Oriental Insurance Company Ltd v. Shibbo And ORS


    


!"#  #$%%&'  (


   

     


   

       )'* +) ,)+,

 

 

! !"

#  ! !

" 

 $%&'(")(*+! "  ,$+(&,")(*+

 -  ! !"

  

! ! " 

$+(&,")(*+ "  * %$%&'(")(*+

./0#

! !"

 1

! ! "  & +$%&'(")(*+   * )$+(&,")(*+ )+,-
  2

2    "  " 

   -




!1 

! *)(3)(*+!  $

%&'(")(*+                )  

! $+(&,"

)(*+ 4    

" 


 )
"

4  " 4" 

     !

   

!   4  5   " 

  *    "

 "

) %$+(&,")(*+6!

44546  7   44 87%&97&)')!   + ,(  '

(()3(+)(*&:  7     - /!



!   44 87&;7(,(' " # 

!       5   *    $ +(&,  " )(*+     &$%&'(")(*+6 

 4 4  ! 

/    7  !    !     4

 

 2 /2  

45



:)6

  

4!   2/2

 4  

   40 

4!"     !   "    4

"  ,

4

 %( 4! /4

    / 

   4  / !

    4 )(!(((<7


" 

     &(!(((<7   !   

   =       4 4 )"  " 




! 

   

2

     

"      !  > ! 4 **!   

4   "   

! :)! 



  

 4    ?

$  4  4

4

    !   

   4   "" 

  4 ! &(!((!(((<7



 "  % @ 

  


! ! 

 "  "   44 87&;7(,('!

 "    

 !       0   

 !    /4 

  0  !

   "



 4     *



  "

 4   
  5   

 $%&'( ")(*+6    

 

 /  

   0 

/" "  !


  " 

 

"  

  4 

 "" 4 !

" 4      

   &   "  4 "    ! "

 4

 "  


7 A* :    >  /

)3+)(*&    - !1 

!  "

  4 4  4  "      4  87&;7(,('

4

 4 4    * 4  " 4B

)

"

* !   

   

 ! " !  " B 

, :    *

  4

  "" 4    "  B

% :  

 4  

 "          B

& :      " 70 70 "

   B +  "C +


D  " 

 !!

:*    "      

! 

  4! 

:)!        "

 

     *', - - 



4 ! "   

"  

"  4  

!

ED  ** *,   
    4D    

!     ! 4 "   !

" 4  " ! " 

 "   4  " !

ED * %    '  4   

"4 4 4    ! 




    "   

!

4 :)!



4 2/2

  ! 

   !

    4   7   

F      

 4   !     " 2 2

7D  

"   $ 

4 !        4D   ! 5  *$+(&,")(*+6 $ !  4   "

    

    

      4"      

 ! 

 

 4 4  4    ;  

"     

!  4

  %)  !    " 4   4*((,*3',! 4       ,;

   3  4   !" 4    

4  "

  4  

   

  / !

/  

!    " 

  1 

   ;*((<7  ,(G"   

 


 "

"

  

 " ! 44      *(!&,(<7!" *<,

      

D !  >    

" " 

5 4

""    "6!"  '()(<7!

 ;%!)%(<7  *(
        

*&!    

"  

"  *)!+,!+((<7
            "   )&!(((<7 "  "

D   4  *!((!(((<7  

"

 

H "" !     5

 *$+(&,")(*+6





 *!((!(((<7"

"   ** 8!    

   

     


*%!;;!+((<7!   I3G 



!

4"  "" 4" 

   

 

 *)   4                 ! 

    ! !   "      0  

    
  4    "    

 "      

   

(,(&)(*;!   4  " "  

 " 

 " !

" 



  



           "   

!  4 

 

"

/ "

 ! 

    "  !

01 5  +$%&'("

)(*+       )    $  +(&,  "  )(*+6! 

 4         

 *,   " "4 ! " *%!;;!+((<7



4     I3G 4 "   "" 4" 

   

 

!

  !  

    4  "

!      " 



  4 )*"  !

     4

4 

7

 *%

     

4   4 4 "

"    $%&'(")(*+! 



      

 A   "

             >   /

  "

 4 4 4"    C! !  !  "      "  4    "4 4 4 

   !   "    4     

D! 4     



4    !    "     !    $ 4    

  

! 

  4  

     J"



4   !



4   

  !"    "    



 4 4  4   





 4

   

 

!  :) 

  4!         

7D       

"

    "   /  4F  !   D

  

           !     4   ! !  !



    2/2      

  

4

:)

"    "   

44"  94  1 



 / !)3(+)(*&!

          - /   1 

!        4 4  87%&97&)') 

        

   

 "



4     " 4 4 4

"   "" ""

!

    ! 87&;7,('

  " # 

!4  * 

 4 4  !       4  /      !

 "   7           !



/8

" "    "  

 /  

 !    

4      0 !      



  4!

4     0 ""   
"  

  "



" 

 
 !       "     "  :)     4  

  "

"   ! 4  "    "4"  




*! "4  "  

.

*&  4    

 


!  

 " 4(***)(*;! 

4



   "

 4     !  " 

 7   5$7%&'(7)(*+6!     " 





 /  ;*((<7 


!   

  4 /

K)3!)(*&!     4  "  "8  !"  /

  /!    &!;*)'& 
4   !    "  -   "     

 

 "" 


! !  4

 4  "   

   !    "  4   - !    "(*(')(*&!   "        

  "     "!     4    &!;;++'"  /

 /!   

    '!+((((! "(***)(*&
"!            4

  )3(+)(*&! 

  /  +!(((<7 4" 

      "  



"   *((  )(( D  !  

     (*(')(*&    (***)(*&         *!;((<7
 ! /4 +(((<7   "  

!  "       



 

     

! 

$7+(&,7 )(*+!  "  " 04 " -   A!"%&!/  &01!&$#  23!&4  +"5  6  1!&#4  ,#"7%85)(*'6*+--+;(    9,!1/!:#12!!&5"7#16

#/7%  1!&31"  131!"%&  !&5  !&"7#18 )((35,6  - 5- 6''!   D     !   4 2   

"

2    0 ()**)(*;

(
   4    "  

 " "   

C

    

!  D  ! ()**)(*;!  !  " 

 $%&'("

)(*+!    "

 4





A-



  "



+!(((<7  %(G$  

)!%((<7


;!%((<7  "ED L

)!*((<7 #

;%((<7576)*((<7M +,((<7  ! +!,((<7D*)M '&!+((<7 

 

*& - "

 '&!+((<7D*&M **!,%!(((<7 -  

 %(!(((<7 

"E

 *&!(((<7 $

ED

 *&!(((<7


 **!,%!(((<7N %(!(((<7  N *&!(((<7N *&!(((<7 M *)!(%!(((<7C *'

  

!  " 

5

$+(&,")(*+!      

4  4   4

 -   "

 "" <A"

C!2  2" 04 "

-   9 !"%&!/&01!&$#23!&4+"561!&!4 ,#"7% 5)(*'6*+--+;( !

) %!  "  

       !     

 


  " 

 !   " 

!

  "

"  

8 !           

 4       "

*!((!(((<7



  "

 "" ! 

 

   "  "  



5  6 *;

  "

 !   

       "   4   !  

04      

!   "  

4  $,;,(")(*'5   1 I    6! 

04 

     K4 $,;,(")(*'

  ! !

  

! 

 

"

!5       

4  

!4

6 A            
 


   !   !

  " # 

   

       

  !    $     % 

  #&  !
' #  

#!   % 

(

 

 ) !

  %     

 
 

 *+,

 -$- $

* 
 




    *+, , -$- $

+.*  . /  0 



##  #    


#    !"  

 
 

 

(12

/ (2' #%    3

 
! (



  
#%   (4 # 

 

(  (  !  
5  " # ! 

%  6  ! 

 %    #  4 

( (  !  
!  

%   56 7-"  4        -  8 (

( 

 
      

-"  !

#   56

  

#         

    &*:   
 
                (   

  (      "! ( !
( #;*  
! / 

  

!,*:   #   (!( ;*&*6    (!(  #&**  

  
!+&:7

 
! 


) 56 6      (  
2
     )


  

 ;*: !
   
! ( (    (!
( #;* 7 

 &:(    (!(  # ;*&* +*:(    (!(  # &** 
!#        / !
       )   56 <     
 
        
 

#)    ! 
   

!#

 !# ,*,
5(

(     ! 56 / 
  
 
 

!

   /!
 
5 ( # ; " #  / #    
! ! 
 # 
 
 56 - !
 #     
    
 
  
           
 )    
 ! -+& ***=2  -;* ***=2    -+& ***=2  


  /  

  
!    +*:

  C
 !     

"

"

 

N

""   

 54  4" 

6! - 

         A 

   C!   

  "

'(!(((<7   



    4

 " 

!      

I*(G , 
             

  "

 '(!(((<7  



"

6 

"

*&!(((<7 6 

"   %(!(((<7 6 $

D *&!(((<7 8!   "

"  !  

  "

 ""  

"    

           4  !   4 "  2  2! !

    4!

"  

>#? 
6  

5  6! !    -   

 "

              6 
#

     

 (

 
    
   

   /  #   (

    


  #

  
     

(





9   (


 )

  (    
  "    D

 !     2 

  2!2 

  2 2"

  2!  

 

"

A/     !(    (

!#   !  
(

#     0$  


(   



C 5E

    04  6
 " ! 

"  

"

6    (   (            -;* ***=2  
<

$   );
 4 !        " %(!(((<7 

  "

 " 

  

!

  " 

 "  

!  "    D "0    -   "   *%)" -   


     >   "  -     9       

 

!  5 

     >#

6 

"  

    %(!(((<75 

" ", "  " 

04 ! "     

, *(G6 5

  

   " - 204 >#5  66 *3
 " !- 

5  6!     "



0    " " 

  

!     " 

  

 "

 

""   ! 4

"

A,(
  4  !        "    1 !    " 

!  ""         "

   " 04  >#? 
6         !   

!         

 





  "

  8 !    1 2        "  "A

""

C    

      " 

   

! 

) %$,;,(")(*'! 0 !  "    >#? 
6  0  !   ""      "

"     

   




 ! "

  %(!(((<7 

  "

 "  

 >#

!"

"2"

  2!  

 "  

!    " 



  

 

! 4    4)% !  4    "   *(!(((<7  5   ;(!(((<7     "

'(!(((<76! 

 

 

        D 40    *%)" -   !  "!      



 "

    !

 4  " - 

!    0    ,* - > ! 

 4     

  "  >    "

     

   

!          " 

 "     

      %(!(((<7!    "      


    4   )*  "    4          !      

 " ;!,3!))*<7

 "         ()**)(*;! >

   4  %

!   !     " 

C )( 8! "  

  04 - 

  

"

" "  "" 4   

 

7  

5D   D  " 

   "   %(!(((<7  4    

6!    





   !   

!

 4 *+  !    )*   4               !  4     4

"    ! 



 

   

  4 

4 ! 4    

  

      

!       

     


 4"    



 

(,(&)(*;!  "

 4)3(+)(*&!      

 ! 4 

  4   "   4       ! 4 A8OC - > ! 4  4 

   

      !  "4" 


5       6

 

))

 "  

  ! 

" 

5

" 


6! /4  "  

!         

!  

  

 "          5$%&'(")(*+6    D     "

*%!;;!+((<7! 

5  * %  

6!       " *)!(%!(((<7
4

      

    + '&G !  


 4

  I3G

!4"  "" 4" 

   



! 

   ! 

     " 

 7

!  

    ),

  4 "  "  

!$+(&,")(*+!

     

!   

! 

$%&'(")(*+       !

   D   " !    4

   .

 



!&0!14- (  ;)+,     :   /4<

 P :  P