 00 #

# 30 0"#" 033" 03"

,-.

7!" "

,-. 7!00- "3 33"

0 0

,-. 7!00- "30 3"

,-. 7!000 " 00 *1

;3 0 3 #& " 0" " 7 0"

! 30

@ 30 &2,. !- 00 7 00 0 % 00 3"! 3" ;3 % "3 0030

3" 03 0 003"-< ,$ 3# $0 $$

)4(+

0 # A-- -- -- '+ 7 % 03- " 03"0" 00 H3"> < '1 7-A DA 00"D 70 ? - A3 % D 3" A 3% % 0 " D;C 0 0" 0 '/ 7-AD 0" 3"= 0< 0 ! 5 ! 6 .

*.. .

2 ..

EF,/*<*(,/*$%G* /+,00!$",8>1,(/7-$!#7$! ($%#'(/7 $< /+,/ -+*(+ -, ,//D0/# :$< ,(($D08* +D%/;7>'/-+*(+-, *D0!$0!81$!

'%,'/+$!* #810!<$!D#*%/+<*! /*% /,%(&C ') 7003"<

1 589(-+ 4.

; < !:0 <" 0 3" ; 30"0% 0" 0

:0 0 >

! 3% 0 0 3 8 < 0 A=3 0 0 003" < 0 0 !*/# *&#*21' 0 00< 03 00"

! 7 < 0 00" 00 30<" 3 00 7 00"

! " 30 <"

00"03 30 00 00" *)#*&#*21'

D '6 73"< !0

& 5 0 ;

( ))+. '2 700 0 3" < 0 5 $( )) +4

; 0" 00 < <% 0% " 3" !

00 7 0 3> < !

" ! 00 <0 " !0 "- - +)(( =0 ! 0" - " - *2(( 7 0

*6(( 7 0 ! 0"> < 0 030 7> < 0 03 3% 0"

3"0 ! 7> < 0 % 00 70000 < 3" 0 0 I

0 #I 000 0 < 0 A7> < 0" 0 3" 0 00" "0

0" 0 0 0 3 3% 0" AD 3"

3" 0 0" 70 ? - 3 % 0" A 3% % 0 " D7 0 0"0

A; !J 0" 3" !

% 30" !33" ! 03 0 D +( 0" 0 0*/ (6 *22/ 3" 0 F " " "

0 " G 3" 8: " 8: 0&& (6 *22/ 0 F

" B0 */ (6 *22/00 003"

0 " - 3" 0 F " 3"< "

, :. 0 */ *22/3" 0 0 0" 3

0 +* ; B 033" " 8: 0 , 0.

;3< 3"

&+ (/ &(*/0 003"-< ,$ 3# $0 ( + 0 33" " 7 003" 0 % % <$=$# #$=0

(-+. *0 0 *6

?0" 3" 00 "0" >3"

:0- #'' 3 # A7 : *&& 0&) (2 &(*/ 00 3" 0 4 3 303003" "3 - 3

0 0 $"

73" : 33 *&+ 0 */ *& &(*/

7 : 3" 003" 0 0"

;3 : 3

)

300"0 3"!7$"

0% 0 *2

0 0 00 " # A;0 0 00 "00 ,.

@ 330C ,3.

@ 30 C ,.

@ 0" - % % C 00 &(

73"00 " 0 < 00 " 00

033 #

;3 3

:6;

&)&

! @ 5 K @ 30 K