Balwan Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Another
!"#"#
$% &
!"# $ % &
'
( $
" &)
&
! "
#$ %" "& '(
)
& *
)*&+ , "-.'/0((1(2(3 "
4(4 4(5 45 (65.7) 4(/.7 & +.7& 8 9
$
!!
(:6(2(3)
; (+& "
, &
" < $ -. "
! !& = '( " > # " "
* !
'( 7 "
& & $# -.
, $
!!
$
$ " & !
? &7=.&&, "
! && ""
& ? !!
.
!& ! 7 % & "
.
7&
& " !
$ ! !!
" & ! ? . &
& @
&
&! $
$ . & ! !!
" ! ? & .! !!
& && $& & #? & "
!
& &"& ! !
& " & ? $? " !
& $
-. , - !
$ !!
&! $
7 -
""& & $? A$& ;7 +,&+,-./"&0012,3 ,4 ,10. *!56 5 ++,768# - %" 8
7 )79+,4 &+,-.,410. /"&0012,3 ,4,10. * 5#6 5 ++,76!8 && -.'/0 ((1(2(3"
4(4 4(5 45 (65.7)
4(/.7& +.7& 8 9
$
!!
(:6(2(3)
; (+ && $ , $? , , 5)
&6 !"#"#
/&1 Whether reasoned / speaking?
Yes / No Whether reportable?
Yes / No