← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/7612/2011disposed of

Tarlok Singh v. Collector Land Acquisition And ORS.

2016-04-23Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi15 pages

    ! "#$%

$ 

$ &&' ( )

*+,&-./0-1 22** 3

**140&&& 2

5'

6#1 5" ,

5 ,7, 518  

 

  

  



  !

 "

## !$  "% & "

!$ !  ' ( ) 

  



 !#

*"

!$   +  (

,  - ./  . '  (  0  . -2   3 4

    

0  /.6,7 +8(9 :

!

)    7 +8(9 :

*   /.6, .  67 +8(9 :

;;;;;

5 ,7, 5189" . !

  6

6.

 

  !

 "

!#

*"

## !$  "%

"

!$ !  0 6   ,, 



 

6 .

<.

  <.

  =0 0   . 

2  

6 . . ,



  !

!$ )  (6   .6 > 1 ? > <.

  @  

( ./ .6

<. .6 A *#

 . .   6 =. . ) 

B .

. D . . ,2E D 

 ?

2 ?,D .

62   $ #A# . . ( "

> <.  A#"

  F F 0   $! $ #A# . (



> <. ?   F>?F 



  A ! ##$



 # *"A #$ 

 ?

 

 "!*A"9H 

 @ 

 "!AA"9H 

 -  .,

B  0

 >?  / . (    ?. 

  $* ##A  

6

.,

 !!%$$$9H 

 @ 

  



6  .      ! $ !$ $ 



 !!%* ##A ./ (

  1

, (6



    ,       

   

  

( 4 , 

,   ! $ !$ $  ?.    

   ,.6

  *$ $ !$



 !$$$$9H 



6

66

 ,.6

  *$ $ !$    ?. 2



   

 

6 

,

,. ,

0



 

6  6  = 6

  . 

  6

 . .  

66 .6 .      

6 0  2 

., 

    2

0 . 2 

6

,. ,

 06 ,

  (

0   , 8D "

8D % .   2  ,



 . .    . .    6   

 >?

  0 2

( !%  .   ,

  D. ,  .

6

4   . =F (.,  /.6, 1* 3 &

&9

:.

;/,

 :9 



    . (   2  ,

.

. . 

)  

 6    0 .



    =F (.,

*!

 /.6, 1* F  .  .2 0  

.  



              

 

 

    

   

        



     !         "   

 #      

 

$  .   . 0 ,  0 . 2 5"

. ?

 . (  8D "

8D %  

 %$$$9H 



 A$$$$9H 

 2  ?



 >?

,

 # *"A #$ 



 . .,   '

  6 

 0



?

 . 0 0 =F (., 1* F  . 

0    .  .  2  ,

6 D. ,  ,2  . 2

( !%  .

  ,



  ?,6 ., 2

0

  . 0   0 H <.

 6 2 6  

 .

2  . 6   

; =0 

   

   , 

 

2 6 

6  66

D, 

  0  0 .6  , 

 8D !!

8D !A  .6 8D !!

  6

6  2  6

2 ,  .6 $



2 . .   6 (  @ .

/6 . 

.   

.6    

.  6

,  0

    

6

(, 2 8D !A

  6 $   . .   6 @

. .  6

0   8D 5%9   5 @ 0 (6  0  = <

@ .

 .  

.  , .

 2   $   8D !A @ .   0  0.      

6

 66

0   , 8D !!

8D !A  

  , 6 

 

8D !* 8D !

4 0 0 =F (., 5<*  8<=&  0 .-/9&+3, !0=>9

.;/,

)( 90 



  

  

 0 . 

.,  

  

8D !*  2  

6

4   . .   8D !* 8D !

 8D !* 

6 

 *!$$$$9H 

 > .6 $"

  $!



. . 

/6  6 > 0  $! #A

4  



 H <.  . .   6 =. . .   8D !* 8D !

0  6  6 > 0  @

. '

@ .

(  @ .

(

 .   0

/6 .   6 =. .  8D !*

.     

6

6

 6    

 =F (., 5<*8<=& 0F  .      =F (.,

* %  /.6, 5<*8<=&0F  . 

2

2   

. % 



         





!

 ""#$        

 &   '( '

( 

    



( (   

 

  #

     



    

    

(     ( 

  

       





        & 

   %

&'& ()

 *

%+

!"",&- -!* * $ ""# * # (

  



   

*+#& ,-(. / +-(.

 (01 2 01 (  

      (      

    #  

 ( 

   

 

 $   (0     

(     

+   $ %      (   

         

(       

    



 

     

(   "          

( # & #   (

            

 # 

 

    

 

    (               

     

   

%   

#    (   

    





? 3       

(          (                



  

+  # 



 % 

 

&     

        (  

      #4

 

  

(  

$ >   ?.  2  ,  6 6

 8D !* .,

  .  6

 .  = 

6., 6 

  8D !* .



  ,

 ,

 H <.   6  6 =. .    ,. .

  8D !* >   ?.  2  , 0. D 

?.

    2   

 

  $* ##A

6

 !!%$$$9H 

 =0



6.,   ( ?.  2  ,

 /  . 

 

. . 

2

6.,

(  8D 5%9 .

  0 

@ (6 6

  . ,6.. ,

 

<.

/6 .

 ?

2 

 6

 0.  . 

 ?

2  .   8D 5%9 0. 0

. 6

:

 2 D6

 ?

2 

.6 . D 

 ?

2 ?,D - 

0

  !A$  , ,

   8D 5%9 (, 2

0 (

  2 #$  , ,

:2 0  0

6 66 , .

(. . >  4 0

.

  2 .



.



,  

6 ,,  2 4 .

 2 . 

0

,, . (

 8D !*   . .



  !%%$  , ,

 0. ,

 , =0



2      

.  .

6

(

   0 =F (.,

 &3, @9

(.;/,

;

98&,&-3, @9

).

/,

; +&>&$A=&>&3 B0&A -&9 0= 9

.:/,

;?).  ,

. 

.   8D 5%9 0.  2 

   8D !* . .   6 > 0  .

 /.    D6

 ?

2

 . 

 .



  ,  8D !* 4 <.

2  



, 



 , 8D 5%9H   .  ! $ !$ 



, 

,   ! $ !$ $   .6

 0

   .

    .  

 ?.  6 ,   ! $ !$ $

 0 ,   .

  

6

4 , 

,   ?.

   6

   ,   8D 5%9

6 .. 

.   6

  ! $ !$ $  06   5     

(     #     %       #(  

 

  

%  #   # (   

#



     

( #  

5 

# #

   5

 

  & (        

 

       

(    # % # ( 

# 

 &

 ( 

    

      

     #  

 

 (  

 

  

  

 # 

 

 $

.2 06 0 =F (.,  

 

 3&*0>  "*=



.$/#@13, 0=9

;.

/ .

&A&*/):

6

  6, 

.

 0

0  ,

.  /. 0   0

 ,    , ,.6

    ?. . 2 

6

,. ,



8D !*  $! #A

.    2  

6

  8D !*

 *!$$$$9H 

 (  . ( "

 . $ #A#    

, 0 2  0

 8D !*



<. 4 0 0 =F (.,  * 5-9  &*    0*    2&  1  3  >& "&A>&!*9

?.

)/,

);   +80 3, @9

;.(/,* 9 0.  !I

.

  .,.  

. , 0 2  - 6  !I

.

 

 0 2  .,.  

 *!$$$$9H 



,. ,

 "$ "$A9H 

 62

   ,

.,

 "$ "$A9H 

 ,  . ( "

 ( ,

.

?

 



  0H/. 66 6 2,

 >?



.,

.   . 6    ?.  . 6 2,

    

<. ?.

 2 

66 . . D  

2  .

 0.

2

2 <.   ,

 

>?



,.

 !%$$9H . ( !*   . 2

 2 

6.,   .

  0 . . .  6  4 .,





6 ,  , H

<. ,2 .6 , ,   6 ,

6   

0

  .  .

2 .     0

..  .

   ?.  2  ,



0 D

   6   .

6., 

 4  0.

 

 

6

2 . 0

<.

0.

 .

2 6 6  (

 ,   .     . (   .  2  , . .

6 2  6

 

)   .  2

 (   (6  ,

(6  

 @ .

@

(6 -.  (6 = / (6

 0 (6   (6  

6

6 ..  .

 6 6

,.

 !%$$9H  . ( !*   . 2

 2  0. 

2 . / 4 6 0 . 26

0.  2

22 

0   . 2 

2 .  



2 ,6

6  0 6

,  ,6 . ,

4 2 . J  .

0 

   ,.2

<. 

,  ,

 06  0   , 6 0  6  6 > <.  A#"

C6 0

. 

.,   

 .

0 .6

0  

6

<. 0. 

,.

 *$$$$$9H . ( !*  . 2

 2  

  , 2

, D 

0   0

0  6   >  2 



 

2      /.  0    

2  

6., 

    ?6 . 

.,   

 . 0 

,  0

    2



 )

2

0 D  



   ,

.,

 "$ "$A9H 

 ,  . ( "



.   

6

<. 0. 

,.

 *$$$$$9H . ( !*  . 2

 2  @ 

 

.2 

  , .      2  . 0 ,

 .  0 . =F (.,

!!

 /.6, @  ,  0&* $A*2 23!,0+9

.

/,

;

. "        

  #           ( (    

       

26 -.        

  

  ( 

  

   

   &

7          4     (       

    

          



(  

-.   

  

             

 4  (   (  

&

  ##

 

-. &

 

    

 ;      

 

   



-.         

  

    (   



(  

   &



 



. 2 0   



   

,

0 0  

 5 ,7, 518D !* $" !$  " $