← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22301/2020dismissed

The Palli Jhikki Multipurpose Cooperative Agriculture Service Society Ltd. v. State Of Punjab And Others

2025-09-15Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri17 pages

 

              

  !"!

#$ %&'&%  



  

    

   

    !

($ )* (& +

 + +





"

#$   % 

  

&   ' %&%

 

  (%%



)* ++++ + +



, & -*.

, 

   

  --*.--/



#    ( 



 $   0   1/,--1,23

 .,25  6

! 7

)8   ,/12-1-13

.,95   

7

): -

  #$       %     

       



%

)*( 0  7  ((  7 07( 

 0

( 0(    (    (                   

     ,;1--1,/ 3

7,5% ( 

 

  0 %   



<



    

%   %)( %

)* 

7,.

    0 ( 00   6  

00  0    (0

# % 



  -;,,-1,83

.,/5((  4

   =4

   

%7   1,1:-1,/( 

)*

.:  

 0 0 0      ( 0

 ( 6  

 (   

)*     0

 0 0    

 (0

 7   (0(  

   %

 

 

  %  0 

 (    

    >   7  1,1:-1,/3

.:5%!

(     00

 $  (0

 .8 

 

    

.;% 

((



%    

 7 

     

)*   

%  

 .*%  

 ( (

   

! % %)(   7     0   0  

 : 



)*

  7  1,1:-1,/

./ -118-1,/ (    0

  

       0   

0  



  0



7 <        00  00       # (%   0 7  

%

.2%!

(   7   

 

)*(      (      % =  >

    (      

  >

  (  

      

%

.9  -11;-1,/( 

)* 

     !

( 0

    =  >

 

7,1%

)*( 



 



  

   3 5      (  0 !

)*  

  0

    ( 0       

0

  % (  0    &

  (( 

0, : ?  % -1,/  

)*(

   %$   0

  8 

% = >



7,,



= ! ( (  (

/    

% %



)*0

 0 0 (

 

 0

7,. 0     

( 0  0

(6  

 !

)*( 

  

0

 0, :?  %-1,/( 

     !

)* 

  

    =4

     0

          (0

 0# (% = >

 

7,,00  ( 

    

)*

%

7,: (7  ( 

)* (  

%

(

7,8   7  (

)*(0

0!

)* 

      6

  ! %      %    '     ) ((

7,2  ( %  6

! %    

0

  

 0

(   



!

,8, 0 

  !

%,99/   0

  0   

 0

( 

 

(     ; 

%     7        (   

 )*   (          

%    6

! % (( 

.,9 (      7 (0   

  

)*  %  

(  0  4

  (

 0

( 

 



!

,83,53535 

    

 !

%,99/  ( 

     

)*# ( 

  7  *  

  



  

     6

  ! %          (    ! 

 %((  

% %       (    0               7   (   ( 

%  0

 

 

)* 

 )*                0

      

% %((



 7,.

  



  -;,,-1,8 3

.,/5 (0

     

 (  0 0       

  ( 7 ( 0% =  >



 

         

      (0

 

)*% ( 

  0



 %   0 0 %( (





 0

0  

0 

)*%   

 !

       7  0 

)* 0<

  ( (0  ! 

 %(  

%    (  (

7 ( %  = >

 (

  

>

(

   

)*0

   % 

0(00      0 0%(( 

<

( 

   0 %   0      6

! %      

     

 ! %            

 0   / >       %      (%     

     

)*

( !

((   7  (

)*(0 0     (<



   

  

 0

 

 

 

)*

.,; ((0 0 # %(  = ! 3

7 ,,5%

   ( ( = !      0

0 

)*



 (

 

   4

 0   =4

  %(

1

-1,8 -;,,-1,8 0(



 <



(

 

( 0

%

.:%7  1,1:-1,/( 

)*( (  0  

./%

)* 00 7

(       4

       % ( 0 

    7                 (  0(      7 (

  7 

0

= >

 

>

 



    0  

 )*%    (    

 

0      

     0  )      (

    

40   0

(   0  = >

%( 

7,,%(         0      %  (    0  (    %        

 ! %              

 

 

)*( % (   0  0 0 0     7 %  

            (%    

   

    

!

%( 0 8.

 

 

)*



 %(   ,;,1-1-8  

      

2  % 0     0= %  

            ( (    <

         7    %      

        (

  <



0

 

  

)*% 7           7      0

      

  

           

  !

  

 % 

  % 

  

       

)*       0  

)*   0%         6

  ! %                

! %        (     

   ( 0  



   (

 

   (<

0  (  6

! %  

% %

)*(0      %

      0 ( 

0 --,--1-1    9  

 

)*

(       



(     



  (        (

  0

% 

    !

        7      

' 

 .-%  ( (     !

      (  0

 

)*( (     

   % 0%  %    

%  0%             0  00

  00     0  

%

.:%7  1,1:-1,/(   00   0

00

  (               0       ( 

% !



.8(  (            00      0

 00

       0  

%

.2% !

(  ( (      

 = >

 0  

>

 

% = >

 = ! 

.,,<



4( 

 

  0

   0 0  

0

%

>

 = >

  0

  

% 



(

7,8((  ( !

  000   0

00

 (%  00

(0%    

%

  (  0      0  <



   00

  0

    

00  00

0 ( 0

%

>

  = >

% 0

    

 

 %   7 (  



            (     

  %       

           

     

)*  

  6

! %  

%  (  

( 0 %       :,1,-1,9 ,1  

 

)*





)* %

     

  % 0 

  ,, #  

    ,- 0           

        

 !

)*( 0  7  (0 0

.,;  

)*   -1,8( (  0           

   (   0           

-;,,-1,8%



 

.,/%((  (    =4

   (  0

  0  

 (      

                   

    

     

%     

  

   !

)* 0

   



7,.(  0     

 (     

4  

- 80

 

 3

7,/5%  (     

 )*# %7 ( 0    

7 ( 

)*%   0  

4( 

 

./%( 

"7 



     





    ! 



"

#$%

    

    

  ! & ' ()%(*%+(),

# !

!

 

$% )"   -"

./   &  0

 "



   

   

 

    # 

 !



     !"



   

  !

    #  #!



   

  #  

 !"



        !

    ! 0 

    

     

*1 !  0 2  !"

+"   -"

(+   &  0

 "



  

   #    !

()%(+%+(), (+%(+%+(), (*% (+%+(), #        ! 

 !"

 

 !

 "

*"   -"

(*   &  0

 "



   



#

 "

- 

     

     

  

        "





   

  3

 

      

   "



   

  !

 "

    

   0

   #

  

   

         

      ! !

#  

  "

-  

!

 #!

   5  %. !

0 

   

   "



         

#     & !

# 00

 #     !

   

  !

#  # 

     "

'$%+(%(6%+(),"

7% 8#  7 8 90

57 :  ;  "

-0  ' "

-"

,:   3

./5( (



)*    0

%  7     

  .2 

      (      

 = >

 

>

 

% = >

  

.,,   (( 

)*  0   %  (   

!  ,;1--1,/  (

)*0

  0

(   0      (

 0

( 

 %               0  

            

         

     0            ( 00   ( 0

 = ! 3

.,,5 

"7

 0

!

0  

# 

  ! 

  !"

              

  

.  8  -   !      !"

 

!

   0   #!



  5     -0   

)1"(+"+(), 

0  !   

  

0

       !

 !

 0   

  "

2              !

  !"

.

           #



 

#!

 %+(),    #   !

() (+ (* <# ! +(), 0 !



 "

2     #   !

  "

 #  !    

 !

  #!

   &  - 

0    $%

5



        !        !  !







  

0

      !



  

 #   !

 

 !

0   #! 

  

    0   

 #== #!

  #     #   !

00    

  ;       

 

    #!



/



 

     "

 

0   

     

 

      !

   !"

 /

   >

!

.?

  

    !

!

    

 

  !"

 0

!

  ! 

 0   

 "@ ,8    ( ( =  >

    0

     

)*  

% %(% 

! % (  = >

# (

 ((      

)*

-;,,-1,8%((0 ( 0

     

)*?0   %  ,;1--1,/%0

  

%( 

%   (  = >

)       

( = >

  

 

  7 40 740 (

   0

   0( 

)*  

    (



>

(    

)* (   0 #    (

 7    

)* 7  % (       %     =  >

     00  0

  ((    %  

% (  ,;,1-1-8   %     ($   7 % 0      

   <(%     0

% 

    

       (  (0 ( %      (  ( (     = >

#       %  (   ( 

   7  0

0 0(

  

)*% 0     ( 

   #     

  (     0  

 

   

  

   0  0

      

  

  

  

  ,; = >

   00 0 

)*<(%    

)*%(  7 %( (   (   0> 

)*      0% ((

  = >

 00 0

0(0

  0  (

  = >

( 

(       (   

 ,* )  % 

 ( % 0%    %((

 = >

 0  (( 



>

%   0   ( 

0   

%( 0

  (  

       0

%0  !

         

     %   

(  !

  #   (%    0

%  =   >

%  

 >

 

 

 %(     

(  

    (

 (           ( 

    



)   0

 

 (    % 

( 



(  (# 



0



)*

(   0 %((  6

 ! %             

 ! %      

    ,/ ?

0%  0                 

   

% (

        

 %    

0   (0     

0  %

6

! %  0   

0 0    0

(   

    0 

 

 0

(  

@ 

 (  

)*%   

 (  0  4



(    ( 0

( 

  

  %

 0

1 

0 0(   0 

 ( 0

( 

  

 ((0  

 ,2       0 %  

  (    

    

   

%    $

%  0 

 % 0  0

0 --,--1-1      ,9 # (



 

)*       

)* -1 !

 )*  (               0     

 7       -, # %  

  

)*

 7 % 0    (   0

    %&'&% -+ +

 .

8   ,@  . "

A.) -@   "

A.)