High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4656/2010allowed

Attar Singh v. Rajender Prasad And ORS.

2015-08-25Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!"##$%&%'()*)&"+ ""!,%'*- ..#//!'"

0#,&)&

!1#'2#, !,&!2 "-#,& #&.'2#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&

3-#"-#, #.,"#,&/$!/.!.#,&4!56#!//7#2"&##"-#1)2*4#'"8 6#,##,,#2""-# #.,"#,&,'"8 9 3-#"-#,"-#1)2*4#'"&-)/26#,#.,"#2%'"-#%*#&"8

,#&#'"( ,!%0%,!2!:+2:$!"#+ ,"-#!..#//!'" '#,"-#,#&.'2#'"& ;;;;; *)+%,'

-#$-!//#'*#%'"-#.,#&#'"!..#!/%&""-#1)2*4#'"&!'2 2#$,##&6"-"-#),"&6#/7+7-#,#65"-#&)%",.&&#&&%', .,.#,"5 &-7' %' "-# &%"# ./!' !'2 "-# 2#4!,$!"%' ,#.," -!& 6##' 2#$,##2"-!&),"-#,6##'2%,#$"#2"-!""-#.&&#&&%'6#*"2#/%:#,#2" "-#./!%'"%!'2.,,4!2##'2!'"&2#$,##,.#,4!'#'"%'1)'$"%' -!&!/&6##'.!&&#2%'!:),"-#./!%'"%,#&",!%'%'*2##'2!'"

,4 ,!%&%'* $'&",)$"%' !'5 <%'2 !'2 ),"-#, ,#&",!%'%'* " "!<# .&&#&&%'"-#,.!,""-#-!-%'2%&.)"#+4)$-/#&&+%'"#,#,#'$#%' "-#.#!$#)/.&&#&&%'!'2)&#"-#./!%'"%!'2.,,4!2##'2!'"& 7%"-!),"-#,%'1)'$"%'"-!"%'$!&#2##'2!'" %&&)$$#&&)/%',!%&%'*

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

4%'#"-#&!%2 7%"'#&&65"!<%'*"-#!%2.,:%&%'& ,2#, )/# #),"-#, &)64%"&"-!""-#&)%"7!&"%4#6!,,#2!&"-#./!%'"%?&7%"'#&&)'#@)%:$!//5 !24%""#2"-!""-#!//#*#2$'&",)$"%'7!&2'#65"-#!..#//!'"95#!,& 6!$<+ 7-#,#!& "-# &)%" 7!& %/#2 6#5'2 "-# .#,%2 5#!,& !'2+ "-#,#,#+"-#&)%",.&&#&&%'$)/2'"-!:#6##'2#$,##2#),"-#, &)64%"&"-!"4!,<%'*"-#2$)4#'"7)/2'"2%&.#'&#7%"-"-#.,:%'* "-#2#4!,$!"%',#.,"!'2+"-#,#,#+//7%'*&)6&"!'"%!/@)#&"%'& /!7!,%&#%'"-#.,#&#'"!..#!/,2#"#,4%'!"%'65"-%&),"(= !

3-#"-#,"-#4!,<#22$)4#'" %'"-#!6&#'$#%"& .,$!'6#/<#2%'"#:%2#'$#8 3-#"-#,"-#),"&6#/7-!:#$44%""#2!'%//#*!/%"5 !'2.#,:#,&%"57-%/#"!<%'*%'"$'&%2#,!"%'"-#)'.,:#2 ,#.,"8

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

&6##'#>!4%'#2+ 7-&"!"#2"-!""-#!)"-,"-#2#4!,$!"%',#.,"7!&&)#,%'*,4 .!,!/5&%&!&&%&"!'$#"-#),"-!&6##'"!<#'"#>!4%'#"-#&!%2 7%"'#&&65,#&,"%'*""-#.,:%&%'& ,2#, )/# "%&'7 &#""/#2/!7"-!""-#./!%'"%-!&"&"!'2'-%&7'/#*&!'2$!''",#/5 ).'"-#7#!<2##'$#,'2##'$#"-#2##'2!'" "-"-#),"&6#/7+%'45:%#7+-!2$44%""#2!'%//#*!/%"5 !'2.#,:#,&%"5%''"'"%$%'*"-#.,:%&%'&#$"%' "-#'2%!'

:%2#'$# $" -# ./!%'"% -!& !%/#2 " 2%&$-!,*# "-# 6),2#' !'2+ "-#,#,#+"-#,#7!&'$$!&%',"-#!..#//!'"=2##'2!'"",#6)""-# &!4#'#&&#'$#+"-#./!%'"%-!&!%/#2".,:#"-#$!"#*,%$!:#,4#'"&%'

"-#&)%"+"-)&+"-#,#7!&'$$!&%',"-#),"&6#/7"2#$,##"-#&)%" '"-#6!&%&)'.,:#22$)4#'" ' :%#7 7-!" -!& 6##' 6&#,:#2 !6:#+ "-# &)6&"!'"%!/ @)#&"%'&/!7!,#!'&7#,#2%'!:),"-#!..#//!'"=2##'2!'" !'2 !*!%'&""-#,#&.'2#'"=./!%'"%-#&)%"%&2%&4%&&#2!'2"-#!..#!/%& !$$,2%'*/5!//7#2 01, *)+%

203 '(-.&