High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4755/2016disposed of

Icici Lombard General Insurance Company Limited v. Harminder Singh And ORS

2018-08-17Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry16 pages

#$#$#%&'( ) (*#! +(!

$&,!-% ,, **! .

( + /(&!

(0!123 2!

2 3 ,!

#$#$#%&'( ) (*#! +(!

$&,!-% ,, **! .

( + !&2!4+(!

2 3 ,!

#$#$#%&'( ) (*#! +(!

$&,!-% ,, **! .

( + &!54+(!

2 3 ,!

!&2!4+( ,, **! .

( + 0+!*4+&(!

2 3 ,!

!*2( 7 (2 ,, **! #!

(( ,!

!#!

( 2*8 7 92 073! 7 (,, **! #!

(( ,!

!#!

::::

(1+& ! 9 2 ( ;+ 1& !9 (

<2 5+ 1& ! '

!1(

=-2 &&!5+ 1& ! +(,, * 2(

#! +(!

$&,!-!

#!5+(

$*&!( !1 (&!

! ( +*!1 ! *!1 2(

*& , ! ,

&&!5+ 1& ! 2** !

#!2 !

,!! 2 $+(9 + 92 2!

(&!!( **9 " >2 2 (!&+!(

!5+(

*&!(* 1*2 (

9( ( 2 ,* 2(1 !

+! 9! &

*& ,* - *'* '

92*

!12 ! !,-'* +!

(2 2 &

?, @

>2 2 (!&+!(

! +(

(&2 9!#! +(!

$&,!- !

+! &1 2 7 *'* '

92* * +*!12 &+! ! !,-'* ( !@

(1+& ! 27 '

!2 ( !

* (&2 * (!

(2 ,( =22 * (!

* 27 (

+,!2 7(+ 5+ 1& ! ,

!$+( 8!1 (1 !7 9 /

2 '

( !2 + !

* % (!

* ,, (!1! '

2* 2 !5+(

92*

*-!1+,!2 5+ 1& ! ,

'-/!A'* 0+,( $+(!2

! !

'-2 $+(!2 "

#$ % &'( )!* + ,"

- ) 2 +'&

2 2 &+! (

'- 2 !5+(

*&,* -,+( 2

'-2&(2 ( !!'

2 9+*

&+! 17!12 '

2 9(!1 ( <2 (

! $*& <('+!*2 * (

+,!2 5+ 1& ! ,

)+5( /12$+(!2 ."

/& '0)!!1 ."

(*/12$+(!2 0 2$

3$ 4"$ )!) & +)*8 7 922

&+!(

2 *&!!5+(

!*'* '

92*

* +*!12 &1 ,-'* !2 2 (2!

* (!

* (2 #! +(!

$&,!- 92* ( *-!1+,!2 5+ 1& 2 $+(!5, 16+)!*

2!)!6 0 2$

- " )!1 ) , )

! 2 + 2&+!(

#! +(!

$&,!-2

*&!!5+(

*'* '

2 !5+(

*&! !!'

17 ! +'* '

02 * (

+,!!2 (5+ 1& !,

$+(!2

4// / )!6 + ,"

- * % + ( (

+**- ?&!

5+ 1& /!A'*

0+,( $+(!/ !$3'

**A +,( ! (

+* ?&!! 5+ 1& !,

'-/!A'*

0+,( $+( ,,( !2/!A'* 0+,( $+(9

*!1 922 &+!(

* 1*2 ( +!

! +(!

,* -!

2 ,* -2*

(!!

!/!A'* 0+,( $+( 2 2 22 *

! +(!

,* - ,+( 2

(7( - ( !

*+ !1!7 & !

+( ++( '-9-

7!1#!

!! +(!

( ,+( 2

( !*

+ !

9( !

?*'*-%

! +(!

( * ,+( 2

+( *! 7 (2 ( 8!2 +!9( !

!2,, !!1 #!,( 5+ 1& !2 $+(

*922 ( ! 92-2

! +(!

,* - ,+( 2

<2 ( ! ,( 5+ 1& ! /!A'* 0+,( $+(

*922 ,(7 ! (.

+*& *- !

2 2 ,

+!(- 7!1

+*!1 (&

2 ! (,(

& !,

+!(- 7!1 &!1 +!

(** (&

22 !9** !!

**2 &7 '* &&7'* 2( '!8

+! !

(-&+!(

7'* +!

!- !( '+ + 2! (,( !9+* ( +*! 7!1(

, 2 9(!1 +* (!

1*1

92 2 !('+ 2

2 #!2

+& !

/!A'* 0+,( $+(2 2 2 &+!(

7'* !

+! *

! +(!

,* - 2**!'

9( * ! !,-'* (

!$*& <('+!* +!

( 2 ( .

/!A'* 0+,( $+( 29 (!,( 2 7 (-5+ 1& !2 !

22 &+!92

*&!(

+! !5+(-(

2(( ,

7 2 2 ( !

+! !

!(!!

2 (9 !2

!!2,, !!1 + 2!

!&+!9 ,-'* B(

'* 2** '

*'* '

6( 5+ 1& ! ?(

-& - $ 3 $ 3 / " 3

/ 22 3 $ 2& 2 2

/2 22$ $ 2 -& /

2 2/23 /

&2*7 3 82 2" 3

2 $ 3$ $ 3

+(2 ( 2 5+ 1& ! 2 '

! **9

'- /!A'* 2

0+,( $+(!2 70 0 2$

3$ , 2 9

)!!) 6):92 !2 $+(2 2

92*

+ !12 5+ 1& /!A'* 0+,( $+(!2

/ !$3'

**A +,(2

1(!2 5+ ! ! #

!7 ( ! *&!6( !

5+ 1& ! ,

'-/!A'* 0+,( $+( ,

**-

*922

+ +(2 ((

(

!5+ 1& /!A'*

0+,( $+(!2 2. 0 2$

3 $

$ )!6 6)1/!A'*

0+,( $+(9

*!1922 3+* (&

0 /(-! ! * 1*2 ( &,*-

92* 2 *

+(!1

#!,( 5+ 1& !/!A'* 0+,( $+(

*92 2 + !

2 22

9( 5+ ! !

'+ ! ! !! '

(

*(1

6( 2

5+ 1& ! ?(

" #$

(

)**+ $,

<2 ( 5+ 1& ! 7(+ /12$+( 8!1!

7 9( 2 2 (29 (!7 9 '!

!1,(

! /!A'* 0+,(

$+(2 (5+ 1& ! ,

2 (/12$+(( !( C+(

( 1( 5+ 1& 2 $+(!!54+&(D 7A

+,(2 & ' **-( +,!2 5+ 1& /!A'*

0+,( $+(!/ !$3'

**A +,(#!,(

5+ 1& ! (,* !1( *!

2 $+(

! +(2 (

( !2

+ #!!54+&(D 7A +,(!

2 (2 !!

$+(9 ! (9!,( 5+ 1& !,

!/ !$ 3'

**A +,(!(6( ;

!25!A +,( /9 (!

9 ?&!

5+ 1& !,

'-2 $+( ! 02 2!8 =2( 95A +,( 2 $+( ( 8!1 !

(!2 7(+ 5+ 1& ! ,

'-2 $+( !

*+ !12

5+ 1& /!A'* 0+,( $+(!/ !$3'

**A +,( 22 +!

& !*

!2 *

! +(!

,* - !

*&,* -<2 ,( &+&!2 &

*&,* - , !

2 ( ,( +*(, ( !

,* - ?,( '-

*+? &

+& **-!

! !+!9( !

!2,, ! +(!12& 2 !&+! ,( &+&, !(

92 !2 *

! +(!

,* -!(&**-2 &+! , (!+&'

( - ( ( 1+*(*-!

2 ( &+! (

! &+(- ( 2 (9 #!

+!9( !

!2 !5+(

(* 1*2 ( ( , , (2 ,* -#!

+& !

2 * (!

;+ 8 7 9 2 2 &+!

2 !5+(

*&!!

+! 2 (2 (9!&

*& ,* -9+* '

*'* '

0&*(*- ! . 2*A +,( 2 $+( 2 *

2 2 &+! &

*& ,* - (

(& 2

! +(!

&,!- *'* '

<2 ' ,+(, ! !1 2 ,(7 ! ( 1(!

! !+!

(2 (.

! !5+(

( ! * 1*2 ( (2 * 92 22 -27 +

!/9 ( + 2 ! ! !!( +*! 2 +!5+ !( 2& ! ( '!!E ( 2 !5+(

( 2 * 1* 2 ( <2

*&! !!'

**9

&8 (+!

+ & (+!

!,(7

( +'* ,-& ! , (0

(

!$*& <('+!*

(&!

&+! ! !92 2,, ( '

5+ ;+ 9+* '7+ *-& !92 ( !'* <2 !(

( $+( 2+* '

! !5+(

!2 !5+(-(2 * 1*2 !2

!17 '!!E2 *&! #!7 9

+ ! ( ,

+**- **9!12

5+ 1& ! /!A'* 2 0+,( $+( !

2 $+( ! 02 2!8 =2( 95A +,( !

! . 2*A +,( 2 $+( 2

*+ !22 &+!(

( !!

*&,* -9( &

* ?, !

*+ !12 ,*E!

2(1 2**'

*'* '

92* * +*!12 ! !

,-'* !

+! &

* ?, 2 & 2 *&! ! '

2 !*

,( &+&, (,+( 2 !12 &

*&,* -'

+ 29 2

&+!92 29 !7

!5+(

2 &- '

+( 8 $ 2 ;< 0&*(*- 8!12 *+ (&2 '7

+ ! 2 $+( * 7 9 ( & ( ! 2 &+!(

*&! ( &1 2 7 (&2 9!! +(!

&,!- * *'* '

2 *&! !!'

**9

(+!

+ & (+!

!!( +*!'!!E( +'* 2

*&! /

+ *

!1*-

-8 $ 2 2 ;<

#!2 *&,,* !

'-/(&!

(0!123 22

(

!$*& <('+!*2 9(

,( (/9 (2 $+(

! 2

+ B , ! +(!

&,!-!

+! ,* -,+( 2

*&!

,!1 ! 7 9 2

+ ! &

'7 2 &+!

'- 2 *&! (& 2 9! ! +(!

&,!- B 2**'

*'* '

/9 (2 *&! 2**'

2 &+! ,( &+&92 22 '

!, *&! ,+( 2 ,* -0!

!2 ( ,

B 9(

+!2 *&! 9* +

*922 ! !,-'* &!5 4+(2 !5+(

02 2 '

!9(

B+ 92 2 &5(&+! !

+! 2 ,* 2(1 !

*+ !1&,*!!

#2 '

! +!

$+(2 2 1( ! (& #$#$# 6(+

!* %

#! +(!

$&,!- 2 ? ! B

,!1!7 92

+ !&

'7 &+! B 2**'

*'* '

92* * +*!12 ! !,-'* /9 ( 9+* * '

2 &+! , !'-2 (!,+( 2

*&,* -0!

2 '

!2 ,

2 $+(9(

B!2 ' +&,! 9* +

*922 !&2!4+(02 9 - ( 1 9(8!1 #! +(!

1 ! 7 ( (?%

#! +(!

$&,!-%&

9 * &,(!1

+ !'- !1+!9(8 !

!2 (*

* 12 '

&,+

, (2

*=( 2 +

, (&!

! '*-2 ? F % (!

(

!$*& <('+!*2 9(

+& B#! +(!

$&,!- ,* !1 ((

+ !92

*&!

8!1 ( !2!

!#&-'

2!2 * 2 ,+( 2

*&,* -!

2 9 (

? B'-#$#$#6(+

!*%

#! +(!

$&,!-+

* +&

+! &

* ?, 2

&+!(

'-#$#$#6(+

!*%

#! +(!

$&,!- 2**'

*'* '

&+! , !'-2 *&! !,+( 2

*&,* - 2**'

*'* '

(

=+ !

2 '

*&! 2 !*

B!2 ,

% (!

*,, (!1 (2 #! +(!

$&,!-2 +'&

22 (

!$*& <('+!*2

!2 ' #!

<?3 +(!

! +'&

!8,*

92 #!

<?3 +(!2 '

!2 2 (2!

* (!

* (2 *&! 92*

(9!12 !! $+(#!

<?3 +(! (2 !!

* - (

2 +'&

2 *&! ,, **! 2 '

! ! !*- 29!1 !2 !

<?3 +(!

! ! 29!-+!( !'* !

&,(

,( 7+ - ( / +(2 ( +'&

2#!

<?3 +(!9***9- '

(2 !!

*- ( 7 (!

2 ! +' !

2 (1+& ! * (!

* (2 #! +(!

$&,!- <2 $+(2 !*-E

(1+& ! * (!

(2 ,( <2 !&

* (!

(

!$*& <('+!* (8!1! !

(!2 !

!2 !

(&#!

<?3 +(!92 29 '

!1 ! !*-

&+ '

! (*-,(7 22 !

!5+(

2 '

!1 ! !*-!

!+!9( (+!( !'* * ,!2

<?3 +(!

(2 !- (

2 (

!$*& <('+!*2 ! &&

! (((!2

+! % (!

* (2 ,, **!#! +(!

$&,!- +(2 +'&

2! (

+* ?&!! #!

<?3 +(! - (

,,( !22 !

92 22 '

! 29! '-2

!5+(

(&+!9(802 +(2 ( 9 !! $+(2

<? 3 +(! 92 2 9

( 2 !!

* - (

!- (

!92 2

B2 '

! (

(& 2 ? %

#! +(!

$&,!- %&

&& !/

2 +'&

22 !( !

!!'

(

(&2 '+ !

#! +(!

1 -02 +'&

2 2 +! 9(8 ! '

!!+

'- 2 !5+(

92+ &+ &7 !

<2 $+( 2 ?&!

2 ! !! 92

7*'* !2 #!5+(

2 '

! ?&!

6>02 2 *&

2 2 1( + +' , (2 #!

<?3 +(! (2 +!!1- (

2 !( !

(&+!

9(829 (, ! ! ( (&2 ,, (

92( 1( 2

? (2 !!

*- (

#!!-

! &5(,( !

9 (&+!9(8 *&!9 ! 212*- C+*

92 2 &- !

(*- ( 2 +

! 2

0& ( 27 7 2 ! + ( ( * ,(7

2 *- +!2 (

! <2 !7*7 * &7 !!

(7 **!1#2 !

2 2 +

(7 '

!92 2 2 !9 !! !!+ + &,+! * 1 !&2!4+(2 *&!92 ! ?&!

2 2 (

**&' ( C+(

2!1

( (- - ( <2 $+(* !

2922 1(9!11 2 (&7 !9+* '

+*02 9+* '

( C+(

!! & !

2(+12+ (*

2 9+* '

( C+(

,, (&!

!2 *, % (!

* (2 #! +(!

$&,!- +'&

2 !

&+!2 '

!9(

(2 (

**&'2 &+! 9(

( '*-2 '

(

02 +'&

2922

(

**&' '*- '+!

<2 $+(2 !

+'& ! /9 (+!'*

(

**&' !!8 ,*

(1!*B!+(*(

**&' !*- (

- +' 92 2

2!*1 * 7!

!C+*- (

**&'2 &,(7

'+2

(

**&' +' !7 #! + 2 +!2 $+(2

92 2 +!

'*-9+* *9-

, +,!2 !+( 9(8!

,'*

((-!1#!2 ,(

! 2 9 9(8!1 !#! +(!

1 ! 7 ( 9 ** &,(!1

+ !2 +

! '- !1+!

9(8#2 !

2 (2

! 2 !'*

!!+ 922 9(8G7 !!

2 '

!,*

,(7 2#!

<?+2( 2 +

2 (!

(! *!12

+(!

,!1 ! 7 9 2 2 $+( 2

7 9 2 ! 2 ,(

! 2 (* $+( 2 (12*-

!* '*-2 ? F

!1*-2 ! !,-'* ! !&2!

4+( ( 9(8

!"#$ %&!'()$%* #

!" #$ %#% ++( &# '

(, (!*& '

*G?, +(

*=** B 3

(& #$#$# 6(+

!* %

#! +(!

$&,!- % - B (

*%&'

(&!

! '*- #!

? F ? ? H B ? F ? ? H B !$2(1

B <(! ,(!$2(1 B B 6!!

(!1

B % & !

B 0,

B #% (

* %&'

++( 2!1

(- - ( <* B B

B #% I ?, !

+((

! ,+( 2 2

*&,* - <*$&, ! ! B B <2 ! !,-'* ! &!54+( ( 9(8

!"#$ %&!'()$%* #

!" #$ %#% ++( &# '

(, (!*& '

B B B / ,*

2(1

*+ !1&,*! B 3

(& #$#$# 6(+

!* %

#! +(!

$&,!- % H B !$2(1

B 0,

B <(! ,(!

B 6!0+

(!1

B <*$&, ! !

B #% I ?, !

+((

! ,+( 2 2

*&,* - <*$&, ! ! B

B %,.&

#(%&

#% ,(& (&)$ % $ /% #$

, )%/ +

%,.&

#(%&

!"#$ %&!'()$%* # $&, ! ! 9(

'- (

!$*& <('+!* B G?, '(!

'- 2

#! +(!

$&,!- B B IG?, !

+((

(,+( 2

,* -

B $&, ! ! 9(

'- 2

/!A'* /12$+( B <9,, * '-#! +(!

$&,!-!

( **9

,, * !

,, * '- *&! !

**9

! ! !2!

'- B 2 2**'

,-'* *!192! 2 ( F, (&2

*&, !**2 ( *E! &+! **2 ,, * (

!1*- ,

01234203 5

6 / 7$#$ . 8(&)9

%& :

9% 7$#$ .% # !':