High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5783/2015dismissed

Magma Hdi General Insurance Co Ltd v. Geeta And ORS

2015-09-096 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*#+"#,-#./0 !1,!#(#.!2('3.!(%#,+!(45"$ ++#22!("

6#.'3' ##"!!($"7#.' #'+($#("'

! !

.#'#(") .6&'7!211!.8!20$9%!"#

."7#!++#22!(" :::

"! #

('"!(" !++#!2 7!' -##( +.# #..#$ -4 !1,! #(#.!2 ('3.!(%# ,+!(4 5"$ &,+31(&(1 "7# !8!.$ $!"#$

; +!''#$ -4 2#!.(#$ ". %%&$#(" 2!&,' .&-3(!20 7!($&1!.77#.#&(!

"#..# #..#$"!'<.&-3(!2< ,+31(#$!8!.$&''3-=#%""%7!22#(1#+.&,!.&24("7# 1.3($ "7!" "7# !%%&$#(" &( >3#'"&( "? +2!%# ( "7# !%".4 +.#,&'#'87&%7%!(("-#"#.,#$"-#+3-2&%+.#,&'#'0"7#.# .#0 "7#&('3.!(%#%,+!(4%!(("-#7#2$2&!-2#

.&# !%"'!'.#9#!2#$!.#"7!"!9&4!2$#%#!'#$ 8!''"!($&(1&("7##%4%2&(1!%".4+.#,&'#'!"9&22!1# !18!2!0 #7'&2 !&+3. !(&0 !(%7?32! ( ;

#($&(1 %.!(# -#!.&(1 .#1&'".!"&( //@ A@ 8!' 3(2!$&(1 "7#

.#%4%2&(1,!%7&(# .,".22!B7#("7#'!&$,!%7&(#8!'-#&(1 "!?#(

.,"7#".22!8&"7"7#7#2+ 7?' "7#%.!(#!"!-3"

;+,!($&"8!'-#&(128#.#$$8(("7# 2.0-,

#($&(1 %.!(# -#%!,# &,-!2!(%#$ $3# " 87&%7 "7# .#%4%2&(1 ,!%7&(# #22$8(!($"7#7? "7#%.!(#'".3%? !1!&('""7# 7#!$0'",!%7!($2# "7!($ !9&4!2878!''"!($&(1"7#.# (=3.&#'8#.#%!3'#$(9&"!2.1!(' !9&4!2087'3%%3,-#$ "7&'&(=3.&#'%%&$#(""?+2!%#$3#".!'7!($(#12&1#("$.&9&(1 %.!(# //@ A@ -4 .#'+($#(" @ !'8&($#.

A3,!.$!"#$ ;8!'.#1&'"#.#$!"+2&%#+'"

!32&0 2&%#'"!"&(!&+3.!(&0&'".&%" !(%7?32! 2!&,+#"&"&(3($#.*#%"&(CC ".6#7&%2#'%"

!($8!'+.# #..#$-4"7#2#1!27#&.' $#%#!'#$!9&4!2087&%7 8!'.#'&'"#$-4"7#.#'+($#("' 228&(1&''3#'8#.# .!,#$-4"7#2#!.(#$.&-3(!2)@ B7#"7#.!9&4!27!'$&#$&(!.!$'&$#!%%&$#(" $3#".!'7!($(#12&1#("$.&9&(1 .#'+($#(" 87&2#$.&9&(1%.!(#//@ A@ D

B7#"7#."7#%2!&,!("'!.##("&"2#$"%,+#('!"&(!' +.!4#$ .D

B7#"7#..#'+($#("8!'("7!9&(1!9!2&$!($ #

#%"&9#$.&9&(12&%#(%#!""7#"&,# !%%&$#("D @ ; #2&# 5#!.(#$.&-3(!2(!++.#%&!"&( #9&$#(%#(.#%.$ %(%23$#$"7!"!9&4!22'"7&'2& #&("7#!%%&$#("%!3'#$$3#" .!'7!($(#12&1#("$.&9&(1 "7#%.!(#//@ A@ -4 .#'+($#(" E !'8&($#. A3,!. ,+#('!"&( " "7# "3(#

;0 C0/ F@8!'!8!.$#$""7#%2!&,!("' #%#!'#$ 8!' ; 4#!.' 2$ !" "7# "&,# !%%&$#(" (%,# "7# $#%#!'#$ 8!' !''#''#$ !' 0;;0 CF@ !

"#.

$#$3%"&( &(%,#"!G("7#-!'&' 7&'&(%,#"!G.#"3.(0G

."7#4#!. @;087&%78!'$324+.9#$-4 !=&9A!3'7!.0 ('+#%".0(%,#!G$#+!.",#("(%,#"!G.#"3.( ."7#4#!.

@ G /0 @ G 8!'!2'+.9#$(.#%.$H &(%.#!'#8!'!

.$#$(!%%3(" 2'' 3"3.#+.'+#%"'?##+&(1 &(9&#8"7#=3$1,#(" "7#(<-2#*3+.#,#3."&(

&9&2 H$#$3%"&(8!',!$# .,"7#&(%,#!''#''#$32"&+2&#.

8!'!++2&#$?##+&(1&(9&#8"7#!1# "7#$#%#!'#$,+#('!"&( !'$#"!&2#$-#288!'!8!.$#$)@ 5'' $#+#($#(%4

00/ F@ G+#('#' &(%3..#$ ( .!('+."!"&(0 3(#.!2 !($2!'".&"#'

0F@ (!%%3(" 2'' 29#!($!

#%"&(""7# %2!&,!("' 00F@ "!2 ;0 C0/ F@ 5#!.(#$%3('#2 ."7#!++#22!("9#7#,#("24!.13#'"7!"

"7#!%%&$#("7!'!$,&""#$24"!?#(+2!%#&("7# !%".4+.#,&''#'0 "7#.# .#0"7#.&-3(!27!'1.''24#..#$&(72$&(1"7!"&"&'!.!$ '&$#!%%&$#("&(87&%7"7#$#%#!'#$'3

#.#$&(=3.&#'87&%732"&,!"#24 2#$"7&'$#!"7('3.!(%#%,+!(4%!(("-#7#2$2&!-2#&('3%7 '&"3!"&( 5#!.(#$ %3('#2 . "7# !++#22!(" 7!' !2' .!&'#$ ! %7!22#(1# " "7# >3!("3, %,+#('!"&( !8!.$#$ +.&,!.&24 ( !%%3(" %,+#('!"&( !8!.$#$ ( !%%3(" 2'' 3"3.#

;

+.'+#%"'!'"7#$#%#!'#$8!'!'#2 #,+24#$+#.'( 7!9#7#!.$2#!.(#$%3('#2 ."7#!++#22!("!($1(# "7.317"7# &2#!'8#22!'"7#+7"%+4 "7#.#%.$087&%77!'

-##(+.$3%#$&(3." +#.3'!2 "7#+2#!$&(1'.#9#!2'"7!""7#+2#! !%%&$#("("%%3..&(1!"!+3-2&%+2!%#7!'("#9#(-##(.!&'#$-4 "7#!++#22!(""''+#%& &%'"!($&'"7!" $#(&!2 "7#!%%&$#("&"'#2 2!&,+#"&"&(&'!22#1#$"-# &2#$!'!.#'32" %223'&(-#"8##( "7#%2!&,!("'!($8(#. "7#%.!(#("7#!-'#(%# '+#%& &% +2#!$&(1'""7&'#

#%"0!++#22!("%!(("-#+#.,&""#$".!&'#"7&' +2#! ."7# &.'""&,#&(!++#!2 ( '&,&2!. %&.%3,'"!(%#'0 "7&' 3." &(

&9&2;/7#2$"7!") I ( !++#!2 &" &' %("#($#$ "7!" "7# !%%&$#(" 7!$ "!?#(+2!%#("&(!+3-2&%+2!%#!($"7#.# .#0"7#.# %32$-#(%2!&, .%,+#('!"&(!1!&('""7#('3.!(%# ,+!(47!9#1(#"7.317"7##("&.#+2#!$&(1'1&9#( -4"7#!++#22!(" ."7#"7&.$.#'+($#("!($&"&'(87#.# '"!"#$ "7!" "7# !%%&$#(" 7!$ (" %%3..#$ !" ! +3-2&% +2!%# ( "7# "7#. 7!($0 "7# %("#("&( 8!' (#

1#(#.!2$#(&!2 "7#!%%&$#("&"'#2 ('#>3#("240"7#.# 8!' (" #9#( ! +&(" . %('&$#.!"&( 87#"7#. "7# !%%&$#("7!9#"!?#(+2!%#&(!+3-2&%+2!%#.("("7# !-'#(%# +2#!$&(1.# 3'#"7#!++#22!(""3.1# .

'3%7!%("#("&(&(!++#!2 ."7# &.'""&,#5#!.(#$ %3('#2.# #.'"%#."!&($#%&'&('87&%7"7&(?!.#(" (#%#''!.4".!9#.'#,!4(24"'!4"7!"<+3-2&%+2!%#<&'

!(4+2!%#87#.#!(4,#,-#. !+3-2&%7!'!.&17"

!%%#''87#"7#.&"&'!"7.317 !.#.("7#.#!.#!(4 (3,-#. %!'#'"7!"19#.("7#'&"3!"&(87#.#9!.&3' %3."'7!9#7#2$"7!" !%".4+.#,&'#'!.#+3-2&%+2!%#' 7# 2&!-&2&"4 "7# ('3.!(%# ,+!(4 &' '!

#24 !($ '3.#24 '#%3.#$ . "7# %2!&,!("' 7# !++#!2 -4 "7# ('3.!(%#,+!(4&'%('#>3#("240$&',&''#$J 7#.# .#0"7#.#&'(,#.&"&("7&'+2#!.!&'#$(-#7!2

"7#!++#22!(" *&,&2!.240 2#!.(#$ %3('#2 &' 3(!-2# " +&(" 3" !(4 &( &.,&"4.&22#1!2&"4&("7#>3!("3, %,+#('!"&(!8!.$#$-4"7# .&-3(!2 (<-2# *3+.#,# 3." &( %!'# '3+.! 7!'

'+#%& &%!2247#2$"7!"!(!$$&"&(&("7#&(%,#(!%%3(" 2''

3"3.#+.'+#%"' 7!'"-#!

.$#$ !%%.$&(1" "7#!1# $#%#!'#$ #9#( 87#( 7# &' '#2 #,+24#$F+.&9!"#24 #,+24#$ 7317"7#>3#'"&( !8!.$(!%%3(" 2'' 3"3.#+.'+#%"'

&(.#'+#%""'#2 #,+24#$F+.&9!"#24#,+24#$+#.'('7!'-##( .# #..#$"!2!.1#. #(%79&$#.$#.$!"#$ ;&( $ % "&"2#$ &'()&* !)+,-&)./ 01&)2 3/-+,+ $,+41&&)5'4/-+0&"&'("$&'+3"#$-42#!.(#$%3('#2 ."7# !++#22!(""7!"+#.!"&( $#%&'&(&( +%!'#'3+.!7!'("

-##('"!4#$(!'3-'#>3#("=3$1,#("

C* ; 0 (<-2#*3+.#,#3." 7!'1.!("#$-#(# &"(!%%3(" 2''

3"3.#+.'+#%"'"!'#2 #,+24#$+#.'(' "7#.!.13,#("'7!'-##(.!&'#$5#!.(#$%3('#2&'

3(!-2# " +&(" 3" !(4 &( &.,&"4 . +#.9#.'&"4 87&%7 8!..!("'

&("#.

#.#(%#-4"7&'3."&("7#!++#22!("<' !93. ('#>3#("240 &($&(1(,#.&"0"7&'!++#!2&'$&',&''#$ (+&"(** *#+"#,-#./0 ,56/ ."'