← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5841/2015disposed of

Naseer v. Ganga Vishan Tyagi & ORS

2018-10-29Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill4 pages



     



!" #"$%&%'( )    &""* ++",, '! -"*&.&  '/ -%&0 '1 /% '#!0"*& "&+'#"'!&  

 

*"&"'!( *&0%&0.+! 2#3$ !" *!0" ++",, '! "&+'#"'!&  '# +*$""#"# / %'&!"4+ *!" *5, 31 6.7 *2#3$ !" **"&+'#"'!89'&.* '$" 7+ '1



 0%& ++" ,0 &:""' %,"#:1!0"$, %7 '!&""5%'/"'0 '$"7"'! !0"$7+"'& !%' ; *#"#!0%7:1!0"," *'"#!*$$%#"'!, %7& *%:.' ,2 "; ! <*%:.' ,= * &0*! 3%#" ; *# # !"# ) 

 ' $$.'! %'>.*%"& '##%& :%,%!1&.

"*"#:10%7%' 7!*3"0%$," $$%#"'! ' )  8

*%"

$!& '"$"&& *1 * #>.#%$ !%'   !0" $ &" *" !0 !  +"!%!%'.'#"*?"$!%' @@ !0"!*-"0%$,"&$!2 ) ; &+*"

"**"#:1 !0" ++",, '!&""5%'/$7+"'& !%'' $$.'! !0"%'>.*%"& '##%& :%,%!1 &.

"*"#:10%70" ++",, '!; &%'3,3"#%' 7!*3"0%$," $$%#"'!'

  8 ;0"' 0" ,'/ ;%!0 ? 0*'2 #*%3"* '# ? >%#2 $," '"* ;"*" /%'/ ! ",0% *7 .> * ! !"* , #%'/ /, && %'  !*.$5 :" *%'/  AA B 0"!*.$5; &:"%'/#*%3"':1? 0*' ! 7#"* !"&+""#' !0","

!0 '#&%#" !0"* #C0"'!0"1*" $0"#'" *!0"&! !." ? 0%#  7 6.7 * %' !0" *"   "** ' A  ' )  82 !0" #*%3"* *"&+'#"'!     '!0"* 3"0%$," :" *%'/  A A B &.##"',1

 ++,%"#:* 5"&;%!0 .,, *$"2;%!0.! '1%'#%$ !%'& *"&.,!!0"*" !0" 3"0%$,"   !0" +"!%!%'"* &!*.$5 / %'&! !0" 

"'#%'/ 3"0%$," ++",, '! &.&! %'"#7.,!%+,"%'>.*%"&'0%&+"*&' ,'/;%!0 * $!.*"'0%&:!0,"/& ;0%,"? >%#&.&! %'"#%'>.*%"&'0%&0" #' $$.'! !0"& %# $$%#"'! 0" $$%#"'! !5 +, $" &,",1 #." ! !0" * &0 '# '"/,%/"'! #*%3%'/  *"&+'#"'!  ."!!0" $$%#"'!2 ++",, '!*"7 %'"# #7%!!"#%'

"0** '#6 %, &0&+%! ,2 "0**;" )  8!  8 '#; & +"* !"#.+' & ;",,%&,"/& ;"*"&0*!"'"# '# !"*!0" $$%#"'!!0" ++",, '! $"# #%

%$.,!1 %' &%!!%'/ '# ; ,5%'/ 0" ++",, '! ; & +"*7 '"'!,1#%& :,"#!; &+," #"#!0 !!0"$, %7 '! !!0"!%7"  $$%#"'! ; &#*%3"*:1+* "&&%';%!09& ""+ 5 '#7+ '1 '#.&"#!" *'%'/ 9A +"* 7'!0 " $, %7"# ! :" !0" &"$'# #*%3"* ' 3"0%$,"  AA B 7+"'& !%'; &2!0.&2+* 1"# * D" *'"#*%:.' ,'$'&%#"* !%' !0" $!& '#"3%#"'$"' *"$*# 0",# !0 ! !0" $$%#"'! %' E."&!%' !5 +, $" #." ! !0" * &0 '# '"/,%/"'! #*%3%'/   !0" 

"'#%'/ 3"0%$," :1 %!& #*%3"* 0"*" %& ' #%&+.!" *"/ *#%'/!0" :3"& %# %'#%'/ !0"," *'"#*%:.' ,'!0%&%&&."2;0%$0 0 & !! %'"# %' ,%!1 0" ," *'"# *%:.' , ; *#"#  &.7   & * 7"#%$ ,"4+"'&"&'!0"*&.7 & 29A; & ; *#"# *+01&%$ , '# 7"'! ,+ %'&.

"*"#:1!0"$, %7 '! '#&9A " $0 *!* '&+*! !%' '# &+"$% , #%"! ! , $7+"'& !%'   & 282 ; & ; *#"# ! !0" ++",, '! ,'/;%!0%'!"*"&! !!0"* !" BF+"* ''.7 *7!0"# !"

%,%'/ $, %7+"!%!%'!%,,*" ,%& !%' D" *'"#$.'&", *!0" ++",, '!&.:7%!&!0 !'$7+"'& !%' 0 & :""'

*#"# ! !0" ++",, '! !; *#& ,&&   %'$7" D"&& $7+"'& !%'0 &:""'

*#"#' $$.'! + %' '#&.

"*%'/& &;",, &

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

$"#' *"$*#*"3"*2%!$ ''!:",&!&%/0! !0 !"3"'7%'%7.7; /"  ' .'&5%,,"# , :.*"* ! !0" !%7"   $$%#"'! %' !0" ?! "    *1 '  ; & )@B9A+"*7'!0!%&$'&%#"*"# ++*+*% !"! &&"&&!0"%'$7" !0" ++",, '!!:"&9A+"*7'!06""+%'/%'3%";!0"%'>.*1&.

"*"# :1!0" ++",, '!20"%&"'!%!,"#! &.7 & 29A &,&& %'$7"%" !0" %'$7" * !0*"" 7'!0&2 #.*%'/ ;0%$0 +"*%#2 %' ,, +*: :%,%!%"&2 0" ;.,#'!0 3":""' :,"! !!"'#0%&;*5?.7 & 29A ; *#"# ' $$.'! 7"#%$ ,"4+"'&"&%&7 %'! %'"#&.7 &29A%'&!" #  & 29A %& ; *#"# !; *#& + %' '# &.

"*%'/& '# & %'&!" # &9A *&+"$% ,#%"! *&+"$% ,#%"! '# !!"'# '!$0 */"&%& ; *#"#!%&'!%$"#!0 !!0" $$%#"'!%'E."&!%'!5+, $"%'!0" *"  3%,, /" "0**  > &!0 ' 0" ++",, '! ; & #7%!!"# ! %3%, &+%! ,2

"0** '# !0"*"

!"* 0" /! !*" !"# ! "0,  > &!0 ' ;"3"*2 !0" $, %7 '! %& #7%!!"#,1  *"&%#"'!   -%,, /" 62 %&!*%$! "; !  &.7 

 29A %'&!" #   &9A %& ; *#"# ' $$.'!   !* '&+*! !%' $0 */"& 0.&2 !0" $, %7 '! %& "'!%!,"# ! $7+"'& !%' & #"! %,"# 0"*".'#"*(A  

  

 "#%$ ,"4+"'&"&

  %' '#&.

"*%'/& &29A 8 D&& %'$7"G4 87'!0&

 ?+"$% ,#%"! '# !!"'# '! $0 */"&  * '&+*! !%' 29A 

229A  0" 7.'! $7+"'& !%' ,*" #1 ; *#"#!!0" ++",, '!2 '""#,"&&!& 12&0 ,,&! '##"#.$!"# *7!0" 7.'!$ ,$., !"# & :3" ++",, '!&0 ,,:""'!%!,"#!%'!"*"&! !!0"* !" BF+"* ''.7'!0" "'0 '$"# 7.'! *7!0"# !" %,%'/ !0"+"!%!%'!%,,*" ,%H !%' C%!0!0" :3"& %#7#% %$ !%'%'!0" ; *## !"# ) 

2 +*"&"'! ++" ,%&#%&+&"#  



  $!:"* )2 &0; * C0"!0"*&+" 5%'/9*" &'"#(A"&9 C0"!0"**"+*! :,"(A"&9