High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-LP/64/2025allowed

Jyoti Saini And Another v. Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Limited And Others

2026-05-08Justice (To Be Nominated),Mr. Justice Rohit Kapoor7 pages

!" !"

!#$%&$'

%)** + ,--$..!#( /(* / + + ,$(-%"$#(

0$($#) 0*!1 2#3!!34+$ %0"2%'!#$5 #6 0*0 1$(676%(.!4"2%'!#$&%0#6$0$2 '!#(%* * 0* +!1$$2 7!8(6 94 "2%'!#$ &%0 #6$ 0$2 $5 !--.

'!# 0$(-%"$#%* * 0*(65!

!.5!04+0*"2%'!#$5 #6 0*$$-!9 %:!#4"2%'!#$&%0#6$%!--.

'!# !--$..!#* ;;;

"#"!$%

"#"! $.!:%& "!:( & <#6$!''%3-!:

<0$2 %4 6!(=$$(!# (&!'#%0 .:$>-.!

$"* #6!#2 $5%&#6$3!##$04#6$!--.

(!..%5$"!""$.!: %& "!:( & <#6$0$2 %4 ('%"%$"* '($')**$+,$-%.* * 6$($ 0$2 %( 6!2$ =$$ & .$" ?8$(# % < #6$ 18"<3$#%&#6$ %$'6-!(($" %*%& 456$0$=:#6$

D -0%3%# %3!"$ &!2%0%&#6$0$2 '!#%* 6!(=$$($#!#!8<6#* 6$%-$0!# 2$-!0#%&#6$%0"$08"$00$2 $50$!"(!(8"$0)

& ' ' '(

! !

' '(% !

! !!

! 1

CED

* 6$50 %$0(5$0$#6$$3-.%:$$(5%09 < #6$!0:!! / ":8#0!(!0! <!3

#$"@&%0(6%0#F/ GB56%5$0$!<<0 $2$"=: %'%( "$0!# %%&#6$ 0'.!

3&%0-0%3%# %#%#6$-%(#%&''%8#!#*6$ %5!(6$!0"=:#6$.$!0$"+ <.$8"<$%&#6 ( %80#!"5!( "

(-%($"%&=:%=($02 <!(8"$0) 2

! %

! 3

4 ,

4 2

!1 E* <<0 $2$"=:#6$%0"$0%&#6$.$!0$"+ <.$8"<$4#5%%&#6$ %$0(& .$"#6$ (#!#!--$!.56 '66!(( '$=$$!..%5$"=:#6$ % $'6 2 "$ #6$ 18"<3$# 56 '6 ( 8"$0 0$2 $5* 6$ $'6 6!( #!9$ %#$ %& #6$ %# % "!#$" *E* 56$0$=: #6$ 0$'08 #3$# !" -0%3%# % -%.

': 0$(-$'# %& 8"

# ''%8# H < 5!( &%03!.

I$" &%0 -0%3%# % #% #6$ -%(# %& ''%8#!#* 6$ -$0(%( &0%3 !''%8#'!"0$5$0$$.

< =.$* *

.!8($ E %& #6$ %.

': -$03 ##$" !( %$ # 3$ 3$!(80$ #6$ !"18(#3$#%& %33$0'

!.(( (#!#(!.(% #6$'!"0$*6$ %$'64

(8'6'

0'83(#!'$(45!(%&#6$2 $5#6!#!&#$04 #5!(%#%-$&%0#6$ <!3#%6!2$-0%3%#$"!:-$0(%&0%3#6$3

(#$0 !.'!"0$#%#6$-%(#%& ''%8#!#$2$#6%8<66$3!:6!2$-!(($"#6$"$-!0#3$#!.$>!3 !# %& %!.''%8#!#*#5!(6%5$2$0=0%8<6##%#6$%# '$%&#6$ %80# #6!# '$0#!

-0%3%# %( 5$0$ $&&$'#$" &0%3 3

(#$0 !. '!"0$ #6$ -!(#

'.8"

<#6$-0%3%# %%&#6$0$2 '!# #6$:$!0 4!((8'64#6$ %$'66$."(8'6-0%3%# %#%=$=!" .!5* * $2 %(!0$-0$(($"=:#6$.$!0$"($ %0'%8($.!( 5$..!(+#!#$'%8($.=:0$&$00 <#%#6$-0!:$0'.!8($%&#6$50 %4 56$0$ 4#6$.

#$"-0!:$03!"$5!(#%"

0$'##6$$3-.%:$0#%-0%3%#$#6$ -$# %$0(!( %!.''%8#!#5*$*&** 4!"%##%3!9$!: -0%3%# %%#6$-%(#%& %!.''%8#!#!"+$'# && '$0("80 < #6$-$"$':%&#6$50 %*6$50 %!"3 ##$".:5!(& .$" #6$ :$!0 =:56$#6$-0%3%# %%&#6$0$2 '!#%* 5!(!.0$!": 3!"$*# (!--!0$#&0%3#6$-0!:$0'.!8($%&#6$50 %#6!##6$0$5!( %'6!..$<$3!"$#%#6$-0%3%# %%&&$0$"#%#6$0$2 '!#%* * * 6$-0 3!0:<0 $2!'$0!

($"%=$6!.&%&#6$0$2 '!#(

(#6!##6$ %$'6&$.. $00%0 8..

<#6$-0%3%# %%&0$2 $5 !--.

'!# !.0$!": 3!"$4 %#5 #6(#!"

< #6$ &!'# #6!# % (8'6 -0!:$0 5!( 3!"$ #6$ 50 # -$# %* # ( !.(% '%#$"$" % =$6!.& %& #6$ 0$2 $5 !--.

'!#( #6!# #6$ 0$(-%"$#( % !''%8# %& 2!0 %8( '

0'83(#!'$( %#6$05 ($!..%5$"-0%3%# %%&$3-.%:$$(&0%3#6$3

(#$0 !.'!"0$!"4 #6$0$&%0$4 #6$ "

0$'# ((8$" =: #6$ % $'6 '!(# <!# < (8'6 -0%3%# (8'!..$"&%0* J*

$!0$"'%8($.&%0#6$!--$..!#(%--%($(#6$-0!:$03!"$ #6$ 0$2 %( =: 0$&$00 < #% %# % %& 4 !( 5$.. !(

CD (8=($?8$#%# %"!#$"E** 456 '63!9$(0$&$0$'$#%"%I$( %&-0%3%# %-%.

$(&%038.!#$"=$#5$$#% *H #60$&$0$'$#% #6 (-%.

':4 # (80<$"#6!# &!'##6$'%( (#$#(#!"%&#6$ <!36!(=$$ #% 0$(#0 '# #6$ -0%3%# % % #6$ -%(# %& %!. ''%8#!# &0%3 #6$ %&& '

!.(5%09 < #6$& $."'!"0$%&!''%8#(!"!8"

#"$-!0#3$#!.%$ !"#6!#!:"$-!0#80$3!"$=:#6$ <!36!(0 <6#.:=$$8..

$"=:#6$ %$'6!"#6$0$2 %(3$0 #0$1$'# %* * 6$ !00!# % %& &!'#( 5%8." '.$!0.: "$- '# #6!# #6$ 50 # -$# % & .$" =: #6$ !--$..!#(4 #6$ .

#$" -0!:$0 3!"$ 5!( #% "

0$'# #6$ <!3 #% !''%0" '%( "$0!# % #% #6$ '.!

3 %& #6$ 50 # -$# %$0( &%0 -0%3%# %*# (8"

(-8#$"#6!##6$-0%3%# %%&#6$0$2 '!#5!( 3!"$-0 %0#%#6$& <%&#6$50 %*6$0$5!(6%5$2$04%'6!..$<$

#6$50 %#%#6$-0%3%# %%&&$0$"#%#6$0$2 '!#* '$ #6!# =$ (%4 !" #6$ 0$2 '!# 5!( !.0$!": 5%09 < % #6$ -%(# %& %!.''%8#!#&%0($2$0!.:$!0(45$!0$%&#6$2 $5#6!##6$0$5!(% %''!( %&%0#6$ %$'6#%6!2$8..

$"#6$-0%3%# %%&&$0$"#% #6$0$2 '!#*%(8'6$>#$#45$& "#6!#!$00%0!--!0$#%#6$ &!'$%&0$'%0"6!('0$-# !(#6$0$.

$&56 '65!(%#'.!

3$"&%04'%8."%# 6!2$=$$<0!#$"*#!--$!0(#6!##6$!##$# %%&#6$ %$'65!(%#

#$"#%#6$&!'##6!##6$-0%3%# %3!"$&0%3#6$3

(#$0 !.'!"0$#%#6$ -%(#%& %!.''%8#!#5!($2$0'6!..$<$"*H$4#6$0$&%0$4!''$-# #6$'.!

3%&#6$0$2 '!#!"6%."#6!#56 .$"

(-%( <%&#6$!--$!. ! !"2$0#$#$00%06!(%''800$"* * H$3!:&80#6$0%#$#6!#56$#6$3!##$05!(6$!0"$!0. $045$ '!..$"8-%#6$ <!3#%'.!0 &:!(#%56$#6$($-!0!#$!''%8#'!"0$6!(

CD =$$'%(# #8#$"*!&& "!2 #6!(=$$& .$"#%"!:%=$6!.&%&#6$ <!3 (5%0=:#6$ "$0+$'0$#!0:4/ (#!# <!(8"$0) '

! '( 6

! '7

! ) 8')) 8 ''))9%

! '9 0:";#

! 3

= '8 !

06>7

/ ! 7

! ,

'$ '9 ! 0

*";

'9$ '(

@: 0:";#<

6= " .% ,

%( "$0 < #6$ &!'# #6!# #6$ 0$2 '!# 5!( !.0$!": -0%3%#$" !"#6$0$5!(%'6!..$<$#%6 (-0%3%# %45$!0$%#

$" #% $3=!09 8-% #6$ &!'#8!. !(-$'# !( #% 56$#6$0 #6$ -0%3%# %&&$0$"#%#6$0$2 '!#5!('%( (#$#5 #6#6$-0%3%# %-%.

':%0

CJD %#*# (%#6$05 ($#6$'%( (#$#'!($%&#6$ <!3#6!##6$.!(#-0%3%# &0%3#6$3

(#$0 !.'!"0$5!(!..%5$"!(%$# 3$3$!(80$ 4!"#6!# % -0%3%# % 6!( =$$ %&&$0$" #% !:%$ &0%3 #6$ 3

(#$0 !. '!"0$4 #6$0$!&#$0* +8'6 &!'#8!. -%( ( %# "

(-8#$" % #6$ -!0# %& #6$ 50 # -$# %$0(* * (8'6'

0'83(#!'$(45$!..%5#6$-0$($#0$2 %( !" -0%#$'# #6$ -0%3%# % !.0$!": %&&$0$" #% #6$ 0$2 '!#(4 56 '6 5$0$ %# '6!..$<$" #6$ 50 # -$# %* H$ !.(% "$$3 # !--0%-0 !#$ #% %=($02$ #6!# #6$ '.!

3 %& #6$ 50 # -$# %$0( &%0 -0%3%# % #% #6$ -%(# %& %!.''%8#!#38(#=$!''%0"$"'%( "$0!# %=:#6$%!0"5 #6 ! -$0 %"%&#60$$3%#6(&0%3#%"!:4 !''%0"!'$5 #6#6$-0%3%# %-%.

':* #6$$2$#4 # (&%8"#6!#-$0(%(18 %0#%#6$50 %$0(6!2$!.0$!": =$$%&&$0$"-0%3%# %#%#6$-%(#%& %!.''%8#!#4#6$!8#6%0 $( (6!..-!(($'$((!0:%0"$0(<0!# <(8'6=$$& #%&-0%3%# %#%#6$-%(#%& %!.''%8#!##%#6$50 %$0(&0%3#6$"!#$(8'6=$$& #5!( <0!#$"#%#6$ 018 %0(* * ..-$"

<3 ('*!--.

%@(B4 &!:4!.(%(#!""

(-%($"%&* /0 /0 ** 0!1$(6 *H6$#6$0(-$!9 < 0$!(%$"K ) $( %

*H6$#6$00$-%0#!=.$K ) $( %