Joginder Singh v. State Of Haryana And Another
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -1-
!
!
! " "# $%&'" ("(') # $% &%'( & " $
)$ &*"
%'( + ,& "(')* & ( -./ , 0 %1 0 , %,& 2 34 $ , 0 0 , %,( (1"56 '
,% + 1 7 8
9 1"
:& ) ; ""1 '1<) )
" ('1 &
" '1 ",(
;
( 2 ( 6
5%.
/ :7&2) & ,,),2 &) ) '
) 1", 1 )
34 1 ,= ('1 > "
;
6
:
5%.
/
7& 5%.
/ ?7
: 5%.
/ @7 "
) " 2 " ,( ( ,, A " " 5!( 1 '(7!
, &
%2 $
) ( " ( "
""1'1"
12
( 1 &
" ,1& ",( ?5 .
/:72
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -2-
,,( 6 ,) '(& ,2"
1 ) ( ,( 1 ((
,,, ,4 "
("
B -
( (5B-07 + 1 5
),7&8
9 1"
:&"
,( 234 1 , " 0 1&
11) > 1 B -
( ( 1 2 6 '
, % A, 1"( + 1 B1 2 & 5B-07 + 1 2 ", () % + 1 >
, % + 1 2
, ( " '234$ ,
""
%.
/?%"
1 &" )"
' ,,',&2'
),
( ? ", ( '
,( ' '4 & * (
>2& ', >2& ( ('1 ( ( %,( 1" "
1 : ""(,,(',
%.
/ 5(,, 7 ?
) ' ) ( ? 5%.
/:7 6 ; '1<)
)2, <( ' 6 = "",( ""1 ,,
)1
& 2
;" " = 2
' 1 <( 02
, 12 1 2
!>0) (/',, ' 1 5%.
/
7&
( 1 <( "",( 2 " ",( /
2
(, 1 ' 1 5%.
/ 7&2
&(
"2
)(
"",( ), ( ?5%.
/:7
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -3- 0
(&2,
( 12"&(
"2
(((,
11 ") (/ 3( ' 3 "(
&2 , ) "" " (
1),2#/
!
!"
!#$ %& '()* + + + !, !$ !!, - #, !.
!#/%&'(.* - 01 234!)(5 67'89 : 2 3 , ;+ # !!) !#/ + :+ !, !5 !#" %& '(5* <
= '%> 9 +* > !#" & +,! ? # # !#" 9 + 68688 + + ? !5 !# !#5 @
- # !/ !#5%&'(#/* > 8 ( + >@ ? !5 !, !#5 + ? #"
!) !#5 @ + !#"%&'(5* - # # !#" %& '(# * @ +
!5 !# !#5 %&'(#$* - < + (
"
!/ !#/%&'(#)* ; ## !#5 A
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -4-
%"
12 )'&" ;
2 ,
"( , ) (( 7 ) ./ '(1 )7 "1 C
), 5'
,, 1"
7
2, ' 1 '( ", <0 %1
:
3 , ""& 2
, 1 & ))@ :
&
" 1 ( ( (
) (,- ( 3 * 2 0 %1 & " 2
(11 1 1
1 ;2
# 1 ,&"( ,'($ ,/ 1 , A" < $ ,58 , 7 : , '0 %1 &"2
" )& 2
< &
,"1 ,
' 0 ,, &2
)@ C'
,, ( ""
" 1(/ , ,.
1 ( :: %00$&2*,9 &
1( ,, .
1 11 3
" ,& *, @&22
) C
), (( " ' &
) 1
), ( ( (,,(', (
%.
/ 5(,, 7"2
(, 1( ,, '
0 %1 & 1
1,, ( ,,
,0
,, ( ""5 $ ( ,
(D-1"21&+'1 0 7 2
1"
( , > D ;,, *',"1&* &
/:& ;2
3
( -,(( A (( 1( ,
& " 2
(
1 0 %1 @ " ( ); -./
'(1 0 ( %.
= / =%& "(',
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -5- @ " ,( ? 5%.
/:72( 1'
,"
),( "
("
" 0 "' ""1 +'1<)
2,,
( (' " " & 221 !,
( &"
""1 11
& ,( ? 2
, 1 '
) 6 ",(
@ 5%.
/@7>,'
. ( )" ,(
" (),2#/ +," &-..!
/ !
012(" 347
- :+ + + B %#* 6 + B( * && && && * && && && %* - : CD : C0D : C9D B( * : = : :CD * + 01 = : : : 9 : :C0D * ' = : +
9 : E 9
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -69 1
1 + F :C9D +* = + !, !$ !!,
+* ' +
*
+ + + + , < + - + G + H
* - 7 + H
-
- @
& H H H F + * - 9 9 +
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -7- + G ' G : G 9 -
G :++
!"# $ 8 + 7 ; (7((8( !#$F "$,.( "/!5 !
!"
!#$ :+ $ %$
* + B %#* 6 + B( * && && && * && && && %* - :CD:C0D: C9D B( * && && && * && && && * ' = : + 01 :F9 :
E 9FE 9 9 9 1
1 + F :C9D - +:F 9F 9 1
8 F0
F 6 A
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -8-
% "
, / 1 " ,( ? ' /E/'
1" ,( 2 , ,(
34$ , % + 1 6 '
, & ( .("
( ( ' 2
+ 1 = 1" "
,)(4) ((0 ,%
( =B
1 2 " 341 , & ,, 1 & (1",, 1 "" ( $ 2) , (1", $ &
1", 2
"'
"
", :5%.
/ 7 2
1 1
) (' ) ("
, ( & " , ( ,, ) ; )
( ( 0 ,
& " 2 , )
""13
&" ( 2
>1 2 "
" ;" 1 ",, " ", ' 12
'
( ' , 2 ,( 1 ) ""10"1)/
&2 "'
( " &2
1 2 ",(
2 )
5%.
/7& ;2
A " " 5!( 1 '(7!
, /
5 &F
" !
, 7A,",( ' ) (& & " 2
;
)1 "",(
2",(
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -9-
>,'
!
,:5 7 2!
, ? " " 5!( 1 '(7 !
, &
" (),2#/ &"
' # %#* - > = %> 9 +*> !#"
% * - =:1 %$* - 0 9 9 I+ - :+ :+
&&& &&& &&& $ %#* E 9 9 9 9 E I+ : + ( % * %$* % * = : , ) . (8 (88 %$* = : : 9 : ,0)0.0 (8 (88 &"
( $ ) %/* - + + % *
)'
,, ),
2 " & 2 ,4 2
) 1 1 ,) "
1&
)1 "",( :
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -105%. 7 A :
5%.
/
7& (11 ( 2
(' 1
( "&2) 2
1
(
,, "
1 "' ",(
5%.
/ 7& & "",( <( (&2 "
? 0< ,) " & "
" "", <) ,
"", '1<) (
('134$ ,B -
( (5B-07 + 1 ,8
9 1"
5$
7 1
: :
( 2 " :
5%.
/ 7>
2"
1.
1 "",( " ,), <)
/!
, > " 2
((, 1 ' , :
5%.
/
7 2
1', 5%.
/ ?7
"!
,:5 7 (
&1 .1 1 ,1
)" ()
)1
(" '
, "",( & ,),3 & 1 2 2 34 1 , (' (
<(
)<
1 ,",
' '
,( &0 1 '2 "1 ((" ( 0 ,,2"((1
1
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -11-
B 1 ,
.
1
2"
"", <))
" ('1 2( " ",( 2
, , ,'
1
2,,
"(' "",( ),
" !
, > "",( ),
" !
, ), 2
( 1 "
),( A
( , + 4
!
, 57
" !
, , 2 ' "G "",( ;
""1(, " (1", ) $ABB==
=
@
$ 2& "
1
"
5%.
/ 7
"2" ,( '1& ' 1", 1
" " &
( '1&
2
,( ;&(
A1 ;
& 2,, ) ( ' 1", 1
" ",( B 1 " / *(& *"
1 " H %
&
&
, : 1" 1 : 2
, 1 " ("
, ( & " 1 "( ' )
""'
, ( "
(=("
1 2,,) 1
& "
"", ""1)
" ('1
11 , "
&.
( "",( (, 3
1 &,
.
2(
" ",( 2 ,'(, 1 "
: % , ,&"
)1 ( 1 3
1 1 ')'
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -12- (1", 2,<( ( 2(2
( ,
> "
2 ,,
"",&,'
",( , ,2
"%.
/: /@ ? & "(', % "
,
",( ' 2
"" ,1 " () '
""1 ( 0 (.& &,( "
( (1",, ) ( , & 2 ",( 1",
)
('1 ,
% ' "
("
"&
1 "
"
1&2(2
,8
9 1"
:& 6 '
,% + 1
@ %"
, !>0 1 5%.
/ :7' 1 : 2( 2
, 8
9 1"
& 2
"( ( 1
' 6 '
, % + 1 & ( ",2
( !
< 8 2
"
("
1 12
1", 1 + " 2 ) (; > & <( ( ((" ( & " 2 6
,, ", (& (; ,1 " 1& " "
" 1 1 ( , (1 %"
, !>0 1 2 " 6 ;
(6
" "",(
)1 ) " ' (
" " &
(& 2
<( 2 ) (;
,), ""1)
) , ,), ' 0 , &
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -13- ( 2
<( 2
' (' "0 '
( )('
1& 2 , ' ; 1 1 2
, $ ;!>00 1 ;2
<(= ,), '
-'2 &") -./ '(1 "'
, ",( '1& 2( "",( ), -./
'(1& , , .
. 1, '( ) "' (
1, '( " ,
.1 ) ,
),
2 ) 2 1
, ( (( 1 ( (
(( % ""
1 ( ); .
/ "& '(( ) 1
& 2
( (( 1( ,
),1
'( ,1 01 ",( " , , .
) '1 ) '( @1 '
) ? >
& " , , .
@ 1 @
& ) ; (( " '( 1 ,( 1 &
, .
& "(1
&2(( , 2" ()"
1 >
& "2
,, ,), , ""1>",( '1 2(" !>0%(
""
%.
/
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -14-
)-./ '(1 , , .
(
> ,'
"
-./ '(1 , .
",( :
) " (),2#/ I , "" ,1 " () "
, ?: < ) ', '( !
, & , & /0& 6 "
"
1
: +'1 -1", : (
+ "/*1", &
)( "" ,1 ' +'1'( 1 ,, ( 7 >. ( , .
"" ,1 "( ( ,
&( ,>) 3 (;2 ,
""1 4
2,,
/ 4 '( " 2,, ( )
( 5)7>, .
"" ,1 ( 1 "( ./ '(1
( +'1 ( , @ / +/ @=
&
, & @&2,,(
02 &( 1 )( " ",
(
1, '( ) & 5(70 ( '( , & "" ,1 "1
), (( "( , ( (( ( "' ,,( 1 (J %"
1 )' -./ '(1 ",( & ) , .
1 .1 1 ,1
)'
) (; @ 1 ) 1( @/ +/@=
@ @
1
( ( +'1
,, *"
1 2) +'1 (,) ,4((
1
),-./ '(1 1 .1 1 ,1) 1"
:57 ,( ::&
),2#/
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -15-
)%* &J H J- & + & + + & +
+ + & +
A >
"( 1 & )( "
) & ) ',; 0 & " @C
),& 2( "
) "
1 0 '2 & ((, , "( ,) , .
'
! 2 *
), %(& : %
1&
( ( '((
5%.
/ 7 ( ,, *"
1 FG ' ,,2(#%)(( ( #/ 5 67 6' * I & %* %#, 9F 09* : D CD% *
, %#! 9F 09* : CD : C0D +&K %* %#, 9F09* :CD : C0D + & * >& + + + A %(,,('
( 2 -./ '(1",( , ' 1 ) )( -./
'(1 *
), &"2
, , .
CWP No. 24851 of 2019 -16-
1
)2, 1> &<( ( )' ), ? % "
1 (
)'&1"
< ( , ( ((,
( ) ' ) ""1
" ( ?5%.
/:7(11
2 ('1 "
2 !
< 8 & 2
1, ) ' ""1& "
("
6 '
, 1 2, "
) 1, )
,2,,)2 " 21 >" ,,), ,) 2
( 1 !
< 8 & " 2
'
""12,"
1 ) B"1 <)& ,,),
"(", F2;&"
G >2" ,,2 )'1
!
!
1"(')8 '
(.) " ;=
# H = " ),# H =