High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4763/2016allowed

United India Insurance Co Ltd v. Mohit & ORS

2018-09-25Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu11 pages

!"#!!!$ %&#&'()!!"# ''#))" *#%$ $ +!""+#%$ %#$'#"$

!"#!!!$ %&#&'()!!"# ''#))" *#%$ $ +#""+#%$ %#$'#"$

+#""+#%$ ''#))"$ *#%$ $ $&+!!"")"+#%$ %#$'#"$

+!""+#%$ ''#))"$ *#%$ $ $&+!!"")"+#%$ %#$'#"$

', ,%-./$.,0123 ,.4455

,,42

,$60764123 ,,42

1 ,,42

2 ,.4455

888888

".,2,.5522

529: . 2 !2 !6, &04:1 ;< ,26 04 =,22 6 2. .6= 9. 1 =.5

.39 529:.50> 05:009, . 228.6= 1 ;< .0 . 04 =,22

".45

.,96 .22.6= =,2. 05:2 >84, 0...<.,22.06<.95.5<. 222

&8,2?. .&6,

52@

52 A

B$25:1.

66,4,4.39=,22=.,3= .2 &8 ,2 ?. . &6,

0 5 ,96 22 .6= =,2 . 05:1 66,

4,4 9 =,22 )5:1 . 9. . 228.6=3 =, :, <1., ,106545, @@=944523= 2 +B95 . $64,0 &6,

! "## 1 =.,06545, @ @.294452

$%5,265 ,.50>445522 . . 2 . &6,

52 A

B,52649:5,265 ,44558!6,&04: = 44595 2 1 . 2 2 2 2. . .6= = 2.",965.22.,96 .228= C >84,0.1=.,.+<.&6,.2;< 6. .320.54,62.5;0:9 3595. >84,0.1455:=..6= .2 4, ,0 065 ,6 26 2 ., , .2 2 . 356 . ,3 . 22 .6= C >8 4, 0. );=1 . ,5@&'( &!=5,53.2 1.2 2. .22.6= = .:, 2 . ,601 . 5 0 . 22 = 2

>84,0.1=.,.1.22.6=322 .:, ! .3 2,2 . 690 5,2 65 , . 4,20 .3=..,96 .6= =,2.

05:99:;<63,64?21&') 64,1.:, 2.= 1=.5.1.:, 2. ! . ,601 ! 20 44,4, .

,96 .22.6= =,2. 05: 1>84, 0. . 5<. 2 &8,2 ?. . &6,

52@*% + +#,&-.,% "/"0 %@1=.,.2 2. ..6= =

,<,21 . 45 5,2 65 , . 44558 !6,&04:.. 0 50 . 221 66,4,4,9=,221, ,902 .2 &8,2?. .&6,#', ',) 64,%53D, .0,4,26262, 8 E!

=,;<.50 ,.6= . 06 .652 9 222 , 66, 4,4 ". +@95 $64,0 &6, ,6 /60, <<,=5 2 ., 3 5!6,&04:2.,1 ')%$& 22=,2:.< , 66,4,4=.,.6= .2 22 $05,5: /,. 745 3 )51 %&% &35

.52.2222=F62<?. .+@95 $64,0 &6, =.5 =,2< 04 22 ; :.< , 66,4,4!0:4=..50 ,6954,3..22=,<25 0;6 ,565<.51.9

, 66,4,4.6529222!.<6 0 , 66, 4,4 =. . 0 4,3 96 =., . 0 5 . 62 , .6= 10:944,4,=,2 6,.,9 5 66, 4,41 4,65,5: =. .

5 0 . &6, , 0;< : 226 , 4,5D4G

,2<5:1.5<. ,0221=,2 . 5,2 , 2 &50 ",9651 '5=51 02 2 . D..,42>50=652952 66,4,4 , =652 : 226 9 02 =,2 . 4,5 D4 . 22 ,<,21 . 50 , ,26 6 =,< 445 06545,120<.2287<3= 2025: :, <4,.2 +@95.$64,0&6, @"'1,)64,1 <<,64 106545, @@ 44595 %53 D, . 2 "' 1,) 64,,4,26262, 8 E H., ,.52..06545,962.6529 02 560 . 95 93 4,4,2 9: 445:<$600".01",5;&.2,2&.,51=.. ,=.4,306545, ,.<<,64 2

:,1 ,262 9: 6 , 3,: 3 :,1.8 , :,18 ,

:,1 8 ,

:,18 , :,128 , :,1.,2629:=6 ,3,: 3:,1 .18 ,

:,18 ,

:,28 ,

:,G ,<,21 . 50 . 44558!6, &04: , ,26 06545, 4452. $.53 ,0 1

2 < . . @",965@ 9: ;< 6 . < . 22

.9 '0,0%4,#D'8 .24452. 06545, @ @1 =., 5,2 65 , . 44558!6, &04:.6<.445:< 06545, @@.<,62. 5 . . 50 .053 .2 2 . 50 4 . 228$.5 3 = :, < ". @",965@ 9: ;< 6. .,32.29529:.50=. ,<,2 . < 228$.5 3 ; 6 . < 44,<.'0,0%4,#D'8 2.2914452 .06545, @ @ ! 2 , 2<, =. . 2< . 5,2 @",965@ , 445:< . 06545, @ @ 3= . <,5 32 9 , 0 . 22 9<

:, < . 9 '0,0%4,#D'8

,<,21 . =,2 04 5,2 65 , . ,42>5022.3= 4,<,4. 3 . 2 ',: $.B . ,42>50 =, 52 1>8 6 5 2 1>8 =,2 6,5 D462,35.2<1>8=,229:. ",965 92 . 44558.692 2 . . 4455 .52, =,52465,60>4,5,60C ,2=..2 +@95.$64,0&6,52 @<07,5!6,&04:)023,66%05&.6.,6 %02.,

',<,4. 3 .2',:$.B 4,<,4. .2@0,2'+#,&- .,% 64,,4,26262, 8 ',<,4. 3 .2',:$.B 3%95 <6,35.2105:15 15 ,602 6,5D4.6529 1>811>82 1>8,435:". ,2 06.6529.2., I3,:., :,G ',<,4. .2@0,2'+ #,&-.,% E &6?. .&6,$-"%64, 25=..3,6.262,=..049 =,22 2. . .2 ) &,60 ! 5<5 4,51 E,60G 0426 ,0 =.. 04 A465 ,60B1 A4,5 ,60B1 2 55,60B ".,<.,60=652562.04:1,1.541 0 ,1<62152

.221=.. 5. 05:H.,4461=652562 D65,5=..2246 $465,60 <,55: 2 2 ,<. 4,< .,5.4 .6928= =..55=04 .6,33<46 ,5 E04:1:14,1

122 ..,3,:-6<5,5G ',5,60<,2..5264.4,06, 2. 4,1 ,5 E4,5214,1

1 :12451<622,<G 55,60.,<. .4,04 . 252. .52252< .2. .526<,.;2<:.4, 2 05: .22".<,<: ,4,

5.,.5226,<.,5 0&.52,,3562 ,., 531

104.42.,,5. 05:6 &,60454,0, 5<.<<,096 .62=,. 65,5.42,-6,2 =,523,.3,<J2..356 .52B,60

,D2.0356 .04=,22 . . 2. .52 -6,2 ., , 4,0 4, 9 =,22 04 62, 5 ,60.2. .52".06=,22. 4,04 ,5 .531

1,2 04.4 .22.52 ". , *.5 9 5 5<5 02 4,32< ,5 . 30 , ., 051 <650!=.,4,.5.,0,.521 , 60,,2 , 26<.,1 . 4, , 52 9 =,225 ,6062,..2 55&,60 ',5 &,60 =,22 .52, =. 5 ., 4,0,3.5262,. = +<. &6,.3 =,2204. 6 +=3,1.,=5,:=.,4.4,45 =.. 04 652 9 =,22 5 55 &,60 ".06 049=,22,60=55 9<3,29:.

4,45 =,2<0462, A) &,60B522=$-"%64, !.4,1=2044,4,=,2. ., 2., .22106 1. , 5 55&,60G ,2<5:1.5<. .2 +@95.$64,0 &6,@0,( &!1.,428.692. . .52525 465,60C1>81=.5. . .52, .22,.

!.5<. .42931

, 55=2 . D 250 . ,42>50 ,3 66, 4,41 =.5

, 55=2 . D 0 5 0>,96 .22.6= =,2. 05:9. 1>84,0.+=3,1226.55902=,2 . 4,5 D4 . 22 3= . 2 &.50250B $64, ?21 . 4455>50 , 5 .52 52 1>8 . 6 5 2 1>8 =,2 6,5 D4 92 1>8 . . 4455>50 6 5 465>4,5 ,60 ,435: "..5<. .42931.4455>50

> ,.5252. 55=<04 !"# $%&'!## ## "()'* +(%&!, $%&'!## ## "()'* % ' !0 >8 >8

66,',4

I 5

"5!02 >8 26 > ,2 5

6545,4452

42:65

6,5D4 ) ) 4,5>465 ,60 1>8$ 1>8$ 1>8+692 !,

);=14455>50

> ,.52 52. 55=<04 !"# $%&'!## ## "()'* +(%&!, $%&'!## ## "()'* % ' !0 >8 >8

66,',4

I 5

"5!02 >8 26 > . 5

6545,4452

42:65

6,5D4 ) ) ) 4,5> 465,60 1>8$ 1>8$ 1>8$ 1>86<., 1>86<., 1>86<., 1>8+692 !,

I --././01

,2<5:1 . 5<. . 4 2 931 . 4455850

, .52 52 =,2 04

1>8 < 1 >8 =,22 9: . ",9651=.550

,.5252=,2 04 <12,28,080/- =,229:.",965 5<=.,C I4,60= .2 504552 4:0 +=3,1 9 , 4:0 ,02 061 . .692 2 0, .52, .55 9 42 1>8 . =,2 5 ,60 9 , 44,0 04 25 01 44,0 04.55902,2=..0, 46529:.@",965@

,2<5:1

,55=2.0, 22939:02 :<.=,2.D293 2' $( -3-/. ,-. H..,4;<>,2

(> H..,,4,95