← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4715/2010allowed

Bije Singh v. Banwari And ORS

2019-08-06Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan15 pages

 

     

 

!"#$ %&%$%'#$$(#($%

&&(( )%' !*%$%

&       %#'+, % -./0 %$&&((

% )012$%/0 %%&3 

 !%(,/$%$&(!" #$$+%'#$'%&#!*%/ -  #$/  0  5(/  6*%/  $%  #$    6  - -&(#$+%$%!(+%#$$#$&%%- 

&%$$&(/$(#*$$+%$% !(+%#$$#$/&%%-3

$

  &'%$  &(  3   /             (  ( -'%#71(-%(0%#%(3  

8$$,*%(0%&$ &($,%-&'(&$% 9*0%/ 3  ((#((,''$%:(,1& &(3  +'0,%+1(+, +'%,*((8$$&(&%%-$( ;0('3   /$*0%*-8$$&&( &%%%+,$-#$"'#-%(-*$ $- 30%$($&(&%%- %-*%$&(*$*$$3 $0 %8$*0%3 7%#+%$ %0'%%$*#&3  0% $&(8$$#%$1$%#%*% *0%#0$&(%&%%-/$%%$ ((#$#1$%#%*%%((#(/'((0 *$'"'%8$$&(<'(,$ -' 

=&%-$#0%-&%/$ &((- 

=-#%-

7

%#$&(/$&3  0%$&(%&%$,$0%#$(* <',%-&8$*$$%' &$(-$&($0%&$

7 '($-/(###%0/$+%'#$$'<' 1#&+,-(+'%,*((2$ &(3  %#%-&%%-$ '(($0(#*$-# 

=&% -$

/3 7$&&%( "*%-#$'  /$,$% &%(-%,  +"  $  $  '  *  (/  %0('   0>'8$'%$&(+%#$ '8$$'*-+(*-+%%8$$ ;'%>$&(*'8$$'*+ '"%-"%%,&%8$ $  *%#    $  &'%$  $  '  (  %- - ;$*( 0(7   /*$$&'%$ $  -  %-    !#%*8  $  -'    $%  *  7    $*%#$0+ &  $%    7       -%/  $  *%# $$$'($+&'%$+,$ &(&%%-0%#%(3  

%$$&$+(0%$- $& ?$*%#$$%& ''$%:%%&% %#$-/1$%#%*% $&(&'**%#(,'#$-,/

 - ;$%2%$ 5(8 $ +%$##$1$% #%*%0'%$*%#/&%&%* %0'&'$&%/+'$,$($0((#(# +1/$%%$%$1$%#%*%*%%%(, $#0'%$*%#$%* ,%0#,$%$&(%&%%- $-% @$/'$&%,% -($'

@-,+-$%$3 *% &%#>&%%

?$  &(  $  (  %&(  %0%#  $ ((#$*%-*$%%%#$0%- $&(

$&(#$&%/((*#'*% %-

A$$%&(&%%-%*%' &(B

A$$%&((%(&%& '&(+,-(+'%,*((B

A$$%  &(    (    -#    $  '    

=B

 A$$%&((%(&%-"' &%,%B

  A$$%'-+(&%%-B 6

A$$%$&($'(' ($&%'B 6

A$$%&%&%;'%$+>&(B

6

A$$%  '    +  %  -"%    "%   %,&%B 6

A$$%&($-$;'%*$($/ /B 6

(

@%%&%0$/$&(#$- %%6A +>-#$ 2%$2'-%6A $ $0%6%$6A7%0% '-

$$%$/$$>-$ - #$A+%#%'- @&% -$%$&&(%(0-0 +$(    $    *%  ((*    $    ( %0%'-

%$%#(%'(%$&%/$%( ;'%'3 #$&(/'3 

0'%$&(#$/'3  0'%$&(#$/'3 #

  $/'3 #$ '((,/' $&(*- ?$*0"'#- %

 C(###%0+,$"'#-%/$ &($(&&($;'%%.'#/9% *$$*#(%.'#/9%/*$0 "'#-%



-$-

3*$$"'#-%&+, $;'%+(*/$&($11$%$;'% +,*,(#%#'(%&&(&%,#$$-+ &/$-&'#"'#-%&+,$;'% +(*+ 

  ##      %#'(%    &&(/  $ %&3  $0&'&&%$%'#$'(

@$0$%(%'(%$&%+## $%'#$$%%

&%'($"'#-&+,$%(;'%# $*$(,%(*(('-%,0 +%'#$(+,$%#$ %'-$/$%(;'%'$$%* "'(  #  %#%#  *%$&    $  &(    *((   &%%-0%&(3  8$0"'#- D>  $&%0''+*$&%/$%(;'%$

 +%0$$&($-'('&%0# $%&#&$+%0%(( 8$0D>  D>  - ;$*( *%>('0 &    &(  3         0  D> /  $  ( -'%# 1( -%(*-'0'% 3  $+(+,- ;$*( $%0'%8 $$'#$*%$&3  $+$* D>  /D> D>  +'$('-'(0/$ &    -  ;$%/  ,    2%$  5(  $  + $*8$*0%3  $#$%%-  '$ ('-      %(  $% -   +  >('0 &&(3  &(-;$% ?$ %(;'%$'$&(+,#0#%# &%3 $"'#-/*$$%%,%%+# %&%''%

          

     

    !    " ##  $ $%     &% '

 '#  ##

(  $   )       " ##      !  $ %    *+"   "  + *  ,        --  .  +                $   " ##   

+    $ $ $ "     $ 

      / 0 +"       &1 $ $  "     /   " ##/   $ $ 2* 3( 4!43 "   $ +   $      $"     $               $ $ &% '

 '

 '# 0   $      / '     &% '

 '# $   %   2       $         $       + $ 2    "

     %  0        "$       )   "  !  %   $   

A$$-%*%+,$C%&&(( ;'%/$#%*$$%(;'%+,#0#*%#/ *$$&%3  $"'#-/*$$% %,%%+#%&%''%

0 "            )        +"   $    +"    ) $ +"

3 05  ) $ 

33 5   6     "+    $"

  + *+ ) $          +"    6   7  $   +  6# "$  +        &  *      +  " $  '

'#         - 

  '          + +"      ) $             "

/ 3  3  5    $"  +    $ $ "+ *"/

- ,  . "   " ## +     

/ #   ) $  $      +"%

+* +"  6               +"

6    $ $          +

  8        &       +"

6    #

- #+"

4   9   $ $              6%

 +                    "  ##  +"

6      "  + "       & *      $          :              ";2 $ :2 $, .  +"

  !<+& )+

  !"! $5 +""  $  + $+ $     "

 "     +   "   $ + $  $   7 "  +    +                        35  $"  %  $  6  

$$#/$&((#*$&%%- *%$('/*$%$& '+$3  3*$<'/*$$ %*$$%$(-$&(%0+&% %" !$$;'%+(**$(-#$('$ &((#*$&%%-%*%$'( $'3  +&$%  %#$;'%+(*/$$&( $$$+&%-$'(+' ,% %(%*+($$%*$#%%$* $ $% $%&%%-  0% 1 %%-  &$'(  $$%$/+ %(,#'&(7   D> $(&(( %0'%%D>  D> D> &%0$%0( (0%$'(/*$$$+'&$(+,$;'%0 "'#-D>  D>   D0        1  $  $  &(  %  &%%-

 *%&((#+,$-/$%($ '(+($0%#:+,$;'%+(* @ $&(&%%-%$(+*%$ '(/$$,$0#0%,%#$%0%&$% %-$&%/*$%$*$0+%($$ %-% %( $5-/ 7&%0$%(# '%&--0+(&%&%,%,%$% +(/$(-&%0 ,%%*$ $&$+-0%$&( @ $/$$0*$%1$&(0% &/%$%$,$0+(-#$-(0+*% $('/$%%/$'+$(+-+%% +,,%$-#

5%  '(  %  $  &&((  $  %%%   '$%, 



 +,$ &>;'%*$%*+%0$*$'%& $+(($$&(+' (+($$+%(0'-$% 0  '(  $    &%0  0%  &  % &%%&0&%

$%"'#-%%%*    

   !"#"$ +,$&>;'% *$%    *  +%0  $    $  &(  $  (  $  '

  (-#(0%$'&%&%,%-%(   $5-/ 7/$+'%*'(+$ &%0$$$<'%(+,0%&

;'(%$&&((&%%0$% "'#-+,0!$$;'%  %&  '

(  

&    )   

    '    &

   *

+  ,)- .& !!/$"!0 *$%*+%0$ *$$%%*(/$$(&%%-$(( &%0($->'(/$0% *'($0,%#$%($&%&%,/*$$($$ '+<'&'%$%*$,%#$%(%% +%($$&

D01$3  $+ &$'((#$0#%%' $%/'($,&%0$%+%($$&(%1   +($  &(    0%  &/  '$     %(,%&$'(

@+-$%$$(0'% &(&%%-

>'+, !$#%*9'-;$/2$5($ -*(($1%;$'-%, 0'%&(!"#$/!(+%#$$#$ @ (%(,-$%$$&$+(0%

7 $0 ?$('-(*$% %#%$%0'%% ?$%0'%%((, &%&%%(&'%&  %-$(+(,&,-  ( %0'  $ -   + 1  +'- 0#*%$& $&%*$-%% $*%$&('- ?$'#$&%'-&%'$$ %    $  "-+  '%        $  6'"+  5 0'+'$&%'-&%+'+( ?$( &'%*%+,$/&,D> 7   >'+,- ;$*(0**!$#%**(( '#$%!$#%*0'%3 7 

!*%/-#$05( 9*0%/+($ %%$!$#%*$(%,($$%&( &%%-/$*(*$,%#$%($' (/'$/%$$$(#($%'($0%%% $(3  ?$%%/3  <'%,($'( ?$'#$!"#$/!(+% #$$#$$('%&%-"' #!*%-#$/*$$*((*+,;0(.'#

.% 0 /9%0"'#-

 *% %%%%&'(&&(*$%#% $1$%3 -'%#1(/$*0%/$(-$ &(0%1$%3     *%"+'$

 $;0(;'%((%%%#<'($'% "' @'$,&'/(,$&&%+  ?$;'%$$*0%$&(+*% $'&%&%,$+(

 ?$ &%&(&%%-$+%'#$'% (%&%-"'#$1%5(/! -!%'-9-6-*$%#% $'( 9*0%/$'$((##$(

     -'  3    

     0'%   3  *-+#-+%% !'0 $'+0/$(*$%#%$' %%0'%$&(&%%-$ +(+,%(%*%/$(#(%&%0 $0%'($0>'$(0'% 3  $,*%(*$,($ '(

?$%%/  $  "'#-    %  &  +,  $ ;'%  +(*  %    '+(    $  %  +  '& -&&%(0-%&%(* ?$-%  ?$&&(&*$$%'#$''( +,$&(%0'%$&(&%%- #$3  -'$ %%&+,-(+'%,*((2$

 &(3     '0((#;$'(!#%/ ?$(-&'%/%9%&0'%$&( # 3     '%$%+, *, &%&'( "'/3  %%%%-(#% %#,$%#0%$&%&%,,-%%%-%# ,'%$%%'$% 9*0%/'%$%'-/ $%(%#%-&%$% 

=&%-$ (

 !%"

 

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*   "&#

 '# !+,

  "&#