← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4722/2016disposed of

M/S General Electronics Of Haryana Ltd. v. Uhbvnl And ANR

2016-08-107 pages



     

 

 !""#$%$&'()(%!*

+%"&", --"#!,&$#% ,. & *"/"-0$ 11"-- &!

2",%(%

!! , ,. & $3-$2$!, &$) 45$4$!"6* &#07(-   &!0",  "%1&6"&!%  



 !

!

"#

$%

,"%"&!'

,8 &/ -3$!9$&)0*9"&$,6:# !"/$!0

,4 &6""19$&)0 "0*6:# !"* ,!0" 11"-- &!

, 9 &$ *6:# !"* ,!0","%1&6"&!% ;;;;; !

"#

&'( $:$- $%#<=> 0"1, .",$&!0" 11-$# !$&$%,#&:",!$&)!0"1,"%"&! ,":$%$&1"!$!$&!!0"   %!0" / ,6/ %1 %%"6(&6",!0"&"/#!* !0()0!0","","&#"/ %4 6"(&6",!0"-6#! 11-$# !$&$% --/"6 ":$%$&1"!$!$&$%,6","6!?"

!," !"6 %  

$&# %"

,8 &/ -3$!  9$&)0*  -" ,&"6  9"&$,  (&%"-  %%$%!"6  ?.

,4 &6""19$&)0 "0,!0" 11"-- &!%(?4$!%!0 !  (,#0 %"

,6",6 !"6@>@>/ %1- #"6?","!0" 11"-- &!=#&!, #!,, %(11-.A8 9 &6(#!,#&%$%!$&)%!, &6%? ,6 6, /& -(4$&$(4:",&"%!, &6%0$)0!"&%$-") -: &$%"6%!""-/$," %$B"A@44 !!0", !"@>+=1",(&$!1",8 0"&"!1,$#"/ % *@*+=  "  %(?4$!%  !0 !  $&  1(,%( &#"  !  !0"  ,"4"&!$&"6

(,#0 %" ,6",*!0" ),""4"&!/ % -%"&!","6$&!0"#&!, #!,/ % !%(11-.>A8 9 &6(#!,C" %"-?. >>@> &6 !0"," !",>A=8 ":",.4&!0,41,$-*@>&/ ,6%0"

%(11-.#(-6&!?"4 6" %!0" -(4$&(4/ %&! : $- ?-",/ &! %0,! )"    !0"  % 4"  0"  1 ,!$"%  /","  ?(&6  ?.  !0"  ),""4"&!* 1 ,!$#(- ,-.- (%",!$#-"=*- (%"% &6,!$#-"2!0" ),""4"&!  "  0 %  6, /&  !0"  !!"&!$&    !0$%  (,!  !  !0" ,"4"&!$&"6- (%"%*/0$#0," 6!0(%'= D5 9=5  '



     

                   

 

           

                       

 

   



)

          



        

    

        

          

 

       

           







     

 

 

  

    

                

   

 



   

 

  



     

        

   

        

       

   

            !

"#$%&'()*%+,-.*/(0 %1

   



    

  

    0&    "#$%& 22$"(+/%,)+*"+/()"(-)"0 

   

 

   

  

    

      

    

       

!

"%(?4$!%!0 ! 256$6&!$%%(" &.&!$#"%":"& 6 .%,# &#"-- !$& &61(,#0 %$&)!0"4 !",$ - !!0"#%! &6,$%7 !0" 11"-- &!*."!-6)"6!0"#- $4?","!0",?$!, !, %!0" ),""4"&! #&! $&"6!0","%-(!$&6$%1(!"!0,()0 ,?$!, !$&0","%1&6"&!% 6$6  &!  1- #"  &  ,"#,6  &.  6#(4"&! ,.  ":$6"&#"  ,") ,6$&)  !0"

(,#0 %" ,6",,1(,#0 %$&)!0"4 !",$ - !!0",$%7 &6#%!%!0" 11"-- &!*4(#0-"%%& 6: &#"&!$#",") ,6$&)!0"% 4"/ %%"&! &6 4","-.  ?.  1- #$&)  &  ,"#,6  !0"  ,6",  /(-6  &!  ?"  %($#$"&!  ! %(?%! &!$ !"  !0"$,  #- $4  ?","  !0"  ,?$!, !,*  ?(!  6"%1$!"  !0 !  !0" ,?$!, !,!," !"6!0"#- $4 %6 4 )"%(&6",9"#!$&>!0"&6$ & &!, #!#!*/0$#0/ %&!/$!0$&!0"-"!!", &6%1$,$!!0" ),""4"&!*

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

, 9 &$ *-" ,&"6#(&%"-,!0","%1&6"&!%%(?4$!% !0 !!0","$%&6"$ &#"!!0"!",4% &6#&6$!$&%!0" ),""4"&!* ?(!*$& #!*!0"% 4"/"," 60","6!$&-"!!", &6%1$,$!(4",(% -"!!",%/","%"&!!!0" 11"-- &!=#&!, #!,*?(!0 :$&) $-"6!6%*

(,#0 %" ,6",6 !"6<@/ %1- #"6! &!0",41 &.* $"* +% ,"4 ?-"%* $1-$ &8 - &* 3 %!0 &  &6":"&1, 1 .4"&!4 6"?.-"!!",6 !"6>0 %?""&1- #"6&,"#,6*?(! !0","$% %! ,76$","&#"$&,"%1"#!!0"1,$#" &67""1$&)!0$% %1"#!   !0"  4 !!",   $&!  #&%$6", !$&*  !0"  ,?$!, !,  / ,6"6  !0" #41"&% !$&*!0(%*!0","$%&,#"$&!0"%(?4$%%$& ,8 &/ -3!$

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

,"#"6$&)!!0 !*&(4",(%-"!!",%+&!$#"%0 :"?""&/,$!!"&!!0" 11"-- &!,%(11-.4 !",$ - %!0"4 !",$ -/ %? 6-.,"H($,"6, 4 %%!(?"/"--"&",)$% !$&0"- %!-"!!",/ %6 !"6@ &6!0"

(,#0 %" ,6",/ %<@:"&!0"&*1 .4"&!!0"% 4"0 % ?""&1,:"6&,"#,6:$6"-"!!",6 !"6>0",?$!, !,*&!0" ? %$%!0" ,"4"&!$&"6":$6"&#"* ,,$:"6 ! #&#-(%$&!0 !!0"," / % 6$","&#" *A*A+=* %&!$#"6 ?:" &6 ##"1!"6!0" #- $4!0","%1&6"&!%?. / ,6$&)$&!","%!FG# &&!,"4 $& ?-$:$(%!0" #!!0 !!0"#&!, #!/ % / ,6"6$&@>*/0"," %!0"



(,#0 %" ,6",$%%("6!!0"!0$,61 ,!./ %1- #"6$&!0"4&!0(-.* @ &6!0" / ,6/ %1 %%"6&>>"&! $-$&)!0"$&!","%!F G0","# &?"6"",4"&!!0"$&!","%!$&%!" 6G!G$&!0" 1"#(-$ , #!% &6#$,#(4%! &#"%!0"# %"*/0$#0%0 --&!?"," 6 % #&6$!$&1,"#"6"&!

,!0",")$&)," %&%*46$.!0" / ,6!!0""E!"&! !0 !$&%!" 6$&!","%!FG*$!%0 --?"G!0,()0(!,4!0"6 !" 6"4 &6!$--," -$% !$&*/0$-"(10-6$&)!0" / ,6 11" -%! &6%6$%1%"6

"#,6%?"%"&!? #7,!0/$!0 +,+-.

#

 !

"  &'/0-1

$%

"10.10& -20'345,6&0'-507 80-6 "10.10& 02&.'9(0 80-6